Kauaʻi County Council Meeting Summary - July 16, 2025
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Kauaʻi County Council Meeting - July 16, 2025
The Kauaʻi County Council met on July 16, 2025 at 8:30 AM in the Council Chambers. Chair Rapozo was excused. The meeting began with a words of wisdom session by Kumu Alapal Jardine, followed by a presentation of a certificate to Sergeant Matthew Spang, a wounded warrior, and his family. The council then proceeded through the agenda.
Consent Calendar
- C 2025-150: Communication from the Mayor regarding the appointment of Jaclyn K. Kaina (Business) to the Planning Commission – received. (Note: The subsequent confirmation resolution was later withdrawn at the request of the Planning Director.)
Public Comments & Testimony
- Bruce Hart and Lonnie Sycos testified on C2025-152 (E-911 funding), with Sycos questioning the funding source and future sustainability.
- Lonnie Sycos also testified on the Plantation Camp bills (2961-2968), supporting wildfire safety but questioning the long-term affordability of rebuilt housing.
- Karen Diamond testified in strong support of the Shoreline Setback bill (Proposed Draft Bill 2969), providing examples of private encroachment on public beaches. Lonnie Sycos also testified in support, praising the bill and noting the difficulty of writing such legislation.
- On Bill 2960 (sewer connection fee waiver), Andrew Pereira (Pacific Resource Partnership) testified in support, and Lonnie Sycos raised concerns about exemptions for federal/state agencies and the term "voluntary hospital." Bruce Hart expressed no objection to a sunset amendment.
Discussion Items
- Interview: Christine L. Ing was interviewed for the Charter Review Commission. Council members praised her background and willingness to serve.
- Communications:
- C2025-151 (records disposal) – approved.
- C2025-152 (E-911 funding: $1,022,025 from the E-911 Board) – approved.
- C2025-153 (State funds: $201,306 for three dispatcher positions) – approved.
- C2025-154 (Teen Court: $55,000 from Office of Youth Services) – approved.
- C2025-155 (donation of a 40-foot shipping container from Hawaiian Lifeguard Association) – approved.
- C2025-156 (Planning Commission recommendation on Plantation Camp amendments) – received.
- C2025-157 (Shoreline Setback bill) – received.
- Claim: C2025-158 (Maria Lourdes Henry) – referred to County Attorney.
- Committee Reports: CR-PWVS 2025-03 (on Bill 2960) approved; CR-HIR 2025-02 (Housing Agency briefing) received.
- Resolution 2025-31: Confirmation of Jaclyn K. Kaina to the Planning Commission – withdrawn at the request of the Planning Director. Councilmembers expressed appreciation for her consideration.
- Bills for First Reading:
- Proposed Draft Bills 2961-2968 (Plantation Camp zoning, wildfire, and land use amendments) – all approved on first reading, public hearing set for August 13, 2025, and referred to the Planning Committee. Councilmember Cowden raised concerns about affordable housing commitments; it was noted that language in Bill 2968 applies to all camps.
- Proposed Draft Bill 2969 (Shoreline Setback and Coastal Protection) – approved on first reading and referred to the Planning Commission. Councilmembers Cavalho and Rapozo introduced it; discussion highlighted the need to protect public beaches from private encroachment and to clarify definitions of hardening and repairs.
- Bill for Second Reading:
- Bill No. 2960 (amending sewer connection fees) – council debated a sunset amendment. An initial motion for a 5-year sunset failed on voice vote. A subsequent amendment for a 10-year sunset was approved. The bill as amended was then approved on second reading.
Key Outcomes
- All consent calendar items were received.
- Communications C2025-151 through 155 were approved; C2025-156 and 157 were received.
- Claim C2025-158 was referred to the County Attorney.
- Committee reports were approved.
- Resolution 2025-31 (Planning Commission nomination) was withdrawn.
- Bills 2961-2968 passed first reading (6-0-1) with public hearing on August 13, 2025.
- Bill 2969 passed first reading (6-0-1) and was referred to the Planning Commission.
- Bill 2960 passed second reading (6-0-1) with a 10-year sunset amendment.
- Executive sessions were held for two pending lawsuits: Evan Schaben v. County of Kauaʻi and a settlement proposal in Stacey Palomar and Donald Lindsey.
Meeting Transcript
Yeah, that's just all right. Um, why don't we get started before we formally call the meeting? What are people read? It was green. Um is excuse today, and we're gonna start with uh as we do from time to time words of wisdom, and for today we're having Kumulina Alapal Jardine, and it looks like some of the members of the halal. Please come forward. Hit that mic so it turns green the red light. Aloha kaka hiaka, good morning, everyone. You know, um I've learned over years from speaking and doing blessings that don't even prepare a script because the best message comes from the heart. And so when I was invited to to share some words of wisdom this morning, I've been thinking about what am I gonna talk about? What am I what do I have to share? Unless you want to learn how to kaholo, you know. But you know, the last year has taught me a lot, and I think every day is we're blessed to be alive, we're blessed to live on this island and call this island our home. Um, and you folks are blessed with a huge kuleana, which is to make decisions for the betterment of our Lahui, our people on this island, and you know, Kauai is special, Ni'ihao is special, and uh we on behalf of the people of our of our uh islands, mahalonui, because I know each and every one of you have have you know it's a big task, it's a big, big task to to do what you do, and so I wanted to talk about a little bit about change. I truly believe nothing happens by accident. Each of you, all of us here, we're here for a reason. We're here because we want to serve our community. We hear we're here because we want what's best for our people. And sometimes change is not welcomed, right? People are afraid of change, and and this uh group of our leaders, I think it's time for change in our community, and we get really scared. And I share this as a mother of a 16-year-old who does who is in on his way to Georgia right now to play baseball. And and why am I talking sports? Is because when I travel to the mainland, they have the most beautiful athletic complexes. They have all these things that we look at and go, gosh, but what they don't have is they don't have Kauai, they don't have Hawai'i. And so uh I recently had the blessed opportunity to do the blessing at Waimea High School, and they're getting a huge gym at Waimea High School, and with that, a tree needed to be removed. And so that change you could see in the faces of some of the people there, they were just afraid of that change. And so when you go through uh making big decisions, which affects people and their emotions and and connections to certain things on our island or places, um, sometimes it's bitter. The change is tough because it comes with criticism. And so I want to share something that King Kamehameha, and some of you may have heard this before, but you know, we love King Kamehameha. He never conquered our island of Kawaii and I, but we still, you know, Mahalo and Aloha are Ali. They kind of, if you think about it, paved the way for all of us, yeah. But there is a saying that he said, he said, Imua enapoki a inui kawaii ava'ava. Aohehope, e ho i mayay. It is a well-known battle cry. Some of you may have heard of this before that Kamehameha called out while at battle on the island of Oahu. Hundreds and thousands of lives were lost. But he said it he said this, the phrase drink of the bitter waters, unfortunately talks about how sometimes we gotta drink that bitter water, we gotta take the criticism, but we know that in the end we are making porno decisions for our people. And I just hope that today I want to start off with a prayer, and then we're we have some avail. You do not have to partake if you don't want, but if you would like, we will serve you a little bit today. Um, and I have with me my daughter Breeze, and we know through my health journey, Brees has really stepped up to the plate. And boy, you know, it's it's being a kumuhula. You're getting not for the weak. Not there's bitter, bitter, you gotta get through it. Turn your thing on, honey. Yeah, there you go. But but in the end, when you do things the right way with the greatest of intentions, you forget that avah, you forget the bitterness of the avail. You just feel the accomplishment and the aloha from everyone else. Behind me, I have four of my homana, and I asked them to specifically to be here today. These four attend kamehameha schools, kapalama, and they're home on summer break. So I wanted them to be here today because this is a melee.
openpublica.com