0:03It is approximately 4 03, and we're calling the meeting for finance committee to order.
0:10At this time, we have special guests today for finance committee meeting.
0:15This meeting is going to be centered around energy.
0:18At our last meeting, we had questions about energy.
0:22Energy is normally one of the larger items on our claims docket.
0:26This meeting will only deal with numbers, bills, et cetera.
0:30Things that deal with the budget.
0:32It will not be a direct what conversation with energy about any problems or anything else.
0:37It's strictly about the figures that we pay energy and trying to figure out what we have been billed for, how to reduce costs, and basically it's about street lights and not about utilities in buildings.
0:51At this time, I'll let Energy introduce themselves, and they have provided information that they'll be going over.
0:57And at the end of their presentation, we can have questions and answers, but not in between.
1:17Delana Jones with NGG Mississippi.
1:19I am the manager of Region Customer Service for Jackson's area.
1:28My name is Victoria Love, Customer Service Manager for Entergy for the Jackson area.
1:34And my name is Andrew Mitchell.
1:36I'm the lighting coordinator for Energy Mississippi.
1:56So as councilwoman Clay mentioned, we are here to discuss the street lighting concerns that you all have voiced to us.
2:04What we have in front of you, just to kick it off with the lighting piece of what entergy owns and what is held in the responsibility of the city.
2:15If you look through our documentation, and I apologize, we did not number the images themselves, but this is just to give an outlay of who covers what within the city of Jackson.
2:28So on the first image, you can see that across Old Kenton Road near exit 100, these are M.Dot lighting facilities.
2:36So MDOT will be the owner of that light or those lightings.
2:40If you keep flipping, you'll see high street on the east side of 55 North.
2:53Right in front of about Whataburger, that's when energy picks up the lighting, and I believe that's mixed ownership.
3:04So if you keep flipping through the documentation, it will give the descriptions and just give an area view of what energy owns, what the city of Jackson owns, what is mixed ownership, and then what MDOT owns as well.
3:19So I'd be I'd be happy to continue speaking through these images, but if you all would prefer to look at them on your own time, then we could do that.
3:29So one concern that we have heard um is street lighting.
3:34So just to let you all know, we have about 22,000, and that's approximate, 22,000 street lights within the city of Jackson.
3:43Um do you have that exact number?
3:4622, 22,254 lights within the city of Jackson.
3:52As of now, or as of yesterday, we did a we did an assessment to confirm how many outages are occurring within the city, and it is less than one percent.
4:02We have about 63 outages within the city of Jackson as of now.
4:07So we know that has been one of the concerns.
4:09If you look at the other document that has been provided to you, that is the reporting street light outages document.
4:19This this document right here, it is the reporting streetlight outages document that helps you share with your constituents how they can report streetlight outages within the city of Jackson.
4:32Keep in mind that we have a three business day commit to perform our streetlight repairs, unless there is some additional issues or damage that has been taken place or that has taken place with the that the lights themselves.
4:47But for the we try to maintain that three business day commit for any street light outages and those simple repairs.
4:54So just to let you know where we stand on the street lights, um, as far as amount as well as how many are currently out.
5:10All right, as far as billing, um currently the city is being billed a base rate of 344,626 and 44 cents a month, and that's the base rate, not including the um riders and fuel charge.
5:29We did um a couple of weeks ago speak with the city in reference to a increase to that current rate due to a billing.
5:39We had a billing system upgrade um that caused billing to be paused for municipalities, and once that upgrade was corrected, um, those charges were um updated.
5:53So no installs, removes, or exchanges had been billed to municipalities.
5:59So any um you know, lighting exchanges that were done, any new installs that were done, and that's included on the handout that I that you have that says entry lease lighting estimate.
6:14So this is all the signed lighting agreements that we have since um 2019, where we have either exchange lights and upgrading them to LED or added new lights, um, like the project on highway 18.
6:30So all of those were included within this um billing uh conversion, and that changed the uh price of your bills, which is now gonna be 360,000 183 cent, 183.50 cent.
6:50Yes, 360, 183.50 cents.
6:56Now entity did decide to not do any back billing on those of installs for that time frame that the billing was paused, so that did save approximately 447,244 and 26 cents, and we also will not bill for any conversion fees, and that's for any light swaps that were swapped over to LED, and that came up to around 47,545 and 38 cents.
7:24So we will start billing for conversion fees for any light going forward, but not during the time frame where the billing was paused.
7:34And just to add a little clarity, the bill itself wasn't paused.
7:38You were still receiving a bill.
7:40We just did not perform that update.
7:43So you were receiving the same bill without the updates that are taking place due to various projects.
7:51Can you um time the question asked questions now?
7:55Yes, when they get finished.
7:56Oh, I thought they were finished.
8:00Have you provided us with the information you're reading?
8:02Yes, we we had a meeting.
8:04Um, no, I don't have not the bill amount.
8:08No, I didn't provide that.
8:10No, I've provided the um agreements that were signed.
8:24So anything that you're requesting, we can send that to the upgrades that they're speaking of in the bills have not reflected yet that we'll move forward with the April billing cycle.
8:36So we can send you a copy of what the previous months bill is.
8:40That's very in terms of the pause and update that should have remained the same for those months because we did not upload all of the changes, the conversion of the day that is taking place.
8:52Of course, with LED conversions when we began this process, there was a per light fee.
8:59There was a per light fee to convert and entergy waived those fees due to the delay in updating the billing.
9:08So it's like $32.71, which was agreed upon and understood by the previous administration when they signed for us to move forward with those conversions.
9:23Anything else you guys want to present to us about billing or anything at this point before we open for questions.
9:30I would like to mention um the fuel rate rider has increased since that billing Victoria just shared, which was I think 344,000.
9:42Um, so your bill for March 2026, and I believe for February as well, is already within the 404,000 uh price range, and that's due to the fuel to the fuel rate rider um changing, and the cost is a little different.
10:00It it increased per se.
10:01Um, but that's just due to the fuel rate itself and what was approved by the Mississippi Public Service Commission.
10:08And that that fuel adjustment rider is a credit, so the credit amount decrease, which you made the bill go up.
10:16So yeah, it is still a credit, but that amount is less now.
10:24I would like to add they we've given you a quantity of lights, but your bill reflects poles that are street light only poles.
10:35Typically, the lights are installed on our distribution poles, which would be no charge to you to use that pole, but if it is if it is a street light only pole specifically for the purpose of a light, there's a charge associated with that.
10:48There could be a charge associated with additional facilities to serve that light, such as transformers, um underground wiring.
10:58So there's the breakdown other than lights that goes into making up that bill.
11:03So you don't divide 300,000 dollars divide.
11:07That is one proposal, if I'm not mistaken.
11:11But that's not you that's not in the no, that's I'm just what I'm saying is the 22,000 light count that she gave you.
11:21There are additional facilities that are associated with the bill.
11:26You don't have a copy of a bill, you have a copy of a sign proposal that was accepted, that was presented to the previous administration and accepted for us to proceed with that conversion or installation, but for a bill itself, we don't have a copy of that that you can't get that back to what I'm saying is when you pay the bill, when you're paying for street lighting, that could also include total transformers that are necessary to serve the transformers' purpose is only to serve the street lights.
12:00It's not like just say, for instance, you're on a block, a neighborhood block, and you have houses and you have a transformer that's serving those houses.
12:10You would not be charged for that transformer because the purpose of that transformer is serving those houses, which is already covered.
12:17But if you were to go along a boulevard and just want to put poles and lights up, there are no transformers to trans to um to to drop the voltage, you would be charged a per a facilities charge for that because that equipment is solely for the purpose of those lights.
12:36So what I'm saying is not only are there lights that you are paying for, there are facilities.
12:41If you choose to have underground, if you want to have lights run underground, there's a charge for that, whether it's trenching or boring under the street, that underground wiring that is a secondary cost, so that cost is passed along to the customer.
12:57And you provide that too.
12:59Andrew, we we can yes, sir.
13:02Yeah, we can um all this is like you have 22,000 lights within the city, but as Robbie's saying, there's other equipment as well, but we have all that on our books, so we could give that to you.
13:13What all's included in your street light monthly costs?
13:16We could give that to you.
13:17So you need the breakdown of everything.
13:24On how the um the components of the bill that what that was 344,626, and now it's I guess it's uh whatever it was, 44,000, something, whatever it is.
13:39What are the the uh components?
13:41Some of the stuff is stuff you own, some of the stuff is stuff we own.
13:45Uh then there's kilowatt hours, and I don't know if kilowatt hours are part of the components.
13:49Can you tell us how it comes up to 344,626 a month?
13:58Yeah, so the way that street lighting works is there's a rate schedule, and there's different rate schedules.
14:03There's one for LED lighting, there's one for HPS, like old lighting, and the rate commission approves this, but every light has a the rate commission, the public service public service commissioner.
14:16So they approve, they help approve the rates to a rate admin process.
14:20And so every single light has a base rate that's approved by them.
14:24So for instance, the lower lumen LED lights, there's probably a lot of them within the city.
14:32They are $12.77 per light per month.
14:37That's a monthly fee that the city is paying for that light.
14:41Now, with Rob, what we're saying goes into that as well.
14:44There's also equipment that's on your street lighting books as well, whether if that's a transformer that's just serving a light, or it could be a boring cost.
15:05Your new base rate is actually going to be 360,000.
15:10That's the base rate prices.
15:13So the if is there um what happens if a light goes out and it doesn't get turned in or don't get fixed.
15:26We still paying the 12.70 cents a month, even though it's burned out.
15:30Yes, that's correct.
15:32But if there's any kind of documentation, and this is on there, this is customer service hub, but if there's any kind of documentation that it has been reported, and for whatever reason, energy's not getting that to us, I'm sure you could present that to us and we could have a further conversation about what needs to happen for that.
15:50That'd be hard for us to keep track of if there's 2020 of them for us to document, you know.
15:58Oh, there's a light over here on Timbuktu that that was out for the last three weeks or whatever.
16:02I uh you can't expect us to to be able to track all that down and then report it to you all.
16:08Well, let me add so our team does perform night patrols just to go around the city, confirm what may be out that we obviously won't see in the daytime, um, just so we can keep an eye on what is taking place within the city itself.
16:24So we have our team that performs those um on a frequent basis.
16:28I can't confirm the the timeline of that, but they do perform that on a frequent basis, just to ensure that um the lights are working as they should, and I think that has helped with us having such a low outage count within the total 22,000 out uh lights that we have within the city of Jackson.
16:46Man, I tell you uh one percent.
16:47I have a hard time believing it.
16:49My trips around town, particularly down in uh you know wide areas of highway 80 and Pascagoula and Pearl Street.
16:57I've got driven out there when it's completely black, there's no lights at all working.
17:01And so it's hard for me to imagine that our allegiance late is really one percent.
17:04So I'm I'm I have a hard time believing that.
17:07But that aside, but the if I can add okay to clarify on those night patrols, that's the major thoroughfares.
17:14Okay, we don't go neighborhood street by street.
17:17We're talking about the neighborhood, the uh the major thoroughfares.
17:20Perl and Pastor Law are major thoroughfares.
17:23But there is a there's also, and that was in the handout.
17:27We didn't go to that detail, but there is a combination of um what we call, I guess we could say mixed, that may not be the best word.
17:35We have a combination of lights downtown where the city owns the pole and the underground wiring, and entergy owns the fixture itself.
17:46So, how does that how do we pay for that?
17:48How's that what's the rate on that?
17:49You're paying for the light, the fixture itself, not the pole.
17:53So we're just paying for like $12.70 for the light.
17:56Depending on the wattage of that light, you could be paying because the the lights can go anywhere from a hundred watts to 400 watts.
18:04Okay, that was the high pressure sodium, but as we're transitioning to LED, those numbers are changing.
18:10But certain some streets have larger what uh larger wattage lights as opposed to what you may have in the residential area.
18:17They wouldn't want a 400 watt on their street.
18:19It's just too much light, and then again, that's a higher cost that you may not authorize.
18:24You just want the typical residential 100 watt light.
18:29So, in terms of the outage, that there is a document that you have that shows how to report street lights out in our app.
18:37So we communicate that via social media, we communicate that through um radio advertising, various forms of advertising.
18:44We share that with homeowners associations, we've shared that information with you.
18:49That's something that you can post on the city's website, but it makes it easy for customers themselves to call in and say there's a street light in front of my house that's out, give the address, and that light is then reported, and we can then uh prepare to respond to repair that light.
19:05So do we gonna stop your question?
19:08Okay, but we're gonna have a time limit so we can get through before five o'clock, and then we'll come back if that's okay, okay?
19:17Let's let's just we're gonna limit our time to each council person the first time around to four minutes, and then we'll come back.
19:25And they may have to come back another day, but we want to get through billing and understand what's going on.
19:33Um, I'm gonna keep okay.
19:51Okay, I'm gonna keep my questions targeted on the financial components per surprise's request.
20:00You mentioned the the base rate initially 344, now 360, and you mentioned that does not include fuel and something else.
20:08I didn't hear the other component you of what else it would include.
20:14There's also riders.
20:15Um there is a first you get a municipal municipal street light discount.
20:21Um that's included in the bill, um, a formula rate plan rider, which is the light rider, or a storm damage mitigation restoration rider, and a fuel adjustment.
20:33Those are also included that's not in that base rate.
20:40So fuel fluctuates on a month by month basis.
20:44Is that the only variance?
20:47The only thing that will change from month to month is how much fuel is used.
20:53So those three riders, um you can see them on your bill.
21:00The riders can change month by month, but it would be very slight.
21:05But those riders, how they're calculated on their bill is there by the kilowatt hours, which is a set number based upon the amount of lights that you have.
21:14So for instance, your your previous bill, those 22,000 lights that you had, the kilowatt hours for those lights were a hundred and make sure I say this right.
21:28So one million two hundred and eighty thousand three hundred and thirty-seven kilowatt hours.
21:35That's a that's a set number that's playing into those riders.
21:40Okay, and for the uninformed is would a if a street light is out, does that contribute to kilowatt hours?
21:49Um it's a it's a set number, like each light has a set number of kilowatt hours.
21:55So, like uh C2, they mentioned the uh lower lumen LED light that has a 24 kilowatt hour set number.
22:05It's not gonna fluctuate based on light on or not.
22:08Is that a set number if it works?
22:12Let me add in the base rate that you pay for a light, the kilowatt hours estimated to be used is included in that cost, so you're not charged for kilowatt hours monthly.
22:28Your credit or your charge for the fuel per kilowatt hours is there, but the the base rate that you pay, you're these lights are not metered, so it's not like at your house where you your usage is going through a meter.
22:42So that is again that is a calculation that Energy has come up with to set these prices and present it to the public service commission for approval.
22:52So kilowatt hours are not billed to answer your question.
22:56If that light is not working, those kilowatt hours aren't deducted, but the fuel charge is per kilowatt hour.
23:03So that was the number, the one million number that Andrew gave you.
23:07So that pretty much would stay the same unless you're adding or removing lights from the bill.
23:15And just to just to give you one in particular, the highway 18 lighting project is a new project over a year and a half.
23:26So that was not that's a part of what that don't get me wrong.
23:31It didn't make the entire increase in the bill because there were other lights that were added here and there.
23:38Customer of constituent call in and say we need additional light on our street.
23:42You all authorize it.
23:43It was not a light there previously.
23:46Those are the type lights that made up the bill increase that we due to technical issues, had not updated until current day that we're speaking of.
23:58How do you think billing is going with the city?
24:04I think I think it's pretty much apparent that it's a gray area for you all, and you don't understand.
24:12And so we need to break that bill down and present it to you in a way that you can understand.
24:18It's not as easy as looking at your own personal bill.
24:21Your kilowatt hours fluctuates monthly.
24:25It fluctuates monthly, but when we when we prepare those presentations, we don't expect the summer months.
24:32I'm using my air conditioning, my kilowatt hours are gonna go up.
24:35That's not what it's going to happen on street lights because it's just a set number of of uh kilowatt hours that we are basing that on so that we don't have to go around and have meters everywhere for all of the street lights that are in place.
24:49I think also that for the most part we're paying for our bills, regardless of whether half the lights in the city are working or not working, makes it crucially important that as many lights are on as possible.
25:07Many of us want to see even more lighting, but will we're paying this rate, and to hear let me make sure I understand.
25:17When you say one percent, you mean one percent of the people have reported it on this app.
25:25I heard you say this makes it easy for the citizens.
25:28It is not easy for the citizens.
25:32Okay, we're gonna let you close out with that question here from there.
25:53Which is what determines dust to dawn, the light coming on.
25:56If it's anything more than that, a voltage, a wiring problem, a failed fixture.
26:03We cannot make it in that three-day, it may have to go back.
26:07Yes, you are paying.
26:09But the understanding in the best case scenario, people are actually notifying you, either filling out the app or calling you.
26:17That's relying on citizens because we have a night patrol, which I I don't believe exists, but to the extent that it does exist, it's only going on major thoroughfares.
26:28And even that it's not even nightly, it's a quarterly or an annually or whatever, whatever.
26:35This is the this is about our budget.
26:37I understand that, but Miss Ms.
26:39Brown has four minutes, and then we'll come back.
26:41I know you can pause your thought.
26:49And I was listening on um why I was in route here, and you say it's a night patrol, because my area is South Jackson, and I have a lot of lights out.
27:01That is my major complaints.
27:03I get several calls every day about lights out.
27:08And also some of my concentrants, they have said that they call the 1-800, but don't let them never be done.
27:16They report these lights.
27:19Well, that's that's good feedback for us to hear from the customers who are attempting to make these reports and they're not successful in that.
27:27That's the feedback that we need so that we can continuously improve our processes.
27:31Um, because we do offer those three ways for customers to report streetlight outages, but we do want to be sure that the options that we provided them are proving beneficial for them.
27:41So I appreciate you providing us with that feedback.
27:44Um, and to provide clarity on the night patrols so they can take place before um it's kind of like a dust to dawn kind of thing while the sun is not out, just so we can see what lights are currently active, so we can have a better tally of what is out.
27:59Because if the sun is up, we won't be able to see it.
28:01So our team makes those patrols in the morning before the sun rises or at night.
28:07So, what can you tell me the best way to report these lights so I can take it back to my constituents in reference to what to do?
28:15I believe all three options, and they would have to determine which option is best for them.
28:19Um, if you ask me, I would like to report it on the app.
28:22It's just a little easier for me, but someone may not be as tech savvy, may not be willing to use the app.
28:28So that's why we have the the number that's still available, so you can just simply make a call.
28:33Some people are not fond of making calls, so there's a website opportunity as well.
28:38So I think showing and displaying all three options would be the best thing, and having and making sure that they have that awareness of hey, you don't just have to use the app, you can also call in and then use the website if necessary.
28:50So I still have all three options available for everyone.
28:53And just one more thing is in reference to it.
28:56It's also in reference to other things.
28:59I talked to Miss Love in reference to the contractor, they did some work in my ward and I sent her the pictures.
29:05They left trash, they left the equipment, everything in someone a yard, and I got complaints about that.
29:12Well, I apologize that you had to experience that, and like I said, that's some feedback that we need to receive as well.
29:17That way we can better define to you all um instead of an expect expectation for our customers, your constituents when it comes to some of the projects or um the work that we're performing on a daily basis or whether it's storm related, just so you all can have that expectation of what to uh expect during those times.
29:37But I appreciate you providing that feedback and feel free to share that information with us real time so we can address it and make a and have a resolution for it.
29:45And I'll also add on the street light reporting with reporting it on the app, it pins point it pinpoint the exact light that's out when it's reported.
29:55Versus sometimes when a customer calls the light in, um, if they don't have that poll number, they just say, you know, light out on Capitol Street.
30:02If we send someone out during the daytime, they don't know which light it is.
30:06So, you know, we ask that either they, you know, if they can supply the poll number or the nearest house address to where that light is out, so that we'll be able to find that light, but reporting it on the out of pinpoints the exact light and give the location of where that light is.
30:24Yes, uh, hopefully just very, very quick.
30:27First of all, what is the status for our current contract with energy?
30:33When was last time it went through?
30:36Uh when is it up for review?
30:39Anyone know any of that information?
30:41Municipal municipal street lighting is something that we offer in the entergy Mississippi territory.
30:46The 45 counties we serve, municipal street lighting.
30:49Jackson, but we don't we don't review, we don't have uh renewals on contracts.
30:55If you decide that you no longer want lights, or if you want the lights that we have in place taken down, that is something that you notify us and we remove the lighting.
31:05And I understand what my my question is right now we have certain fees, okay, and we have to agree upon that as a city, correct?
31:15And we sound uh the city signs some kind of agreement with the entity.
31:20A letter of authorization if you are requesting additional lighting.
31:24Okay, that's additional lighting.
31:26I'm just wondering when I'm not trying to make this complicated when does it come up for review or change, or it has to be something that's asked for by the city.
31:36Is that what I'm hearing?
31:38I'm I'm not clear on what what has to be asked.
31:42Well, uh, normally we deal with contracts here.
31:44Okay, contracts come up for renewal, okay, and then there are clauses in the contract where this have to happen, this and this and this.
31:52Uh, and so that's different with energy.
31:54I'm seeing as far as street lighting.
31:56So I and I think it's very important that you that uh energy provide to this board uh the details of how I mean your menu, what's charges for this and that because it seemed like there's a lot of different things going on that's gonna affect our bottom line.
32:13And as a time when we're looking to do cuts in the city, and we have major, we have some uh financial issues.
32:20We're looking at the details.
32:22We need to know those details.
32:24And so if we need to make changes to that arrangement, we can make changes, but it has to be informed changes.
32:31Who is the city's contact that you all normally talk with concerning the the money side of things?
32:38Stevenson, can you answer those questions for Mr.
32:44I'm gonna defer to energy on that, and the city's contact is not me.
32:52Victoria Love is your customer service manager.
32:54We respond to the city and their request for meetings.
32:59This is the third meeting that I'm aware of this year alone.
33:02Okay, what I'm what I'm asking is when you go when those changes are made, and we said, hey, we need to change this, this, and this, and this, and it's gonna reflect in your budget.
33:13Who do you normally talk with?
33:15Um, we talked with several different people within the city.
33:18Um, we've talked to um Angela Brown, Ms.
33:22Brown, we've talked to um Lorenzo Anderson, Von Anderson, um James Caldwell as well.
33:33Um but finance side, the money side, who are you talking to?
33:38Well, that's whoever reached out to us from the city.
33:41We don't talk to anyone, if someone from the city's financial, which was the meeting that they had two weeks ago.
33:47We just we were requested to attend.
33:50We need to get okay.
33:51We need on our side, we can't get that money.
33:53And I will say that all of the riders are approved by the customer um public service commission, so all of that is online.
34:00We can we can provide you those writers that's included in your bill.
34:06Well, and Councilman Hartley, I do want to address your question.
34:09So thank you for providing clarity.
34:11Um, the letter of authorization, so that LOA that Robbie was referring to is the form or contract type form that we have.
34:19We don't necessarily have a contract agreement, but the LOA is used in that case.
34:24Um, to Victoria's point, the writers are approved by the public service commission.
34:30Um, and if that's something that you all would like to be notified of during those changes so that you can make those necessary adjustments, um, then we can continue working to be sure that we can provide you with some necessary information as it arises, but the public service commission's information is also public, so we can work towards um providing additional information, but the contract is a little different on this side, it's more of a LOA.
34:52I hope that clears up a not much.
35:04Okay, I just want to make one comment.
35:06We're very pleased that energy is here today.
35:09This is the first time that energy has actually met with our council and going through a bill.
35:14We know it's gonna take time for us to understand what the bill is.
35:17Several of us have been on the council longer than others, and um we respect energy and we want to work with energy and we want lights in our city, and we understand the importance of lights, and maybe we as a city need to help come up with a way to report lights out because sometimes we know what's actually out, and I know myself I've made calls to energy, and I told them how many polls were out, et cetera, and they came instantly and corrected it.
35:44So as we see things out, we need to report it, and I'm not saying that based on a bill or any service or anything.
35:51I agree we all want the city lit, but if you don't know it's dark or where those polls are, they don't know.
35:59Thank you, madam chair.
36:01The um appreciate y'all being here today, and um Miss Love, you've helped me out in the past on on some issues.
36:06I appreciate that as well.
36:08Um I'm frustrated, not with y'all, but with the setup for this situation, and my frustration is that um this is part may partly maybe part this public service commission.
36:22But my frustration is so they they they have these lights, 22,254 street lights.
36:28I guess that those are the ones that entergy owns, and we've got other lights, and some of them are M DOT lights, and some of them are City of Jackson lights, and then there's a rate schedule that's come up with by the public service commission that they have authorized, um, and we have 1,280,337 kilowatt hours that are estimated what must have been an estimate that what our lights will um how much power they will use if they're all operating, okay.
37:00And then uh the problem is a lot of them are operating, and I think the one percent number from our you know thing is disingenuous to say the only one percent of Jackson's lights are operating, or one or not functioning.
37:17I think the number is more like 10 percent, some gigantic number, and it's it's a matter of public safety, it's a matter of crime, it's a matter of uh providing a safer environment for our citizens.
37:29So this is a really big important issue for us, and I know it's an important issue for entergy as well, but just relying on the citizens to like I drive down highway sometimes, I'll see a whole bunch of lights out, but I'm going 40 miles an hour, and I can't figure out what the poll number is.
37:44I'm driving 40 miles an hour at night.
37:47You'd have to have a damn X-ray thing on top of your cart to know what the number is.
37:51So my frustration let me finish.
37:54Let me finish because it's not five o'clock yet.
38:00The uh so we got a real because there's a disconnect here between uh the service being provided and the billing and the service we're getting.
38:12And I'm not I don't want to blame any particular person, but a system that relies on us reporting a light that's not working or some citizen out there on a highway or whatever it might be when you're driving by at 40 miles an hour.
38:25That is not a good system.
38:28We got to have a better system.
38:30Whether we have to get our policemen to go out and inventory all the lights at once a week, or a fire department or somebody.
38:37We got to come up with a better system so the lights are actually working and we're paying, we're paying the electricity, whether it's being used or not.
38:45That's a you know, that's a win-win for energy.
38:47That if the lights out, then there's not using the electricity, but we're still paying for electricity because it's based on an estimate.
38:53So we we've got to come up with a system for billing and a system for the lights functioning that really deliver the lights for our citizens and makes Jackson a safer place.
39:11Um, one thing that I do want to clarify, and I don't want it to be misinterpreted, is Mississippi Public Service Commission said we could.
39:23They chart they sent the rates.
39:24No, no, no, no, no, no.
39:26Well, they approve the rates that Entergy calculates and justifies.
39:33And the public service commission approves that.
39:36I don't want it mistaken that the public service commission made us do it, told us we could do it, said to do it.
39:44And I'm just saying how others may interpret that.
39:46So the public service commission approves all the rates in the state.
39:49They approve the rates I pay at my house.
39:52So I just don't want us on pays out at wherever you're in.
39:54I don't want that to go, you know, sideways otherwise.
40:00And entergy does not guarantee continuous service.
40:03But here is the problem.
40:04If they I understand that light gets shot out by some, you know, um, gang member.
40:11The but the fact is you're getting paid whether the service is being provided or not, because they use the estimate for all that.
40:18So the the the that you know is is a you know bone of contention from by me.
40:24I realize that you the the rates are determined by the public service commission.
40:29But we've got to come up with a better way, the council and the city and everybody else to make sure those lights are working, operating as much as possible.
40:37Just having an app on your people's phone and relying on them to turn it in to call it in is not sufficient.
40:44That's one you know, one uh part of the solution, but it's not the whole solution.
40:49I I hear you and I understand I do hear you, and I really safety matters a lot.
40:55People feel safer when there's more lights out there.
40:58And to to the to the um explanation that we gave, that was one percent that we have received as reported out that has not been repaired.
41:10So that's there are lights that could possibly be out that have not been reported.
41:16But of what we have received, that's one percent.
41:20If we have a continuous delay in repairing something, I understand that that comment, but I'm just saying, I'm not we're not saying only one percent of the lights are out.
41:31We're saying what has been reported to us that it rem that is currently out as of yesterday's pull of that data is equivalent to less than one percent.
41:41All right, thank you.
41:42And I I do accept your comments related related to improving upon this process.
41:58I just have a it's just a comment.
42:01You know, Atmos sends robots through neighborhoods looking for leaks.
42:07JPD has cameras everywhere, and we can, you know, we we're in an age of a lot of modern technology, and I just believe that the monster that entergy is, we got drones, there's a lot we can do other than just trying to send some guys on a truck through neighborhoods or through therapies late at night.
42:25And that's just all I ask that we look at other technology to see if we can help the customer, which is the seat of Jackson, to better find these outages and get them repaired.
42:37Received and agree, Mr.
42:45The first is on this this related uh item, and and uh just making sure that all the lights are on and functioning.
42:52I like uh our president's suggestion of technology, but even if it's not technology, I wonder if entergy would be willing to provide, or maybe it's something where we split the cost of a small crew that goes not just on major thoroughfares, but when you're talking about a client of of our size, I mean we are paying over 400,000 a month, a month.
43:16It's one of our largest ticket items when we do claims every month.
43:20If we can if we can get um one or two people that doesn't just go in major therapies, but their full-time job, they work the night shift, and their full-time job is to drive around neighborhoods, uh, major thoroughfares, the entire city of Jackson and reports these and gets these lights back on.
43:44Because I think this works exceedingly well if you are somebody who has the time and and know and you know about the system and and all those things, but to rely on individuals reporting this one's out, this one's out, that one's out, and and even if they don't know the exact one, and then someone comes during the day and says nothing I can do because I don't know what I mean.
44:05That just the system is broken.
44:08And so whether we have drones flying around the city or whether we split the cost of a full-time employee uh who can go around and and note these, I think something else I think needs to be done.
44:23Uh so that's the first note that I'll make.
44:25The second note, and and this is to your defense, this is not entergy's fault, but as a city, and Mr.
44:31Tarson, I love your thoughts on this.
44:33We have assembled a Hajjpage where most of the lights are entergy lights, but some are City of Jackson lights, which I don't even know if we have the ability to switch those lights out.
44:46Um, even if and some are like a hybrid where they're half energy, half city of Jackson, and um I don't know.
45:00I mean, I I don't know what can be done about that if we want to revert some of those lights back to entergy and just say every light in the city, entergy is responsible for or whoever.
45:07But this this Hajj, I think it's part of the mass.
45:13Peter Taywatson, CAO.
45:15I agree, Councilman Parkinson.
45:18I think part of the reason for the Hodge Podge historically has been the city has received money at different times from the federal government or the state to install street lights or to install traffic lights and a street light within so many feet or yards.
45:32So they kind of contributed to the hodgepodge was where the funding came from at any given moment.
45:39I don't think the city can just abandon the paid for infrastructure and give it to entergy.
45:44I think there are some legal ramifications there that would pose problematic.
45:49I have a simpler suggestion, uh, which I'm sure will end up not being workable because it's so simple.
45:56I just like a list or a map of everywhere that the city pays for a light.
46:02We could then we've got redundant employees.
46:05Y'all have heard me say that every month.
46:08We could take some redundant employees and then go check the list or check the map to see if they're working.
46:14If they're not, report them to integy and do something along those lines.
46:19And there may be some lights that we should indeed deactivate or turn off.
46:24I know most of us think we need more lights, and there are areas of the city we absolutely need more street lights.
46:30But I also suspect, because I I spend a fair amount of time driving around our city, that there are parts of this city that no longer need the number of street lights they once had, especially if they were in a business or commercial area where those businesses have left.
46:45So my suggestion would be if integy, if you have any way to identify by list or map uh everywhere that the city pays a bill for a street light, that would be super helpful.
46:56Yes, we do have that.
46:57We can provide inventory list of lights.
46:59I can send that via email.
47:02Can y'all look at the fourth page of this that you provided?
47:06It's of the fairgrounds in Pascagoula and Pearl Street.
47:10And help me understand because those lights are out.
47:13So I see it says City of Jackson owns the poles, wires, and street light arms, and then energy and owns and maintains the light fixtures only.
47:22That whole Pascagoula is pitch black.
47:26What is the breakdown?
47:28Is that a light fixture issue?
47:30Is that a pole wire and street light arm issue?
47:33That's a wiring issue.
47:34It's a wiring issue.
47:40Um that solves the problem for why is dark.
47:46Yeah, but it identifies it and it solves it too.
47:52Yeah, we gotta pay for it.
47:56And we don't pay for MDOT.
47:58We don't pay MDOT lighting facilities at all.
48:01MDOT runs that is at the state level, right?
48:06We have previously discussed um entergy taking over those lights on Pascal Street, and also have a proposal of what it will be for us to take over those, take ownership of those lights, so I can provide that to you all as well.
48:23If I can just explain M dot lighting, the high mass lighting that you see out on the interstates on 220, 55, 8 uh 20, the high mast in the medians.
48:38But what often gets confusing in some areas and on the first page of that sketch, if you're taking 55 north, and you take that Meadowbrook exit, and you get on Old Canton Road, those are what we call Cobrahead lights, which you would think are entry lights, but those are M dot as well.
48:59And as you go down South State Street, by Stanley's wine and liquor, those are Cobrahead lights that are leading to the interstate.
49:11Those are M dot lights as well.
49:13So that's the that's the combination of lights that's within the city.
49:27And the May Street Bridge are city-owned lights for my thank you.
49:33Okay, mine is simply this.
49:35We're paying for polls, right?
49:37The city of Jackson is paying for polls.
49:40Yes, some street light only poles.
49:46Not the distribution poles, no, sir.
49:48Okay, and who maintains that?
49:51If the light, if it's an energy, if it's a light street light leased by energy, we maintain that.
49:58You pay for the light, not the pole.
50:01My point is is this.
50:03Um and I'll just be frank with you.
50:06In my ward uh entity does not get big ratings.
50:11A lot of times it comes to the polls, and we need to work that out.
50:15And if we're paying for it, then we just expect the best service, not only for that light, but for polls as well.
50:24We see stuff leaning, we see stuff hanging, we see transformers out, and we report that.
50:30And our report those we send it into our 311 system.
50:34Folks are constantly reporting.
50:36But we have to work that out.
50:37And if we're not paying for it, or if it's not your responsibility, then we're gonna have to find out whose responsibility that is.
50:45I think that's the best point that has been made today that we need to find out who has what responsibility, get the list of polls and work from that and work as a council, work with the city, provide lights to the city, and energy help us, and we as a council work toward doing that.
51:06Coming today, we appreciate you.
51:08And if there are any other questions or if we need to schedule another meeting, but would you please follow up with the bill and the list of polls?
51:16And if each council person is willing to take that list and look at that list based on their ward and see what's what and we get with Mr.
51:24Taverson on extra personnel and try and work through that list.
51:28I think we'll have a bright Jackson.
51:30Miss uh Madam Chair, if we could ask the entry to provide us that breakdown on the list for as the options, so we the money keepers here, we're trying to make the best decisions possible.
51:43We may want some changes to that.
51:45So if you could provide us the breakdown, I know you started out with well, it depends on this, and well, that but so we just need to know all our options on the table.
51:55I'm sorry, you're asking for a breakdown of what, Councilman Harley?
51:59And and and the add-ons and you know what options we actually have.
52:03Yeah, we we can do that.
52:07Any other questions?
52:10If if I may add just one more comment, um, in addition to the list, Victoria's that she would share.
52:17We have shared with the city of Jackson um a mapping of energy owned lights.
52:21That way they can overlay that map and confirm where all the city owned lights are.
52:26We have provided that a few on a few occasions to the city, so we have shared that information, and we're working with the city to ensure um that you all have the information that you all need and trying to help however we can.
52:38Is it just uh a list?
52:40Um just a list of addresses or is it actual map?
52:46So Victoria will provide an actual list, but there's an actual map that we've shared.
52:53Yeah, we we've shared that map and we can share it again if necessary.
52:56Will you share it with the clerk of council and she'll share it with all seven of us?
53:00Give us both the list and the map.
53:02Okay, thank you so much.
53:10Any other comments, but we appreciate you for coming and we look forward to working with you, and we look forward to solving the city's lighting problem and to reduce our cost any way we can.
53:20Thank you for having us.
53:21Thank you for your feedback and your questions.
53:25This meeting is now adjourned.