OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Livonia, Michigan/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Livonia City Council Study Meeting - September 14, 2026

City Council — Monday, September 14, 2026
BodyLivonia, Michigan
SessionCity Council
DateMonday, September 14, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:18:47

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

11:37

Good evening, please rise for the Pledge Allegiance led by the Honorable Vice President Patrick Brackway.

Speaker 2

11:44

I pledge

Speaker 3

11:45

allegiance.

11:49

And to the Republic for which it

Speaker 4 · Possibly Jerry Kersinski

11:52

stands.

Speaker 1

12:02

Welcome to the September 14th, twenty twenty-six study session of the Lavonia City Council.

12:07

This meeting sets the agenda for the two thousand forty-ninth regular meeting, which is a voting meeting that will take place on Monday, September twenty-eighth, twenty twenty-six, where tonight's items will be officially voted on.

12:18

I just wanted to note that the yellow agendas that were printed are missing in item, but there are QR codes posted where you can get the full agenda.

12:27

It's item number six that was missing.

12:41

You have three minutes to speak.

Speaker 5

12:45

Yeah, Steve King, Country Gardens.

12:48

I just want to address Patrick.

12:49

You might want to write this down.

12:53

Chapter Four, Section 16 gives the council authority over the city's parks and recreational facilities.

13:16

So I am not asking this council to do something outside its authority.

13:20

I am asking you to use the authority the charity specifically gives you and take a look at what's going on.

13:27

Couple other things.

13:31

But when somebody comes up and starts attacking me again and again, I'm leaving rent free in John Pastor's head.

13:39

So I've spent more than fifty years contributing to this community, and Lavonia honored me by placing me in its hall of fame.

13:46

I'm proud of that record.

Unassigned speaker

13:47

I don't need to diminish anyone else to establish my pace place in this community.

Speaker 5

13:53

But falsehoods.

13:55

I was charged with breaking and entering.

13:57

It was dismissed.

13:58

This is public information.

14:00

The fine was $50.

14:02

There were no traffic, there was no signs listed.

14:05

This was a public place.

14:08

This is public property.

14:09

He's espousing all these lies, and that's all I'm gonna say.

14:13

But I am gonna do a reel, my next Facebook reel where I get 60,000 views, and the subject will be the Rotary Pavilion.

14:22

So John should enjoy that one when I point out uh some of the issues over there.

14:28

And finally, Eileen, is there's a pattern here.

14:33

Eileen challenges a bid, something she knows about.

14:36

The boiler bid was illegal.

14:38

I want you to please look at my Facebook reel on this because I go blow by blow and spell it out.

14:43

She was absolutely right, it was unsigned, they didn't attend the pre-bid meeting, they were not, it should have been thrown out.

14:50

So what happens?

14:52

Mr.

14:52

Murray attacks her.

14:54

He comes after I leave because she challenges the status quo, the bid procedure.

15:00

Come on, this council has got to really grow up and stop this.

15:06

You should support Eileen and her expertise.

15:09

You should support people who have expertise, Brandon has expertise in areas.

15:13

You should support these people.

15:15

All right, that's all I gotta say.

15:17

Thanks.

Speaker 1

15:17

Thank

Unassigned speaker

15:18

you.

Speaker 1

15:21

Good evening, sir.

15:22

Name and address, please.

15:23

You have three minutes.

Speaker 6

15:24

Jay Murray, mean streets of L Town.

15:25

Councilwoman's response to my comments were reprehensible.

15:29

The reason that we have procedures in place for her to request documents about the city about the boiler or whatever boiler or whatever project is that she doesn't leave a digital footprint on the bidding website, so other bidders will come in, see a member of the city council in there with a company attached, and then she voted at least once on

Unassigned speaker

15:50

it.

Speaker 6

15:50

So her refusing to apologize is reprehensible.

15:54

Her response to me is disgusting, and she doesn't want to get she doesn't want to admit that she went in there because she was monitoring something.

16:01

My questions went unanswered.

16:03

What were you doing in there?

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Engineering And Infrastructure█████████████████████████████████33%
Procedural████████████████████████████28%
Parks and Recreation███████████████15%
Public Engagement███████████████15%
Technology and Innovation█████5%
Personnel Matters████4%
Summary of Proceedings

Livonia City Council Study Meeting - September 14, 2026

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on September 14, 2026, to set the agenda for the regular voting meeting scheduled for September 28, 2026. The meeting opened with the Pledge of Allegiance led by Vice President Brockway. Discrepancy noted: The meeting minutes header lists the date as August 31, 2026, but the agenda and transcript confirm the meeting occurred on September 14, 2026.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Steve King (Country Gardens) stated he was not asking the council to act outside its authority under the city charter, and urged the council to examine the Rotary Pavilion. He defended Councilmember Eileen McDonnell's expertise, described attacks against her as false, and referenced his own Hall of Fame status and dismissed charges.
  • Jay Murray (L Town) criticized Councilmember McDonnell for accessing a bidding website under a company name, alleging ethics violations and a chilling effect on other bidders. He demanded an apology and explanation.
  • Christopher Martin complained about ongoing priority waste garbage pickup issues and requested the matter be placed on a future agenda.
  • Nicole Hefty (Melrose Street) discussed procurement, criticized long-term consultant contracts without rebidding, and called for more transparency and limits on consulting spending.
  • Steve Johnson expressed confidence in Councilmember McDonnell's ethics.
  • Jerry Karasinski (later) commented on purchasing procedures and budget priorities, noting the need to reevaluate processes and free up funds for capital infrastructure.
  • Elijah spoke against proposed Flock cameras, arguing that high accuracy rates (96%) lead to false positives through the base rate fallacy, and that errors and data leaks could generate costs for the city.

Council Reports and Updates

  • Councilmember Brandon McCullough commended recent renovations at the Community Recreation Center, noting improvements like a cleaned-up kids' corner and overall appearance.
  • Erica Smith, Director of Government Relations, provided an update on Sheldon Park. She explained sidewalk widths meet ADA requirements (5 feet for non-major, 6 feet for major roads), and the budget does not allow changes. A wider curved path is planned near high-traffic areas (playground, splash pad). She also stated she had no knowledge of a pavilion removal.

Consent Calendar

The following items were placed on the Consent Agenda for the September 28 regular meeting by unanimous direction:

  • Item 1: Block Party by Theresa Burgess (October 31, 2026, Brentwood Street)
  • Item 2: Block Party by Danielle Greason (October 31, 2026, Emerson Court/Tulipwood)
  • Item 3: Waiver Petition for Fogo De Chao Churrascaria to obtain an SDM liquor license (beer/wine off-premises sale) at 38888 Six Mile Road (address corrected to 39006 by petitioner)
  • Item 4: Waiver Petition for Hands of Time to operate a second-hand store at 19704 Middlebelt Road
  • Item 5: Waiver Petition for Mt. Hope Memorial Gardens Cemetery to construct a mausoleum at 17840 Middlebelt Road (Councilmember McCullough inquired about a soil erosion permit; petitioner confirmed an amendment is in process)
  • Item 6: One-year cooperative agreement with Livonia Public School District for continued use of John Stymelski Veterans Park (Councilmember Ptashnik disclosed her school district employment but no pecuniary interest)
  • Item 7: Agreement with BS&A Software, LLC for payment processing, lowering credit/debit transaction fee from 2.8% to 2.65%
  • Item 9: Storm Water Facilities Maintenance Agreement with Baci Development, LLC for Baci Estates drainage system

Discussion Items

Item 8: Five-Year Extension of QBS Contracts with Engineering Firms. City Engineer Todd Zilincik presented the request to extend qualification-based selection contracts with OHM Advisors, Hubbell, Roth & Clark, Spalding DeDecker, and Anderson, Eckstein and Westrick. He argued the Brooks Act allows selection based on expertise and cited past cost savings and project successes. Councilmember Brandon McCullough expressed support for the firms but requested more documentation, including market comparisons, to justify not bidding competitively. Councilmember Eileen McDonnell asked about the fee schedule, which was established in 2010. The item was placed on the Regular Agenda for further discussion.

Item 10: Award of Contract for 2026 Rear Yard Drainage Improvements on Westbrook Drive. City Engineer Zilincik reported Dynamic Underground Group as the lowest qualified bidder at $84,694. A bid bond error occurred (the submitted bond listed Commerce Township), but the purchasing manager confirmed a correct bond had been issued a week prior. Councilmember McCullough initially moved consent, but Councilmember McDonnell raised concerns and moved to place on Regular Agenda. Residents Jerry Karasinski and Denise Mika questioned the bid bond resolution. The item was placed on the Regular Agenda.

Key Outcomes

  • All ten items received direction for the September 28 regular meeting: items 1–7 and 9 were placed on the Consent Agenda; items 8 and 10 were placed on the Regular Agenda.
  • Council requested additional documentation from the City Engineer on cost savings and market rate comparisons for the QBS contracts.
  • The City Treasurer confirmed a lower transaction fee for residents (2.65% vs 2.8%) through the new BS&A agreement, which also streamlines processing.
  • The meeting adjourned at 9:24 PM.

Meeting Transcript

Good evening, please rise for the Pledge Allegiance led by the Honorable Vice President Patrick Brackway. I pledge allegiance. And to the Republic for which it stands. Welcome to the September 14th, twenty twenty-six study session of the Lavonia City Council. This meeting sets the agenda for the two thousand forty-ninth regular meeting, which is a voting meeting that will take place on Monday, September twenty-eighth, twenty twenty-six, where tonight's items will be officially voted on. I just wanted to note that the yellow agendas that were printed are missing in item, but there are QR codes posted where you can get the full agenda. It's item number six that was missing. You have three minutes to speak. Yeah, Steve King, Country Gardens. I just want to address Patrick. You might want to write this down. Chapter Four, Section 16 gives the council authority over the city's parks and recreational facilities. So I am not asking this council to do something outside its authority. I am asking you to use the authority the charity specifically gives you and take a look at what's going on. Couple other things. But when somebody comes up and starts attacking me again and again, I'm leaving rent free in John Pastor's head. So I've spent more than fifty years contributing to this community, and Lavonia honored me by placing me in its hall of fame. I'm proud of that record. I don't need to diminish anyone else to establish my pace place in this community. But falsehoods. I was charged with breaking and entering. It was dismissed. This is public information. The fine was $50. There were no traffic, there was no signs listed. This was a public place. This is public property. He's espousing all these lies, and that's all I'm gonna say. But I am gonna do a reel, my next Facebook reel where I get 60,000 views, and the subject will be the Rotary Pavilion. So John should enjoy that one when I point out uh some of the issues over there. And finally, Eileen, is there's a pattern here. Eileen challenges a bid, something she knows about. The boiler bid was illegal. I want you to please look at my Facebook reel on this because I go blow by blow and spell it out. She was absolutely right, it was unsigned, they didn't attend the pre-bid meeting, they were not, it should have been thrown out. So what happens? Mr. Murray attacks her. He comes after I leave because she challenges the status quo, the bid procedure. Come on, this council has got to really grow up and stop this. You should support Eileen and her expertise. You should support people who have expertise, Brandon has expertise in areas. You should support these people. All right, that's all I gotta say. Thanks. Thank you. Good evening, sir.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com