0:17Good morning, everyone.
0:19My name is Elliot Payne.
0:20I'm the president of Minneapolis City Council.
0:22And before we convene our meeting, we have presentations of honorary resolutions.
0:27We are pleased to welcome guests to the space to share in these presentations before taking up our agenda.
0:32First up is a resolution recognizing young Southeast Asian Leaders Initiative Professional Fellows Program, presented by Councilmember Palmasano.
0:44Morning, good morning, everybody.
0:46We're here with the first resolution of the day honoring the fellows of the Young Southeast Asian Leaders Initiative, the Professional Fellows Program.
0:55And we have an alumnus of this program with us too.
0:58I learned how to do this from my friend and Councilmember Latricia Vita.
1:14So Margaret Anderson Kelleher and I were both hosts here in City Hall of this program, as were others across the street with the county, and you'll you'll learn a little bit more.
1:26I'll read about half of this.
1:33Honoring the fellows of the Young Southeast Asian Leaders Initiative Professional Fellows Program, whereas the Young Southeast Asian Leaders Initiative Professional Fellows Program is sponsored by the U the U.S.
1:46State Department Bureau of Education and Cultural Affairs.
1:50And whereas Y Selly Program begins emerging brings emerging leaders to the United States for intensive fellowships designed to broaden their professional expertise.
2:02And the Y Selly program affords promising young professionals the opportunity to have firsthand experiences in and exposure to United States offices working on a variety of issues related to innovation, entrepreneurship, and economic empowerment, society and governance, civic engagement and sustainability and the environment.
2:26And whereas the Y Selly program builds the leadership capabilities of young professionals in 10 member countries and promotes cross-border cooperation to solve regional and global challenges, and whereas fellows will gain additional exposure to U.S.
2:44communities through enhancement activities, community service, and a host of hospitality experience.
2:51And whereas the YCLE program promotes the following broad goals to promote mutual understanding and lasting partnerships between emerging leaders from the 10 member and United States, uh provide opportunities for participants, ages 25 to 35 to collaborate, share ideas, approaches, and strategies to develop solutions to pressing local and global challenges, increase Americans' global competitiveness through new and expanded partnerships with professionals from Southeast Asia, create resilient communities and more.
3:24Whereas the current cohort of YC Lee Fellows in Minneapolis have been assigned to the City of Minneapolis, Hennepin County, the Downtown Improvement District in topic areas of judicial processes, economic development, communications, public planning and infrastructure, and legislative systems.
3:42Whereas the fellows have immersed themselves in American and Minneapolis culture by volunteering at the food bank at the community emergency assistant program, visiting the Minnesota Sioux, Target Field, the Minnesota Supreme Court, and many others going to concerts at the Armory and Grand Casino Arena, eating at many local restaurants, and experiencing the joy of a juicy Lucy.
4:06And whereas the hosts of the eight fellows in Minneapolis are Chief Judge Carrie Meyer, Assistant Chief Judge Mark Kappelhoff, Judge Annual Angelo Wilms, Hennepin County Commissioner Marion Green, Hennepin County Director of Broadband Phil Essington, Downtown Improvement District Director Adam Dunnock, Minneapolis City Operations Officer Margaret Anderson Kelleher, and myself.
4:46So just briefly, I um I engaged in this program because I got a call from Mike who said they needed one more host.
5:00And um, you know, I I agreed to it in part because my friend and colleague Letricia Vita has hosted one and I got to sort of be a part of that process a little bit and and learn about the amazing experience that that she um and Maina had together.
5:13And um I just I could not have uh thought of how much joy it would bring me to see Minneapolis through the eyes of the fellows again and to introduce them to a couple of things.
5:26Um Ali is is my fellow, and I have so enjoyed learning about the Philippines from her.
5:32I have so enjoyed bringing her to um exciting competitive high school soccer games in my community, um, and and and trying out restaurants, none of which are spicy enough for her, um, and more.
5:45Um so I I have learned a lot through this program, and I I hope you've enjoyed fall in the Midwest here.
5:53So I'm gonna have Margaret say a couple words and then we're gonna try to introduce all of the fellows and have a couple of words from you.
6:01Thank you, Council members, and thank you to the council for having our guests here today.
6:06Um, James was our fellow in the COO's office and focused on sustainability and health-related issues and climate.
6:14I do want to thank staff as well.
6:17I want to thank Anna as well as Ruth and Molly for really helping everyone get around.
6:24But uh the the reason I have participated over and over again in many different roles of hosting a fellow is that I think the exchange of ideas is so important in the world.
6:36Um you come to learn here, but we are also learning from you.
6:40And I know James did over 30 meetings with city staff over the last four weeks, spent sort of a residency and health and climate, and did all of those things.
6:51And I just know also that we are looking at a group of people who there's a future prime minister in here, there's a future chief judge in here.
6:59We know that you are all going to continue to excel, and we hope you remember your time here in Minneapolis and Minnesota fondly.
7:08So thank you for being here.
7:10And I will pass the mic down so everyone can introduce themselves, and then I think we have a couple speakers from the group that have been designated.
7:17So let's do the introductions and then come back and do the comments.
7:22Um good morning, everyone.
7:23I'm Trum from Vietnam.
7:24I'm a fellow at uh Minneapolis Dao Tao Council with Edam Dunik.
7:29Thank you very much for uh hosting us and giving us the honor today.
7:34Good morning, everyone.
7:35My name is Fen from Thailand.
7:37I'm so grateful that I'm here.
7:41Uh I'll go back to Thailand and tell people how generous you guys are, and also Josh Willems, my host.
7:50Um, good morning, everyone.
7:53I'm from Indonesia, and here I'm at touch with Chief of Judge uh Kerry Mayer.
7:58Um just want to say we fly we've we all fly more than 20 hours all the way from our own countries to the United States, and I think since day one, uh the biggest blessing that we have so far is that every each individual that we met has been very much welcome us since day one, and I think that's something that we never take it for granted.
8:17Every single encounters that I have um since day one, getting our fits here into Minneapolis has been filled with so much warms, kindness, a lot of foods, love, events, concert, hockey games, and everything that I think we never have that experience back home.
8:31So definitely four weeks here is not enough, and we've just been um so much grateful and blessed with every kindness that we met uh so far.
8:41Good morning everyone.
8:43I'm from Sabah, Malaysia, and over here in Minneapolis, I'm attached to um Commissioner Green and Director Phil Asentin.
8:51Um I guess I can go on to my stream.
8:54So um thank you, Council members, for this incredible honor.
8:58So um I can see on behalf of the YC Lee fellow, I like to express my deepest gratitude to the city of Minneapolis, our hosts, partners, and new friends, for welcoming us so warmly over this four weeks.
9:12Um, your commitment to community inclusivity.
9:15Um, and we'll bring we'll be bringing back not just lessons and leadership, but the heart of Minneapolis itself, its kindness, openness, and sense of shared purpose.
9:25Um, thank you again for your hospitality and sharing your Minneapolis spirit with us.
9:34Um I'm JD from the Philippines.
9:36I'm a gender and development professional from the Philippine Commission and Women.
9:40Um I'm a touch with um Hennepin County Commissioner Marion Green and Director Phil Essington.
9:45Um it's been so um amazing journey for us, and we're so very grateful, and this will be a forever long-term memory for us.
9:56So thank you so much for this.
10:00Mabu hi, I am Aliana Ainika Mambato from the Philippines.
10:03I'm a prosecution back home.
10:05And in behalf of the Young Southeast Asia Leadership Initiative program, we thank the city of Minneapolis, especially the council members.
10:12Thank you so much for today, and especially to my host, Councilmember Linnae, Paul Mistano, for bringing us here and for showing us around Minnesota and Minneapolis.
10:19And we will surely be very grateful that we found North Star here in the United States.
10:25And you will always have an ally in Mindanao in the Philippines.
10:28So I mean Salamatpo.
10:33I'm James Nathaniel Fuyo.
10:35I'm attached with my CEO Mac, uh, Margaret Anderson getting her in.
10:41And I don't know, uh in fact, I don't know what to say at this moment since uh every time that uh I enter in the city hall, I feel like oh, I'm having uh this feeling separation anxiety.
10:54And I've been working with uh with the uh Office of Public Service with dealing with different uh offices and at the same time learning their stories.
11:07And I think uh I already have a second home when I go back here in the United States, and I believe uh Minneapolis will be always part of my heart.
11:22I'm a magistrate judge back in Malaysia.
11:24Uh here I'm attached with Judge Mark Keppelhoff, and thank you for the experience and the welcome.
11:32Thank you, everybody.
11:33We're gonna take a quick picture where we're gonna need you between these two black pieces of tape.
11:59So I have nine who was here with me.
12:09Thank you very much.
12:23Next, we will recognize Election Judge Appreciation Day with Councilmember Palmasano.
12:36Hi, JD, how are you?
12:46Again, good morning, everybody.
12:48Um this next resolution is about election judge appreciation.
12:53I don't know how many people know this, but I got my start as an election judge on the front lines of democracy.
12:59And it is so impressive to see how it's run.
13:03It's so impressive to see how committed the people who volunteer their time.
13:07You know, they don't work for the city very long, um, but they are absolutely essential to what goes on in this democracy and and this year in municipal elections.
13:18So let me just briefly read the resolution and then I'm gonna turn it over to Director Katie Smith.
13:23Um, whereas the city of Minneapolis is proud of its enviable national reputation as a leader in voter participation, the high quality administration of its elections, the caliber of its cadre of professional election administrators, and the unwavering community focus on ensuring all voters have free, fair, and equitable access to the ballot box.
13:46And whereas their service election judges in Minneapolis bring the dedication, commitment, and expertise that upholds the integrity and accuracy of elections in compliance with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations, while providing the direct support to serve all voters, whether during the early voting period or at the polls on election day, they play a critical role in achieving a representative system of democracy and in building and sustaining public trust in the electoral process.
14:16And whereas an estimated 2,070 individuals have been recruited, trained, and scheduled to serve as election judges for the 2025 municipal general election, thereby to help ensure this year's election is conducted in accordance with the principles of freedom and liberty upon which the United States of America, the state of Minnesota, and the city of Minneapolis were founded.
14:39Now, therefore, be it resolved that the mayor and city council hereby designate Tuesday, November 4th to be Election Judge Appreciation Day in the city of Minneapolis in recognition of their valued service and contributions.
14:52Furthermore, the mayor and city council hereby extend their sincere appreciation and gratitude to all election judges for their service to the people of the city of Minneapolis.
15:04I'll turn it over to Director Kitty Smith.
15:13My name is Katie Smith.
15:14I'm the director of elections and voter services with the City of Minneapolis.
15:18I'm joined also by our deputy director, John Martin.
15:21He and I would like to express our gratitude for all of the election judges who are going to be working at the polls on election day.
15:28We're also fortunate today to be joined by some members of our staff who work with voting ahead of election day.
15:35So we have representatives today with us from early in-person voting, vote by mail, our training team.
15:42We have members of our logistics team, our voter outreach, our election judge and polling place team.
15:49And I'm just really fortunate to be joined by such a dedicated staff of individuals who are just consistently dedicated to making our elections happen here in the city of Minneapolis.
16:02I also want to express our continued thanks for our elected officials for their ongoing support and also a special shout out to Clerk Carl for his ongoing leadership.
16:13So with that, thank you.
16:17All right, let's gather for a quick photo here.
16:20Thanks, I'm completely disposable.
17:38Next, we will welcome Councilmember Jenkins to recognize National Disability Employment Awareness Month and Invisible Disabilities Awareness Week.
18:35Good morning, my name is Andrea Jenkins.
18:38I'm the Ward Aid City Council member, and I am thrilled to offer this resolution recognizing national disability employment awareness month and invisible disabilities awareness week.
18:55Whereas October 2025 marks the eightieth anniversary of National Disability Employment Awareness Month to increase education about disability employment issues and celebrate the many and varied contributions of America's workers with disabilities, and whereas the history of indeam traces back to 1945 when it started as a week and focused only on people with physical disabilities.
19:29Later, it expanded to a full month, and its name and scope evolved to acknowledge the importance of increasing workforce inclusion of people with all natures of disabilities.
19:43And whereas October 19th through the 25th marks Invisible Disabilities Week, and whereas in 2024, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, for all ages, the employment population ratio is much lower for people with a disability than those with no disability.
20:07And whereas unemployment and underemployment rates were much higher for people with a disability than for those with no disability across all educational attainment groups.
20:21And whereas workplaces welcoming the talents of all people, including people with disabilities, are a critical part of our efforts to increase to build an inclusive community and strong economy.
20:38Awareness will reinforce the value and talent of people with disabilities and add to our workplaces and communities and affirm the city of Minneapolis's commitment to increasing access to good jobs for all workers, including workers with disabilities.
21:12And whereas the term invisible disabilities or non-apparent disabilities refers to disabilities which are not visibly apparent, leading this person to fight a battle seldom acknowledged.
21:23Some examples of invisible disabilities include Alzheimer's disease, anxiety, depression, arthritis, autism spectrum disorder, inflammatory bowel disease, deafness, vision impairment, and blindness, diabetes, epilepsy, fibromyalgia, post-traumatic stress disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, traumatic brain injury, Usher syndrome, bipolar disorder, cystic fibrosis, and multiple sclerosis, among many others.
21:54And whereas since invisible disabilities are not readily apparent, the person's condition may not be acknowledged by others.
22:03A lack of acknowledgement of the disability often translates to a lack of funding, accommodations, medical resources, medical diagnosis, and overall support.
22:12And whereas in 2012, the city adopted an ADA transition plan.
22:18It was required under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and was last updated last year.
22:25And whereas in 2016, the city's neighborhood and community relations department renewed the city's commitment to the ADA by c conducting a program and services evaluation and developing an updated plan known as the ADA Action Plan, which has been updated this year, and whereas the ADA Action Plan demonstrates the city's commitment to the inclusion of people with disabilities and programs, services, and decision-making processes by adopting emerging accessibility and technological practices and identifying areas where there are gaps and needs for improvement to better serve people living with disabilities in every form.
23:09Now, therefore, be it resolved that the mayor and city council do hereby recognize this 80th anniversary of National Disability Employment Awareness Month and honor October 19th through the 25th, 2025 as invis invisible disabilities awareness week in the city of Minneapolis to commemorate the many contributions of people living with disabilities, both invisible and apparent to America's workplaces and economy.
23:48You know, I I just want to just acknowledge the the um incredible determination and grit that it takes for uh people living with invisible and apparent disabilities to to get up and and go to work every day and and be a contributing part of our economies and our community.
24:12So thank you very much.
24:16And I think we should all gather for a lovely photo, and hopefully one of you guys hold on to the resolution.
24:47Thanks for being here.
24:50Thanks for being here.
25:05I have one more resolution.
25:07You want to introduce it?
25:28Our final resolution is recognizing Domestic Violence Awareness Month with Councilmembers Jenkins, Vice President Shugtai, and Councilmember Koske.
25:56I have out of magnifying.
26:00Hey, good morning again, Andrea Jenkins, Ward Aid City Council member, and this resolution this morning is recognizing October 2025 as domestic violence awareness month in the city of Minneapolis.
26:18Whereas National Domestic Violence Awareness Month was first declared in 1989 to acknowledge the more than 10 million adults annually who experience domestic and intimate partner violence in the United States.
26:37And whereas the types of domestic violence include but are not limited to physical abuse, emotional abuse, verbal abuse, sexual abuse, financial abuse, digital abuse, psychological abuse, sexual coercion, reproductive coercion, and stalking.
27:00And whereas, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the CDC, 41% of women, 26% of men, and 54% of transgender and non-binary people have experienced intimate partner violence in their lifetime.
27:21And up to 10 million children are exposed to domestic violence each year.
27:28And whereas domestic violence can cause a variety of negative outcomes, including worsened psychological and physical health, decreased quality of life, decreased productivity, and mortality.
27:50Whereas over 4.5 million women report being threatened with a gun by an intimate partner and access to a firearm increases the risk of intimate partner femicide by at least 400%.
28:05And whereas domestic violence is one of the leading causes of homelessness with the national network to end domestic violence reporting, that being that between 22% and 57% of all homeless women report domestic violence as the immediate cause of their becoming unsheltered, that over 90% of homeless women report having experienced severe physical or sexual abuse at some point in their lives, and that 63% have been victims of intimate partner violence as adults, showing that the public health crises of domestic violence and unsheltered homelessness are inextricably linked.
28:48And whereas Violence Free Minnesota, a statewide coalition of programs working together to end relationship abuse, has been reporting on domestic violence, homicide since 1989.
29:02And in 2024, violence free Minnesota documented two residents of Minneapolis who were lost to intimate partner violence, including 35-year-old Leah Liara Cayley Sai, who is remembered by her community as a talented artist with a unique presence and magnetic personality, and 47-year-old Alison Lucher, whose family members whose family remembers her as kind, generous, caring, and loving, and continues fighting for justice for Allison nearly two years later.
30:00And whereas so far in 2025, Violence Free Minnesota has documented two residents of Minneapolis have been lost to domestic violence, including two-year-old Kinsley Princeton, who is remembered by her mother as a beautiful angel who is always happy, and Mariah Samuels, who is remembered by her children, sisters, father, and friends as loving, sweet, outgoing, and free-spirited.
30:21And whereas in Minneapolis, three out of four documented losses as a result of domestic violence or as a result of intimate partner violence, where a black woman, an indigenous woman, and a trans woman, which reflects the staggeringly disproportionate impact of domestic uh violence and intimate partner violence experienced by marginalized women across this country.
30:46And whereas domestic violence violence, homicide is a local and national public health concern that disproportionately affects women, particularly black, indigenous, Asian Latina women and pregnant and postpartum women.
31:03With every town for gun safety reporting that an average of 70 women are shot and killed by intimate partner violence every month.
31:12And whereas LGBTQ and people with disabilities communities who are highly vulnerable to severe forms of relationship abuse and relationship abuse resulting in death due to a national ecosystem that disenfranchises them, still lack representation and data and are underreported, resulting in a lack of information to fully capture the magnitude of the harm they are experiencing.
31:40And whereas the city of Minneapolis is committed to honoring the memories of those who are lost due to domestic violence, homicide, and those currently suffering from domestic abuse by bringing an end to this preventable epidemic through investment in awareness education.
31:59You're good, please.
32:04The city of Minneapolis is committed to honoring the memories of those who were lost due to domestic violence, homicide, and those currently suffering from domestic abuse by bringing an end to this preventable epidemic through investment in awareness, education, training, violence prevention and gun control, direct service and policy change.
32:25Now, therefore, be it resolved that the mayor and city council do hereby recognize October 2025 as domestic violence awareness month in the city of Minneapolis, and that October 23rd, 2025 be recognized as a day of remembrance for all victims of domestic violence.
32:45Thank you for joining us today.
32:47Um, I actually want to open by um welcoming three families and uh and starting by um inviting them to share some remarks.
32:59So um first we're gonna hear from Allison Lucer's family, then Mariah Samuels' family, and then um Sarah Patrick's family, and all three of them are gonna talk to you about um about their loved ones, how precious their lives were and and how they came to an end because of this preventable epidemic that that is a direct consequence of us as a society not taking the violence that is perpetrated against women seriously.
33:29Uh I'm Jana Williams.
33:31I'm Alison Lucher's aunt.
33:33First of all, I do want to thank Minneapolis City Council for giving Alison Lucer and every American Indian victim out here wings.
33:43Without you, this story never would have been heard.
33:46Nobody would have listened.
33:48Amongst the crisis in Indian country in this uh in in America today, uh, missing a murdered indigenous uh relatives is a real thing.
33:57Allison's case is exactly why we go missing or murdered 10 times any other race, but yet we are less than one percent of the population here.
34:06Alison, um, there's a lot of things that happened in her case.
34:10Statutes, Minnesota State statutes and policies are absolutely barbaric that need change, not yesterday, but 20, 30, 40 years ago.
34:21We need statute change, policy change.
34:24Um, Allison would be here today if we did not have those statutes in place.
34:31And with Minneapolis PD, I appreciate this because uh her case should have been investigated as a homicide, plain and simple.
34:40As a marginalized community, we can no longer stand for this.
34:44Um, Allison Lucer, Justice for Allison, we stand with every victim that is out here.
34:49I stand right here next to Mariah Samuels' sister, Simone, and I'm gonna pass this off to her, Miguelch.
34:57Um, I just want to say thank you for having me out today.
35:00My family really appreciate it.
35:02I'm here on behalf of my dad and my sister Selena, who couldn't be here, she's out of state right now.
35:08Um, but I'm just here to say that um this morning was really hard, actually, when I woke up and I realized every day almost I've been getting text messages, emails about all these different events for domestic awareness, and um, it really hits me that my sister is no longer here and I will no longer see her anymore.
35:27And that is such a heavy thing to try to process every day.
35:33And I still don't think I understand.
35:36I don't think I ever will.
35:37I don't think my dad will ever realize that his baby is never gonna be able to come home to him.
35:43Um, and my dad is a very uh stoic guy, so the fact that this has hit him so hard, it's so hard to watch that for him.
35:53It's so hard to see him break down almost every day.
35:56He's not a man that cries or has shows his emotions that way, but it's been really hard to see even my sister deteriorate over the course of a month of losing her.
36:09So Minneapolis police, you guys have to get your priorities together.
36:14This is unacceptable.
36:16There's should be no reason where people call you for help.
36:19They take the steps that you asked them to take to do things the right way, to do things illegal the legal way, excuse me, and still they end up murdered in her own front yard.
36:30This was something that was personal for us.
36:33This was something that will deeply traumatize us for the rest of our lives.
36:40And it all could have been prevented with a simple arrest.
36:44And the fact that there are four people on the domestic case when there is constant calls for domestic violence in this city is outrageous.
36:52You guys have mixed up priorities.
36:54You guys are honing in and choosing over police in some areas while you leave the north side by itself to defend one another.
37:01You leave the south side to defend each other.
37:04There should be no way that Little Earth has to come up with its own protectors to protect its citizens.
37:09It's not any sort of way of right.
37:12We are Minnesota citizens, we pay taxes, we deserve to be protected.
37:16Minneapolis, you gotta get it together, and you have to allocate the right funds, the right manpower to protect us, or things are really, really gonna become dire.
37:49Sarah Patrick was a sensitive, creative, and bright spirit, a true Minneapolitan who is my steadfast companion since we were 16 when she embraced me with unconditional friendship.
37:59I'm not the same person I was before Sarah was murdered.
38:02When a loved one is taken from us so brutally, there's an acute grief, of course.
38:06But then there is the aftermath.
38:08For me, it was an all-consuming dullness to the world, a distorted capacity for purpose and joy.
38:13This new way of being lingers.
38:15I miss my friend's Cheshire Cat smile, her vivacious laugh.
38:19And every so often I still listen to old voice messages from her to remind myself of the contours of her voice, that she was real, that she was here.
38:27Sarah should still be here today, and she isn't.
38:40So we knew there would be no trial.
38:41We expected at least an accounting, though, an acknowledgement of what had happened.
38:45He had murdered her.
38:46Unfortunately, this was not our experience.
38:49The investigators we worked with routinely undermined Sarah's humanity, speculating wildly that she entered a suicide pack with her perpetrator, despite her phone activity, showed her playing Pokemon Go, a favorite pastime of hers, just minutes before her murder.
39:03When that nonsensical theory didn't pan out, they suggested it might have merely been a game that went wrong in direct contradiction to the medical examiner's ruling that her death was a homicide.
39:12The investigators tried to frame Sarah's battle with addiction as tacit reasoning for her being shot in the head.
39:18Sarah was a beautiful, complicated and flawed person, and one of the things I admired about her the most was her resilience and dedication to her recovery.
39:26She just wasn't a virtuous enough victim for them.
39:29Most galling and hurtful was how deeply wrong that framing was.
39:53Police need a better understanding of how abuse and violence cycles perpetrate and more responsiveness to those who are able to seek help before they are killed.
40:18I stand here in disbelief for the statistics of frustration and hope, and most acutely with a desperate longing for a world where these statistics for such murders trend downward and not upward.
40:29A world where when these tragedies occur, the public servants who are in charge of the cases treat them with the decency and empathy they deserve.
41:05Soy parte de Amor Propio, un organization de salud mental para la communidad.
41:24Uno de cada si hombres pasa por abuso.
41:29Una de cada three mujeres pasa por abuso.
41:58Her name is Alicia Robles.
42:00She's from an organization called Amor Propio that provides mental sub mental health support to victims of trauma.
42:10This resolution is really important.
42:29In Mexico, we celebrate Dia de los Muertos between October 27th through November 2nd.
42:37And this is a really great opportunity to remember our loved ones and know that they are with us and we are with them.
42:45And we're here to advocate for the survivors and victims.
42:55Hello, my name is Jess Pallian.
42:57I am the policy program manager at Violence Free Minnesota.
43:00We are the statewide coalition against relationship abuse.
43:17Over north, we have Agape Oasis doing amazing work in Northeast.
43:20We have the Domestic Abuse Project serving victims directly and working with abusive partners to change their behavior.
43:27We have larger programs like Tubman and Cornerstone having a presence here.
43:32We have culturally specific programs like Isarun and Pillsbury United serving our Somali neighbors, transforming generations serving our Hmong neighbors, Esperanza United serving our Spanish speaking community.
43:44We have other culture-specific programs like Think Self serving our deaf and hard of hearing community and outfront serving our LGBT community.
43:52There is a network here.
43:53There are more services that I haven't listed because I don't want to take your time up all day today.
44:00If you are listening to this and you need services from a community-based confidential uh provider, uh please contact the Minnesota Day One hotline.
44:10They will be able to connect you with services that are appropriate to you.
44:14And I just wanted to make sure that everybody knows that there is a community here that is ready to help you.
44:27That is a beautiful note to end on.
44:29So with that, I will see if anyone else has some comments they would like to jump in with.
44:43So it's between the black lines.
46:26At this time, I'm going to call this regular meeting of the city council for October 23rd to order.
46:31The clerk will call the roll.
46:34Councilmember Coskey.
46:37Councilmember Wonsley.
46:40Councilmember Jenkins.
46:42Councilmember Palmasano.
46:45Councilmember Chowdhury.
46:47Councilmember Cashman.
46:50Councilmember Osman.
46:52Councilmember Rainville.
46:55Councilmember Chavez.
46:57Councilmember Vitock.
46:59Councilmember Ellison.
47:04Vice President Shuktai.
47:08There are ten members present.
47:10Let the record reflect we have a quorum.
47:13Before we begin the meeting, I want to offer a friendly reminder to all members and staff that this meeting is broadcast live to enable greater public participation.
47:21The broadcast includes real-time captioning as a further method to increase the accessibility of our proceedings to the community.
47:28Therefore, all speakers need to be mindful of the rate of their speech so that our captioners can fully capture and transcribe all comments for the broadcast.
47:57Second uh councilmember Jenkins has moved to amend the agenda.
48:03Her motion should be before you for a gift acceptance.
48:08It's been properly seconded.
48:09Is there any discussion?
48:14Councilmember Jenkins, did you want to speak?
48:16Or is that your computer catching up?
48:19Yeah, I I mean it's uh gift acceptance for uh uh conference to take place next week.
48:26Vision cities vision zero cities, which is a transportation conference, and I'm doing to participate and I would uh ask for your support on this resolution all right uh the uh motion has been moved and seconded.
48:49Uh may have a motion to adopt the agenda as amended.
48:52So move second the clerk will call the roll councilmember Koski.
48:58Aye, Councilmember Wandsley, aye, Councilmember Jenkins, aye.
49:02Councilmember Palmasano, aye, councilmember Chowdhury is absent.
49:06Councilmember Cashman.
49:08Councilmember Osman.
49:10Councilmember Rainbow.
49:11Councilmember Chavez.
49:13Councilmember Vitock.
49:14Councilmember Ellison.
49:16Vice President Shugti.
49:22And before we move on, I'll recognize we've been joined by Councilmembers Wansley and Ellison.
49:26The next item is acceptance of minutes from our regular meeting of October 9th.
49:30I would entertain a motion to accept those minutes.
49:33The clerk will call the roll.
49:34Councilmember Koskey.
49:36Councilmember Wansley.
49:37Councilmember Jenkins.
49:39Councilmember Palmasano.
49:40Councilmember Chowdhury.
49:42Councilmember Cashman.
49:43Council Member Osman.
49:44Council Member Rainville.
49:46Councilmember Chavez.
49:47Councilmember Vitock.
49:48Councilmember Ellison.
49:53There are thirteen ayes.
49:55And I'll recognize we've been joined by Councilmember Chowdry.
50:00Finally, we have the referral of petitions, communications, and reports to proper committees.
50:03May I have that motion, please?
50:05The clerk will call the roll.
50:06Councilmember Koske.
50:08Councilmember Wandsley.
50:09Councilmember Palmasono.
50:11Councilmember Chowdhury.
50:13Councilmember Jenkins.
50:15Councilmember Cashman.
50:18Councilmember Osman.
50:19Councilmember Rainbow.
50:21Councilmember Shavez.
50:22Councilmember Vitaw.
50:23Councilmember Ellison.
50:25Vice President Shugtai.
50:29That carries, and those matters have been referred.
50:31The next order of business is the presentations of reports from our standing committees.
50:35Those are taken in alphabetical order, beginning with the report of our administration and enterprise oversight committee, which will be presented by its chair, Councilmember Wandsley.
50:46Thank you, President Payne.
50:48The Administration and Entreprise Oversight Committee is bringing forward 16 items.
50:54The first is a professional services contract ordinance.
50:57The second is a gift acceptance from the Metropolitan Police Department for Transportation Meals and Lodging.
51:04Three is a gift acceptance from Urban Institute for Travel and Lodging Expenses.
51:09Four is a gift acceptance from OP Open Mobility Foundation for Travel and Lodging Expenses.
51:16Five is a contract amendment with PC Rose LLC for the First Avenue South Sanitary Sewer Reconstruction Project.
51:25Six is a contract amendment with Shehee Construction Company for Convention Center Concessions.
51:31136 remodel project.
51:34Seven is a contract amendment with AVR Inc.
51:37for ready mixed concrete.
51:40Eight is a contract amendment with Meyer Contracting Inc.
51:43for the Fremont Avenue South Sanitary Pike Replacement Project.
51:47Nine is a contract amendment with Q3 contracting ink for lead service line replacements, year two restoration only project.
51:5610 is a contract amendment with Morcon Construction Inc.
52:00for Hearthorn Office Build Out Project.
52:0311 is a contract amendment with Meyer contracting Inc.
52:07for the Second Street North Sewer Improvement Project.
52:1112 is a contract amendment with Minger Construction Inc.
52:15or Construction Companies Inc.
52:17for Boston Terrace Sanitary and Storm Sewer Improvement Project.
52:2313 is a bid for the Convention Center Mill City Kitchen Concessions 134 Remodel.
52:2914 is a collective bargaining agreement, law enforcement labor services Inc.
52:34representing 911 dispatch supervisors 2026 through 2027.
52:4115 is Americans with Disabilities Title II policy.
52:4616 is a master contract for eligible providers of workforce development services for 2026 through 2028.
52:55And with that, I will move all items of approval and then we'll pull item number one for uh comments and a separate vote.
53:05Councilmember Wandsley has moved approval of the committee report, taking up item number one for a separate vote and discussion.
53:12Is there any discussion on the remainder of the report seeing none?
53:18I'll ask the clerk to call the roll.
53:22Councilmember Koske.
53:24Councilmember Wandsley.
53:25Councilmember Jenkins.
53:27Councilmember Palmasano.
53:28Councilmember Chowdhury.
53:30Councilmember Cashman.
53:31Councilmember Osman.
53:33Councilmember Rainbow.
53:34Councilmember Shavez.
53:37Councilmember Ellison.
53:38Vice President Shugtai.
53:44And we will take up item number one and I'll recognize Councilmember Wandsley.
53:48Thank you, President Payne.
53:50I would just like to speak to item number one, which is an ordinance that I author title Professional Services Ordinance.
53:57This is a fairly straightforward change that I believe will significantly improve transparency and accountability around the city's procurement practices.
54:06As many of my colleagues are already aware, currently the council only approves contracts with a total of 175,000 and above.
54:16These contracts are on our agendas and require a vote, ensuring uh opportunity for oversight by the council and public and establishing a way for also the public to track what the city is doing or who we're doing business with.
54:31Contracts though, under this 175,000 threshold do not require council approval and thus allow for the administration to execute these smaller contracts through department heads or other city leaders.
54:44As of now, there is no formal oversight over these smaller contracts.
55:00And these have included in quite or questionable contracts to vendors who either do not have the professional expertise at the matter of hand or the scope of focus for set contract.
55:09For example, council learned that there was a contract awarded out of the neighborhood safety department where the staff member overseeing the contract had a personal relationship with the vendor.
55:21And even with the questionable per per personal relationship between the vendor and the former director of NSD, the commissioner then signed off on this contract, which contributed to the questioning of the credibility of our violence prevention services or the integrity of the department overall.
55:40And there are other concerns that have left many of us as well as our constituents understandably questioning other contracts.
55:48In thinking of another example, I'll uh allude to our rescue, which was uh anti-human trafficking nonprofit um that had a controversial past, which included uh them being under federal investigation.
56:03Again, these patterns of vendors or contracts being awarded to vendors that have concerning past practices or do not have actual professional expertise has potentially led to lawsuits coming forward and overall just rep reputational damage of the uh city's credibility as it relates to us being able to administer um contracts up to professional standards and legal standards.
56:30Um, I believe this ordinance change will ultimately improve transparency and again allow this body to take corrective actions when we are coming across contracts that do uh raise a number of red flags or questions overall.
56:45Um it's also a way for the council to have a greater or clearer picture of which city departments are working with which vendors out in the public in or in the community and help us essentially keep a tab of the workflow flow of the administration as well.
57:03Um earlier this year, in fact, in response to one of the problematic contracts that council raised concerns around, um, council member Cosky authored a legislative directive that resulted in the public and this council receiving a count of all small contracts that have been administered over the past 10 years and in reviewing even um the report that came from that legislative directive.
57:27My office was able to get um tons of insights as to why uh the work that we did around passing carbon fees and we had were were told by health department leadership in 2023 that a contract was going out to help us figure out amounts for those carbon fees through that report.
57:46We learned that that was not the case.
57:48And us not having that information gave us really or left us in the dark as to why there was almost a two and a half year delay from the health department in terms of coming up with concrete numbers for carbon fees.
58:02So I just want to say thank you to council member Koskey's leadership and also giving us an opportunity to understand how contracts are being handled and also how they shed light on either the lack of work that's not being done that's being initiated by this body.
58:18Um so I really hope that this ordinance is just one of the many ways that we could demonstrate to the public that council do not take taxpayer money for granted.
58:28It also will help ensure transparency, ultimately with a goal to limit fraud, waste, and abuse in government contracting, and the public should absolutely feel confident in the city's contract process, and now this ordinance will help bolster that conf uh confidence by maximizing more transparency.
58:46Um I of course look forward to working further on initiatives, policy initiatives that aligns with what we're considering today.
58:54But of course, I would love my colleagues' support in advancing this ordinance forward and will motion it for approval and ask for a second.
59:03Also more than happy to stand for questions.
59:07Uh Councilmember Wandsley has moved approval of this item.
59:11I added myself to queue uh just to say I just really see the wisdom in this approach.
59:17Some of the earliest work that I did at the city before being elected was around uh procurement reform and making sure that it was easier to do business with the city because we know that some of our bureaucracy can be really hard to navigate, especially for our small uh business owners and our disadvantaged uh entrepreneurs.
59:35Uh, this is a really good balance of making sure that we're not adding more barriers to doing business with the city while still upholding a commitment to transparency.
59:44So I really appreciate Councilmember Councilmember Wandsley's approach to this.
59:48I will recognize Councilmember Cosby.
59:51Uh thank you, Council President, and thank you, Councilmember Wandsley for bringing this forward and continuing the work.
59:56And I just wanted to ask if I could be a co-author on the ordinance.
1:00:04Seeing no one else in queue, and I'm assuming the clerk's got that uh co-author guidance.
1:00:10Uh I will ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:00:14Councilmember Koske.
1:00:16Councilmember Wansley.
1:00:17Councilmember Jenkins.
1:00:19Councilmember Palmasano.
1:00:20Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:00:22Councilmember Cashman.
1:00:23Councilmember Osman.
1:00:25Councilmember Rainbow.
1:00:26Councilmember Chavez.
1:00:27Councilmember Beaton.
1:00:29Councilmember Ellison.
1:00:30Vice President Shagtai.
1:00:34There are 13 items.
1:00:36That carries and that completes the full report of the AO committee.
1:00:41Next, we have the report from our business housing and zoning committee, which will be given by that committee's chair, Councilmember Osman.
1:00:48I will pass it to Vice Chair Chowdry.
1:00:51Vice Chair Chowdhury.
1:00:53Thanks, President Payne.
1:00:54The Biz Committee is bringing nine items forward today.
1:00:57Item number one is approving a liquor license with business conditions for the Cedar Inn.
1:01:03Item number two is approving a fine and tobacco dealer license suspension for campus market.
1:01:08Item number three was a license revocation for noon restaurant.
1:01:12However, we have received a clearance letter from the state, and I will move to delete this item from the agenda.
1:01:19Item number four is considering a combined trades license revocation held by PMR Mechanical Inc.
1:01:27This item was sent forward without recommendation.
1:01:30Unfortunately, we have not received any updates from the license holder.
1:01:34So I will move to approve the revocation of this license.
1:01:39Item number five is approving one liquor license.
1:01:42Item number six is approving 26 liquor license renewals.
1:01:47Item number seven is accepting a grant for regulatory services to attend the best friends conference.
1:01:54Item number n item number eight, excuse me, is approving the applications for the fall 2025 Brownfield grants.
1:02:02And lastly, item number nine is authorizing an ownership and opportunity loan for vital 24 LLC.
1:02:10With that, I will move all items for approval except item number three, which I will move to delete from the agenda.
1:02:17Councilmember Chowdhury has moved approval of the committee report, including the deletion of item number three and the revocation of for item number four.
1:02:27Is there any discussion?
1:02:28Councilmember Cashman.
1:02:30Thank you, President Payne.
1:02:32I just wanted to speak in support of item nine, the ownership and opportunity fund loan to Vital 24 LLC.
1:02:39Vital Print Press has been open for 25 years.
1:02:42It's a BIPOC-owned small business in Uptown, and this loan will enable the recipient to move and purchase a larger building just across the street on Hennepin so that the business can grow.
1:02:53This building needs significant renovation and environmental cleanup, so it's a really powerful investment that the city is making here to help Uptown revitalize in many ways.
1:03:04And I know that the owner plans to continue to lease out his current building to business tenants and then build a new uh build a new base of tenants in the building across the street.
1:03:14And this is such a good example of what we want to see in Uptown with local ownership of beautiful historic buildings and a growing uh small business community that's able to thrive.
1:03:24So I'm really glad that we're supporting this here today as a council, and I wanted to congratulate uh Mike Todros on this on this uh fund loan.
1:03:35Councilmember Jenkins.
1:03:37Thank you, President Payne.
1:03:38I just wanted to speak to item number one, the Cedar Inn.
1:03:43Um, I think we have 18 conditions on this license, uh which is quite a bit, but many of the neighbors in this community are are concerned about the activities on at this site uh and concerned about the expansion of the Cedar Inn.
1:04:06I just want to, you know, encourage the owners to um really live up and live into these conditions and hopefully um this business will um be continue to be a welcoming um place in the community.
1:04:27Councilmember Chowdry.
1:04:30Thank you, President Payne.
1:04:31I also uh wanted to speak on item number one, the conditions for Cedar Inn.
1:04:37Um first of all, just wanted to express a lot of gratitude for city staff, Amy Lingo, Max Cervantes, Mohammed Akbar, or Akbar Mohammed, and um uh my staff, uh Ben Petty.
1:04:52Uh we spent a lot of time meeting with community members and the owners and management and staff of Cedar Inn.
1:05:01And it was a challenge to kind of address uh concerns that have been built up a lot over the last five years.
1:05:12Um essentially, there Cedar Inn is a beloved community bar that is also open till 2 a.m.
1:05:20365 days a year in an area where there are a lot of residences.
1:05:26And I think I I just want to express a lot of pride in the community for coming together and being able to lean in and find a compromise that everyone can live with.
1:05:38I think it's an example of being able to balance uh supporting a local business because the Cedar Inn is expanding and also considering the needs of community members because the hours are are shortened, um especially for Sunday and Monday, and um it's no longer gonna be open 2 a.m.
1:05:58365 days in a year.
1:06:01It's gonna close um at 1 a.m.
1:06:04except for Sunday and Monday, which it will close at 12 a.m.
1:06:09And also there's several conditions to ensure not just Cedar Inn, you have to do this, but creating channels for communication from the community to the business, so there's just better better relationship building.
1:06:23And I appreciate everyone kind of um being willing to move closer and closer until we got to our final meeting.
1:06:32And I think we have a good set of conditions.
1:06:35Um they will not be receiving uh liquor license immediately.
1:06:40Uh uh for the first eight months.
1:06:43It's going to continue to be a strong beer and wine license.
1:06:47And if all the conditions are followed and there's no alcohol code violence violations, it will go right into hard liquor, and I think it just gives an opportunity for the business to kind of show that it can balance the needs of its growth and um working working with the neighborhood and addressing these concerns that have built up over time.
1:07:09Councilmember Ellison.
1:07:11Just wanted to speak to item nine and maybe just the ownership and opportunity fund more broadly.
1:07:15Um, you know, it's great to every time I see one of these uh OOF loans come out of the department, and because it means that we're seeing more local ownership.
1:07:24Um, but I also want to remind folks this fund is not that old.
1:07:28Uh it faces existential crisis uh every budget cycle.
1:07:32Um, you know, it was conceived uh back when uh uh Jim Terrell, who's formerly who's uh has retired from the city, uh Sean Pierce, who used to work in the mayor's office, and myself, we you know put together this this idea um and really championed it and the mayor has been a champion for it, but again, that has not faced that has not stopped it from facing multiple existential crises over the years.
1:07:54Um, you know, uh uh, you know, I know that I've play I've tried to play a role in making sure that this this fund has money in it, and I've you know uh maybe you got some of you guys have experienced me sort of fighting you off of this as a source during budget markup.
1:08:08Uh and I won't be around here to do uh to do that in the future.
1:08:11And so I just want to say, you know, if we value the kind of local ownership that we see coming out of this fund, if we value um uh uh uh you know increasing who gets to own commercial space in the city of Minneapolis, there is not another gap financing tool that achieves this end in the city's you know arsenal.
1:08:29This is the gap financing tool that we have that meets this end.
1:08:32Uh and so I just want to again prop it up, highlight it um, and uh and and just uh congratulate uh staff and thank staff for all the work that they've done uh to keep this this ball rolling.
1:08:45Seeing no one else left in queue.
1:08:47I'll ask the clerk to call the roll on the biz report, including the deletion of item number three.
1:08:53Councilmember Koske.
1:08:54Councilmember Wandsley.
1:08:56Councilmember Jenkins.
1:08:58Councilmember Palmasano.
1:08:59Councilmember Childry.
1:09:01Councilmember Cashman.
1:09:02Councilmember Osman.
1:09:04Councilmember Rainville.
1:09:05Councilmember Chavez.
1:09:06Councilmember Vita.
1:09:08Councilmember Ellison.
1:09:09Vice President Shug Tan.
1:09:12There are 13 items.
1:09:14That carries, and the report is adopted.
1:09:16The next report is from our Climate and Infrastructure Committee, which will be presented by that committee's chair, Councilmember Cashman.
1:09:25The Climate Infrastructure Committee is bringing forward six items.
1:09:29Item one is a resolution approving municipal consent for the Mindot University Avenue Northeast Improvement Project.
1:09:35Item two is a resolution approving 2026 proposed services and service charges for legacy special service districts.
1:09:43Item three is a resolution adopting the water and sewer service line repair assessments.
1:09:47Item four is authorizing a temporary construction easement at 2225 West River Road North.
1:09:53Item five is a resolution authorizing a grant application for the 2025 local road improvement program for projects on 35th and 36th Street, Lindale Avenue South, and First Avenue North.
1:10:05Item six is a resolution designating the West River Parkway Phase 2 project for the Upper Harbor Terminal, adopting the report and cost estimate related and setting a public hearing for December 4th.
1:10:16I'll move approval of all six items.
1:10:19Councilmember Cashman has moved approval of the committee's report.
1:10:23Is there any discussion?
1:10:24Councilmember Rainville.
1:10:28I just like to speak briefly to item number one.
1:10:31I will not be voting for this.
1:10:32I'm very, very disappointed that uh the state hasn't come up with a plan to stage University Avenue in conjunction with Central Avenue and the county's uh redo of Marshall.
1:10:45These are the three major north-south routes through Northeast.
1:10:48I've asked all of those uh entities for over a year since they began public hearings for a plan uh to not severely impact the businesses and residents in the area.
1:11:01And also if you throw in the county's plan to uh uh redo Lowry Avenue from the river to Washington.
1:11:08We have four major road projects going on at the same time, yet no one, no one from these entities has offered a plan on how to mitigate the damage it's going to do to the community.
1:11:19So I I'm uh I would like to send a very strong signal today.
1:11:22Uh I have no uh ill will to our public works department who uh will help mitigate this and who will and have promised and hopefully they will uh provide some input to both uh Council President Payne and I on this.
1:11:36But this is really poor service from both the state and the county, and I will not accept this for the residents of my community.
1:11:48Let's take up uh all items except for item number one.
1:11:52We'll take that up on a separate vote.
1:11:54And I'll ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:12:00Councilmember Koskey.
1:12:02Councilmember Wandsley.
1:12:03Councilmember Jenkins.
1:12:05Councilmember Palmasana.
1:12:06Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:12:08Councilmember Cashman.
1:12:09Councilmember Osman.
1:12:11Councilmember Rainbow.
1:12:12Councilmember Chavez.
1:12:14Councilmember Vita.
1:12:16Councilmember Ellison.
1:12:17Vice President Shugtai.
1:12:20There are thirteen ayes.
1:12:22Those items carry, and we will take up item number one, and I'll ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:12:29Councilmember Koskey.
1:12:31Councilmember Wansley.
1:12:33Councilmember Jenkins.
1:12:34Councilmember Palmasano.
1:12:36Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:12:38Councilmember Cashman?
1:12:40Councilmember Osman.
1:12:42Councilmember Rainville.
1:12:44Councilmember Chavez.
1:12:46Councilmember Vita.
1:12:47Councilmember Ellison.
1:12:49Vice President Shagtai.
1:12:54There are 10 ayes and three names.
1:12:56That item carries, and that completes the CNI report.
1:12:59The next report is from the Committee of the Whole, which will be be presented by that committee's chair, Councilmember Chavez.
1:13:07The Committee of the Whole is bringing forward three items.
1:13:10Item number one is opting a 2026 transition calendar for regular meetings of the City Council.
1:13:17Item number two is approving a legislative directive requesting the enterprise white salary and compensation study produced by Guide House Inc.
1:13:24And lastly, item number three is a resolution pro placing the Board of Estimate and Taxation Executive Secretary position in the Office of City Clerk for administrative and operational support purposes.
1:13:35With that, I'll move approval of items one and two and pull item number three for a separate discussion.
1:13:41Do you want to pull item three for a separate discussion or two for a separate discussion?
1:13:45Number two, sorry.
1:13:47Let's take up items number one and three.
1:13:50If there's any discussion on those.
1:13:53Seeing none, uh oh, Councilmember Jenkins.
1:13:58Thank you, President Payne.
1:14:00You know, I just on item number three.
1:14:02I guess, you know, I think it's fine to move this into the clerk's office.
1:14:08I I thought administration of this work initially was in the finance department.
1:14:20And it seems like that would be an appropriate um place for the administration of this position to land.
1:14:29But you know, certainly the clerk's office uh which has a lot of responsibility, I I think can can shoulder this work.
1:14:44But it seems to me more aligned with with the finance department.
1:14:48And those are just my comments.
1:14:57And maybe the clerk can jump in as well.
1:15:00Uh but I I I believe that uh the finance department didn't have the capacity to take it on, and so the clerk is graciously uh offering some of that support.
1:15:11Carling started, it was even hard to get her a laptop and a desk because of that lack of administrative support.
1:15:17And the BT is a unique independent body, so there wasn't a clear place for her to land.
1:15:22So we're really grateful for the clerk to take that on.
1:15:24I don't know if there is more context than that, Mr.
1:15:27That summarizes it.
1:15:29Uh seeing no one else in queue, I will ask the clerk to call the roll on items number one and three.
1:15:36Councilmember Koske.
1:15:37Councilmember Wansley.
1:15:39Councilmember Jenkins.
1:15:41Councilmember Palmasano.
1:15:43Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:15:44Councilmember Cashman.
1:15:46Councilmember Osman.
1:15:47Councilmember Rainville.
1:15:49Councilmember Shabazz.
1:15:50Councilmember Vita.
1:15:52Councilmember Ellison.
1:15:53Vice President Shakti.
1:15:56There are 13 ayes.
1:15:58Those items carry.
1:15:59Next we will take up item number two.
1:16:03Is there any discussion on item number two?
1:16:07Councilmember Koske.
1:16:09Uh thank you, President Payne.
1:16:11I just wanted to make a couple comments on this item.
1:16:14You know, it seems that there's been a bit of misunderstanding in the administration about what the specific ask was and why there's been a hard press by council to access this study.
1:16:25Uh the bottom line is that the workforce compensation is one of the biggest drivers in our city budget.
1:16:32I uh noted before it's almost half our general fund.
1:16:35This study provides a comprehensive analysis of our workforce and its compensation.
1:16:40The council is in the middle of considering the mayor's 2026 supplemental budget recommendations, and we, the council, have the legal authority to request any information necessary to perform our official functions, which absolutely includes finalizing and adopting the city budget and under Article 9 of the city charter, all financial controls and authority are vested in this body, not the mayor, and certainly not the mayor's administration.
1:17:06So no matter the basis, we the council have a legal right to that study, the full study, not a summary or briefing from staff.
1:17:14Certainly we welcome the assistance of our professional staff in understanding the context of the study and its implications for this enterprise and the fiscal impact that it may have for our constituents.
1:17:26The city attorney has confirmed that we have the legal right to have that study, not just a summary or just a briefing.
1:17:33We have a legal right under the city's constitution to have access to that entire study, and we've asked for it multiple times and in multiple ways.
1:17:41Any further delay is simply a distraction from the issue at hand that the administration is refusing to abide by the charter and is through its action and inaction denying the council access to data that is our legal right to have.
1:17:56That in my opinion is a violation of the city charter.
1:18:00So absolutely, we welcome briefings being organized for members.
1:18:04But first and foremost, we the city council want the full compensation study since we now have that confirmed and that we we know it exists.
1:18:14Um it should be very, very easy for them to provide this.
1:18:18And actually it it could have been provided within hours or at least within a couple of days of the very first email request.
1:18:25Uh so simply make 13 copies, put them in secure envelopes that are marked confidential and sealed and deliver them today would actually be fine.
1:18:34There shouldn't be a need to frame this as anything other than a request from council for information that has legal that has a legal right to that we have a legal right to have.
1:18:44That is the core issue, and since we know from the city attorney that we have that right, we expect it to be respected and observed.
1:18:52I hope I can earn uh the support from my colleagues today so that we can fulfill our fiduciary duties for the residents of Minneapolis and support our workforce.
1:19:04Councilmember Palmasano.
1:19:10Per the city attorney um on Tuesday, this is private data.
1:19:15It can't be publicly released.
1:19:18Um as our COO Margaret Anderson Kelleher says in her memo that we all received, we have been regularly communicated to on this.
1:19:28Um council was apprised of its status and offered regular updates.
1:19:33I think we also need to appreciate that while our salaries are public, this is a sensitive topic for city employees.
1:19:42Here's another example about protected and confidential data.
1:19:46We've had to spend resources trying to identify the leak of confidential confidentiality and confidential documents up here when we've had closed sessions on things like our settlement agreement.
1:19:59What makes this any different?
1:20:01I think it actually is a reasonable decision of the city administration to decide not to print 13 copies and distribute them to all of us.
1:20:10I also see in COO Anderson Kelleher's communication that she apologizes for being wrong.
1:20:18She originally said we could have this in a closed session, and she apologizes for being wrong.
1:20:23I think that maybe we should too here on the date on the dais.
1:20:28I also see social media from your appointed employees indicating that the administration is only giving us a summary, and that is not what Margaret Anderson Kelleher said in her memo.
1:20:44Vice President Chugtai.
1:20:47I just wanted to make sure that all of our colleagues saw an updated motion that uh Councilmember Koskey has brought forward clarifying based on the discussion at Cow on Tuesday that the that non-public data as it relates to this report is is not being requested to be published publicly and that this information be provided to members of this city council as we have a right to it.
1:21:21Yeah, I'll just add uh the charter is very clear.
1:21:25We have the legal right to have this full report, not a redacted, summarized version of it.
1:21:31Uh and then any council member who's not interested in that content can certainly uh email the city attorney and let them know that they'd like to opt out of that disclosure.
1:21:39Um seeing no one else left in queue, I will ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:21:46Councilmember Jenkins.
1:21:48Um is there a specific timeline for responding to um council requests according to the charter?
1:22:04Uh we adopted a policy for uh uh legislative directives and informal requests.
1:22:10Uh I don't know, Mr.
1:22:11Clerk, do you recall the timelines outlined in that policy?
1:22:15President, uh I'll start by saying with informal requests there aren't timelines associated with when to respond, obviously, as soon as you can.
1:22:24There are limits about uh what would be an approximate use of time that's appropriate to respond to an informal request by the administration.
1:22:32So approximately five hours of work uh or less would be an appropriate use of an informal request with a legislative directive as this body knows that's an that's an official act.
1:22:43So if the legislative directive is adopted, then it goes to the mayor.
1:22:47The mayor has five days upon receipt, not including Sundays in which to make a decision to either approve, not approve or return that act unsigned, which is to be deemed approved.
1:22:57Uh and then after that, the administration would be you know required to follow up an act uh if if approved or deemed approved.
1:23:04So not a hard deadline in terms of when the data would be uh provided, but that is a general guidance that if the legislative directive is adopted by council, its next step in this formal process is to go to the mayor's desk.
1:23:18The mayor has five days after receipt, not including Sundays to consider that and return it to the clerk, either approved or not.
1:23:25Uh and then the administration would follow up in response to uh whatever action is taken by the mayor.
1:23:36And then this the LD is requesting this information by October 27.
1:23:48President, if I can add in there and certainly the city attorney can weigh in, uh I want to be clear with council.
1:23:54We've said this in terms of how legislative directives are framed.
1:23:58Uh requesting a date is still a request from council uh and that the administration uh can try to honor dates that are put in there, but hard dates that are put in there might not be observed by council since that may have an operational or management impact in terms of the ability to respond.
1:24:14So dates can certainly be included as a request, but might not be the date when when uh information or data or things are are actually provided.
1:24:26Councilmember Chavez.
1:24:28I just hope that there isn't any further delays in getting this information.
1:24:31I think it's pretty reasonable request.
1:24:35I hope there's no violation of the city charter and that we just get this information as soon as possible.
1:24:39It didn't have to come to a legislative directive, but it's clear that with this administration, sometimes you have to do that.
1:24:47Seeing no one else left in queue, I will ask the clerk to call the roll on COL item two.
1:24:54Councilmember Koskey.
1:24:55Councilmember Wansley.
1:24:57Councilmember Jenkins.
1:25:00Councilmember Palmasano.
1:25:01Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:25:03Councilmember Cashman.
1:25:04Councilmember Osman.
1:25:06Councilmember Rainville.
1:25:08Councilmember Chavez.
1:25:09Councilmember Vito.
1:25:11Councilmember Ellison.
1:25:12Our Vice President Shug Tai.
1:25:16There are 13 ayes.
1:25:18That carries, and that completes the COW report.
1:25:21Finally, we have the Public Health and Safety Committee, which will be presented by that committee's chair, Councilmember Chavez.
1:25:28The Public Health and Safety Committee will be bringing forward five items.
1:25:32Item one is a resolution recognizing the month of October as Health Literacy Awareness Month.
1:25:37Item number two is approving an appointment to the Homegrown Minneapolis Food Council.
1:25:42Item number three is accepting the health block grant for maternal and child health initiatives.
1:25:48Item number four is accepting a racial and ethnic approaches to community health grant for chronic disease prevention.
1:25:54And item number five is authorizing a contract with the Minnesota Timberwolves for bomb detaching security services.
1:26:00I'll move approval of these items.
1:26:03Councilmember Chavez has moved approval of the committee's report.
1:26:06Is there any discussion?
1:26:08Seeing none, I will ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:26:12Councilmember Coskey.
1:26:14Aye, Councilmember Wandsley.
1:26:16Councilmember Jenkins.
1:26:17Councilmember Palmasano.
1:26:19Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:26:20Councilmember Cashman.
1:26:22Councilmember Osman.
1:26:23Council Member Rainville.
1:26:25Councilmember Chavez.
1:26:26Councilmember Vita.
1:26:28Councilmember Ellison.
1:26:29Vice President Shugtai.
1:26:32There are 13 ayes.
1:26:36And the report is adopted, and that completes the reports of our standing committees.
1:26:41The next order of business is noticeable ordinance introductions.
1:26:44We have four notices today.
1:26:46First, I am giving notice of intent to introduce at the next regular meeting the subject matter of an ordinance amending the fire and police protection code, adding provisions for public data reporting on response to First Amendment events, reportable force statistics, any steps taken to address any racial disparities that are found to be produced by particular types of law enforcement actions, behavioral health crisis response numbers, misconduct system statistics, off-duty work numbers, officer hiring, recruitment and retention efforts, and officer assistance and support programs.
1:27:18Second, Councilmembers Ellison and Osmond give notice of intent to introduce at the next regular meeting the subject matter of an ordinance amending the housing code, updating lead safe standards and cross-department enforcement, and amending licensing standards and duties related to compliance and cross-department enforcement.
1:27:36Third, Councilmember Vita gives notice of intent to introduce at the next regular meeting the subject matter of an ordinance amending the administration code, updating and making technical changes to provisions pertaining to payrolls, pension deductions, and other related items.
1:27:50Finally, Councilmember Wandsey gives notice of intent to introduce at the next regular meeting the subject matter of an ordinance, amending the fire and police protection code, adding report a reporting requirement for use of city resources and outside work.
1:28:02Are there any questions on these notices?
1:28:08Seeing none, those notices are hereby given and no further action is required at this time.
1:28:13The next order of business is the introduction and referral calendar.
1:28:17We have four introductions today.
1:28:19First, Councilmember Chavez, Chugtai, and Chowdhury move to amend the prior introductions of the subject matter of an ordinance amending the administration code given at their regular meeting of City Council on July 10th, 2025 by updating the committee referral from the public health and safety committee to the committee of the whole.
1:28:37Second, pursuant to notice, Councilmember Rainville moves to introduce the subject matter of an ordinance amending the liquor and beer code for first reading and referral to the business housing and zoning committee.
1:28:49Adding and amending provisions related to public safety regulation in on-sale establishments.
1:28:55Third, pursuant to notice, I and Councilmember Wandsley move to introduce the subject matter of an ordinance amending the administration code for first reading and referral to the committee of the whole, updating government structure implementation to address outstanding gaps and improve government operations and collaboration.
1:29:11Finally, Councilmember Wandsley and I move to introduce the subject matter of an ordinance amending the administration code for first reading and referral to the administration and enterprise over sight committee, adding a new section relating to the Office of Enterprise Risk Management.
1:29:26May I have a motion to approve those introductions?
1:29:29Is there any discussion?
1:29:30Uh Councilmember Wandsley.
1:29:32Thank you, President Payne.
1:29:33I just want to speak cut off on me.
1:29:47Uh we've even talked about some of this during today's meeting, but we're all aware and have tried to troubleshoot several issues that have arisen from the problematic decisions being made by our current mayoral administration and have questioned whether there's actual risk analyses being done on some of the decisions that are often made or contracts or initiatives that are moved forward.
1:30:00We've even talked about some of this during today's meeting, but we're all aware and have tried to troubleshoot several issues that have arisen from the problematic decisions being made by our current mayoral administration and have questioned whether there's actual risk analyses being done on some of the decisions that are often made or contracts or initiatives that are moved forward.
1:30:12And specifically, is that analysis being done in a systemic uh approach in regards to implementing city programs and services.
1:30:20And while we've done our best, you utilizing tools like legislative directives or after actions, uh all you know, tools available to us through the authority that we have in uh a legislative body.
1:30:34This proposed ordinance is a comprehensive response and solution to what is clearly a systemic issue throughout the entreprise.
1:30:42And ideally, this position will improve city services and programs and ultimately help restore credibility to how the city manages taxpayer dollars that supports a number of critical services being extended to residents in the community.
1:30:56I also think it's important to highlight that this position came as a recommendation from our city auditor.
1:31:02Um we received a report on um where this recommendation was included to the public health and safety committee as it pertained to the audit of the HELICS contract, which um in that audit report, there were uh numerous discrepancies that was uh revealed in terms of why uh how and why that contract got administered and the lack of accounting and just oversight over it um from the administration.
1:31:31So um that was a council-led action that came forward with recommendations.
1:31:35This is one of the recommendations that we're looking to move forward.
1:31:38Um, and again, with the idea of improving transparency and accountability and oversight over programs that's being administered by the administration and making sure that we're doing a thoughtful risk assessment when those initiatives are being rolled out.
1:31:53Um, I also want to note that I do plan to complement this ordinance with a budget amendment as was also highlighted in that report and recommendation to the public health and safety committee.
1:32:03Um, I intend to bring that during our normal markup process.
1:32:07Um, and hopefully, should it be advanced and supported, um, this ideally will allow our administration and city overall to have uh better governance oversight tools in place as we're walking into a new term and new years, and hopefully something that helps to outlast us and really restore credibility to our city in entreprise-wide initiative.
1:32:30So just want to give that context and that's all.
1:32:35Councilmember Travis.
1:32:37Uh thank you, President Payne.
1:32:38I want to thank Councilmember Wandsey and you, Mr.
1:32:41President, for introducing item number four.
1:32:43Particularly, it is important to address many of the concerns in this enterprise, and I hope that this ordinance can help rein on those concerns.
1:32:51As you all know, the office of the city auditor identified 177 over 177,000 in what they classify as overpayments to Helix Health and Housing Services, a single source vendor contracted by the city at the urgent request of the mayor's administration.
1:33:06This vendor was to provide temporary housing, substance uses order treatment and mental health services for individuals experiencing homelessness.
1:33:14Some of these issues regarding Helix came about after housing and social service providers wrote a letter to which they alleged misuse of funds.
1:33:21This prompted an ask for myself and Councilmember Wandsey to the mayor's administration requesting an update on the services in committee last year.
1:33:28I am concerned with a lot of what I read in the city auditors' report, particularly regarding the quote, duplicate and erroneous payments that were made.
1:33:37Such payments show a lack of oversight, which creates an environment ripe for fraud.
1:33:42It's important, it's always important that we as a city are good stewards of city resources.
1:33:47It is especially critical for this council to use all the tools at our disposal to hold the mayor accountable for the actions of his administration.
1:33:55As we continue learning about the real world impacts of our still relatively new strong mayor government structure, we'll continue learning about the ways the city council can act and to ensure the efficient and effective oversight of city resources.
1:34:09I hope that these ordinances get developed and I hope we can work on these issues with strong oversight and accountability over the mayor's administration.
1:34:17And I'm hoping that uh Councilmember Wandsey and Council President Payne can add me as an author on item number four.
1:34:27Uh Councilmember Wandsley.
1:34:29Actually, if he wasn't going to do it himself, I was gonna actually uh add Councilmember Chavez as a uh co-author to this ordinance.
1:34:37I just also want to say thank you for your leadership.
1:34:39I know you in your your efforts to get questions answered about the Healett's contract and us ultimately receiving the audit report um to the public health and safety committee.
1:34:50Like you had become aware of this recommendation much earlier and reached out to the city attorney's office.
1:35:00Um is my understanding that there was not a response given to you around how to advance this very thing that we're considering and introducing right now several months ago, and Nera could have been a world where we could have already had this in place had you received the follow-up you deserved and gotten support in crafting the ordinance language by the city attorney's office.
1:35:14Um so we wouldn't have to be doing this at the end of the year.
1:35:18So I just want to say thank you for your leadership.
1:35:20I'm super grateful to advance this work alongside you and glad that you, after I told you you was gonna be one regardless, uh co-author on this ordinance.
1:35:30Um you've played such a critical role in making sure that again we're exercising our oversight arm over the administration, the Fry Administration, where we're constantly running into these issues or contracts that's put us in a position of raising flags around waste fraud and abuse and making sure that we have appropriate systemic responses in place, guardrails in place that catches these things, so it's not just relying upon us all the time.
1:35:56So thank you, Councilmember Chavez, and so happy to have you as a co-author on this.
1:36:02Seeing no one else in queue, I will ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:36:08Councilmember Koske.
1:36:10Aye, Councilmember Wandsley.
1:36:11Aye, Councilmember Jenkins.
1:36:14Councilmember Palmasano.
1:36:16Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:36:18Councilmember Cashman.
1:36:19Councilmember Osman.
1:36:21Councilmember Rainbow.
1:36:23Councilmember Chavez.
1:36:24Councilmember Vita.
1:36:25Councilmember Ellison.
1:36:27Vice President Chugtime.
1:36:30There are 13 ayes.
1:36:32That carries, and those matters are referred to the committees as listed on the agenda.
1:36:37The next order of business is resolutions.
1:36:39We have four resolutions on our agenda today.
1:36:46Are there any questions or comments from council members?
1:36:51May I have a motion to adopt the resolutions.
1:36:54The clerk will call the roll.
1:36:56Councilmember Koski.
1:36:58Councilmember Wandsley.
1:37:00Councilmember Jenkins.
1:37:01Councilmember Pomassano.
1:37:03Councilmember Chowdhury.
1:37:04Councilmember Cashman.
1:37:05Councilmember Osman.
1:37:07Councilmember Rainville.
1:37:08Councilmember Chavez.
1:37:09Councilmember Vitock.
1:37:10Councilmember Ellison.
1:37:12Vice President Chucktai.
1:37:15There are 13 ayes.
1:37:17That carries, and those resolutions are adopted.
1:37:20Our next order of business is new business.
1:37:23As we discuss at the top of the agenda, we are considering an acceptance of a donation for Councilmember Jenkins to go to the Vision Zero Cities for transportation and lodging for the conference.
1:37:38Is there any discussion on this item?
1:37:42Seeing none, I will ask the clerk to call the roll.
1:37:45Councilmember Koskey.
1:37:47Councilmember Wandsley.
1:37:49Councilmember Jenkins.
1:37:51Councilmember Palmasano.
1:37:52Councilmember Childry.
1:37:54Councilmember Cashman.
1:37:55Councilmember Osman.
1:37:56Councilmember Rainbow.
1:37:58Councilmember Chavez.
1:37:59Councilmember Vitoff.
1:38:00Councilmember Ellison.
1:38:02Vice President Shov Top.
1:38:05There are 13 ayes.
1:38:10Our next order of business is a request for closed session.
1:38:13Before I recognize the attorney and we recess for closed session, I will ask if there are any announcements from council members.
1:38:22Councilmember Angle.
1:38:24Thank you very much.
1:38:25I have two announcements.
1:38:27The first one is that I I celebrated my 37th wedding anniversary last weekend.
1:38:33And my wife and I had a nice dinner and we reminisced over the good times as well as the bad times for 37 years and believe being married to me.
1:38:42There's a lot of bad times.
1:39:11So tonight we will have a rally in support of Fletcher's Ice Cream at 6 o'clock.
1:39:17That's right on East Center Pennette University.
1:39:19And I would invite all my colleagues.
1:39:21I know you have very busy schedules, but if you could spend a little time to come stand with me as we show support uh against this act of hatred in all of our communities.
1:39:32Six o'clock tonight, Fletcher's ice cream.
1:39:36Councilmember Wandsley.
1:39:38Thank you, President Payne.
1:39:39I just wanted to give a shout out to our election and voter staff on Tuesday, I believe, um, the University of Minnesota had its uh early voting pop-up, which has been a very phenomenal innovative um effort led by our election and voter service staff.
1:40:00And was super uh proud of the turnout this year, I believe in 2023 um election there was 95 votes potentially and then this year we had over uh 440 uh voters show out at their early pop-up so historic turnout and again our elections and voters staff was just phenomenal and professional and really supported um the increased turnout in a really uh meaningful way and just wants to give them uh much gratitude council member vita thank you president payne i i just wanted to acknowledge the same today is pop up voting at uh the Minneapolis Urban League and it's gonna be from eleven to six um and that is the address is 2100 Plymouth Avenue North so 11 six uh 11 to 6 p.m anyone can go in and vote at this pop-up site and then there's gonna be another one on Monday October 27th at Weber Community Center from 11 to 6 also and that address is 4400 DuPont Avenue North Councilmember Chowdry.
1:41:09There's gonna be a theme in these announcements so there's also another pop-up voting happening tomorrow Friday October 24th on the Southside at Midtown Global Market at 920 East Lake Street from 11 a.m to six PM great opportunity to use the B line get out and vote everyone I think that was the theme today.
1:41:38Um with that we've completed all items on our agenda and we'll now consider the request for our closed session which is to receive a briefing on the litigation matter listed on the agenda.
1:41:48Before I move to close the meeting I'll recognize the city attorney to provide the legal basis for the requested closed session.
1:41:55Thank you, Council President The next item on the agenda is the case of City of Chicago et al.
1:42:02versus Nome et al.
1:42:03And let me just stop and say at all means and others so in this case it's City of Chicago and also the City of Minneapolis versus GNOME et al.
1:42:15Your lawyers wish to provide a briefing to the council on this litigation matter accordingly under the Minnesota open meeting law Minnesota statutes section 13 D point oh five subdivision 3b the council may upon a proper motion close the meeting for the purposes of attorney client communication as permitted by the attorney client privilege in considering the motion the council should weigh the right of the public to know what its government is doing against the need of the city to preserve the confidentiality of its discussions with its attorneys thank you madam city attorney I move to close our public meeting as authorized under open meeting law specifically Minnesota statutes section 13d dot zero five for the purpose of receiving a briefing on the litigation matter of Chicago City of Chicago et al.
1:43:01versus Noam et al.
1:43:03May I have a second to that motion so moved second somebody else second please all right the clerk will call the roll council member once council member Jenkins Councilmember Palmasano Chowdhury.
1:43:20Councilmember Cashman Councilmember Osman Councilmember Rainville Chavez Councilmember Vita Hi Councilmember Ellison Vice President Shagtai is absent President Payne there are 12 eyes that carries for the viewing public I will note that the broadcast of this meeting will continue and the council will reconvene in public after we've concluded the closed session
2:25:43The time is now twelve oh five, and the city council has reconvened an open session following our closed session.
2:25:52Council Member Koskey.
2:25:58Councilmember Palmasano present.
2:26:00Council Member Chowdhury.