The Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission (IHPC) held its regular monthly hearing on Wednesday, September 2, 2026, at 5:30 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The meeting covered approval of August minutes, policy updates, a brick change for a hotel project, an enforcement action on a property in disrepair, and a public hearing on a proposed new single-family house in the Cottage Home Conservation District. The commission voted to approve the policy updates, the brick substitution, and the new house with stipulations, while directing staff to pursue enforcement and a progress report for the Burgess Avenue property.
2026-COA-206 (Cottage Home) – 929 Stillwell Street – Matthew Peyton, applicant: The applicant, Matthew Peyton (Pat Architecture, 6219 Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis), presented revised plans for a two-story single-family residence with a detached three-car garage connected by a breezeway. Changes from the previous hearing included: greater separation of the two front gables, recessing the chimney from the front facade, reducing the size of the south gable, adding windows to the garage to make it more cottage-like, and modifying the fence to have a lower 42-inch section in the middle with a taller privacy section near the patio. The property owner, Jason Owens (929 Norman Street, Indianapolis), spoke briefly, expressing willingness to adjust the fence further.
Staff Position: Morgan (staff) recommended denial, stating the proposal remains non-compliant with the Cottage Home Conservation Area Plan due to excessive height, massing, scale, and complexity. Staff acknowledged the garage windows were an improvement but believed the design still needed reworking.
Commission Discussion:
The applicant agreed to work with staff on the fence and provide a roof plan.
That's really true. It's like old. It's really cool though. If it works, it works. Yeah. Let's get down to business. How's the chair? I keep forgetting. Sooner or later you're gonna get the whole commission. That's my goal. That's my whole thing. Everyone's getting West Allen. What do you want? Lemon know. I even deliver, ask Susan. She got a chair. A very beautiful chair. David's got barstools. Yeah, who's next? Make them a bonus here. I don't know. Yeah. I'm won't make them all once. I'm gonna give them that 2500. Make it all the way. No, if you guys get engaged, I'll get you something from Sonoma. But it's a hundred dollars. I know that I think we can't do this because I thought it's a hundred dollars. You want like a Dutch edit or something? Some like crusade. I think the plan we don't have one. I'll get you one. Get engaged. You watch it. Oh my god. What's that shining on the screen? What is this? Oh, that's my COI appear. I can't. This is like just a mirror of my screen. I can't like duplicate it like the other one, so it's my biggest reason I don't like this one. Oh shit. Right? My family doesn't like books. Do they have brisket at 5 a.m.? Yes, 7 a.m. Breakfast. Yeah. All right. Good evening.