This meeting of the Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals (or similar body) considered several variance requests, including a convenience store redevelopment on Shelby Street and a new single-family home on Wright Street. The board unanimously approved four consent calendar items and granted variances for the convenience store. For the Wright Street property, the board approved setbacks and open space variances but the vote on a front-loaded carport was not completed in the available transcript.
Rod Bohannan votes yes. Joanna Taft votes yes. Percy Bland votes yes, and Brian Hannon votes yes. That variance is granted. On case 2025-DV3-013, Rod Bohannon votes yes. Joanna Taft votes yes. Percy Bland votes yes, and Brian Hannon votes yes. That variance is granted. On case 2025-DV3-014, Rod Bohannon votes yes. Joanna Taft votes yes. Percy Bland votes yes, and Brian Hannon votes yes. That variance is granted. On case 2025-UV3-015, Rod Bohannon votes yes. Joanna Taft votes yes. Percy Bland votes yes, and Brian Hannon votes yes. That variance is granted. And on case 2025-UV3-010, Rod Bohannon votes yes. Joanna Taft votes yes. Percy Bland votes yes, and Brian Hannon votes yes. That variance is granted. Okay, let's proceed to the full hearing. These are petitions for public hearing. Case number 2024-DV3-037 amended. Property address 1625 Shelby Street. Center Township, Council District No. 18, zoned C3 TOD. The petitioner is Jugod LLC, represented by David Rutherford. Variants of development standards of the consolidated zoning and subdivision ordinance to provide for the construction of a convenience store with a front building line width ratio of 10.64, 80% required, and deficient transparency along Shelby Street, 40% required, and with deficient landscaping. Will those who plan to speak on this case please raise their right hand to be sworn in? Do you swear or affirm that the testimony you will give is the truth and nothing but the truth? I do. Allergies. Excuse me. My name is David Rutherford. I'm a zoning attorney down on the southeast side of Indianapolis at 8801 Southeastern Avenue. And first of all, if you look at this case, you'll see we continue this booger a lot. And I want to thank you for letting us do that. This was really an unusual scenario where the input from the neighborhood associations was really important, not only to my client, but I think also to the board. And the good news is we were actually able to hop through the various hoops to get to the right people and get some uh information back, and we actually have the support of this petition from the Fountain Merchants Association, which is which is something we really were critically looking for here. Um we don't, as you can see, have any remonstrance at all. Um there's been a lot of discussion with the neighbors. And there's also been a lot of changes in this site from when it was first uh or this case since it was first filed. Um is it possible that we could put like maybe the locator map up there so we could help everybody understand where we're looking at, and then follow it up with a site plan when we get ready for that. The property is located at the intersection of uh Shelby Street and Pleasant Run. And if you are familiar with the site at all, you'll know it's it's an island. It's a tiny little site, it's very sharp, triangular. That's you can kind of see it there. Um, and by the time you it's a quarter acre in size, and that's before you take into account the setbacks. So we have um from the very beginning, we have a couple of fairly unusual practical difficulties with any use on this site, and that is the presence of two streaks, sharp triangle, the the impact of the setbacks. Um but actually the most significant um issue is that we have an existing gas station that's been there since from the staff report sometime in the early 70s.