OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Lynn Haven, Florida/City Commission
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Lynn Haven City Commission Meeting - July 28, 2026

City Commission — Tuesday, July 28, 2026
BodyLynn Haven, Florida
SessionCity Commission
DateTuesday, July 28, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Unassigned speaker

4:42

I uh let's go with the biggest thing.

Speaker 1

4:54

So we'll go ahead and get started.

5:02

Steve Taylor from Emerald Coast Fellowship is not here tonight.

5:06

So you know what that means?

5:08

Means you're stuck with the mayor giving the prayer tonight.

5:10

So if y'all would please stand and bow your heads with me.

5:15

Heavenly Father, we come to you tonight gross graciously and humbly and proud to be able to call Florida home.

5:23

Let's help each other be good neighbors, help each other build the best community we can, and be understanding of each other as we go through some very challenging times ahead.

5:33

Um in your precious name we pray.

5:35

Amen.

Unassigned speaker

5:37

I

Speaker 2

5:38

pledge

Speaker 3

5:38

allegiance through the flag of the

Speaker 1

5:40

United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation and indivisible with

Speaker 4

5:48

liberty and justice for all.

Speaker 1

5:56

Pastor Steve Taylor, I am not, but I hope I did all right with y'all tonight for that.

6:01

All right.

6:01

First thing tonight, we're a call to order.

6:05

Uh we have additions, deletions, or modifications of agenda.

6:10

Commissioner Tinder.

Speaker 5

6:11

I would like to add.

Speaker 1

6:14

Sorry.

Speaker 5

6:15

I'd like to add uh something about the memorial.

6:19

Okay.

Speaker 1

6:20

Um new business uh number 20 is what that would be, memorial gardens discussion.

Speaker 6

6:30

And Mayor, we need to remove item 10 uh the Dunlap shipment contract.

6:35

It is not ready yet, so we will have that for the August 11th meeting.

Speaker 1

6:38

Okay, copy that.

6:40

So I have a proposed uh new number 20, Memorial Gardens discussion with Commissioner Tinder, and we will remove uh old business number 10 until our next meeting.

6:53

Uh if that is agreeable with the rest of the commission, is there anything else changes or deletions y'all would like to

Unassigned speaker

7:00

make?

Speaker 1

7:02

If not, can I get a motion?

Speaker 7

7:07

Motion to approve.

7:08

Second.

Speaker 1

7:09

Thank you.

7:10

I have a motion and a second.

7:12

Uh any discussion regarding the uh addition and deletion of the two items to the agenda from the public.

7:20

Hearing none, City Manager, would you call the roll?

Speaker 6

7:23

Commissioner Perno.

7:25

Yes.

7:26

Commissioner Peebles?

7:27

Yes.

7:27

Commissioner Wark?

7:28

Yes.

7:29

Commissioner Tinder.

7:30

Yes.

7:30

Mayor Lowry.

Speaker 1

7:31

Yes.

7:32

So 5-0 has it.

7:33

Thank

Unassigned speaker

7:34

you.

Speaker 1

7:34

All right.

7:35

We have one proclamation tonight.

7:38

And it is the National Disability Independence Day.

7:43

Proclamation.

7:44

Whereas National Disability Independence Day commemorates the signing of the Americans with Disabilities Act or the ADA on July 26, 1990.

7:54

The ADA provides protection from employment discrimination as well as better access to goods, services, and communications for persons with disabilities.

8:02

Whereas the day not only celebrates the anniversary of the ADA, but it also serves several other purposes.

8:39

Whereas the as accessibility improves, the world continues to change in many other ways.

8:44

Today's brick and mortar businesses are ADA compliant.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Budget Equity Analysis███████████████15%
Employee Benefits██████████████14%
Public Engagement████████████12%
Fiscal Sustainability███████████11%
Procedural██████████10%
Contract Management███████7%
Parks and Recreation███████7%
Technology and Innovation██████6%
Water And Wastewater Management███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Lynn Haven City Commission Meeting - July 28, 2026

The Lynn Haven City Commission met on July 28, 2026, at 5:30 PM in the Walter T. Kelley Chambers. The meeting covered a wide range of topics including approval of consent agenda items, employee benefits renewal, budget amendment, drainage and construction contracts, discussion of James Rogers Park, setting the millage rate ceiling, and public comment on various issues. The meeting also included a proclamation for Disability Independence Day and a discussion of the Memorial Garden.

Agenda Adjustments

  • Commissioner Tinder added a discussion of Memorial Gardens as Item 20.
  • City Manager Lightfoot requested removal of Item 10 (Legal Services Agreement) as it was not resolved.
  • The agenda was approved with these changes by a 5-0 vote.

Proclamations & Announcements

  • Mayor Lowery read a proclamation declaring National Disability Independence Day, commemorating the ADA.

Consent Calendar

  • Items 5-9 were approved unanimously with a 5-0 vote.
  • Item 5: Approved Amendment 4 for the W 10th St Utility Improvements Project (project number corrected to 22032).
  • Item 6: Declared utility bill pay kiosk as surplus for auction on Govdeals.gov.
  • Item 7: Approved commission meeting minutes from July 14, 2026 (corrected date on agenda cover).
  • Item 8: Approved service agreement contract transfer for Wastewater Treatment Plant staffing from Yates Plumbing to U.S. Water Services Corporation. The city manager confirmed the contract price remains the same and the same staff will be retained.
  • Item 9: Appointed Mr. George Hines to the Finance Review Committee.

Public Comments on Consent Agenda:

  • Jodi Moore asked if there would be a price increase for Item 8; the city manager confirmed no.
  • Naylor Bearclaw spoke against the transfer to U.S. Water, citing water quality issues in Sunny Hills (brown water, pressure loss, boil notices). He warned the commission that U.S. Water has poor management and is not a local company.
  • Commissioner Tinder asked the city manager if he was comfortable with the company; the city manager affirmed and noted U.S. Water will retain the existing Yates staff.

Public Comments & Testimony

Comments are grouped by topic for clarity.

On Millage Rate and Budget:

  • Ryan Scray noted this may be the last opportunity to set the millage rate if Amendment 3 passes; he provided analysis on homestead exemptions.
  • Mr. Beshearse urged the commission to set the rate high enough to balance the budget.
  • Ralph Langford said the Financial Review Committee is underutilized and should meet weekly to deep-dive into the budget; he recommended a joint workshop.
  • Ms. Day spoke against the millage process and encouraged the commission to end contracts with Panhandle Engineering and Chris Forehand.
  • Jodi Moore asked if there is no room in the budget for festivals (Fourth of July, Easter, etc.), and was confirmed by the city manager.
  • David Switzer said this was the most sobering meeting; suggested cutting 50 people instead of 29, and using volunteer labor and tree giveaways for James Rogers Park.
  • Naylor Bearclaw agreed with Switzer and offered to volunteer.
  • Mrs. Beshearse called the millage vote an "exercise in futility" and advised setting the highest rate without tying hands.

On Consent Agenda (US Water):

  • Naylor Bearclaw detailed problems with U.S. Water in Sunny Hills, arguing the city should not contract with them.

On Flock Cameras:

  • David Switzer requested a town hall focused solely on Flock, taught by a police subject matter expert.
  • Naylor Bearclaw stated "Flock is no good" and voiced civil rights concerns.
  • Ralph Langford spoke in support of Flock, praising Deputy Chief Enfinger's explanation at Commissioner Warrick's meeting.

On City Finances and Personnel:

  • Ms. Day asked if there are pending lawsuits; the city attorney confirmed there are always lawsuits and they are public record.
  • Pamela Parker recommended firing Chris Forehand and criticized staff for allowing Vicky Gainer back in the facility after her termination.

On Memorial Gardens:

  • Naylor Bearclaw endorsed the volunteer effort for Memorial Gardens.

Other:

  • Ryan Scray (Vice Chair of Charter Committee) reminded voters of the August 18th charter referendum.
  • Zack Howard shared his vision for the city, focusing on corporate shareholders of public utilities.
  • Ms. Day questioned the removal of Vicky Gainer's photo from the city hall mural.

Discussion Items

SMART Goals for City Manager (Item 11)

  • Commissioners Warrick, Peebles, and Perno submitted proposed goals. Topics included reducing general fund expenditures by 5%, increasing public-private sponsorships by 250%, and biannual state of the city reports.
  • Commissioners discussed consolidating similar goals and agreed to have Assistant City Manager Hodges compile a unified set for review at the next meeting.
  • Commissioner Warrick emphasized that the goals should be published for public transparency.
  • No vote was taken; the item will return at the next meeting.

Employee Benefits Plans (Item 12)

  • Assistant City Manager Hodges and broker Owen Wingate presented the annual renewal. Florida Blue offered competitive rates due to the city's excellent claims history (50% claim rate). Three plans were proposed, including a new Blue Care HMO option with lower premiums.
  • The city's potential cost savings if employees migrate to the HMO could be up to $178,000 annually.
  • Motion by Commissioner Peebles, second by Commissioner Warrick, to approve the renewal. Passed 5-0.
  • Public comments: Ryan Scray praised the coverage but challenged the city to investigate Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) for employees who rarely use medical services. Mr. Wingate responded that the premium spread was too small to be advantageous. Ms. Day asked if the city put the plans out for bids; she felt other companies might offer better plans. Mr. Wingate noted the city didn't bid because the Florida Blue renewal was so favorable.

FY 2025-2026 Special Budget Amendment (Item 13)

  • Finance Director Kiki Roman explained the only change to the budget was recording the city's $625,000 settlement with Mr. Finch (for prior litigation). Motion by Peebles, second by Perno, passed 5-0.

Mill Bayou Boulevard Drainage Contract (Item 14)

  • Approved a $197,269 service contract with Gulf Coast Utility Contractors, LLC for drainage improvements. Motion by Peebles, second by Perno. Passed 4-1 (Commissioner Tinder voted no).

Culvert Removal, Installation, and Site Restoration Services (Item 15)

  • Approved a three-year master services agreement with American Sand & Asphalt Paving for up to $250,000 (no funds encumbered until purchase orders). Motion by Peebles, second by Perno, passed 5-0.

James Rogers Park Bid Award (Item 16)

  • Discussion only. The city manager recommended rejecting all bids due to budget constraints (no FEMA funds remaining, would require general fund reserves). Commissioners Peebles and Tinder agreed that at minimum, the city should clean up safety hazards in-house (hanging wires, overgrowth) and convert the space to a simple green space. Commissioner Perno noted a promise to residents for something decent and suggested at least one piece of playground equipment, but the city manager said that would cost a minimum of $100,000. The commission directed staff to bring an item to the next meeting to reject all bids and proceed with in-house cleaning.

Setting Millage Rate Ceiling and Hearing Dates (Item 17)

  • Finance Director Roman explained the TRIM Act process. The current millage rate is 4.05. Options: rollback rate (3.9707) requires 3-2 vote; 4.35 (110% of rollback) requires 4-1 vote but still leaves a $405,000 deficit; 4.5869 balances the budget with all cuts (29 positions eliminated, 191 total employees) but requires a 5-0 vote.
  • The commission set the maximum millage ceiling at 4.65 (motion by Commissioner Perno, second by Commissioner Warrick) by a 5-0 vote. (Note: The minutes record a motion for 4.5869, but the transcript indicates the motion was for 4.65, which passed unanimously.)
  • Two public hearings were scheduled for September 8 and September 22, 2026.
  • Discussion highlights: Commissioner Warrick noted that the ceiling is not the final rate and that setting it high provides flexibility. Commissioner Peebles said this is an administrative step and the final vote in September will set the actual rate. The city manager confirmed that even at 4.5869, the budget would still have no capital funds, no events, and the personnel cuts.

Florida and Ohio Avenue Corridor Improvements (Item 18)

  • Awarded ITB #26.26-15 to Gulf Coast Utility Contractors, LLC for $3,150,762 (phases 1A, 1B, 2, and alternate 1). The project is 100% grant-funded.
  • The architect had recommended a general contractor with a general contracting license, but the city attorney clarified that Florida statutes exempt utility and road work from that requirement. The city manager noted GCUC has the bonding capacity and has performed work for the city before.
  • Motion by Commissioner Warrick, second by Commissioner Perno, passed 5-0.

Fee Schedule Amendment (Item 19)

  • Adopted Resolution 2026-07-572, correcting the wholesale water capital connection fees (pass-through fees for the county). Motion by Warrick, second by Tinder, passed 5-0.

Memorial Gardens Discussion (Item 20)

  • Commissioner Tinder reported ongoing vandalism at the Children's Memorial Garden at Kinsaul Park. The gate has been ripped off, solar lights broken, fountain stagnant, and grounds overgrown.
  • The park is deeded to a 501(c)(3) and maintained by volunteers. The police chief is ensuring cameras are operational.
  • Commissioner Tinder and Terry Raw (steering committee) appealed for volunteers (weed eaters, lawnmowers, gate repair, plumbing, electrical) for a cleanup day about three Saturdays hence.
  • Tinder also mentioned a child who suffered second-degree burns from a hot slide at the playground and suggested posting a warning sign about checking equipment temperature.

Reports

Commissioners' Reports:

  • Commissioner Perno thanked staff.
  • Commissioner Peebles reported on a successful Kids Government Day and Coffee with a Commissioner event.
  • Commissioner Warrick discussed the Flock meeting attended by eight people, where attendees reported getting their questions answered. He also noted a resident alerted him to a contractor taking water from a fire hydrant; the city manager had the permit pulled.
  • Commissioner Tinder noted missing letters on park signs and asked about dedication signs at parks.

City Manager's Report:

  • Introduced new agenda software by Civic Plus, which is ADA compliant and allows easier navigation of meeting videos.
  • Commended Deputy Chief Enfinger for training on Flock and attending the public meeting.
  • Announced fall sports registration, splash pad schedule, and an opening on the General Employee Pension Board for commission appointment.
  • Discussed cemetery plot pricing: proposed increasing from $1,000 to $1,500; Mayor recommended January 1, 2027 effective date, which the commission agreed to.

City Attorney's Report:

  • Will circulate rules of decorum ordinance and resolution.
  • Announced this was his last commission meeting; he has served since 2002.

Key Outcomes

  • Consent Agenda (5-0): Approved items 5-9 with noted corrections.
  • Employee Benefits Renewal (5-0): Approved annual renewal with three plan options including new HMO; cost savings possible.
  • Special Budget Amendment (5-0): Incorporated $625,000 Finch settlement.
  • Mill Bayou Drainage Contract (4-1): Awarded to Gulf Coast Utility Contractors.
  • Culvert Services Contract (5-0): Awarded to American Sand & Asphalt Paving (up to $250,000, three-year term).
  • James Rogers Park: No award; staff directed to bring item to next meeting to reject bids and perform in-house safety cleanup and greening.
  • Millage Rate Ceiling (5-0): Set at 4.65 mills for TRIM notice (discrepancy with minutes who record a motion for 4.5869); public hearings scheduled September 8 and 22.
  • Florida/Ohio Ave Corridor (5-0): Awarded to Gulf Coast Utility Contractors.
  • Fee Schedule Amendment (5-0): Corrected water connection fees.
  • SMART Goals: No vote; Assistant City Manager to consolidate commissioners' goals for next meeting.
  • Cemetery Plot Prices: Commission agreed to increase from $1,000 to $1,500 effective January 1, 2027.
  • Next Steps: Rules of decorum ordinance/resolution to be circulated; joint planning workshop to be scheduled; Finance Review Committee to be activated for budget assistance; city manager to meet with committee chair.

Meeting Transcript

I uh let's go with the biggest thing. So we'll go ahead and get started. Steve Taylor from Emerald Coast Fellowship is not here tonight. So you know what that means? Means you're stuck with the mayor giving the prayer tonight. So if y'all would please stand and bow your heads with me. Heavenly Father, we come to you tonight gross graciously and humbly and proud to be able to call Florida home. Let's help each other be good neighbors, help each other build the best community we can, and be understanding of each other as we go through some very challenging times ahead. Um in your precious name we pray. Amen. I pledge allegiance through the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation and indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Pastor Steve Taylor, I am not, but I hope I did all right with y'all tonight for that. All right. First thing tonight, we're a call to order. Uh we have additions, deletions, or modifications of agenda. Commissioner Tinder. I would like to add. Sorry. I'd like to add uh something about the memorial. Okay. Um new business uh number 20 is what that would be, memorial gardens discussion. And Mayor, we need to remove item 10 uh the Dunlap shipment contract. It is not ready yet, so we will have that for the August 11th meeting. Okay, copy that. So I have a proposed uh new number 20, Memorial Gardens discussion with Commissioner Tinder, and we will remove uh old business number 10 until our next meeting. Uh if that is agreeable with the rest of the commission, is there anything else changes or deletions y'all would like to make? If not, can I get a motion? Motion to approve. Second. Thank you. I have a motion and a second. Uh any discussion regarding the uh addition and deletion of the two items to the agenda from the public. Hearing none, City Manager, would you call the roll? Commissioner Perno. Yes. Commissioner Peebles? Yes. Commissioner Wark? Yes. Commissioner Tinder. Yes. Mayor Lowry. Yes. So 5-0 has it. Thank

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com