OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Huntington, New York/Meeting Portal
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Huntington Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting October 29, 2026

Meeting Portal — Thursday, October 29, 2026
BodyHuntington, New York
SessionMeeting Portal
DateThursday, October 29, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:39:24

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

10:30

Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the zoning board of appeals for the town of Huntington for our meeting of October the 29th, 2026.

10:40

Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance to our flag.

Speaker 2

10:44

I pledge

Speaker 1

10:45

allegiance

Speaker 2

10:46

to the flag.

10:51

One

Speaker 1

10:51

is under God.

10:56

Please be seated.

10:58

First order of business tonight is for the minutes of October the 22nd, 2026, last week.

11:13

If there are no deletions, additions or corrections to make, I'll entertain a motion to accept the minutes.

Speaker 3

11:18

I'll make that motion.

Speaker 1

11:19

Mr.

11:20

McGrath on the motion, Mr.

11:21

Castagna on the second.

11:23

All in favor.

11:24

Any opposed, the minutes are accepted.

Unassigned speaker

11:30

Don

Speaker 1

11:31

are all the applications properly sworn to for the postings and the publications to give us jurisdiction for the hearings tonight.

12:17

23784, 10 Jameson Court and East North Port.

12:21

Two three seven seven four four twenty-seven Wolf Hill Road and Dix Hills.

12:25

And finally, two three seven eight six, which is nine fifty East Jericho Turnpike in Huntington Station.

12:34

Well, the applicant or the representative of the applicant for two three seven four seven twenty-seven Carmen Road Dick Sales.

12:41

Please address the board.

Speaker 4

13:03

Now this is just south of where Carmen Road begins at its intersection with Wolf Hill Road.

13:08

Perhaps you know Terry Farrell Park is right there.

13:11

Terry Farrell was a volunteer chief of the Dix Hills Fire Department and a member of the FDNY when he lost his life at thirty-nine years old at nine-eleven.

13:20

This property belongs to my clients, Joel Rojas Ortiz and Felix Martinez, and they purchased it in 2022.

13:28

It's an extraordinarily well-maintained piece of property.

13:31

Mrs.

13:32

Martin looking at the photographs, took a particular shine to it when I filed the application.

13:37

It's improved with a dwelling, as I mentioned, as well as a rear in ground pool.

13:43

Joel and Felix would like to add an addition to the property.

13:47

And their practical difficulty is for the reason I stated at the outset, this is a substandard lot.

13:53

We do not have the requisite lot width for the R 40 zone in which it's located.

13:58

Within the R40, which is our one acre residential zone, lots have to be 125 feet across.

14:06

We're only 97 feet across.

14:08

So when you have 25% less lot width than the zone requires, you're going to have an awfully difficult time meeting the minimum side yard setbacks.

14:16

And the minimum side yard setbacks of the R 40 are 25 feet on each side with a 50-foot aggregate.

14:24

Further complicating the appellants' practical difficulty is that it is, as I mentioned, an improved lot.

14:30

So they have to work off where the existing single family dwelling has been sited on the property.

14:37

So from a technical standpoint, we are going to be holding a 36 foot aggregate across the property, and all of the additions, the entirety of the addition is on the easterly side of the premises.

14:49

We are in the R 40, so we need that lot width variance, and we need the side yard setback variants.

14:54

Notably, we have an excess of the minimum lot area.

14:58

We have 1.3 acres.

15:00

But if you looked at the survey, which comprises part of your digital pack this evening, those 1.3 acres are put into a long bowling alley shaped lot.

15:10

It runs 500 feet deep.

15:13

And the house now doesn't meet side yard setbacks.

15:15

And indeed, relief was issued for that some years ago, so the prior homeowner could uh expand it.

15:22

Um what we have tonight, Joseph Scarpula, our project architect, he's located in Huntington.

15:28

We're merely looking to make the house more amenable and up to today's standards.

15:32

So if you looked at the floor plans, our first floor primary bedroom will remain where it is.

15:37

It will only be expanded, however.

15:40

There will be a full master bath because you're not allowed to say that full primary bath installed with walk-in closets.

15:47

On the second story with that side yard addition, we'll additionally be able to add a bedroom with closets and respective uh baths for each.

15:57

The question then becomes is there any impact?

16:01

And the answer is quite simply no.

16:04

And that's because in the site photographs, and Mr.

16:06

Weeder can always anticipate where I'm going.

16:09

Um the most impacted neighbor is on the side where we're going to put the addition on the east.

16:15

On that property, in the photograph you're about to see, I took from the end the deepest portion of Joel and Felix's house toward the house on the east.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Zoning And Land Use█████████████████████████████████████████████80%
Transportation Safety███5%
Engineering And Infrastructure███5%
Procedural███5%
Water And Wastewater Management█2%
Parking Variance█2%
Public Engagement█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Huntington Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting - October 29, 2026

The Town of Huntington Zoning Board of Appeals met on October 29, 2026, for a regular evening meeting. The board approved the previous week's minutes, conducted six public hearings, and handled other business including zone change referrals, a consultant resolution, and accessory dwelling unit preliminary approvals. Five of the six applications were granted; one decision was reserved. The meeting adjourned to November 5, 2026.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes of October 22, 2026, accepted unanimously (motion by McGrath, second by Castagna).
  • Jurisdiction confirmed for hearings 23784, 23774, and 23786.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Robert Levignon of 424 Wolf Hill Road, Dix Hills, opposed application 23774 (427 Wolf Hill Road), describing four years of flooding, mud, blocked sewers, construction vibrations, and alleged town enforcement failures. He asked the board to deny the request and review the full scope of development, noting that a neighbor who died that weekend had said the project "was going to kill me."
  • Neil Arichio, speaking for his fiancée at 6 Ivy Hill Court, Huntington Station, questioned the traffic study for application 23786 (950 East Jericho Turnpike), citing unsafe truck loading in roadways and potential noise from jet skis/ATVs. He urged the board to set a precedent for more aesthetic, compliant development.
  • No public speakers appeared for the other five hearings.

Discussion Items

Public Hearing 23747 – 27 Carman Road, Dix Hills

  • Applicants/owners Yoel Antonio Rojas Ortiz and Felix Martinez requested side yard and combined side yard relief to construct a two-story addition and roof over deck.
  • The attorney stated the R-40 lot is substandard: 97.9 feet wide where 125 feet are required. The house currently does not meet side yard setbacks; relief was previously granted. The requested variances were 11.58 feet where 25 feet are required, and a combined setback of 36.08 feet where 50 feet are required. The lot has 1.3 acres and three times the required front yard.
  • No opposition. Board granted the application.

Public Hearing 23765 – 9 Montana Street, Huntington

  • Owner Patricia Franco requested accessory structure and lot area relief to legalize an existing front deck. She stated the deck predated her ownership, no devaluation had occurred, and the community's development pattern was unchanged.
  • The board recognized the R-40 neighborhood had mostly been built under R-5 zoning, resulting in substandard lots. The deck is 19.2 feet where 50 feet are required.
  • No opposition. Board granted the application.

Public Hearing 23764 – 56 Wintercress Lane, East Northport

  • Architect Tom Winnis, for applicant Bobby Vaughese and owners Bobby and Betsy Varughese, withdrew the request to construct a two-story addition; that portion would be revised and refiled without needing ZBA approval.
  • The remaining request was to legalize existing pool equipment set back 2 feet where 5 feet are required. The pool and equipment were installed in 1986.
  • No opposition. Board granted the application.

Public Hearing 23785 – 169 West Pulaski Road, Huntington Station

  • Owner John Casey sought to rebuild a fire-damaged detached two-car garage on an existing poured foundation, requesting an area variance for 810 square feet where 750 is allowed, and a height variance for 25 feet where 15 feet is allowed.
  • Casey stated the prior garage had a certificate of occupancy at the same height, and he uses a car lift for rebuilding cars. A neighbor's letter in the record supported the rebuild.
  • No opposition. Board granted the application.

Public Hearing 23784 – 10 Jameson Court, East Northport

  • Attorney Ryan Brown, for applicant Uygar Konur, sought relief to convert a balcony to living space, add an egress window well, and legalize existing shed, hot tub, and fence. The R-7 corner lot is 8,268 square feet with 50-foot width where 75 feet is required; prior lot width relief was granted in 1983.
  • Requests included: balcony setback 22.6 feet vs. 25; addition setback 6.8 feet vs. 7; unobstructed side yards 3.66 and 3.5 feet vs. 5; and zero fence setback vs. 2 feet.
  • No opposition. Board granted the application.

Public Hearing 23774 – 427 Wolf Hill Road, Dix Hills

  • Attorney Ryan Brown, for 427 Wolf Hill Road LLC (Gene French), sought to legalize retaining walls, a sports court with fencing, and a detached covered patio. Requests included: retaining wall facial area 2,510 sq ft vs. 833.54 allowed; retaining wall setbacks 4.4 ft west and 1.4 ft east vs. 10 ft; sports court fence setbacks 9.58 ft west and 9.66 ft east vs. 10 ft; and cumulative accessory structure square footage 2,207 sq ft vs. 1,200 allowed.
  • Brown explained the slope and a design professional's misinterpretation of tiered retaining wall rules; existing arborvitae screening was noted.
  • Robert Levignon, the across-the-street neighbor, objected at length, claiming flooding, mud, unauthorized construction, and disproportionate scale. He asked for denial.
  • The board closed the hearing and reserved decision.

Public Hearing 23786 – 950 East Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station

  • Attorney Tara Visconti, for Motorrad Realty LLC (Erik Habberstad), sought a special use permit for a motorsports repair, service, and parts facility with outdoor overnight storage of personal watercraft and ATVs in an existing building vacant since 2024.
  • Variances requested: five parking spaces where eight are required; parking buffers and landscaping; and signage area of 100.5 sq ft where 97.5 sq ft is allowed.
  • Traffic expert Wayne Muller (RM Engineering) testified parking and traffic impacts would be minimal; real estate expert Michael Lynch testified the use was consistent with the surrounding motor-vehicle corridor and would not harm property values.
  • Neil Arichio spoke in opposition, citing traffic safety and noise concerns.
  • The board discussed conditions, including that all repair work would occur inside, only watercraft/ATVs would be stored outside, hours would be Monday–Friday 9–6, Saturday 9–5, closed Sunday, and site plan approval would still be required.
  • Board granted the application with a negative declaration.

Key Outcomes

  • 23747 (27 Carman Road): Granted. Motion by Basso, second by Castagna. Vote unanimous.
  • 23765 (9 Montana Street): Granted. Motion by Whalen, second by Cote. Vote unanimous.
  • 23764 (56 Wintercress Lane): Granted after withdrawal of addition request. Motion by Castagna, second by White. Vote unanimous.
  • 23785 (169 West Pulaski Road): Granted. Motion by Cote, second by McGrath. Vote unanimous.
  • 23784 (10 Jameson Court): Granted. Motion by Whalen, second by Castagna. Vote unanimous.
  • 23774 (427 Wolf Hill Road): Decision reserved; no vote taken.
  • 23786 (950 East Jericho Turnpike): Granted, with conditions and a negative declaration. Motion by McGrath, second by Whalen. Vote unanimous.
  • Approved a resolution to retain H2M Architects/Engineers as a consultant for ZBA 23729 (35 Hemingway Drive, Dix Hills) concerning retaining walls, with an initial escrow of $6,100. Motion by Castagna, second by Basso.
  • Issued preliminary approval letters for accessory dwelling units at 4 Griffin Place (ADU 2284), 8 Basswood Place (ADU 2295), and 3 Greystone Drive (ADU 2297), all subject to building department referral to Suffolk County.
  • Took no action on zone change referrals 2026-ZM-492 (Railroad Street west of 11th Street) and 2026-ZM-493 (Woodman Road north of Gwyn Road, West Hills), treating them as informational coordination items.
  • Adjourned to November 5, 2026.

Meeting Transcript

Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the zoning board of appeals for the town of Huntington for our meeting of October the 29th, 2026. Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance to our flag. I pledge allegiance to the flag. One is under God. Please be seated. First order of business tonight is for the minutes of October the 22nd, 2026, last week. If there are no deletions, additions or corrections to make, I'll entertain a motion to accept the minutes. I'll make that motion. Mr. McGrath on the motion, Mr. Castagna on the second. All in favor. Any opposed, the minutes are accepted. Don are all the applications properly sworn to for the postings and the publications to give us jurisdiction for the hearings tonight. 23784, 10 Jameson Court and East North Port. Two three seven seven four four twenty-seven Wolf Hill Road and Dix Hills. And finally, two three seven eight six, which is nine fifty East Jericho Turnpike in Huntington Station. Well, the applicant or the representative of the applicant for two three seven four seven twenty-seven Carmen Road Dick Sales. Please address the board. Now this is just south of where Carmen Road begins at its intersection with Wolf Hill Road. Perhaps you know Terry Farrell Park is right there. Terry Farrell was a volunteer chief of the Dix Hills Fire Department and a member of the FDNY when he lost his life at thirty-nine years old at nine-eleven. This property belongs to my clients, Joel Rojas Ortiz and Felix Martinez, and they purchased it in 2022. It's an extraordinarily well-maintained piece of property. Mrs. Martin looking at the photographs, took a particular shine to it when I filed the application. It's improved with a dwelling, as I mentioned, as well as a rear in ground pool. Joel and Felix would like to add an addition to the property. And their practical difficulty is for the reason I stated at the outset, this is a substandard lot. We do not have the requisite lot width for the R 40 zone in which it's located. Within the R40, which is our one acre residential zone, lots have to be 125 feet across. We're only 97 feet across. So when you have 25% less lot width than the zone requires, you're going to have an awfully difficult time meeting the minimum side yard setbacks. And the minimum side yard setbacks of the R 40 are 25 feet on each side with a 50-foot aggregate. Further complicating the appellants' practical difficulty is that it is, as I mentioned, an improved lot. So they have to work off where the existing single family dwelling has been sited on the property. So from a technical standpoint, we are going to be holding a 36 foot aggregate across the property, and all of the additions, the entirety of the addition is on the easterly side of the premises. We are in the R 40, so we need that lot width variance, and we need the side yard setback variants. Notably, we have an excess of the minimum lot area. We have 1.3 acres. But if you looked at the survey, which comprises part of your digital pack this evening, those 1.3 acres are put into a long bowling alley shaped lot. It runs 500 feet deep. And the house now doesn't meet side yard setbacks. And indeed, relief was issued for that some years ago, so the prior homeowner could uh expand it. Um what we have tonight, Joseph Scarpula, our project architect, he's located in Huntington. We're merely looking to make the house more amenable and up to today's standards.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com