This administrative hearing, held on October 30, 2024, at 9:00 AM, considered Rebel Vintners' appeal of the City of Napa's decision to revoke their parklet outdoor dining permit (PL23-0027). The hearing officer, Cheryl Shaffner, presided independently. The City argued that Rebel Vintners failed to comply with permit conditions—including late fee payment, failure to remove a canopy, and allowing the parklet to remain vacant and deteriorate for nearly a year—justifying revocation under Napa Municipal Code sections 12.64.110A, B, and F. Rebel Vintners acknowledged the violations but attributed them to the departure of a managing partner and communication challenges, and requested an opportunity to resume compliant operations with a new partner. The City sought upholding the revocation, restoration of the parklet area to pre-permit condition, and reimbursement of fees and costs totaling $7,477.
Okay, good morning. Um this is the hearing on rebel vintners appeal from the city of Napa's permit revocation, PL23-0027. Can everybody hear me okay? Okay. The date is uh Wednesday, October 30th. It's nine o'clock, and we are recording these this proceeding with audio and visual, I believe. Okay. That'll all be available to both parties after this is done. And uh we will start with um introduction. So my name is Cheryl Shaffner. I'm the administrative hearing officer, uh, brought in for this purpose. I'm not employee of the city. I'm an independent administrating administrative hearing officer. And if we could have each side introduce their representatives and their witnesses, for anybody who would want to testify as to factual matters, we will want them introduced and when the time is right, uh uh swear them under oath for their testimony. So let's start with the city. Good morning, Christina Hickey of Best Best and Krieger representing the city, and we have uh Mike Walker and Ricky Capperton here today. Good morning. And for Rebel Vintners. Uh my name's Jason Holman. I'm joined by my own partner Timothy Keith here, and um also a um uh potential new partner um who I don't think will speak today, but he's here also in attendance, Luis Callegos. Okay, and um I'll also note that we have our uh the city's proceedings are being handled uh very kindly and capably by our city clerk's office. Would you like to introduce yourself as well? I'm Samantha Pasco, the deputy city clerk for the city of Napa. Thank you. Okay, I think that's everyone. Well, let's administer the oath. If everyone who will who plans or may testify, raise your right hand. Oh do you solemnly state under penalty of perjury? The testimony you shall give in this matter shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Yes, yes, yes. Thank you. I'm sorry, I just had that in my notes. We had you do it last time, didn't we? Uh just mixing it up to keep everybody awake, okay. And uh this is an informal proceeding. We um the formal rules rules of evidence do not apply, but objections will be considered as to irrelevant cumulative, privileged or other potentially still applicable rules in the interest of fairness and efficiency. And I understand that uh the appellant is not represented by counsel, so I know you may not know what those things might be, and that's okay if you feel something is unfair or unfair or just not something that is um should be admitted as reliable and um appropriate uh evidence for admission into the hearing. Feel free to object and we'll talk about it. I don't expect you to play lawyer, so it's okay. Um I think I sent out in the uh notification about the procedures. Each side will have 15 minutes to present their opening statement summary of positions you've you've submitted it all in writing, so it's already in the record, but summarizing it here would be helpful. Maybe add anything that wasn't in your written materials if you need to. Um then we will go into examination and cross-examination of witnesses, and then you'll have time to summarize at the end with closing statements. And I try to get a uh ruling out. I think with I will get a ruling out within with today's time schedule. I think I need three weeks, so we'll we'll have something out in writing within three weeks. Try to do it sooner, but I want to be realistic. Okay. So let's proceed. Would the um city like to begin?