The Board of Zoning Appeals for Indianapolis met on July 9, 2024, at 6:00 PM. All five board members were present: Chairperson Craig Von Dale, Beth Brandon, Tom Barnes, James Duke, and Patrice Duckett Brown. The meeting covered procedural matters, continuances, an expedited case, and three regular public hearings. Key decisions included granting variances for a carport, a large residential project on Sunset Lane, and denying a commercial contractor use and oversized pole barn.
Public testimony was given during individual case hearings, summarized in the case sections below.
Multiple continuances were granted, all to the August 13, 2024 hearing without additional notice:
One case was heard under the expedited process:
Petitioner: Ted Darnell for J. Lilly LLC sought a variance to reduce the side yard setback from 5 feet to 3 feet for an 8-foot-wide carport. He argued practical difficulty due to limited space and safety, and noted that neighboring structures have similar reduced setbacks. Staff: Recommended denial, stating the hardship was self-imposed (the house was built wider than originally permitted) and that alternatives existed (e.g., street parking). Outcome: The board granted the variance on a 4-1 vote (Tom Barnes dissenting).
Petitioner: Attorney Misha Rabinowich for owners David and Victoria Temple sought variances for a 50-foot front yard setback (93 feet required) and a 135-foot-wide driveway (30 feet permitted) to accommodate their nearly completed $5 million home. They cited steep topography, unique lot shape, historic landscape features, and a city error in issuing permits. Support came from the neighbor to the south, Michael Freewald, who stated the house enhances property values. Remonstrance: Attorney Murray Clark for Phil and Nicole Grove (north neighbor) argued the house is out of character with the historic, low-density community and severely impacts privacy. The town executive (Mayor Bill Lawson) and the Crows Nest Neighborhood Association also opposed, citing inconsistency with DS zoning and the National Register historic district. An alternative plan that would comply with a deeper setback was presented by RWA architects. Staff: Recommended denial of the setback variance (but suggested a compromise of 83 feet) and approval of the driveway variance. Staff acknowledged the lot’s topography but found the 50-foot setback a significant deviation from the neighborhood pattern. Outcome: The board granted both variances unanimously (5-0), accepting the petitioner’s arguments of practical difficulty and fundamental fairness due to the city’s permit error.
Petitioner: Alan Atwell for Gonzalo Ariola sought variances to operate a commercial construction contractor from a home (not permitted in D3 zoning) and to build a 1600 sq. ft. pole barn (larger than the primary dwelling). They argued the barn would store equipment and materials, reducing visual impact, and that similar structures exist nearby. Remonstrance: Pat Andrews of the Decatur Township Civic Council, along with neighbor Tim McWarter, opposed. They cited code enforcement violations, drainage concerns from nearby Newton Creek, and incompatibility with the residential neighborhood. The 2018 Trotter’s Landing commitments prohibit mini barns larger than 10x12 ft. Staff: Recommended denial, finding the use self-imposed and too intensive for the D3 district, and that a smaller ordinance-compliant barn could be built. No practical difficulty linked to the property itself. Outcome: The board denied the variance on a 4-1 vote (James Duke voted in favor, all others against).
The board has copies of the zoning ordinance that will be incorporated by reference into the record of each case heard today. The proceedings of this hearing are governed by the board's rules of procedure. The expedited cases will be heard immediately after all requests for continuances or withdrawals. As each non-expedited case is called, petitioners and demonstrators interested in that particular case will please stand. Those who intend to testify will please remain standing and be sworn. Statements and arguments in support of the petition. Statements and arguments in opposition to the petition. Staff will then present the administrator's comments regarding the petition. No further evidence, statements or arguments will be heard unless it is at the discretion of the board. These conditions and commitments are an integral part of the board's decision and must be met for a granted variance to be valid. Compliance with conditions imposed by the board must be approved by an affidavit of compliance submitted by the petitioner within 30 days of completion. Unless otherwise specified, an improvement location permit must be obtained prior to the establishment of the authorized improvements. Failure to comply with any conditions or commitments of a variance grant is a violation enforceable by the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services. A person may file a written request to receive notice of the filing of petition for judicial review of a decision of the board. The written request must be filed within five days of the board's decision and must include the person's full name and correct mailing address and a reference to the board's petition number. Forums are available and may be obtained from the board secretary. Please be advised that contacting members of the board regarding a matter pending before the board outside of this public hearing process is prohibited. Please be courteous and orderly at all times. And please be sure all cell phone ringers are turned off. There are only oh, we have a full board today, so that should not be a problem. If your petition, okay, if there's anyone in the audience who has any questions about our procedures. None being seen, before we hear special requests, I'll ask for a waiver of our rules of procedure to allow the board to vote for all expedited petitions and adopt their findings of fact without any additional testimony from the individual petitioners. Do I hear a motion to do so? Brandon, so moved. And a second. Duke, second. And I'll ask for the vote. Brandon. Brandon, yes. Barnes. Barnes, yes. Duke. Duke, yes. Doug Brown, yes. And I am also yes. Um before we move on to the rest of our agenda, I will ask for approval of our meetings from a previous or our uh minutes from our last meeting. Um were there any amendments to those minutes? None being seen. I'll ask for a motion to approve those minutes. Brandon, so moved. And a second. Duke, second. Um, and I'll go ahead and just by consensus, they are are they approved? Yes. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience who has any questions? Oh, sorry, moving on. We will consider special requests of the continuances at this time. Um 2415. Yeah, please state your name and address first and then the case.