Note: The meeting minutes indicate a date of June 25, 2025, while the provided metadata states June 26, 2025. This summary uses the date from the metadata as instructed.
The Parks and Recreation Commission and Urban Forestry Board met on June 26, 2025, at 7:03 PM in the Maple Room at 201 South Rengstorff Ave, Mountain View, CA. The meeting was conducted with a virtual component. The commission voted on two heritage tree removal appeals for the same property at 1158 Cuesta Drive. The meeting adjourned at 8:57 PM.
Oral Communications (non-agenda): Bruce England (Wisman Station Drive, member of Green Spaces Mountain View) spoke about the meeting process, expressed concern over the number of tree removals in the city, and urged the commission to complete the Biodiversity and Urban Forest Plan to streamline future hearings.
Public Comment on 5.1 (Modesto Ash): Leslie Friedman thanked staff for the tree health presentation and noted that living things are rarely symmetrical, praising the tree's health.
Public Comment on 5.2 (Liquidambar):
Staff report: The Liquidambar had a 40-inch diameter, 60-foot height, and 20+ foot canopy; health and structure were good. The applicant cited poor structure, lack of grow space, necessity for construction, and proximity to structures causing damage. staff found that removal was necessary to construct improvements given the modular design (state-approved, difficult to modify) and the driveway location. Issues included sidewalk lifting, sewer root intrusion, and proximity to two other heritage trees (coast live oak and camphor tree).
Key positions:
Vote: The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to approve the appeal and overturn staff’s recommendation for removal of the Liquidambar, on the grounds that the criteria under MVCC 32.35(a)(2) (necessity of removal to construct improvements) had not been met, and no other criteria were met. The motion was made by Commissioner Sommer and seconded by Commissioner Bryant.
Welcome to the June 25th meeting of the Parks and Recreation Commission and Urban Forestry Board. I am calling this meeting to order. Thank you for patience where we got the IT display up and running. The city would like to remind all participants that the business of the PRC shall be conducted in an orderly manner. Disruptive comments or conduct that impedes the board's business or infringe on the rights of other participants will not be tolerated. The board welcomes all orderly, non-threatening public comments regarding matters over which the board has jurisdiction. Comments or conduct deemed otherwise by the chair will be grounds for terminating a speaker's comment period and or participation at this hearing. Continuous continued disruptions will be the grounds for removal from this hearing. With that, Alison, could we have a roll call, please? We can. We have Commissioner Bryant here. Commissioner Ilio, Commissioner Summer, here, Vice Chair Mitchell. Here and Chair Davis. Here next item, item number three on the agenda are the minutes. Do the commission members have any comments or suggested edits. See no indication. We will open it up for public comment. Anyone in the attendance that would like to provide public comment on this item and fill a blue card or raise your hand if you're online. There'll be a three-minute limit for any speaker. And Allison will give you a one-minute warning. Staff will not respond to questions during public comment. Are there any public comments regarding the minutes? No one online. Seeing none. I will entertain commission discussion or a motion. I'll move approval of the minutes. Second. We have Commissioner Bryant. Yes. Commissioner Pelio. Yes. Commissioner Summers. Yes. Vice Chair Commissioner. Yes. Chair Davis. Yes. And on to item number four, oral communications from the public. This portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any matter that is not on the agenda. Speakers are limited to three minutes. One way. And state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items. Are there any members of the public that wish to address the commission on a non-agenda item? We have one online, Bruce England. Mr. Englund, please proceed. Thank you, Chair. And hello, uh PRC members, commissioners, and staff. Bruce England, Wisman Station Drive, also a member of Greenspace's Mountain View. Just two things.