OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Livonia, Michigan/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Livonia City Council Study Meeting Summary: August 17, 2026

City Council — Monday, August 17, 2026
BodyLivonia, Michigan
SessionCity Council
DateMonday, August 17, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 40:31

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

9:05

Welcome everyone.

9:06

Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance, led by Honorable Council Member Robin Persiconi.

9:28

Welcome to the August seventeenth, twenty twenty-six study session of the Lavonia City Council.

9:33

This meeting sets the agenda for the two thousand forty-seventh regular meeting, which is a voting meeting that will take place on Monday, August thirty first, twenty twenty-six, where tonight's items will be officially voted on.

9:43

We have all seven council members here.

Unassigned speaker

10:00

Um a while back at one of the previous meetings, there was discussion over at the Costco of them building a new gas station, you know, and moving that.

Speaker 2

10:10

At that time, the the topic of remediation of the old gas station was brought up and assured that they would go through that process.

10:19

What I would like to have the council consider is something along that line, because in the city of Lavonia, it seems to be a common practice that a lot of our small gas stations are being purchased and want to be remodeled.

10:35

The problem that I see is the only thing that they're remodeling is the size of the footprint of their store to be more profitable.

10:43

Not for the safety of the public of the citizens of Livonia.

10:48

I would like to have some kind of a of a policy that if any of the gas stations want to remodel that an abatement and a modernization of their pumps be included for the safety of the citizens of Livonia.

11:06

Thank you.

Speaker 1

11:07

Thank

Unassigned speaker

11:08

you.

Speaker 1

11:09

Good evening, sir.

11:10

Name and address, please.

11:11

You have three minutes.

Speaker 3

11:12

Steve King comes from Gardens.

11:13

The agenda is way too long.

11:15

If I was a council person up there, I would get together and say too long.

11:19

Uh want to talk about the process.

11:23

The boilers.

11:24

There are bylaws and processes in place.

11:27

I find it interesting.

11:28

The lawyers on the the lawyers are the ones saying we can ignore the law.

11:33

The lawyers.

11:34

An employee comes forward and says, I appreciate all that we hear.

11:37

I appreciate it all.

Unassigned speaker

11:38

You

Speaker 3

11:38

know what we would appreciate?

11:40

If you follow the law.

11:41

He said it checked all the boxes, but well, then they didn't check all the boxes.

11:46

You cannot accept that bid.

11:47

It's it's wrong.

11:49

Okay.

11:49

The finance department comes up and tries desperately to explain something to you guys.

11:57

Everybody up there on council bent over backwards trying to get that over the finish line.

12:02

Finally, it took three people, three people to explain what we're trying to do.

12:07

Three.

12:17

No one asked the simple question, how much is it going to cost?

12:20

No one asked that.

12:22

A 300,000 over 300,000 for a bathroom.

12:26

I can build you a three-bedroom, three-bath house with ADA compatible bathroom for less money than that.

12:32

Nobody said anything.

12:34

Come on, people.

12:35

Come on.

12:36

Full gut and convert is 50 to 100,000.

12:40

This is just ridiculous.

12:41

Okay, finally, 48154.

12:44

Have you heard about the good news?

12:46

Sixth.

12:47

We're number six in the top 10 of real estate because houses are going over bid.

12:55

40%.

12:56

They're off the market in 30 days.

12:59

So to spread the news.

Speaker 4

13:01

The mayor.

Speaker 3

13:03

And uh and a school board trustee Dave is also a real estate agent.

13:08

They did a video.

13:10

Well, here's the problem.

13:11

They did that video in my park, Coverage Regards, Shoreham Park.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Engineering And Infrastructure█████████████████████████████████████████████54%
Parks and Recreation███████████13%
Public Engagement██████████12%
Affordable Housing████████10%
Procedural███████8%
Public Safety███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Livonia City Council Study Meeting Summary: August 17, 2026

The Livonia City Council held a Study Meeting on Monday, August 17, 2026. Although the agenda listed an 8:00 p.m. start, the meeting was called to order at 10:11 p.m. by President Reid. All seven council members were present. The meeting served to set the agenda for the Regular Voting Meeting on August 31, 2026. Most items were directed to the Consent Calendar, while the Security Camera Bid and the Library Elevator Modernization items were moved to the Regular Agenda. Several residents provided public comments.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • John Schafer requested the council consider a policy requiring gas station remodels to include environmental abatement and pump modernization for public safety.
  • Steve King criticized the lengthy agenda and city procurement processes, raising concerns that rules were being ignored. He specifically referenced a bathroom project costing over $300,000 and stated no council member asked for the cost breakdown.
  • Jim Biga discussed the 'Book 5' master plan, stating the promised 45-day public comment period did not occur as expected. He argued the plan should address converting industrial sites to housing and the lack of affordable housing, noting that new construction in Livonia has not been approved under $400,000. He also claimed the plan contained inaccuracies, such as stating the city has 94,000 housing units when it actually has around 37,000.
  • Jerry Karasinski noted Livonia is the eighth largest city in Michigan with a $76 million general fund budget and 300 employees, and urged the council to follow established rules and processes rather than pushing them aside.
  • Denise Mika (on Item 5) questioned why the contract for golf course roof replacement professional services was awarded to OHM Advisors over a lower bidder (DAG), asking if the timeline was the deciding factor.
  • Lamberto Smigliani (Item 1 applicant) requested a sidewalk waiver for a new home at 15505 Auburndale Avenue.
  • Sarah Mahison (on behalf of property owner) requested approval for sign rebranding at the Amoco station at 29401 Seven Mile Road, but preferred not to modify the existing monument sign structure as requested by the Planning Commission.
  • Vito Cicinelli (Kimley-Horn & Associates, for Target) confirmed the request was for five wall signs, with one being an existing sign.

Discussion Items

  • Item 4: Security Camera Upgrades. Superintendent Michelle Koppin requested approval of a $72,063.37 bid to ASC Security Systems for 20 new cameras and 14 upgrades or replacements at the Kirksey Recreation Center, Botsford Pool, and Clements Circle Pool. Councilmember McDonnell requested the item be moved to the Regular Agenda to review detailed pricing and ensure all bidders quoted on identical scope.
  • Item 8: Library Elevator Modernization. Assistant City Engineer Dave Lear requested approval of a $379,655 contract with City Elevator for upgrading the passenger and service elevators at the Robert and Janet Bennett Civic Center Library. The vendor is an approved provider under a State of Michigan contract. Councilmember McDonnell requested the item be moved to the Regular Agenda.
  • Book 5 Master Plan: Councilmember Budzinski confirmed with Planning Director Mark Taormina that the Planning Commission is considering holding an additional 45-day public comment period and a new public hearing for the 'Book 5' master plan.
  • Item 1: Sidewalk Waiver. Assistant City Engineer Dave Lear supported the waiver, noting there are no sidewalks on the street. Councilmember McCullough supported the waiver but suggested the council consider developing a long-term citywide walkability plan.
  • Item 2 & 3: Sign Petitions. Director Taormina explained the rebranding of the Amoco station (Shell to Amoco) and Target store, both located within special area development control districts.
  • Item 5: Golf Course Roof Replacement. Koppin explained the professional services contract ($23,168.75 to OHM Advisors) was brought to council because combined costs met the approval threshold. Councilmember Budzinski praised the transparent presentation of the item.
  • Item 6: Middle Belt Road Improvement. Lear requested approval of the intergovernmental agreement with Wayne County. The city's share is 9.075% ($204,387 of the $2.59 million project). The work has already been completed.
  • Item 7: Storm Water Agreement. Lear presented the formal storm water facilities maintenance agreement for True Community Credit Union.

Key Outcomes

  • Direction for Consent Agenda (August 31, 2026): Items 1 (Sidewalk Waiver), 2 (Amoco Sign), 3 (Target Sign), 5 (Golf Course Roof Professional Services), 6 (Middle Belt Road IGA), and 7 (True Community Credit Union Storm Agreement).
  • Direction for Regular Agenda (August 31, 2026): Item 4 (Security Camera Bids) and Item 8 (Library Elevator Modernization) were moved to the Regular Agenda for further discussion and voting.
  • Further Direction on Book 5: An additional 45-day public comment period and rehearing are being considered by the Planning Commission.

Meeting Transcript

Welcome everyone. Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance, led by Honorable Council Member Robin Persiconi. Welcome to the August seventeenth, twenty twenty-six study session of the Lavonia City Council. This meeting sets the agenda for the two thousand forty-seventh regular meeting, which is a voting meeting that will take place on Monday, August thirty first, twenty twenty-six, where tonight's items will be officially voted on. We have all seven council members here. Um a while back at one of the previous meetings, there was discussion over at the Costco of them building a new gas station, you know, and moving that. At that time, the the topic of remediation of the old gas station was brought up and assured that they would go through that process. What I would like to have the council consider is something along that line, because in the city of Lavonia, it seems to be a common practice that a lot of our small gas stations are being purchased and want to be remodeled. The problem that I see is the only thing that they're remodeling is the size of the footprint of their store to be more profitable. Not for the safety of the public of the citizens of Livonia. I would like to have some kind of a of a policy that if any of the gas stations want to remodel that an abatement and a modernization of their pumps be included for the safety of the citizens of Livonia. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, sir. Name and address, please. You have three minutes. Steve King comes from Gardens. The agenda is way too long. If I was a council person up there, I would get together and say too long. Uh want to talk about the process. The boilers. There are bylaws and processes in place. I find it interesting. The lawyers on the the lawyers are the ones saying we can ignore the law. The lawyers. An employee comes forward and says, I appreciate all that we hear. I appreciate it all. You know what we would appreciate? If you follow the law. He said it checked all the boxes, but well, then they didn't check all the boxes. You cannot accept that bid. It's it's wrong. Okay. The finance department comes up and tries desperately to explain something to you guys. Everybody up there on council bent over backwards trying to get that over the finish line. Finally, it took three people, three people to explain what we're trying to do. Three. No one asked the simple question, how much is it going to cost? No one asked that. A 300,000 over 300,000 for a bathroom. I can build you a three-bedroom, three-bath house with ADA compatible bathroom for less money than that. Nobody said anything. Come on, people. Come on. Full gut and convert is 50 to 100,000. This is just ridiculous. Okay, finally, 48154. Have you heard about the good news?

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com