OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

March 10, 2026 Joint Council and P&Z Meeting – Murphy Master Plan and Two Rezonings Adopted

City CouncilTuesday, March 10, 2026
BodyIdaho Falls, Idaho
SessionCity Council
DateTuesday, March 10, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:17:34

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

Welcome as I call to order the March 10th, 2026, City of Murphy joint city council and planning zoning commission meeting.

0:10

Time is 6 p.m.

0:12

Rise with me as I offer the uh communication question.

0:16

Can I get a time from Christine Johnson PC chair?

0:19

I'm sorry.

0:20

Can you call P and Z to order, please, ma'am?

0:22

Yeah, P and Z in order as of 6 o'clock for March 10.

0:28

All right, very good.

0:31

Our Heavenly Father blesses as we consider the agenda reposed tonight.

0:34

Give us the wisdom to act with compassionate vision for what is best for community blessed and watch over our public safety officers and community they serve.

0:42

Right.

0:45

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

0:49

And to the Republic for which it stands under indivisible with justice for all.

1:06

Mayor Scott Bradley?

1:07

Here.

1:08

Mayor Pro Tim Elizabeth Abraham.

1:10

Here.

1:10

Deputy Mayor Pro Tim Janae Butler.

1:13

Here.

1:14

Councilmember place to Scott Smith.

1:16

Here.

1:16

Council member place three enter chase?

1:18

Here.

1:19

Council member place four can open.

1:21

Here.

1:21

Council member place five Laura Deal.

1:23

Here.

1:26

I will turn this over to Maria Palmer to call the role for planning and zoning.

1:31

I'm actually gonna do that for you tonight.

1:33

Chair.

1:34

Chair Christine Johnson.

1:35

Here.

1:36

Vice Chair Destiny Vargas.

1:38

Here.

1:39

Secretary Beverly Gaither?

1:41

Commissioner Trisha Colbert.

1:43

Commissioner Raj Mandalga.

1:46

Commissioner Camille Hoover.

1:48

Commissioner Don Bryant.

1:51

Alternate Commissioner Jacob Coleman.

1:54

Alternate Commissioner Amanda Turner.

1:56

Chair.

1:58

And let the record show that Camille is here at 602.

2:04

Chair, if you have a certify the presence of a forum, and mayor certify the presence of a forum for council.

2:09

Thank you.

2:11

All right.

2:13

Is it going to be run a little bit differently?

2:15

Because we're running this as a joint.

2:17

Christine and I are going to be echoing each other quite a bit tonight.

2:22

We are going to go into public comments.

2:25

Each one of the items tonight, um item 6B and 6C, which are the items that most people are concerned about, are public hearings.

2:38

So I will open up the public hearings and we can have each one of us.

2:43

Christine will open up her public hearing, uh, finalize their process, then I'll open up public hearing for city council, finalize our process.

2:50

Um so if you want to speak on either 6A or 6B or 6C tonight, you'll have an opportunity, two opportunities under each uh item.

3:03

But we do have a public comments uh component tonight.

3:08

So if you have one address council on something else, or you just want to get your comments in quickly, uh the time is available for you in that.

3:17

Uh so item four, the city the council chambers is open to the public.

3:21

This portion of the agenda is the public's opportunity to address the council about any general comment.

3:27

Uh comments related.

3:28

The public hearing will be heard when uh when the specific hearing begins.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Community Engagement█████████████████████████25%
Economic Development███████████████████████23%
Procedural███████████11%
Planning And Zoning███████████11%
Engineering And Infrastructure██████████10%
Affordable Housing██████████10%
Zoning And Land Use████4%
Transportation Safety██2%
Public Engagement██2%
Summary of Proceedings

March 10, 2026 Joint City Council and Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting

The City of Murphy held a joint meeting on March 10, 2026, at 6:00 p.m. to consider the adoption of the 2026 Murphy Master Plan and two city-initiated zoning changes. After a public comment period and executive session, both bodies approved the master plan and the rezoning of 11.56 acres near City Hall, while the rezoning of 3.221 acres at Murphy Road and Betsy Lane was approved by the Planning & Zoning Commission (6-1) and later by the City Council (tally not specified, but a supermajority was required). The meeting adjourned at 8:34 p.m.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Item 6A (Master Plan): One speaker (Jazz) requested more detailed presentation materials for the public, noting that the slides shown were not sufficiently explanatory.
  • Item 6C (3.221 acres – Murphy Road & Betsy Lane): Numerous residents and property owners spoke. Opponents included:
    • Syed Hussaini, the developer, argued that his 2021 residential zoning approval was proper, that the master plan process never discussed his property, and that neighborhood services would harm nearby property values and increase traffic.
    • Riaz Odin (future resident within 200 feet) stated that he purchased his home relying on the residential zoning and opposed commercial uses.
    • Amin Bata (owner of 1015 N Murphy Rd) shared his experience that leasing neighborhood services space in Murphy takes five years and that 45,000 square feet of similar space is currently vacant; he opposed adding more.
    • Mary Pat Elliott (realtor and resident) supported the original townhome plan, arguing it would serve downsizing seniors and millennials.
    • Several other residents expressed concerns about traffic, property values, and potential nuisance businesses (vape shops, etc.).
  • Supporters of the rezoning included:
    • Valita Logan, Michael Padilla, Bentley Vergeese, and others who argued that commercial development would diversify the tax base, provide walkable services, reduce traffic from residential density, and implement the new master plan.
  • Item 6B (11.56 acres – City Hall Circle & Murphy Road): Only one speaker (Mary Pat Elliott) commented, expressing support for the mixed-use town center vision.

Discussion Items

  • Item 6A: Adoption of 2026 Murphy Master Plan – Abra Nesser (LJA consultant) presented the 15-month process: community forums in July and November 2025, updates to future land use including a new Murphy Opportunity District (MOD 11) at the southeast corner of Murphy Road and Betsy Lane. The plan prioritizes walkability, mixed-use, and preservation of existing neighborhoods. The implementation section includes prioritized actions with cost estimates. The resolution originally contained a typographical error (“Denison, Texas”), which was corrected via a substitute resolution. Planning & Zoning approved it unanimously; City Council also approved it (7-0, with one nay from Altman? Actually transcript shows one “Nay” from Mr. Altman, but later roll call unclear; the motion passed).
  • Item 6C: Rezone 3.221 acres (SE corner Murphy Rd & Betsy) – from PD Single-Family Attached to PD Neighborhood Services – Jared Mayfield (city staff) explained that the current zoning does not comply with the 2008 comprehensive plan or the newly adopted 2026 master plan. The proposed PD allows reduced setbacks (50 ft for single-story, 75 ft for two-story) and encourages street-oriented buildings with parking in the rear. Staff noted that the rezoning would bring the property into compliance and likely result in less traffic than the 32 previously approved townhomes. Discussion focused on traffic projections, existing commercial vacancy rates (staff cited 96% occupancy citywide, while a speaker cited 45,000 sq ft vacant and a 21% vacancy for neighborhood services spaces), and the fairness of the city-initiated change. The developer and nearby residents argued the process lacked transparency and that the original 2021 approval should be honored. Planning & Zoning voted 6-1 (with one abstention counted as negative) to approve. City Council received additional comments and engaged in lengthy debate; Councilmember Butler noted the need to weigh pros and cons, and the mayor emphasized the master plan vision. The motion passed (no explicit tally, but mayor declared passage).
  • Item 6B: Rezone 11.56 acres (SE corner City Hall Circle & Murphy Rd) – from PD Townhomes to PD Mixed-Use – This rezoning covers a 7.5-acre tract owned by Syed Hussaini and a 4-acre city-owned lot (“Mount Murphy”). The PD allows mixed uses including office, retail, hospitality, and up to 65 brownstone townhomes (by SUP). Design standards for architecture are included. Staff noted that the previous 2022 approval for 53 townhomes is now non-compliant with the new master plan. No public opposition was voiced. Both Planning & Zoning and City Council approved it unanimously.

Key Outcomes

  • Adoption of 2026 Murphy Master Plan: Approved by Planning & Zoning (unanimous) and City Council (majority vote, one opposing). The plan will guide future land use and development.
  • Rezone 3.221 acres (Murphy Rd & Betsy Ln): Approved by Planning & Zoning (6-1) and City Council (with supermajority required due to 20%+ protest from nearby property owners; the mayor stated the threshold was met). The zoning changes from PD Single-Family Attached to PD Neighborhood Services.
  • Rezone 11.56 acres (City Hall Circle & Murphy Rd): Approved unanimously by both bodies. The property will be rezoned to PD Mixed-Use, enabling a potential town center development with design standards.
  • Next Steps: Future site plans for the rezoned properties will require separate approval from Planning & Zoning and City Council. The master plan will be posted online and used for zoning consistency.

Note: The transcript contains some disjointed audio; key statistics and vote counts are captured as stated by participants.

Meeting Transcript

Welcome as I call to order the March 10th, 2026, City of Murphy joint city council and planning zoning commission meeting. Time is 6 p.m. Rise with me as I offer the uh communication question. Can I get a time from Christine Johnson PC chair? I'm sorry. Can you call P and Z to order, please, ma'am? Yeah, P and Z in order as of 6 o'clock for March 10. All right, very good. Our Heavenly Father blesses as we consider the agenda reposed tonight. Give us the wisdom to act with compassionate vision for what is best for community blessed and watch over our public safety officers and community they serve. Right. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands under indivisible with justice for all. Mayor Scott Bradley? Here. Mayor Pro Tim Elizabeth Abraham. Here. Deputy Mayor Pro Tim Janae Butler. Here. Councilmember place to Scott Smith. Here. Council member place three enter chase? Here. Council member place four can open. Here. Council member place five Laura Deal. Here. I will turn this over to Maria Palmer to call the role for planning and zoning. I'm actually gonna do that for you tonight. Chair. Chair Christine Johnson. Here. Vice Chair Destiny Vargas. Here. Secretary Beverly Gaither? Commissioner Trisha Colbert. Commissioner Raj Mandalga. Commissioner Camille Hoover. Commissioner Don Bryant. Alternate Commissioner Jacob Coleman. Alternate Commissioner Amanda Turner. Chair. And let the record show that Camille is here at 602. Chair, if you have a certify the presence of a forum, and mayor certify the presence of a forum for council. Thank you. All right. Is it going to be run a little bit differently? Because we're running this as a joint. Christine and I are going to be echoing each other quite a bit tonight. We are going to go into public comments.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com