OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Lynn Haven, Florida/City Commission
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Lynn Haven Budget Workshop #5 Summary: August 25, 2026

City Commission — Tuesday, August 25, 2026
BodyLynn Haven, Florida
SessionCity Commission
DateTuesday, August 25, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

2:17

Welcome and thank you for joining us for this workshop today.

2:20

Uh I see many irregulars.

2:23

Glad y'all are here with us.

2:24

I genuinely appreciate y'all.

2:26

Uh and with that

Unassigned speaker

2:29

thank

Speaker 1

2:29

you, Fire Chief.

2:31

Uh thank y'all to the regulars that come and and uh give your time, blood, sweat, and tears to help us make this city better.

2:38

So today is a workshop, budget workshop.

2:41

This is our third one, I believe, City Manager.

2:44

They all run together now.

2:46

Um

Unassigned speaker

2:47

our

Speaker 1

2:48

fifth budget workshop, and we're gonna turn it over to City Manager and let him roll with it.

2:53

So thanks again for coming and uh we'll get this party started.

Speaker 2

2:56

Thank you, Mayor.

2:57

Um yes, so we had a finance review committee meeting a few days ago, week ago, they all run together as you said.

3:06

Um in discussing the proposed fiscal year twenty-seven budget with the finance review committee.

3:11

They brought back some recommendations.

3:13

Um we have modeled that and we are here to present that to you all today for discussion.

3:17

Uh Kiki will bring it up on her screen to show what the millage rate currently is with a surplus at a four point three five.

3:26

Um, how we arrived at that at the finance review committee's recommendations.

3:31

We have done a few things.

3:32

One is to eliminate the CRA in the proposed fiscal year twenty-seven budget that gives about five hundred and fifty thousand dollars or so back to the general fund.

3:42

Um however, that is definitely a commission decision.

3:44

You all will have to decide as that the approach to go forward.

3:48

I've got a couple of different things for you to see today.

3:51

Uh the first one I'm gonna pass around is a projection that uh Mr.

3:56

Janke and Miss Roman worked on to show a couple of different scenarios of what we will leave on the table if we do away with the CRA.

Unassigned speaker

4:07

So

Speaker 2

4:08

you will see at the bottom of your sheet there the 26.2 million estimate that is projected out to 2043 based on the growth pattern that the CRA has has seen since 2004.

4:20

Um potentially we could receive best case scenario on this projection, around 26.2 million dollars from the county until 2043.

4:31

The lowest estimate as you see right there is the eleven point five million.

4:35

On the right side of the page is what the city would contribute until 2043.

4:40

Best case scenario around 17.6 billion.

4:44

Worst case around 8.2 million.

4:47

So as we've been discussing in all of our budget workshops, you know, at this point everything is a luxury in the general fund.

4:52

Um CRA, sports and rec parks and grounds.

Unassigned speaker

4:55

Um so we are just you know, here to give a couple of different approaches to see where the commission wants to go.

Speaker 2

5:02

Um we are coming up on the time to approve a budget, so we do need some direction and some guidance.

5:08

Um

Speaker 3

5:09

so as

Speaker 2

5:10

you can see, um Kiki, go back to your uh millage screen.

Unassigned speaker

5:17

And

Speaker 2

5:17

Harold, will you also put those on the screens in front of the commissioners?

5:21

So we're at a 4.35 millage with a surplus of 260,000.

5:25

That's now on on your screen in front of you as well, so you don't have to turn around and look at that.

5:29

Uh but that is eliminating the CRA.

5:31

The finance review committee also did also recommend to eliminate flock cameras and the crossings at the rails to trails.

5:39

Staff did not put those recommendations in the proposed budget because staff does not agree with those recommendations nor feel that that is necessary.

Speaker 1

5:54

Thank you for that city manager to kick this off.

5:57

Uh, I want to quickly say to the finance review folks that are here in the audience.

6:03

I see three of y'all.

6:04

Thank you for your due diligence.

6:07

I watched your uh three hour huddle last week, uh, I believe on the 17th.

6:13

And um I appreciate the due diligence that y'all brought.

6:18

Uh and Mr.

6:19

Hines, you jumped right into the fire on that one with your first meeting, sir.

Unassigned speaker

6:23

But

Speaker 1

6:24

uh y'all, y'all definitely did a lot of uh discussion and back and forth, and I very much appreciate that.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Community Redevelopment Agency███████████████████████████████31%
Budget Equity Analysis████████████████████████24%
Fiscal Sustainability█████████████13%
Transportation Safety███████7%
Economic Development█████5%
Personnel Matters█████5%
Parks and Recreation████4%
Public Engagement███3%
Public Safety███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Lynn Haven Budget Workshop #5 Summary: August 25, 2026

The City of Lynn Haven held its fifth budget workshop for Fiscal Year 2027 on Tuesday, August 25, 2026, at 3:00 PM. The workshop focused on balancing the budget by weighing Financial Review Committee (FRC) recommendations against the future of the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA), setting the millage rate, adjusting sanitation rates, and defining the scope of the new City Clerk position.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Mr. Scray: Criticized the approach of solely cutting expenses, urging the commission to find overlapping uses for restricted funds (like CRA and surtax) to free up general fund dollars. He stated the FRC was asked to find cuts, not to be innovative.
  • Mr. Beshearse: Expressed confusion over the 50% CRA reduction, stating it was a valuable tool. He felt the push-button crossing light proposal would not have prevented a recent fatality and argued the $45,000 cost for a City Clerk is a necessary expense of government.
  • Mr. Walker: Questioned historical promises made by the CRA, noting it took 30 years to accumulate funds. He asked whether proposed cuts would affect staff salaries or the Tax Increment Financing (TIFF) funds directly.
  • Mr. Aaron White: Spoke in support of the CRA, highlighting his positive personal experience with it as an economic development resource that connects community leaders and businesses.

Discussion Items

  • CRA Future and 50% Reduction Proposal: Mayor Lowery proposed reducing the CRA's tax increment capture from 95% to 50% as a compromise to balance the budget while preserving the program. CRA Director Ben Janke explained this would drastically reduce project capacity, limit grant matching opportunities (e.g., a $500,000 safe routes to school grant), and slow progress on major infrastructure. Commissioners Peebles, Warrick, and Perno expressed cautious support for keeping the CRA, citing its long-term benefits to the tax base and economic development, despite the short-term fiscal logic of cutting it. Commissioner Perno relayed a text from local builder Brian Knox stressing the CRA's importance. Commissioner Peebles stated the "pros slightly outweigh the cons."
  • City Clerk Salary and Position: Mayor Lowery noted that over 70% of voters approved the new City Clerk position. He proposed adjusting the budgeted salary down from the City Manager level to align with the Assistant City Manager, saving approximately $45,000. He also suggested filling the role by promoting and upgrading an existing employee rather than creating a fully new standalone position.
  • Millage Rate and Budget Scenarios: Finance Director Kiki Roman presented several scenarios. Eliminating the CRA created a $260,000 surplus at a 4.35 millage. Maintaining the CRA created a $287,000 deficit. The 50% CRA cut resulted in a $13,000 deficit, which could be brought to balance with the clerk salary adjustment. A 4-1 vote is needed for rates above the base rate of 3.97. Final state revenue numbers are still pending.
  • Sanitation Rates: The commission discussed raising rates for the first time since 2019. A debate ensued between Commissioner Peebles (who favored spreading the increase more heavily on double-can users) and Commissioner Perno (who proposed a schedule with slightly higher rates across the board). The proposal on the table was roughly a $12 increase for single-can and $14 for double-can, or variations thereof. The option of a separate yard debris fee was tabled in favor of a general rate increase.
  • Rails-to-Trails Crossings: The $80,000 cost to replace three crossing lights was discussed. The City Attorney advised against removing the existing constant-flash lights, warning that shifting the activation duty to cyclists/bikers (push button) could increase liability. Commissioner Peebles identified crossing 389 as the top priority.
  • Emergency Fund: Mayor Lowery requested budgeting an emergency fund. Ms. Roman recommended putting away $1 million annually. City Manager Lightfoot noted that emergency requests can be brought to the commission as needed, and major system emergencies are typically covered in water/sewer enterprise funds.
  • Sports Field Fees: Commissioner Peebles suggested adopting a County-style piecemeal fee schedule for field rentals, charging extra for amenities like mounds, field chalking, and jersey number selection to offset maintenance costs.

Key Outcomes

  • Direction to Staff: The City Manager and Finance Director were directed to prepare a new FY27 budget scenario that includes a 50% reduction in CRA funding and a City Clerk salary aligned with the Assistant City Manager.
  • Additional Workshop Scheduled: The commission agreed to hold a sixth budget workshop on Tuesday, September 1, 2026 at 3:00 PM to finalize the numbers.
  • County Coordination: Mayor Lowery asked City Manager Lightfoot to consult with Bay County regarding their willingness to support a temporary 50% CRA reduction with the possibility of scaling it back up in future years.
  • Public Hearing Scheduled: The final budget vote is anticipated at the regular commission meeting on September 8, 2026.

Meeting Transcript

Welcome and thank you for joining us for this workshop today. Uh I see many irregulars. Glad y'all are here with us. I genuinely appreciate y'all. Uh and with that thank you, Fire Chief. Uh thank y'all to the regulars that come and and uh give your time, blood, sweat, and tears to help us make this city better. So today is a workshop, budget workshop. This is our third one, I believe, City Manager. They all run together now. Um our fifth budget workshop, and we're gonna turn it over to City Manager and let him roll with it. So thanks again for coming and uh we'll get this party started. Thank you, Mayor. Um yes, so we had a finance review committee meeting a few days ago, week ago, they all run together as you said. Um in discussing the proposed fiscal year twenty-seven budget with the finance review committee. They brought back some recommendations. Um we have modeled that and we are here to present that to you all today for discussion. Uh Kiki will bring it up on her screen to show what the millage rate currently is with a surplus at a four point three five. Um, how we arrived at that at the finance review committee's recommendations. We have done a few things. One is to eliminate the CRA in the proposed fiscal year twenty-seven budget that gives about five hundred and fifty thousand dollars or so back to the general fund. Um however, that is definitely a commission decision. You all will have to decide as that the approach to go forward. I've got a couple of different things for you to see today. Uh the first one I'm gonna pass around is a projection that uh Mr. Janke and Miss Roman worked on to show a couple of different scenarios of what we will leave on the table if we do away with the CRA. So you will see at the bottom of your sheet there the 26.2 million estimate that is projected out to 2043 based on the growth pattern that the CRA has has seen since 2004. Um potentially we could receive best case scenario on this projection, around 26.2 million dollars from the county until 2043. The lowest estimate as you see right there is the eleven point five million. On the right side of the page is what the city would contribute until 2043. Best case scenario around 17.6 billion. Worst case around 8.2 million. So as we've been discussing in all of our budget workshops, you know, at this point everything is a luxury in the general fund. Um CRA, sports and rec parks and grounds. Um so we are just you know, here to give a couple of different approaches to see where the commission wants to go. Um we are coming up on the time to approve a budget, so we do need some direction and some guidance. Um so as you can see, um Kiki, go back to your uh millage screen. And Harold, will you also put those on the screens in front of the commissioners? So we're at a 4.35 millage with a surplus of 260,000. That's now on on your screen in front of you as well, so you don't have to turn around and look at that. Uh but that is eliminating the CRA. The finance review committee also did also recommend to eliminate flock cameras and the crossings at the rails to trails. Staff did not put those recommendations in the proposed budget because staff does not agree with those recommendations nor feel that that is necessary.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com