OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Lynn Haven, Florida/City Commission
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Lynn Haven City Commission Special Meeting – September 16, 2026

City Commission — Wednesday, September 16, 2026
BodyLynn Haven, Florida
SessionCity Commission
DateWednesday, September 16, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

2:16

All right, good evening, everyone.

2:18

Welcome to Lynn Haven City Hall tonight for our special meeting.

2:22

It's five thirty, so I'm gonna go ahead and call this meeting to order.

2:26

First thing on the agenda is uh invocation followed by the pledge of allegiance.

2:32

And Lynn Haven Police Department chaplain Cameron Newman is gonna lead us in prayer tonight.

Speaker 2

2:48

Luke chapter sixteen, verse ten says that whoever is faithful with very little will also be faithful with much.

2:56

Please bow your heads.

3:11

Grant these leaders clarity of mind, integrity of heart, and a spirit of cooperation.

3:17

Above all, help them to listen intently, to deliberate justly, to make decisions that promote the common good, safety, and prosperity of all the citizens.

3:28

Father, may our civic duties be handled with humility, fairness, and respect.

3:37

Praying in the name of Jesus Christ.

3:40

Amen.

Speaker 1

4:19

Before I get started, I'd like to turn it over to the city attorney,

Unassigned speaker

4:23

uh,

Speaker 1

4:23

Miss Courtney Singuria, and allow her to explain and give uh some background here on the current legal situation as currently assessed by her and Eric Krebs, our other city attorney.

4:36

And then we will go from there.

4:37

So City Attorney.

Speaker 3

5:02

They declined to weigh in at this time.

5:04

We also did reach out to the Bay County Elections Office who explained that their function is more ministerial.

5:11

Mr.

5:11

Krebs and I conducted our own extensive legal research into this matter, and we did uh issue a written legal opinion to the city commission that has been made public on the city's Facebook page for you all to read in full.

5:27

I am going to read, I'm not going to read it in full tonight.

5:30

Uh I don't want to take that long or put you all to sleep with our legal ease, but I am going to read an excerpt very quickly.

5:38

Um we have been asked to give our legal opinion as to whether Commissioner Judy Tinder's resignation on Tuesday, September 8th, was effective immediately, thereby creating a vacancy on the Lynn Haven City Commission to be filled pursuant to the Linhaven City Charter.

5:53

For the reasons below, our answer is yes.

5:55

It is our opinion that the resignation was effective upon announcement at the public meeting on September 8th, 2026, immediately creating a vacancy to be filled pursuant to the Lynn Haven City Charter.

6:06

It is also our opinion that since Commissioner Tinder's resignation was effective upon her announcement, there was not and is not a need for the commission to vote to accept the resignation.

6:16

Article 10, section three of the Florida State Constitution states in relevant part, vacancy in office shall occur upon the resignation of the incumbent.

6:25

And Smith V.

6:26

Brantley, the Florida Supreme Court was asked to interpret Florida law regarding the resignation of a public official.

6:34

In that case, the public officials' resignation was written and was stated to be effective immediately.

6:40

The court looked to Article 10, Section 3 of the Florida Constitution and at Florida's vacancy by resignation statute, which is now Florida Statute 114.01, which states that a vacancy occurs after the resignation has been accepted by the governor.

6:57

Some have pointed to that statute and noted that there was no formal acceptance of Commissioner Tinder's resignation.

7:03

In the Smith v.

7:04

Brantley case, the Florida Supreme Court grappled with this exact issue.

7:09

Ultimately, the Florida Supreme Court held that a public officer's resignation, stated to be effective immediately, is effective upon submission to the proper authority, and that acceptance is not necessary in order to create a vacancy in office.

7:24

The proper authority has been defined as the entity that has the authority to fill the vacancy.

7:29

It is our opinion that once Commissioner Tinder communicated her resignation to the Commission last week, the resignation was immediately effective and a vacancy was created because the commission has the authority to fill any said vacancy by appointment.

7:43

We note the Florida Supreme Court takes precedent over Robert's rules of order and discuss the issue more fully in our written legal memo, which again has been made publicly available on the City of Lynn Haven's Facebook page.

7:55

Because there is a vacancy, we recommend the commission appoint someone to fill the vacancy.

8:01

We were further asked to research whether the chair of the commission may make and second motions while acting as the chair.

8:07

Our answer is yes, the chair of the commission may make and second motions per the city charter and Robert's rules of order.

8:14

We further note that a tied vote under Robert's rules of order results in a failed vote.

8:19

Legal memos on these matters will also be made available to the public.

Speaker 1

8:28

Thank you very much, Courtney.

8:30

So now what's before us is the city attorney has advised us that Ms.

8:37

Tinder's resignation last Tuesday night was effective immediately.

8:41

And they've pro they've provided Florida case law, Supreme Court decisions to state

Unassigned speaker

8:46

that.

Speaker 1

8:46

So at this point, um we asked for a Florida attorney general opinion.

8:52

That office declined to give us one.

8:54

So we are working with what we've

Unassigned speaker

8:56

got.

Speaker 1

8:57

Nina Ward, our supervisor of elections office was also consulted as well.

9:02

But here we are tonight.

9:04

So before we get started, a couple of administrative things and we'll go from here.

9:14

You wouldn't be here if you

Unassigned speaker

9:15

didn't.

Speaker 1

9:16

So before we even get started tonight, I'm going to ask everyone to be respectful and you don't always have to agree, but we can respectfully disagree.

9:27

Everyone who wants to speak tonight on this particular subject, we're not having general commentary.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Personnel Matters█████████████████████████████████████████████53%
Procedural████████████████████23%
Community Engagement██████████12%
Budget Equity Analysis██████7%
Pending Litigation██2%
Public Engagement█1%
Fiscal Sustainability█1%
Public Safety█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Lynn Haven City Commission Special Meeting – September 16, 2026

The Lynn Haven City Commission held a special meeting on September 16, 2026, beginning at 5:30 PM and adjourning at 7:40 PM, to discuss and potentially appoint a replacement for Seat 4 following Commissioner Judy Tinder's verbal resignation at the previous meeting on September 8, 2026. The four-member commission (Mayor Dave Lowery, Commissioners Pat Perno, Sam Peebles, and Jamie Warrick) deadlocked on multiple candidates, leaving the seat vacant.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Over 30 members of the public spoke during the meeting, with the majority expressing support for reappointing Judy Tinder or criticizing the commission's handling of her resignation. Speakers supporting Tinder argued her resignation was made in the heat of a five-hour meeting and should be withdrawn; some cited Robert's Rules or the city charter as requiring a written, signed resignation.
  • Several speakers, including Gaye Speights, Zach Detwiler, and others, argued that the resignation was legally effective and that Tinder should not be reinstated, citing Florida law and Supreme Court precedent. Detwiler specifically referenced the case Bending v. Reddington Beach (2021).
  • Supporters of individual candidates (Jeff Snyder, Corey Langford, Johnny Beshearse, George Hines, Ryan Scray) spoke to their qualifications. One speaker claimed the city's debt was $28 million, not $18 million.

Discussion Items

  • Legal Background: City Attorney Courtney Sinagra read a legal memo concluding that Commissioner Tinder's verbal resignation was effective immediately upon announcement, per Florida Supreme Court precedent (Smith v. Brantley) and Article 10, Section 3 of the Florida Constitution. She also clarified that the chair may make and second motions, and that a tie vote results in a failed motion.
  • Reappointment of Judy Tinder: Mayor Lowery moved to reappoint Tinder, but no second was offered, so the motion failed. Tinder then recommended Corey Langford as her successor.
  • First Motion (Jeff Snyder): Commissioner Perno moved to appoint Jeff Snyder; Commissioner Peebles seconded. After candidate speeches and public comment, the vote was 2–2 (Peebles aye, Perno aye, Warrick no, Lowery no), failing.
  • Second Motion (Corey Langford): Commissioner Warrick moved to appoint Corey Langford; Mayor Lowery seconded. Public comment followed. Vote: Peebles no, Perno no, Warrick aye, Lowery aye — 2–2, failing.
  • Third Motion (Johnny Beshearse): Commissioner Peebles moved to appoint Johnny Beshearse; Commissioner Perno seconded. After public comment, vote: Peebles aye, Perno aye, Warrick no, Lowery no — 2–2, failing.
  • Attempt to Revive Snyder Motion: Commissioner Warick sought to again nominate Jeff Snyder. City Attorney Sinagra advised that a motion to suspend Robert's Rules of Order would be required to reconsider a failed motion. Mayor Lowery declined to pursue that path, expressing concern it was inappropriate. The meeting then adjourned without an appointment.

Key Outcomes

  • No Appointment Made: After three tie votes on three different candidates, the commission failed to fill Seat 4. The vacancy remains.
  • Legal Precedent Affirmed: The city attorney's opinion that Tinder's resignation was effective immediately and could not be withdrawn was not overruled. The chair's ability to make motions and the effect of tie votes were also confirmed.
  • Public Sentiment: A significant majority of attendees (estimated 75–80% by the mayor and city attorney) raised hands in support of Tinder's reappointment. However, the commission split 2–2 on all votes.
  • Next Steps: No further meeting was scheduled; the commission dispersed. The seat will remain vacant until the April 2027 election unless the governor appoints someone (unlikely).

Meeting Transcript

All right, good evening, everyone. Welcome to Lynn Haven City Hall tonight for our special meeting. It's five thirty, so I'm gonna go ahead and call this meeting to order. First thing on the agenda is uh invocation followed by the pledge of allegiance. And Lynn Haven Police Department chaplain Cameron Newman is gonna lead us in prayer tonight. Luke chapter sixteen, verse ten says that whoever is faithful with very little will also be faithful with much. Please bow your heads. Grant these leaders clarity of mind, integrity of heart, and a spirit of cooperation. Above all, help them to listen intently, to deliberate justly, to make decisions that promote the common good, safety, and prosperity of all the citizens. Father, may our civic duties be handled with humility, fairness, and respect. Praying in the name of Jesus Christ. Amen. Before I get started, I'd like to turn it over to the city attorney, uh, Miss Courtney Singuria, and allow her to explain and give uh some background here on the current legal situation as currently assessed by her and Eric Krebs, our other city attorney. And then we will go from there. So City Attorney. They declined to weigh in at this time. We also did reach out to the Bay County Elections Office who explained that their function is more ministerial. Mr. Krebs and I conducted our own extensive legal research into this matter, and we did uh issue a written legal opinion to the city commission that has been made public on the city's Facebook page for you all to read in full. I am going to read, I'm not going to read it in full tonight. Uh I don't want to take that long or put you all to sleep with our legal ease, but I am going to read an excerpt very quickly. Um we have been asked to give our legal opinion as to whether Commissioner Judy Tinder's resignation on Tuesday, September 8th, was effective immediately, thereby creating a vacancy on the Lynn Haven City Commission to be filled pursuant to the Linhaven City Charter. For the reasons below, our answer is yes. It is our opinion that the resignation was effective upon announcement at the public meeting on September 8th, 2026, immediately creating a vacancy to be filled pursuant to the Lynn Haven City Charter. It is also our opinion that since Commissioner Tinder's resignation was effective upon her announcement, there was not and is not a need for the commission to vote to accept the resignation. Article 10, section three of the Florida State Constitution states in relevant part, vacancy in office shall occur upon the resignation of the incumbent. And Smith V. Brantley, the Florida Supreme Court was asked to interpret Florida law regarding the resignation of a public official. In that case, the public officials' resignation was written and was stated to be effective immediately. The court looked to Article 10, Section 3 of the Florida Constitution and at Florida's vacancy by resignation statute, which is now Florida Statute 114.01, which states that a vacancy occurs after the resignation has been accepted by the governor. Some have pointed to that statute and noted that there was no formal acceptance of Commissioner Tinder's resignation. In the Smith v. Brantley case, the Florida Supreme Court grappled with this exact issue. Ultimately, the Florida Supreme Court held that a public officer's resignation, stated to be effective immediately, is effective upon submission to the proper authority, and that acceptance is not necessary in order to create a vacancy in office. The proper authority has been defined as the entity that has the authority to fill the vacancy. It is our opinion that once Commissioner Tinder communicated her resignation to the Commission last week, the resignation was immediately effective and a vacancy was created because the commission has the authority to fill any said vacancy by appointment. We note the Florida Supreme Court takes precedent over Robert's rules of order and discuss the issue more fully in our written legal memo, which again has been made publicly available on the City of Lynn Haven's Facebook page. Because there is a vacancy, we recommend the commission appoint someone to fill the vacancy. We were further asked to research whether the chair of the commission may make and second motions while acting as the chair. Our answer is yes, the chair of the commission may make and second motions per the city charter and Robert's rules of order. We further note that a tied vote under Robert's rules of order results in a failed vote. Legal memos on these matters will also be made available to the public. Thank you very much, Courtney. So now what's before us is the city attorney has advised us that Ms. Tinder's resignation last Tuesday night was effective immediately. And they've pro they've provided Florida case law, Supreme Court decisions to state that. So at this point, um we asked for a Florida attorney general opinion.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com