0:00All right, good afternoon, everybody.
0:01I do show four o'clock, so we're gonna go ahead and we are going to call to order the Capital Improvement Bond Task Force meeting of the City of Jonesboro, Arkansas.
0:09First on our agenda is the roll call.
0:14And if you are currently present today, if you will mark that on the device in front of you.
0:22Do show five members present, so we do have a quorum today.
0:25Moving into our next item of business, we have approval of minutes from our last bond task force meeting.
0:31Move to approve unless there's noted change.
0:35I have a motion and a second to approve the minutes as presented from the previous meeting.
0:40If everything looks to your favor, if you will denote your vote on the device in front of you, please.
0:51Okay, which brings us to the next item today.
0:53Um we were going to begin with public comments, but we're going to be moving that to a little bit later just because we do have some discussion to go through today.
1:02And first, I do want to go ahead and I do want to read a letter that's been prepared on behalf of the mayor today that he submitted since he is out of town.
1:12So it says, and I quote, first off, on behalf of the city administration, I want to thank each council member on this task for taking time to discuss these options for the real-time crime center E911 Center.
1:27I appreciate each of your attention to the facts and want the public to respect that your decisions are based on what you feel is in the best interest of our city.
1:37During the bond process, it was clear that further discussion on these options were needed.
1:42And this task force was created to ensure those discussions were had in total transparency and honesty.
1:50I can't think of any more transparent way than to talk about this in a public forum with factual information.
1:56From the inception of the task force, I have stated I will support whatever recommendation is made.
2:02I instructed city staff to provide information requested by the task force, such as development cost estimates, property offer paperwork, and economic impact analysis by the city's selected master growth planning firm and other various items so members could make an informed decision.
2:20All of which is available on Legistar or has been discussed in the meetings for the public to review for themselves instead of taking a second or third hand opinion, which may not be accurate or worse, intentionally biased.
2:35For those in the public who do not know, it is the mayor's duty to receive offers, negotiate offers, and then present offers or contracts to the city council that merit their discussion.
2:45After talks with police and 911 leadership, the initial thought process was since the current police station property on Caraway can't be sold due to deed restrictions.
2:56That locating the 911 real-time crime center with police admin and CID would allow them more efficient access, and eventually phase two would include construction of a patrol building and the additional Caraway property if purchased.
3:11Ultimately, this would lead to the selling of the Washington property, offsetting new property cost or possibly turning it into a net positive from a financial standpoint after the property sale.
3:23If the Washington property is selected, we will work to create a construction plan that creates the least destruct disruption possible for the current operations.
3:33Just to be clear on a couple of items that may or may not be relevant to this task force, but have been stated by residents in one form or another, and the public deserves clarity on.
3:44One bond funding can only be used to purchase property.
3:49What was said multiple times during the bonding process was that a bond ordinance does not authorize the purchase of property.
3:57A property purchase still requires a separate resolution to approve a land purchase agreement.
4:02Paul Phillips counsel was contacted this afternoon just to triple check on this item.
4:08Number two, I've seen statements that a possible children's museum would somehow be a city project that we would spend taxpayer money on.
4:18Representatives of the museum effort simply stated that they were interested in the property.
4:23Three, some had stated the cost of the Parker property is overpriced.
4:28I believe the average is about $13 a square foot, which is in line with the appraisal of the city ordered property.
4:35If you figure in half the cost of the road and utilities, it's more like $16 a square foot.
4:41Just to provide comparison, recent appraisals on the city owned C3 portion of the property on Johnson were roughly $4 to $5 a square foot.
4:51A recent appraisal on the tower portion of the Citizens Bank property was roughly $70 a square foot.
5:00Obviously, both of those are notably different situations, and downtown property will bring a premium, but it's probably a fair assumption that the property falls somewhere between those two land values.
5:09There have been statements that it should be priced at what the recent mall property auction was.
5:16That was a private auction with multiple other factors that make it unique and is not an accurate comparison.
5:22Number four, a lot of the initial stipulations requested by the seller were removed.
5:28I do think we are down to the bare minimums the seller will accept.
5:32So the latest offer that includes a shared road and utilities that has been shared and placed on Legistar is likely what would be presented to council.
5:41These requests are not secret or hidden.
5:44They are listed in the offer, and it is up to council on if those will be considerations that are worthwhile.
5:51Now on to the Washington property.
5:54One, any new building foundations can be built up enough to avoid flooding concerns.
6:00Cost estimates were based on elevating the building pads several feet to avoid water getting into the building.
6:06During high water events that shut down Washington, the Monroe entrance would be passable.
6:11Number two, estimates were prepared based off city code, which requires that any new construction not increase flooding.
6:21Site plans created meet those requirements.
6:24We would not require that a developer correct larger drainage issues in that area.
6:29So it would have to, it would have been unfair to inflate development figures to address those issues.
6:36Three, at either location, the current justice complex will have to remain intact until the new E911 center is ready for occupation to ensure continuity of emergency services.
6:50And finally, during all these discussions, it is important to not lose sight of the fact that this is a good problem to have.
6:57We are debating about where to physically place an expanded center and add more life-saving personnel to our great 911 department and create a permanent home for a real-time crime center that has proven its effectiveness over the last couple of years.
7:13Jonesboro's growth is why this is necessary.
7:17There are countless communities across the country experiencing population exodus that would love to need a critical investment like this.
7:25Whether you choose to locate this where you choose to wherever you choose to locate this center, it will make Jonesboro safer and city administration is proud to quickly move to construction planning once that decision is made.
7:44Okay, which that's all the um that's all the statements from Mayor and if anybody has any questions about the items contained therein.
7:59That will go ahead and that will bring us into the ongoing discussions for the capital improvements by the bond task force.
8:08Chair, I'll argue on behalf of the Washington property and Mr.
8:12Street or somebody else can argue on behalf of the uh Caraway Road property.
8:17But before we can do that, our rules require a motion and a second before we can have discussion.
8:22So I'll make a motion that we select the Washington Street property.
8:28All right, with the motion and second on the floor, I'll begin the discussions.
8:34I would like to start with just a couple of uh indisputable facts.
8:38I'll keep my comments short.
8:40I think we've been over most of this.
8:42Uh both of these properties, Mr.
8:44Chair will receive the exact same building, the exact same uh facilities.
8:51Careway Road and uh Washington both.
8:57Washington Street, phase one and phase two will be coordinated construction-wise, just like Caraway Road phase one and phase two.
9:10Washington Street phase one can be completed without any disruption of city employees.
9:16We'll be building on the corner of Munro and Madison.
9:20Current city employees in the 911 will be able to occupy their building until construction is finished, and then we'll be able to move over to the new facility, and then demolition can proceed on the justice complex and the 314.
9:34Other undisputable fact is the city owns the Washington property, clear and outright, and we'll have to purchase the Caraway Road property.
9:46While there were several pros that I saw of uh selecting the Washington Street property, I'll keep the list down to just four or five.
9:56The most glaring is the cost savings.
10:00Phase one of the Washington Street property will save the taxpayer $654,000.
10:05And by the time we complete phase two, the savings will surpass over a million.
10:10It's actually estimated by the city attorney to be one or city engineered to be $1,034,000.
10:18This alone would be enough for me to vote for the Washington Street property.
10:23It's a million plus dollars and savings that can go back into the police department to find officers and equipment.
10:31The second reason is the increased presence in the downtown entertainment district for festivals, events, the barbecue cook-off, winter wonderland, Joy Fest, Christmas parade.
10:45You will literally be able to look out of the window from Washington and see our parking lots for the barbecue festival, Winterfest, Main Street, and a variety of other properties.
10:59The third is strictly convenience.
11:02Convenience for the police department, the city attorney, and the public to all have police, E911, the court system, literally in the same building and directly across the street.
11:22So the public would be able to park in one of the parking lots.
11:25You'd be able to go to the police, city attorney, the court system, the mayor's office, or any of our facilities on a short walk.
11:37Item four, and I just discussed this with Mr.
11:41It's not Washington and Caraway's abandoned.
11:46The plan would be to construct our new building on Washington while maintaining the motor pool at the current Caraway Road location.
11:54I see that as being a great asset.
11:57In the event of a natural disaster, we won't have all of our assets or our patrol vehicles in one place.
12:04We would think maybe that wouldn't happen, but look at us now.
12:07Our building is destroyed.
12:09We're spread out around the city.
12:11Just recently as two years ago, the postal service lost all their vehicles at their main location due to a natural disaster.
12:18So having facilities on both sides of the ridge, I think is just a huge benefit.
12:26The next one would be stability of having government buildings in the downtown.
12:30So I've been on the council for 26 years.
12:33Our goal in the entire 26 years is the redevelopment of the downtown area.
12:39When I was first on the council, I had a guy offer me my choice of 11 buildings on Main Street for $6,000 a piece.
12:49Edwina Acock and I got in an argument over one of them because she didn't want to pay $6,500.
12:55Look at downtown now.
12:58One of the things that I credit that to, originally we met at 314 Washington, and then we moved across the street to the bank building, and then good fortune of Mark Duckworth, we were able to acquire this building.
13:14We remodeled this building.
13:36One of the stable influences keeping our government buildings down here.
13:43Some of the restaurants on Main Street with liquor come and go, they're in and out, but the government buildings are here for the long run.
13:57He's not going anywhere.
14:00One of the things we also overlook, there's some discussion about if we build on Caraway Road, we could then sell the property on Washington and maybe or maybe not recoup part of our money.
14:12We need the parking lot on Washington.
14:16If you came to the barbecue cook-off a couple of weeks ago, barbecue trailers were all the way down Munro and around the corner on the parking lot.
14:25We have numerous festivals.
14:27During Winter Wonderland, when we close the parking lot on Munro, the default parking is over there.
14:34By maintaining our buildings and developing that parking lot, we'll continue to have access for the public to have festivals and other events.
14:45The city attorney would probably have to address my next item because you alluded to it, but it's my understanding that we cannot take the proceeds of the bond and purchase the Caraway Road property right out.
15:00Now, I'll default if the mayor says we can, but the city attorney at one time said we couldn't.
15:04So I'll I'll I'll concede that point if there is a point.
15:10The other advantage, if we build on Caraway Road, we still have two buildings down here and a drainage issue that'll have to be addressed.
15:18Best estimates by the city engineer, it'd be over $700,000 to tear down the two buildings, remove the asbestos and address drainage issues down here.
15:29That number was included in the project cost for Washington, and we were still a million dollars cheaper.
15:48Somebody wants to do the last is just public confidence.
15:53We have the first phase funded with the bond initiative.
15:57It's $10 million to build the new E911 building.
16:01The next phase costs $20 million, and that's the new police department.
16:06Now, somewhere funding has to come up with that.
16:09I'm not a big tax and spend guy, but eventually we're either going to have to have a public safety tax or we're gonna have to have some kind of fundraising to pay for that building.
16:20What do you think the odds are the public's gonna back us and support us on that endeavor if they don't feel like we use the first million dollars in their best interest?
16:31So the last point that I think is priceless is just purely the reassurance of the public that we're spending their money in the best and most appropriate way.
16:40And with that, I'll yield the floor.
16:42Thank you for your comment.
16:44Thank you for your comments, Councilman Moore.
16:47Um the item that you had questioned there, um Miss Duncan or Mr.
16:52Richardson, would you all like to speak about the bond funding being able to be used for the purchase of property?
16:59Moore, I don't remember saying that.
17:01I remember saying that the bond ordinance did not authorize the purchase of the property, that that would have to be authorized separately.
17:09But I don't remember saying that the funding couldn't be able to do that.
17:12If the bond did not authorize us to purchase it, then we'd have to do something different.
17:18That's not what I said at that time either.
17:20Just for just for clarity, because I actually I talked to Paul Phillips earlier today, just that double and triple make sure that you know the bond ordinance creates a revenue stream that you can draw from, but any time that the council approves a contract for like a land purchase or anything like that, that's a separate purchasing resolution, not a legally bound ordinance.
17:37So that I think that's where the concept of that comes from that you know the passage of the bond, because there was some concern about that if you remember during the discussions that passage of a bond ordinance meant that you were you know locked into buying this property and you're not any property acquisition is a resolution in city council, it's a separate legislative action altogether.
17:54But you can purchase property with the bond proceeds.
17:57And I'll concede that point.
17:59I mean, it's just an argument of are we paying for it out of this fund or we're paying for it out of that fund.
18:04So it really has no bearing on that.
18:06So I'll concede to whatever the city attorney's opinion is.
18:12Thank you, everybody.
18:14Um, do I have anybody that would like to make any comments regarding the Caraway Road property?
18:19Well, I mean I agree with what Chris said, and really I agree with what the mayor said.
18:23We're blessed either way we go.
18:26I think we all want the same thing.
18:28We want a dependable and functional public safety department.
18:32We want one that will serve the citizens of Jonesboro.
18:35We want it as cheap as we can get it, but cheapest isn't always best.
18:40But my major concern on the downtown site was the drainage issue, which back 20 years ago when we addressed a lot of drainage problems, it was uh a little over three million dollars to address that one issue right there.
18:52Now, if if Craig's confident that we can do that for the amount that uh he had there, and we are required to build, I think two feet now above base floodplain elevation.
19:03So I don't think the building would be in you know flooded, but access to the building could be flooded if we don't address that in some manner.
19:12I as we talked earlier.
19:15I would hate to see us, I don't think it'd be prudent for us to walk away from our property on Caraway Road because we've got a couple million invested in that as well.
19:24That's also taxpayer money.
19:26Uh it's true we do own this property down here, and if it's functionally uh usable, my main concern too was having a consolidated department.
19:34We've worked very hard, and you know, Chris, since we've been on here, we put almost all our city departments together where it's functional.
19:42That's like this building where all our departments are here instead of being scattered all over town.
19:47But some of the great benefits of that is the centralized location, fosters better communication among officers and departments.
19:55It reduces delays in sharing information, leading to more efficient response times wherever it's at.
20:01Shared resources, such as technology and facilities lowers operational costs.
20:06Streamlined administrative functions reduce redundancy.
20:09You have enhanced collaboration.
20:11Officers from different units can collaborate more easily on cases.
20:15Interdepartmental teamwork improves problem solving and strategy development.
20:20A single location for all of our department enhances community engagement and visibility, which again, either side, I think would work for that.
20:29It's easier for the public to access services and report issues.
20:34Training and development, a big one.
20:35A centralized command structure improves coordinated coordination during emergencies, as we experience with the tornado and other issues if we have a major earthquake or something.
20:46Provides faster mobilization of resources and personnel in critical situations and facilities, unified training and operational procedures, enhancing overall effectiveness and eliminates travel time between two locations.
21:00Now, if if if our CID, our 9-1 or Lifetime Crime Center and all that's down here, that eliminate the travel back and forth, and it will it will produce all of these things that I'd like to see in the unified department.
21:13If it's possible that we can do that, hey, that'd work great.
21:16I'd like to see our department in one spot either way, all of it.
21:20CID patrol, lifetime crime center, 911, because those agencies need to work together to be a functional and and uh dependable public safety unit.
21:33So that's my main concern on that.
21:35And I mean, either way, we're gonna make it work no matter what.
21:38But if we do decide on the Washington property, I'd like to see the majority of the department function together, the Lifetime Crime Center, E911, uh, CID and Patrol all in one facility.
21:53And the only other thing that we wouldn't have quite as much room to expand.
21:57Of course, that can be factored in, I guess, in the initial construction, but I hate to see us build it out and then have no room to expand as as you know, future demands would cause the department to uh to grow.
22:12As I stated before, the building construction, Mr.
22:16Street will be exactly the same.
22:18The same facility would be built on Caraway as would be built downtown, and under no circumstances would the selection of Washington include the elimination of the Caraway property.
22:30We would we would have them both just as we have them both right now, and I'm with you.
22:35Consolidation of services in one building benefits the police, but it also benefits the public being right down here in the downtown area.
22:46Street, was there a question in there for asking Mr.
22:49Light about the drainage for the downtown property?
22:52Is Craig Craig here?
22:53Craig, would you mind speak to that?
22:57What'd you say about 300,000 for drainage?
23:00Is that realistic, Craig?
23:03Piece of paper showed 350,000 for drainage improvements.
23:07The money that was included in the estimate is simply what would we would require of any developer to develop that property.
23:16It's not to fix the overall drainage of that drainage basin.
23:21The estimated cost from that was almost three million dollars.
23:25I think Councilman Moore mentioned that that it that we didn't include that in the estimate because if we sold the property to a developer, they would not be required to fix the drainage in the entire basin.
23:37All they would have to do is manage the water on their site.
23:40So we included some work that to ensure that what we did on the property wouldn't make things worse.
23:46But we'd still have the an event, a rain event, we'd still have water buildup on Washington in front of the where it builds up now.
23:57What we included was a triple run of 42-inch pipe underneath the parking lot to provide some additional storage.
24:04We'd also provide more green space in the overall development.
24:08So right now it's currently asphalt and concrete, so you'd have more grass, more trees, hopefully less runoff.
24:15But you know, that's that's what we would require of other private developers as well for redevelopment project.
24:22So that was what was included in the cost estimate, not the total fix for the drainage basin.
24:28It's interesting to note, Mr.
24:30Street, it's where the problem is with the drainage right now, is actually where the end of the fire station was, and that will not be where the new building is.
24:42So the drainage right there on that spot that Craig's alluding to with the 42-inch arch pipe to help address that.
24:49Uh that's not where the building will be.
24:52The building will sit back and back off to the east a little bit.
24:56So we have plenty of room right there for drainage.
25:00And I had to think this morning, I think I've lived in my house for 31 years on Madison.
25:06I don't think it's ever been where I couldn't pass on Washington.
25:09I've seen water out to the center line, and I saw the uh bay of the fire department one time flooded, but that building would be removed.
25:18So that in itself will be a huge benefit.
25:25Anyone have any more questions for Mr.
25:29I don't have any questions.
25:30I just want to make one comment.
25:33I'm glad we're finally to this point.
25:35When I ran my first time in 2008, this is one of the platforms that I ran on is to get public safety, you know, a new home, E911 is really operating out of an inadequate facility at this point.
25:49They were at that time, and I'm glad we're finally getting this across the goal line.
25:56Anyone else from the committee have any statements, any questions for the administration?
26:05Say that's going to bring us to the next item on our agenda being public comment.
26:10Um, at this time, this is an opportunity from anybody from the public to address the committee with any questions or concerns, and just to remind everybody that we do have a time limit on today's discussions.
26:22We're going to be setting that time limit of five minutes on the clock.
26:26And just to remind everybody that there's a lot of people here with, I'm sure a lot of things to say.
26:32So if you do hear one of your points being made beforehand, just don't mind just to be respectful of everybody's time.
26:39But of course, if you have something new to say, please feel free to come up before the mic and address the committee.
26:44And at this time, we will um accept anybody that wants to come up and talk today.
26:52And if you'll just make if you'll just state your name and address for the record, please.
26:55Yes, my name is Shalee Marquis.
26:57I live at 5300 Prospect Road.
27:00And I have a question for you on the committee.
27:03Um, how many of you have actually done research into a real-time crime center?
27:08Did you go visit a real-time crime center?
27:11Did you talk to people who have developed real-time crime centers?
27:15And have you asked them what worked and what hasn't worked at their crime centers?
27:23Is that a direct question to us that you want to answer?
27:26Yeah, I'd like to know what kind of due diligence you guys put into doing investigation because what I hear is I hear a lot of talk about location.
27:35I hear a lot of talk about money, and it seems like money is overshadowing what this what's going to go on inside this building, right?
27:45We're gonna get the same building regardless of where it goes.
27:48But have you talked?
27:50Did you guys do your due diligence?
27:52And did you reach out and did you go visit real-time crime centers?
27:56Have you talked to them about what works and what doesn't work?
27:59Because I think we're missing that big section of the functionality and the future of this.
28:07I mean, you guys are making a decision on a once-in-a-general lifetime right now.
28:14We're not going to get another real-time trime center in this town or another police department while any of us are probably alive.
28:21So, did you guys do that?
28:22So, the answer to your question is the mayor formed this task force to address the location.
28:29There's an architect and another group will decide all that information.
28:32We're simply tasked with picking between A and B.
28:37We have no other So, how do you pick between A and B when you don't understand what's going to go on inside the market?
28:42That's exactly what we pick between A and B and some other group decides what goes on inside.
28:49We simply pick the location.
28:51Another group will design the building and evaluate.
28:54I'm not talking about the design.
28:55I'm talking about the work that they're going to do.
28:57We're not tasked with selecting that.
28:59We're tasked with the same thing.
29:00So, how do you pick?
29:01So, I'm going to say again, how do you pick a location that is going to house the real-time crime center?
29:12It is going to house the 9-1-1, and it's going to house our police department.
29:17So, how do you pick a location without taking what is needed for that to function properly into consideration?
29:26Just like you said, we base that on location and fiscal responsibility.
29:32We decide which one would be in the best interest of the people and which one would be the most cost effective.
29:38An architect and another group of experts will design the building, evaluate the needs of the E91.
29:45We're not, I'm not qualified to tell you how many screens need to be in there or what kind of connections you have.
29:52We're simply selecting between two pieces of land.
29:56And two the two pieces of land have a direct impact on how that facility is going to run in the future.
30:03While I appreciate those of you who are on city council, I appreciate what you do for the city.
30:09I see the same situation occur over and over and over again, in that you choose to take this position and you choose to not do your due diligence on things.
30:22You vote blindly on things or you vote vote on things simply based on a dollar amount.
30:29You've got to do better for our city.
30:32You've got to be making informed decisions.
30:35What is going to happen inside this building you think has no difference whether it sits on Caraway or sits on Washington?
30:43And that tells me this committee shouldn't be making that decision.
30:46If I if I'm if I may say something, yes, Mr.
30:49I think it's been said several times during this task force committee that the same building is going to be built in either location.
30:57And it's not the actual building I'm talking about.
30:59I'm talking about what's going to be going on inside the building.
31:02That's not part of our what we were tasked with doing.
31:06But what decision you make impacts whether that's successful or not.
31:10And I've heard over and over again, people dismiss the things that Chief Elliott and members of his team have said, and it strictly is coming down to the money.
31:20And you guys have to realize that yes, is the money important as a citizen who pays a lot of taxes to this city?
31:27Do I care about how you spend my money?
31:31But I also think that if you're going to be responsible to select a piece of property that has this specific intention, right?
31:40There's only one intention for this this property, right?
31:43Wherever the building goes, it's gonna house the 911 center, the real-time crime center, and all of the things law enforcement.
31:51I think you need to do your due diligence before you make that decision, and I don't think this committee has done that.
31:58So these two pieces of property are less than half a mile apart.
32:03What what tell me what your point is here because the same thing is going to be housed within both facilities.
32:11Response time is going to be very similar.
32:14Have you been down here at five o'clock in the afternoon?
32:18We have one-way streets, we have narrow streets, we don't have direct on-ramp, off-ramp access.
32:25I mean, it's it's congested down here.
32:28Ingress, egress to the other intersection is congested as well.
32:32Not like it is down here.
32:36I mean, I can I can get from Hill Talk to ma'am.
32:42Yeah, my time's up, but he now I appreciate your time.
32:51And if you'll name I'm gonna take this down a notch.
32:53If you'll if you'll state your name and address for the record, please, ma'am.
32:57Melissa Baldwin, 927 West Matthews.
33:01Um this is out of my wheelhouse.
33:03I don't like to speak up here.
33:05I like to work behind the scenes.
33:07But when I feel passionate about something, I'll get I'll get up here, I'll do it.
33:14I was fortunate enough to have my very best friend from Tulsa come and visit.
33:19And Tulsa does everything first class, they really do.
33:22And she and her husband came and we went downtown for dinner.
33:26And as we were going downtown from my house on Matthews, up Washington to get on downtown, she said, this is just a charming little town.
33:35She said, I would not mind living here.
33:37And then we got down here and she said, 'This is adorable.' She said, 'I just love it here.' And I said, 'Well, it is nice.' And I started thinking about the last time she was here, which was in 1970, how far we have come.
33:49And I thought, it is charming, it is nice.
33:53And then I started thinking after she left, and I started thinking about some of the things, and this has been on my mind before before that.
34:00But I thought we hired a team of individuals to come in and look at our city for city growth.
34:10I don't know if we paid them, I don't know what the funding was.
34:13$885,000, $855,000 DPZ.
34:19And they came up with some fantastic ideas for our city growth.
34:24And we're doing a lot of them.
34:26We're doing a lot of them.
34:27We're walkability, bikeability, green space.
34:31They had great ideas.
34:32And if you've ever seen any of their work, it's wonderful.
34:34The uh compounded Hendricks, gorgeous.
34:37They're doing work in Northwest Arkansas right now.
34:40But the last thing I remember them saying was invest in your downtown.
34:47It will pay you back in dividends.
34:51And if we as a city cannot invest in our downtown, how can we expect other people to invest in our downtown?
35:01That's that's all I got to say.
35:09Name and address, please.
35:11I'm Laura Sustage, and I'm at 905 Heritage Cove.
35:14And my question is we've talked about fixing the drainage being maybe three million dollars downtown.
35:20Did you speak into the market?
35:21Oh, we've talked about drainage being being fixed at maybe three million dollars.
35:27And I look at how much money went into the Justice Center that's now continually needing upgrades and things.
35:35Why do we not invest in the Caraway property and do it right and not worry about the floodplain and all these other issues?
35:43That's all I had to say.
35:51Name and address, please.
35:52Patty Lack, 4108 Forest Hill Road.
35:55And first I'm gonna speak for Ira Stevens.
35:57She unfortunately couldn't be here today, but she sent me what she wanted me to uh speak to you about, and she said, after reading everything written about the issues, watching the meetings and talking to other people, it looks like the most rational, most logical, and best choice for everyone concerned is the downtown area and choosing the Washington Avenue location.
36:21It seems definitely to be the most financially conservative choice and the most responsible one for the taxpayers.
36:30All of the above are the duties and responsibilities that all of you have as council people to consider when making a decision for the citizens that elected all of you.
36:43And that was from Ira Stevens.
36:46My spot is that I'm I'm uh surprised that the mayor isn't here today.
36:53Um, it's kind of interesting.
36:55Um, but I'm gonna reiterate what I wrote a lot of you yesterday and saying that I hope you take your business knowledge and all your years of experience up here on the council seat representing the citizens of Jonesboro to select the best choice for the E91 Center.
37:14With choosing the Washington Center, we get the E91 Center as we would on Caraway, and that is your only decision, what location?
37:25It's the same building.
37:26The city would be investing in the downtown area, just like Missy just said, and we'll have two police locations just in case there's a natural disaster, just like Mr.
37:37That's important because we never know when that's gonna happen.
37:41We can use the 1.5 million dollars, whether it's from the capital improvement fund that we have or from the back of the bond task force.
37:52If we use the money from the bond task, that means we only have four million dollars to build the building if we use it to purchase the land from Matt Parker.
38:02If we use the 1.5 million that we would have extra, then we can apply those funds to complete and the complete and finish the Washington Avenue location because of that $5.5 million that was given to us on July 22nd, is that we'll only have $4 million to work on the Caraway building.
38:25The other day in the newspaper, it says Parker defends the Caraway Road offer.
38:31When I read that, I thought, why is Mr.
38:34Parker trying to defend us, the city from purchasing his land?
38:39Why wasn't it Chief Elliott or the mayor defends that?
38:43One thing I'm upset about is how come we don't have a headline here on the top page saying that citizens defend the Washington location because the citizens own that property.
38:55Why weren't we given the same opportunity?
38:59I shared with you in the paper or in an email yesterday that the letter from Matt Parker to me and to many others show a sign of desperation and entitlement that the city of Jonesboro and the citizens owe us to buy his property.
39:18That property has been for sale for decades, and it's been seven years that Mr.
39:25Parker has been trying to get the city to purchase that land.
39:28And let me remind you that Citizen Copenhagen opposed that from being developed in 2019.
39:36So it's been a long time.
39:39So you ask yourself, why has this prime property not been sold or bought by someone else?
39:45Well, yeah, you can look at the estimates of maybe maybe like the blue wave car wash down the street.
39:52That's a better location than a dead end street here on Caraway right now.
39:57So we have not seen the final contract on this.
40:01We only see the contract on Legister with little post-it notes.
40:06Well, what's the final contract?
40:09We've heard about it, but what is the final contract?
40:12So how can we say yes or no to that deal right now?
40:17If it's taken this long to sell this property, it's not a good investment.
40:23It wasn't in a good investment back in Mayor Parents' day, and it's not a good investment today for all of you.
40:32So I encourage all of you to look at the bottom line.
40:37We get the same building at either location, and we have a million and a half dollars more either to spend down here or to the police department that we can give them more funding of what they really need.
40:52So I encourage you today to vote for the Washington Avenue location, and then when it comes to full council, I hope the whole council votes for that.
41:03So I appreciate your time.
41:07Oh I'm sorry, one last thing.
41:10There's a bunch of people here in the room that are supportive of the Washington location, and I just would like them to stand up if they support the Washington location right now.
41:25These are the people that you represent right here behind you.
41:28I hope you make a good decision.
42:02And that seems that there's so much cash, and then there's commitments that we make to do in addition.
42:09And that concerns me because a lot of times when you take on commitments like that, you run into things, and it can be, you know, end up costing you a whole lot more than it was supposed to.
42:22If we're gonna do that, if I think we need to have a clean amount that we're going to pay, and if whoever it is wants to, you know, do any improvements like that, that ought to be done by somebody else, but we need to be careful that that doesn't run cost us an arm and a leg that we hadn't planned on.
42:48Is this a if you will approach the mic?
42:55I think it's short enough for me already on Tom Lackey.
43:00And just name an address for the record, please, sir.
43:03Well, they got a nice picture of it.
43:04All right, name Tommy Lackey, and those Joe Hefner.
43:08And uh 1003 West Matthews.
43:14I mean I got a perspective, probably looking more at facts than I do other things.
43:20I've listened to what the mayor said, I've listened to what Mr.
43:24Street said, and I've listened to what Mr.
43:27And I uh, you know, I take it in, and I'm a guy.
43:31And the things that the mayor and Mr.
43:34Street have said, they're stating soft fuzzy things, and I don't go with soft fuzzy.
43:42Moore has stated facts, and I go more with facts, and he has presented a logical process.
43:49It's not soft and fuzzy.
43:52And I'm not a soft and fuzzy guy.
43:56Y'all y'all address the issues like you look to.
44:00What I didn't hear anybody say is that wherever it's combined with, whether it's here or there, and you combine them, we ought to be getting rid of resources like.
44:13And I know this this is not it.
44:15But we ought to be getting rid of people in management to give more people, but that's that's a different issue.
44:21But that's my thoughts.
44:23Let's just, and I'm not used to speaking.
44:26So anyway, I'll I'll say what I said.
44:44Uh Tom Elwood, 1520 for our circle.
44:50It's great that everybody participation of the public and the interest in Jonesboro is outstanding.
44:56When they built this building, they they thought the city was too.
45:00When they built this building, they they thought the city this was too it wasn't really big enough for input for people to come thought you know because we're uh we're growing, things are changing things will change again, but the one thing that won't change is that it's gonna rain and it's gonna flood on Washington.
45:17And Washington is the uh the emergency route into St.
45:21Bernard Hospital in case there is a national emergency or something from the bypass.
45:26That's a direct emergency route.
45:30It goes right by there, and every time it rains, it's a serious and every rain, not just not a season, not a widespread event, but anytime it rains, it's a problem getting through there, and that is not going to change in a bigger pipe storing water under the driveway or parking lot, that won't work because it freezes and it rains in the winter time and the summertime, the freeze and heat cycle will destroy the parking lot.
46:00So you're gonna constantly build in other words, it was a mistake to build in there in 1960, and it's a bigger mistake to build in that area and not in 2026.
46:10That's all I gotta say.
46:17Anyone else for public comments?
46:31If you'll state your name and address for the record, please.
46:34Hello, uh, I'm Lieutenant McDaniel with the Jones Royal Police Department.
46:37I'm currently the administrator over the real-time crime center.
46:40Um, I said a lot last time at the last meeting.
46:45Um and I I understand uh where your level of commitment to stay in the downtown area is coming from, but ultimately um I would just like to remind uh this task force that if this is about public safety, it's more than just the building, it's more than just the technology in the building.
47:07There's a human element that goes with it.
47:10There's a uh relationship with that building and the current investigative division, uh, the public information office, the records division, the civilian employees in there with FOIA request, uh discovery motions from attorneys.
47:26There's a constant flow of humans in and out of this building.
47:29And if you take that and divide it geographically by about two miles, not a half mile, two miles, and limit the parking and put construction all around it, making it more difficult for people that I need to work with to come in and out of that building.
47:47You're gonna fundamentally damage the efficiency of public safety in regards to that.
47:53Um I just wanted to remind that that was kind of the crux uh to steal the term from an old friend of the situation here that it's about public safety and it's about what's best for that to work effectively.
48:08And I understand we're talking about layering a police department on top of this years down the road.
48:14So whatever we decide in this room is going to affect the police department for years, and it's gonna be a long time before it gets back to be effective and efficient the way it was before we were separated geographically.
48:27You know, I've been with the city going on about 30 years, and I've seen um the band-aids put on the police department over and over and over.
48:37And I know we're talking about a lot of money, and I don't take that lightly, I really don't.
48:42Um, but it might take that investment to set us up for success now so that we can continue that success down the road when we layer phase two on top of this.
48:53I understand it's a lot of money.
48:56Umfortunately, I think that we have been put off and put in damaged buildings, old buildings, buildings with asbestos and may do what's being spread around for so long, we've kind of forgot to change the oil on the car, which could have been not quite as expensive as now we're looking at replacing the car because we forgot maintenance along the way.
49:18Um again, for the third time, simply would like to remind this task force that if public safety is the point of the location of this building.
49:30Unfortunately, um I think that requires to be at the Caraway Road location to keep that human element, that active team, the the ability for detectives to come in and out of there, the ability for me to just walk down a hallway and uh and confer with investigators and making sure we're on the right path and finding new intel.
50:00Um the store I could tell you stories on and on and on if you wanted to come visit and see how it actually works, it's all day long in there, and if you break that relationship, it will be detrimental to the efficiency of that division.
50:11Well, actually, if you don't mind, I just have a question.
50:14My name's Carol White, 5001 Nicole Cove.
50:17Um I have a question.
50:19Okay, so if we I'm I'm I'm not really followed this like to the nth degree, so forgive me if I'm uh confused on this, but the property on downtown, will we lose that completely if we go with the Caraway Road?
50:36Will that be sold and there will not be a police presence downtown, and everything will go to Careway.
50:44And if we do keep this downtown location and build here, will we have two locations?
50:51We'll have the police department on Careway and we'll have the other offices and a good police presence downtown.
51:00Um I'm talking about the the alcohol, the the problems that we have had.
51:07I'm sure that you know recently we had a pretty big issue.
51:10I can't imagine us not having the police department and the and the facilities down here to patrol what is going on with these restaurants and the people that are frequenting them and and maybe uh you know doing things that they shouldn't be doing.
51:27But anyway, I just had that question.
51:28I I'll sit down and maybe y'all can answer.
51:31The answer to your question, we would keep both properties.
51:39Let's see if there's anybody else that but uh if if we have time, I'll get back to you.
51:47Name and address for the record, please, sir.
51:50Rick Elliott, chief of police.
51:52So I'm this discussion right now is for us out here, not for not for not for the police department.
52:04If I'm out of order, I'll set it down and keep the through.
52:07But it sounds like we're the ones that should be up there talking, not people that have a vested interest in Sir.
52:15Thank you for your point, sir.
52:18You're absolutely right, sir.
52:19I do have a vested interest in what we're doing for my police department and my people.
52:25We do this job day in and day out, so I do have a vested interest in what we're doing here today.
52:31So at the end of the day, where this beautiful building lands, that's fine.
52:35Makes no difference.
52:36We're talking the future, the future growth of the city and the police department.
52:41Phase two, we keep talking phase two.
52:43What's phase two gonna look like?
52:53That's the day if we built down Caraway.
52:56If I have to dislocate the evidence room and other parts of that building to combine everything here on Washington, now we have driven that cost up.
53:08So we're at 20 million, 20 plus million dollar cost we're looking at to build phase two down here.
53:14We're now going to raise that cost down here to 25 to 30 million because I'm gonna have to move some of this stuff down here because I'm gonna combine everything one place or another, except the motor pool.
53:26So I can't just leave the evidence room down here and have my detectives going back and forth to get a piece of evidence out to examine it or do analysis on it and then run back and forth down the street.
53:37We're not efficient today.
53:39It's about efficiency.
53:42And understand that you know everybody's at talking about dollars.
53:47Well, okay, I'm talking about the dollars and the back end now.
53:50The back end dollars the phase two, which we don't know, as you said, we don't know when phase two is going to look like.
53:56I say it's gonna be 10 plus years.
53:58So we're gonna be fragmented in multiple buildings for the next 10 years because I don't see anybody stepping up and coming up with 20, 30 million dollars.
54:10So that's the the time we do that, we're gonna drive the costs up and the cost to build 10, 20 years from now is gonna be way more than it is today.
54:23So it's about efficiency of police operations, and understand that is my goal at the other day.
54:30If we want to pack everything up and build down here, then the cost of what's projected right now, we're gonna drive it on up and we'll move, we'll pack up and move down there.
54:42But that big parking lot, it's gonna be fenced all the way around for security, and the concept of thinking that police presence downtown because of the bars, whatever that 9-1-1 center, there's not officers in there, and there nobody in that building is gonna run out to the bar or anything else for anybody on the west end.
55:00That's not their job.
55:02So police department exists today down the downtown.
55:06It didn't have a thing to do with the fight on Main Street the other night or any other time downtown.
55:12Facilities are already there.
55:13It means nothing to those people.
55:16It's about efficiency of a police department.
55:25Anyone else for public comment?
55:28Oh Brandon Reed, 1511 Honeysuckle Lane here in Jonesboro.
55:40I just want to advocate for the Caraway site because it's like uh Lieutenant like Chief has said efficiency of the police department.
55:48As a proud taxpayer and citizen here in Jonesboro, I want my taxpaid dollars to go to things that are most important to me.
55:56If anyone out here disagrees that public safety should be the number one priority for any taxpayer, then we have to have a serious conversation.
56:05Jonesboro is a great town to live in, and I think we have a great opportunity now to future proof or police department and public safety.
56:15There's only one right answer for that.
56:27My name is Sherry Ray, and I live at 810 East Craig Head Forest Road.
56:33I work hard for my money and I pay taxes.
56:36Pay taxes, income taxes, property taxes, all the taxes.
56:41I would I am about public safety.
56:46I believe our choice should be Washington.
56:49So the money is not spent crazily because at my house, I do not run up credit card debt, have brand new cars.
56:57Do I live within my means?
56:59And I would hope that you guys use their tax money and y'all's tax money and my tax money in a way public safety without spending tons for Caraway.
57:14So I believe the choice would be Washington.
57:17That's my only statement.
57:25Do we have anybody else for public safety that hasn't spoken yet?
57:32Miss Patty, if you would like to absolutely Patty Lack 4108 Forest Hill Road.
57:39You know, so what I'm hearing is that the efficiency, we have an efficient police department.
57:45There is no doubt about it right now.
57:47Your task today is to look at the location.
57:50The location of the E91 Center is already down here on Washington.
57:55So all we're going to do is that we're going to take the money and build them a nicer place right there.
58:00We're not talking right now about moving the facility on Caraway down here.
58:05That was, you know, that is so far down the line, right here.
58:09So your main goal right now is where is the best location?
58:13They're already down there.
58:14As far as communication, gosh, I believe it, computers, texting, everything, electronics these days.
58:22It's amazing what they can do.
58:23They can communicate.
58:24They're doing it right now, today for the last six months or how four and a half months that they've uh been moved from there.
58:32So that's not what the goal is today.
58:34Today is the goal is which place is the best efficient place and most cost effective that the citizens of Jonesboro, since we're paying for this, that you guys can decide we're efficient already.
58:48That's not the question.
58:50It's where this building goes, and it really needs to be on Washington.
58:58Ladies and gentlemen, that'll be all for public comments today, which brings us to um our next item on the agenda, which I have lost in my mountain of paperwork.
59:13Chair, we have a motion and a second on the floor.
59:17I ask you to call the roll.
59:19And just to reiterate that motion and second, it is for the Washington Street property.
59:24The Washington Street property.
59:26So voting in favor of this will be voting in favor of the property.
59:31I'm sorry, of the E911 Real Time Crime Center going on the Washington property.
59:38Madam Madam Clark, will you call the roll, please?
59:51And I'm I recuse myself since it was not a tiebreaker.
1:00:00So and at this point, the um motion on the floor does pass for the Washington Road.
1:00:05For I'm sorry, for the Washington property, for the real-time crime center, for the E911 Center.
1:00:10And that is all that we have on our agenda today for the Capital Bond Improvement Task Force.
1:00:16And the next item on our agenda is adjournment.
1:00:21We do stand adjourned.