OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Milwaukee Judiciary & Legislation Committee Meeting - July 27, 2026

Common CouncilMonday, July 27, 2026
BodyMilwaukee, Wisconsin
SessionCommon Council
DateMonday, July 27, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:40:00

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

We want them to make a good informed decision.

0:03

We see how they interact with the animal.

0:05

We show them a variety of animals that might work out well in their family.

0:09

And we ask that kids are available to interact with the animal if there are kids in the family as well.

0:15

A lot of our programs are education driven.

0:18

We provide programs for children with regard to kindness to animals.

0:23

We always want to promote kindness to animals in all the programs that we do.

0:27

Our entire building is one uh educational extravaganza.

0:32

We've got a lot of information throughout the shelter that people can stop and look at and really get educated with everything from what type of um dog might be best suited to a family to preventing uh any problems from occurring to training, a variety of issues.

0:51

So we're always looking to educate the public.

0:54

While the humane society can help you, you can also help the shelter with volunteer opportunities.

1:01

We have such a variety of opportunities for people.

1:04

Anybody is interested, give us a call because they can interact with the animals and they really do provide a great service.

1:11

Got a problem with a skunk in your window well, raccoons in the attic or tearing at your garbage cans.

1:18

For help with native or migratory wildlife species, you can contact a private trapping and pest removal service or another department of the Wisconsin Humane Society.

1:29

Our goal is to um rescue, rehabilitate, and release native wild animals.

1:37

And uh another function that we have is to help talk people through uh nuisance problems they may be maybe having with wildlife, and also to help advocate for wild animals in the city here and help prevent injury, fear, pain, and disruption for wildlife in the first place.

1:54

The Wisconsin Humane Society's wildlife rehabilitation center annually receives and cares for over 5,000 injured, sick, and orphaned wild animals like this blue heron.

2:06

It has seen some 150 different species of animals, many of them familiar to our area, many are not.

2:14

We'll admit anything here from snapping turtles to uh um great-horned owls and and uh white-tailed deer and all sorts of creatures, any any native wild creature that you can think of that can fly over or live in Milwaukee County, we've we've admitted here for care.

2:32

A creature that's relatively sedentary, like a gray squirrel.

2:37

Um we if it's an adult gray squirrel squirrel, once we rehabilitate it, we'd try and get it back to the neighborhood it came from because that's where it knows where everything is that it needs, it's food, water, shelter, all there.

2:49

Um for juveniles.

2:50

If we get in a baby raccoon, for instance, and uh we rehabilitate that, we would not take it back to where it came from in the city because it needs to learn uh we don't want it to become a nuisance animal by being let go again in the city and trying to find its way and find food in the city.

3:06

So those creatures will go out to private lands.

3:09

In addition to helping animals in the wildlife hospital, the center provides advice to thousands of callers about injured, sick, orphaned, or nuisance wild animals.

3:19

If if people see healthy animals and they have questions about it, they wonder why is this animal in my yard or is it dangerous or not?

3:27

And and you know, anything about it.

3:29

There's a variety of resources they can call.

3:31

They can call one of the nature centers around, but they can certainly call us and we'll talk to them about the natural history of this animal, why it's in their yard, what it might be looking for at a at a particular time of year, and um and how they can deal with with coexisting with that animal and ideally appreciating it.

3:50

If they find injured, sick or orphaned animals or animals they think are any one of those three things.

3:57

Again, we invite them to call us and we'll talk them through it.

4:00

Uh sometimes they they think things may be injured or orphaned.

4:04

For instance, this season right now in the summertime, we get a lot of calls from people who have found fledgling birds, for instance, wild birds, be it a morning dove or uh uh a baby robin or something, and they'll immediately jump to the conclusion that it's orphaned.

4:20

And in fact, it's probably a fledgling that has its parent taking care of it, but the parents not there all the time.

4:27

The parent has to go out, find things to feed the youngster, fly back, feed it for a short period of time, fly out again.

4:34

So we we'll counsel people about watching that animal and trying to determine whether it's truly orphaned or not, whether it's truly injured or not.

4:42

You can also visit the center, check out their wildlife gallery.

4:46

View a behind the scenes video about the work of the wild animal hospital.

4:50

Walk through the animal house to learn how to animal proof your home.

5:00

We get thousands of phone calls a year, sometimes 125 a day from people asking us, I have a chipmunk in my dryer vent.

5:06

Raccoons are getting in my garbage cans.

5:09

Something's in my chimney, something's living under my deck, all sorts of things like that.

5:13

It's very, very common.

5:15

So we have both our animal house here.

5:17

We invite people to come in, look around the animal house.

5:20

It's uh it's a walkthrough model.

5:23

Uh it shows various aspects of uh actually shows things that animals can get into that you may not want them to get into.

5:32

Uh raccoons getting into garbage cans, a simple solution is use bungee cords across the top of the can prevent them from getting in there.

5:40

Um cap your chimney to keep animals from getting in the chimney.

5:43

Some animals get in the chimney and they can't get out.

5:46

So you do yourself and the animals are favored by animal proofing your house.

5:50

Animal shelters receive many calls from people who are not equipped to care for their pets, be they cats and dogs or exotic animals.

5:59

Many of them are simply abandoned, and the humane society says that's irresponsible.

6:05

And unfortunately, it's it's very common for people to just dump things in parks.

6:08

They think, well, you know, I don't want this anymore, it can be free out here.

6:12

Uh these animals are from their perspective not equipped for survival.

6:16

And in terms of populations, in terms of the health of wildlife in general, releasing uh a creature that could have uh a disease that's transmissible to other wild creatures is would be devastating.

6:28

If this monkey pox business had gotten out into the wild, would have been absolutely devastating for for native wildlife.

6:35

So, under no circumstances should anyone release um exotic creatures to the wild.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Pending Litigation█████████████████████████████████████████████63%
Urban Forestry Management██████8%
Business Licensing█████7%
Public Works███4%
Water And Wastewater Management███4%
Public Health██3%
Public Engagement██3%
Animal Welfare2%
Public Education Funding2%
Summary of Proceedings

Milwaukee Judiciary & Legislation Committee Meeting - July 27, 2026

The Judiciary & Legislation Committee of the Milwaukee Common Council met on Monday, July 27, 2026, at 9:08 AM in Room 301-B of City Hall. Chair DeAndre Jackson presided, with Alders Pratt, Bauman, and Perez present; Ald. Westmoreland was excused. The committee heard 15 agenda items, primarily claims and appeals for property damage against the city, as well as real estate tax cancellations and settlements of lawsuits. The meeting adjourned at 12:18 PM after a closed session to discuss litigation.

Consent Calendar

  • Item 11 (260394): Resolution cancelling real estate taxes on five parcels (one residential, four commercial) on the 2025 tax roll, with a total refund of $13,599.12. Recommended for adoption after brief explanation by Assessment Appeals Director Dan Campbell. Passed unanimously.
  • Items 12–15: After closed session, the committee approved three settlement resolutions and one claim payment on recommendation of the City Attorney:
    • Item 12 (260428): Rescinding previous file and authorizing settlement in 875 East 1, LLC et al. v. City of Milwaukee.
    • Item 13 (260375): Authorizing payment of the claim of Branden Walker.
    • Item 14 (260383): Authorizing payment to Yolanda Moffett.
    • Item 15 (260449): Authorizing settlement in Haven Funds, LLC v. City of Milwaukee.

Discussion Items and Key Outcomes

Item 1 – Claim of Keyauna Brumfield (251932): Claimant did not appear (second no-show). Motion by Ald. Pratt to recommend disallowance and indefinite postponement. Passed unanimously.

Item 2 – Appeal of William Welch (252151): Claim for vehicle damage from a city tree branch. City Attorney noted the claim was filed 164 days after the incident, exceeding the 120-day statutory limit. Urban Forestry Manager testified the branch fell on a calm day. Motion to deny (disallow) by Ald. Bauman passed unanimously. Council explained the process for further appeal.

Item 3 – Appeal of Michael Dupar (260238): Claim for vehicle damage from a large branch of a honey locust tree. Dupar argued the city was negligent because a prior complaint about the tree led to crews trimming the wrong tree. Forestry disputed weather severity and noted branch was alive and no decay visible. Ald. Bauman moved to settle for $1,000. Dupar accepted after brief negotiation. Substitute resolution recommended for adoption. Passed unanimously.

Item 4 – Appeal of Mark and Heidi Gremmer (252150): Claim for vehicle damage from a city-owned ash tree that uprooted. City Attorney stated the claim was filed 224 days after the incident, untimely. Forestry noted tree had a decay cavity and was on removal list. Motion to deny by Ald. Bauman passed unanimously.

Item 5 – Appeal of Jason Musante-Klumb (252153): Claim for vehicle damage from a branch fall. City recommended denial because damage was not foreseeable. Claimant argued the city was negligent due to a prior branch failure in 2023 from the same tree. Motion to deny by Ald. Bauman passed 3-0 with Ald. Jackson abstaining. Chair noted claimant has insurance.

Item 6 – Claim of Mario and Chantel Dantzler (252168): Claim for fence damage from a collapsed storm sewer and historic flooding. City offered $5,000 settlement, acknowledging the collapsed pipe may have contributed. Ald. Bauman moved to substitute and recommend adoption. Claimants accepted. Passed unanimously.

Item 7 – Appeal of William Shaw (260226): Claim for sewer backup and basement flooding. City Attorney stated claim was filed 14 months after the incident, untimely. Waterworks staff detailed investigation indicating damage likely not from city work. Motion to deny by Ald. Bauman passed unanimously. Committee noted the 120-day filing requirement is a state statute.

Item 8 – Claim of Ayshia Banks (251170): Claim for sewer lateral damage allegedly from lead service line replacement in 2017. City Attorney stated claim is untimely and lacks proof of causation. Motion to deny by Ald. Bauman passed unanimously.

Item 9 – Claim of Logan Heinrich and Thomas Ravert (251852): Claim for sewer backup damage alleging a 54-inch water main shifted and damaged lateral. City moved denial due to lack of evidence and claim size ($37,200). Ald. Bauman moved denial, stating the committee is not equipped to handle such complex claims without expert testimony. Passed unanimously.

Item 10 – Claim of Charlie Mikel (251851): Claim for wall damage allegedly from a city sanitation truck. Fleet investigation found no evidence of city vehicle involvement. Claimant admitted insurance covered most damage and sought only $1,000 deductible. Motion to deny by Ald. Bauman passed unanimously.

Item 11 – Tax cancellation (see Consent Calendar above).

Items 12–15 – Considered in closed session; approved (see Consent Calendar above).

Key Outcomes

  • Claims Denied (untimely or lack of evidence): Items 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10 were recommended for disallowance and indefinite postponement, moving to the full Common Council on July 31, 2026.
  • Claims Settled: Items 3 (Dupar) settled for $1,000; Item 6 (Dantzler) settled for $5,000.
  • Tax Cancellation Approved: Item 11 (real estate tax refund of $13,599.12) recommended for adoption.
  • Litigation Settlements Approved: Items 12–15 (after closed session) recommended for adoption.
  • Process Note: Claimants were informed that a committee denial is not final; they may appeal to the full council on July 31, 2026, and then to circuit court after receiving a formal denial notice.

Meeting Transcript

We want them to make a good informed decision. We see how they interact with the animal. We show them a variety of animals that might work out well in their family. And we ask that kids are available to interact with the animal if there are kids in the family as well. A lot of our programs are education driven. We provide programs for children with regard to kindness to animals. We always want to promote kindness to animals in all the programs that we do. Our entire building is one uh educational extravaganza. We've got a lot of information throughout the shelter that people can stop and look at and really get educated with everything from what type of um dog might be best suited to a family to preventing uh any problems from occurring to training, a variety of issues. So we're always looking to educate the public. While the humane society can help you, you can also help the shelter with volunteer opportunities. We have such a variety of opportunities for people. Anybody is interested, give us a call because they can interact with the animals and they really do provide a great service. Got a problem with a skunk in your window well, raccoons in the attic or tearing at your garbage cans. For help with native or migratory wildlife species, you can contact a private trapping and pest removal service or another department of the Wisconsin Humane Society. Our goal is to um rescue, rehabilitate, and release native wild animals. And uh another function that we have is to help talk people through uh nuisance problems they may be maybe having with wildlife, and also to help advocate for wild animals in the city here and help prevent injury, fear, pain, and disruption for wildlife in the first place. The Wisconsin Humane Society's wildlife rehabilitation center annually receives and cares for over 5,000 injured, sick, and orphaned wild animals like this blue heron. It has seen some 150 different species of animals, many of them familiar to our area, many are not. We'll admit anything here from snapping turtles to uh um great-horned owls and and uh white-tailed deer and all sorts of creatures, any any native wild creature that you can think of that can fly over or live in Milwaukee County, we've we've admitted here for care. A creature that's relatively sedentary, like a gray squirrel. Um we if it's an adult gray squirrel squirrel, once we rehabilitate it, we'd try and get it back to the neighborhood it came from because that's where it knows where everything is that it needs, it's food, water, shelter, all there. Um for juveniles. If we get in a baby raccoon, for instance, and uh we rehabilitate that, we would not take it back to where it came from in the city because it needs to learn uh we don't want it to become a nuisance animal by being let go again in the city and trying to find its way and find food in the city. So those creatures will go out to private lands. In addition to helping animals in the wildlife hospital, the center provides advice to thousands of callers about injured, sick, orphaned, or nuisance wild animals. If if people see healthy animals and they have questions about it, they wonder why is this animal in my yard or is it dangerous or not? And and you know, anything about it. There's a variety of resources they can call. They can call one of the nature centers around, but they can certainly call us and we'll talk to them about the natural history of this animal, why it's in their yard, what it might be looking for at a at a particular time of year, and um and how they can deal with with coexisting with that animal and ideally appreciating it. If they find injured, sick or orphaned animals or animals they think are any one of those three things. Again, we invite them to call us and we'll talk them through it. Uh sometimes they they think things may be injured or orphaned. For instance, this season right now in the summertime, we get a lot of calls from people who have found fledgling birds, for instance, wild birds, be it a morning dove or uh uh a baby robin or something, and they'll immediately jump to the conclusion that it's orphaned. And in fact, it's probably a fledgling that has its parent taking care of it, but the parents not there all the time. The parent has to go out, find things to feed the youngster, fly back, feed it for a short period of time, fly out again. So we we'll counsel people about watching that animal and trying to determine whether it's truly orphaned or not, whether it's truly injured or not. You can also visit the center, check out their wildlife gallery. View a behind the scenes video about the work of the wild animal hospital. Walk through the animal house to learn how to animal proof your home. We get thousands of phone calls a year, sometimes 125 a day from people asking us, I have a chipmunk in my dryer vent. Raccoons are getting in my garbage cans. Something's in my chimney, something's living under my deck, all sorts of things like that. It's very, very common. So we have both our animal house here. We invite people to come in, look around the animal house. It's uh it's a walkthrough model. Uh it shows various aspects of uh actually shows things that animals can get into that you may not want them to get into. Uh raccoons getting into garbage cans, a simple solution is use bungee cords across the top of the can prevent them from getting in there. Um cap your chimney to keep animals from getting in the chimney.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com