OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Mountain View, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Mountain View Parks and Recreation Commission Meeting - November 5, 2026

City Council — Thursday, November 5, 2026
BodyMountain View, California
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, November 5, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

0:00

All right, I will now call to order the Wednesday, November 4th, 2026 meeting of the City of Mount View's Parks and Recreation and Urban Forestry Board.

0:10

Alison, will you please conduct the roll?

Speaker 2

0:14

Davis.

0:17

Here, Vice Chair Summer.

Speaker 3

0:19

Here.

Speaker 2

0:19

And Chair Mitchell.

Speaker 1

0:20

Here.

0:23

All right.

0:23

We'll move on to minutes.

0:25

This is the these are the minutes from the October 14th, 2026 meetings.

0:33

We'll see if there's any public comment.

0:35

There are any public comment on

Unassigned speaker

0:37

the

Speaker 1

0:37

minutes before we

Speaker 4

0:42

all right.

0:43

Back to us.

Unassigned speaker

0:45

Would

Speaker 4

0:45

somebody like

Speaker 1

0:46

to make a motion

Speaker 4

0:47

or make a motion of acceptance?

Speaker 1

0:52

A second.

0:53

All right.

0:54

We have a motion.

Unassigned speaker

0:56

And

Speaker 1

0:56

a second.

0:58

Any uh any discussion.

1:01

Okay.

1:02

All right.

Unassigned speaker

1:03

Okay, Mr.

Speaker 2

1:04

Brian.

Speaker 1

1:04

Yes.

Speaker 5

1:05

Davis.

1:06

Yes.

1:08

Vice Chair Summer.

1:10

Yes.

1:10

And Chair Benchner.

Speaker 1

1:11

Yes.

1:22

All right.

1:23

Uh we'll move to item four, oral communications from the public.

1:26

Uh, this portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any matters not on the agenda.

Unassigned speaker

1:34

Uh

Speaker 1

1:34

speakers are limited to three minutes, and state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items.

1:40

If you're in the room and would like to speak, please fill out a blue card.

1:44

And if you're online, uh please use the raise hand feature in Zoom and Allison Flynn will recognize you.

1:51

So I'll look to the room first.

1:53

Anyone want to speak on items that are not on the agenda?

1:59

Anybody online?

Speaker 2

2:01

No hands.

Speaker 1

2:02

All right.

2:03

Uh, we'll close public comment and move on to item 5.1, which is the Friends of Deer Hall of Farm annual report.

2:13

And uh we have uh Deer Hall of Farm board president Lubop Sheet Davis, um, who's going to make the presentation.

Speaker 5

2:28

Good evening, Commissioners, City Staff, members of the public.

2:32

Um, thank you for having

Unassigned speaker

2:34

me.

Unassigned speaker

2:34

I

Speaker 5

2:35

am Lub Sheet Davis.

2:36

I'm the president of the Friends of Deer Hollow Farm.

2:40

We are a volunteer working board, um, and I'm delighted to be here to share some of our fiscal year 26 highlights with you.

2:47

Um, I hope all of the commissioners have had a chance to visit Deer Hollow Farm.

2:53

And if it's been a while, I want to personally welcome you back.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Tree Preservation█████████████████████████████████████████41%
Parks and Recreation███████████████████████████27%
Public Comment████████████12%
Public Engagement███████7%
Procedural██2%
Finance And Investments██2%
Engineering And Infrastructure██2%
Public Health██2%
Sustainability and Resilience██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Mountain View Parks and Recreation Commission Meeting - November 5, 2026

The City of Mountain View Parks and Recreation and Urban Forestry Board met on Thursday, November 5, 2026, at 2:15 PM. Chair Benchner presided. The meeting featured a detailed annual report from Friends of Deer Hollow Farm, an extensive discussion on the replanting plan for the library and Pioneer Park, an update to the Integrated Pest Management (IPM) plan, and the unanimous adoption of the 2027 meeting schedule.

Consent Calendar

  • The minutes from the October 14, 2026 meeting were approved unanimously.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Deer Hollow Farm: Bill Lambert, a trustee of the Mount View School District, spoke in strong support of the farm's educational benefits for local children.
  • Library Replanting and IPM (Item 5.2):
    • Anthony Kleinhouse urged the Board to prioritize truly local native trees (e.g., Coast Live Oak) over the proposed Oregon White Oak, arguing that local trees are critical for the local insect and bird food web. He also criticized the overuse of Western Redbud.
    • Tracy, a biologist, strongly emphasized planting locally native oaks (Coast Live, Valley, Blue) to prevent genetic mixing. She advocated for a complete prohibition of herbicides and pesticides, citing insufficient independent safety research for EPA-approved chemicals.
    • Bob, a beekeeper, supported pollinator plantings but cautioned that organic does not always mean safe for bees, using spinosad as an example. He suggested the city consider larger stock for replacement trees.
    • Lara raised significant concerns about oak pollen allergies (1 in 5 adults affected) and the threat of the Mediterranean Oak Borer beetle, which has killed hundreds of thousands of oaks in Sonoma County. She also inquired about plans for the Iwada Friendship Garden.
    • Rashmi Sahai of Green Spaces Mountain View supported the cessation of herbicides in tree wells. She advocated for locally native oaks and the pollinator landscape concept, arguing from personal experience that allergy impacts are manageable outdoors and should not dictate planting choices.
    • Celia preferred the pollinator concept but called for a broader moratorium on all toxins, noting that "organic" does not imply non-toxic. She expressed concern that grub management practices could harm beneficial pollinator larvae.
    • Hala supported the immediate halt to herbicide use, requested an accelerated IPM review timeline, and strongly favored planting locally native Coast Live Oaks.

Discussion Items

Friends of Deer Hollow Farm Annual Report (5.1)

  • Lub Sheet Davis, Board President, presented the FY26 report. Key highlights included $238,000 in revenue (a 10% increase), an estimated 130,000 annual visitors, and scholarships for approximately 70% of the 4,000 student participants (1,200 from Mountain View schools). The nonprofit contributed $75,000 to an animal trust and maintains a large fund balance. Commissioner Bryant questioned the balance; Davis explained it serves as a necessary reserve against potential downturns in fundraising. The farm renewed its five-year agreement with the city and completed its first strategic plan, unveiling a new brand identity ("where wonder takes root").

Library Replanting, Pioneer Park Concepts, and IPM Update (5.2)

  • Staff Report (Tim Youngberg, Russell Hanson): Provided the context of the 33 removed trees linked to the Aminopyralid detection. The staff proposal for Franklin Street was to plant alternating Oregon White Oak and Western Redbud, chosen for their moderate size relative to the confined 20-foot tree wells. Two concept palettes (Native Growth and Pollinator Meadow) were presented for the City Hall break room and the former time capsule site in Pioneer Park. Staff announced an immediate cessation of all herbicide applications and string trimming in tree wells, replacing those practices with mulching.
  • Commissioner Deliberation:
    • Species Selection: A major point of discussion. Commissioners Bryant, Sylvester, and Summer argued strongly for locally native trees (Coast Live Oak) to align with the city's biodiversity plan. Staff countered that Coast Live Oaks would outgrow the small tree wells and damage infrastructure. Russell Hanson shared his experience successfully planting Oregon White Oaks in San Jose and pointed to a thriving 15-year-old specimen in Morgan Hill. Commissioner Davis acknowledged the challenging site constraints and supported staff's species choice for its drought tolerance and size.
    • Centennial Tree: Commissioner Bryant expressed dismay that the Centennial Tree planted at the break room had been removed. The Board reached consensus to replant a locally native specimen oak at that exact location and restore its historic plaque.
    • Time Capsule Site: Commissioners agreed with Commissioner Bryant's argument that dense pollinator landscaping under a new oak tree would create high maintenance burdens and conflict with park users. The Board directed staff to plant the tree with simple ground cover and defer the high-maintenance pollinator palette to future library grounds projects.
    • IPM & Maintenance Capacity: Commissioners stressed that the success of new planting palettes depends entirely on a shift in staff maintenance practices. Staff acknowledged past failures (e.g., Fayette Greenway) and committed to wider plant spacing and low-maintenance design to ease the transition.

2027 Meeting Schedule (5.3)

  • The draft schedule was presented with the January meeting moved to the third Wednesday to accommodate preparation for the new year.

Key Outcomes

  • Deer Hollow Farm (5.1): The annual report was received by the Board with commendation for the nonprofit's strong financial management and community impact.
  • Library Replanting (5.2): Staff received mixed feedback on the Franklin Street species choice and will continue exploring options with a strong directive to consider locally native alternatives where feasible. The replanting timeline will be coordinated with the upcoming library ADA and stormwater construction project.
  • Pioneer Park Concepts (5.2): Consensus feedback directed staff to replant a native specimen tree at the break room site and restore the centennial plaque. The time capsule site will feature an oak tree with simple ground cover. Formal pollinator planting palettes were deferred to other locations.
  • Integrated Pest Management (5.2): The immediate ban on herbicide applications and string trimming in tree wells was formalized and strongly supported by the commission. Staff will present an updated timeline for the comprehensive IPM policy review at the January 2027 meeting.
  • Meeting Schedule (5.3): The 2027 Parks and Recreation Commission meeting schedule was adopted unanimously (5-0).
  • Next Meeting: The next regular meeting is scheduled for Wednesday, December 9, 2026, and will feature a review of concepts for Thompson Park.

Meeting Transcript

All right, I will now call to order the Wednesday, November 4th, 2026 meeting of the City of Mount View's Parks and Recreation and Urban Forestry Board. Alison, will you please conduct the roll? Davis. Here, Vice Chair Summer. Here. And Chair Mitchell. Here. All right. We'll move on to minutes. This is the these are the minutes from the October 14th, 2026 meetings. We'll see if there's any public comment. There are any public comment on the minutes before we all right. Back to us. Would somebody like to make a motion or make a motion of acceptance? A second. All right. We have a motion. And a second. Any uh any discussion. Okay. All right. Okay, Mr. Brian. Yes. Davis. Yes. Vice Chair Summer. Yes. And Chair Benchner. Yes. All right. Uh we'll move to item four, oral communications from the public. Uh, this portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any matters not on the agenda. Uh speakers are limited to three minutes, and state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items. If you're in the room and would like to speak, please fill out a blue card. And if you're online, uh please use the raise hand feature in Zoom and Allison Flynn will recognize you. So I'll look to the room first. Anyone want to speak on items that are not on the agenda? Anybody online? No hands. All right. Uh, we'll close public comment and move on to item 5.1, which is the Friends of Deer Hall of Farm annual report.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com