Miami-Dade Housing Committee Meeting - May 13, 2025
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Miami-Dade Housing Committee Meeting - May 13, 2025
This meeting of the Miami-Dade Housing Committee, chaired by Commissioner Marleine Bastien, convened on Tuesday, May 13, 2025, at 2:00 PM. After roll call, the committee heard a special presentation on the Commission for Women's CEDAW recommendations, received public comments, and then voted unanimously to approve the entire agenda as amended, forwarding all items to the Board of County Commissioners (BCC). The meeting adjourned without debating individual items.
Special Presentation: Commission for Women's CEDAW Recommendations Report
- Presenter: Josie Nova (Legislative Chair of the Commission for Women) and Dr. Martin (new Director).
- Key Statistics Presented:
- 84.7% increase in domestic violence cases; over 300 additional cases and 286 forcible sex offenses.
- Black maternal mortality has nearly tripled; updated figures show it is now five times higher for black women in childbirth.
- Only 57% of black women receive adequate prenatal care.
- 18% wage gap among full-time female workers ($41,454 vs. $50,577 for men); within county government a 16.7% gap (women median $64,522, men $77,446).
- Recommendations: Create two new CVAC centers in underserved areas; fund a maternal health fair; conduct a county workforce analysis to determine why pay disparity exists, not just where.
- Discussion: Commissioners expressed concern and support. Commissioner Gonzalez asked about strategies to fund projects and increase capacity. Chairwoman Bastien proposed a conference with the Women's Fund of Miami-Dade and other partners to develop resolutions. Commissioner McGhee praised the presentation and offered to host events in his district.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Speaker 1 – Sarah Harold (representing YWCA of South Florida): Expressed support for the YWCA restrictive covenant amendment (Item 2C) and offered to answer questions.
- Speaker 2 – Renita Holmes (Director of Waival Women and Public Housing): Addressed violence against women in underserved communities, lack of safe housing, and gaps in police response. Urged the board to consult data from the Black Advisory Board and focus on frontline experiences.
Consent Calendar and Agenda Actions
- Item 3D (Summer Food Service Program) was removed from the agenda prior to the vote.
- Motion to set the agenda in order and then motion to approve the agenda as a whole as amended (excluding Item 3D) passed unanimously (voice vote, no opposition).
- Amendments to Item 3B (Palm Court/Palm Towers Ground Lease): Chairwoman Bastien introduced a floor amendment to limit conversion to market-rate units after the tax credit period to a maximum of 49 units. The amendment also corrected scrivener errors (spelling of “amended,” changing “developer” to “tenant,” and updating department initials). The committee adopted this amendment.
Key Outcomes
- All 14 remaining agenda items were forwarded to the BCC with a favorable recommendation by a 3-0 vote (per the agenda notation; the transcript confirms a unanimous voice vote on the overall amended agenda).
- Items forwarded include:
- 2A: CMS International Group – amended deed and extension.
- 2B: Choix Financial Group – surplus property conveyance for affordable housing.
- 2C: YWCA – first amendment to restrictive covenant (corrected).
- 2D: Mount Sinai CDC – amended deed and extension.
- 2E: Renaming “Black Business Month” to “Black-Owned Business Month 305.”
- 2F: Affordable Housing and Community Development, Inc. – infill housing deed amendment.
- 2G: Tar Holdings International and Sankofa Group – surplus property conveyance (corrected).
- 3A: FY2025 SHIP Homebuyer Education and Counseling funding recommendations (up to $1,200,000).
- 3B: 99-year amended ground lease for Palm Court/Palm Towers ($90.8M lease, $6.66M consulting agreement) — as amended.
- 3C: First amendment to Master Development Agreement with RUDG, LLC.
- 3E: Additional expenditure authority ($4M) for elderly meal services.
- 3F: 99-year ground lease for Liberty Square Phase Five ($48.7M).
- 3G: 99-year ground lease for Liberty Square Elderly ($38.7M).
- 3H: 99-year master ground lease and MDA for West Grove development (Integral Florida, LLC; $434.2M total).
- Next Steps: All items will be considered by the full Board of County Commissioners at a future meeting.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned by unanimous consent immediately after approval of the agenda.
Meeting Transcript
I'd like to invite you to the housing committee meeting on this 13th day of May 2025. Madam Clerk, please call the roll. Good afternoon. The clerk's office has received notice that Commissioner Higgins will be absent from today's meeting. Commissioner McGee. Commissioner Ragalado. Vice Chairman Gonzalez. Chairwoman Bastian. Here. Two members present. We do not have a quorum. Thank you, Madam Clerk. While we're waiting for our colleagues to come, I see Commissioner Gonzalez coming. So we with that, I think we have a quo. Okay. I'd like to invite our vice chair. Yes. To lead us in prayer and the pledge of allegiance. Please bow your head. Heavenly Father, we come to you to say thank you once again for giving us breath and protecting our families and our friends. We also say to you thank you again for once allowing once again allowing Miami Dade County to stand as the beacon of hope for so many across this world. And we also say thank you very much for blessing the state and this country and blessing this day and our mayor and all the county elected officials, along with the county employees who keep this machine going. And we ask for all with your son's name. Amen. Please introduce yourself. Madame. Over 300 more domestic violence cases and 286 forcible sex offenses. These numbers call for action, which is why the CFW is recommending the creation of two new CVAC centers in Miami Dade County in underserved areas to be identified by the administration, as well as a multimedia marketing campaign to advertise these two new facilities and raise awareness for CVAC locations as a whole. Did you have a question? Oh, okay. I'm sorry. Moving on to our next key policy area black maternal mortality rates. We found that only 57% of black women receive adequate prenatal care. Black maternal mortality has increased by nearly three times, and that black women have the highest infant mortality rates. This is why we urge the BCC to authorize and fund a maternal health fair to be held by the Commission for Women, bringing local partners who will provide educational prenatal delivery and postnatal services. And lastly, the CDAW data has identified economic opportunity and the wage gap as an area of need for the women of our community. There is currently an 18% wage gap amongst full-time female workers as opposed to their male counterparts. This figure has increased 5% since 2011. Average earnings for a full-time woman was 41,454 a year compared to 50,577 a year for men. That's 9,123 less per year. And this disparity persists even amongst county employees with a 16.7% wage gap. Women's medium pay for positions in the county was $64,522 compared to men's median pay of $77,446, a staggering $13,000 less on average. This is why our recommendation is for the county to conduct an analysis on the county employee workforce and determine why a pay disparity exists and not just simply where it persists. The goal is to find out why the disparity happens and create a roadmap for internal solutions across departments and leadership levels. This includes our recommendations for this year. Thank you again, Chair Bastien, Vice Chairman Gonzalez, this body, and the administration for the opportunity to discuss our findings and collaborate for the betterment of our community. And our wonderful legislative committee who works so diligently every year to put these recommendations together. Thank you. Thank you so much. I have a question pertaining to the high level of violence, the increase of violence.
openpublica.com