OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Napa, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Cultural Heritage Commission Regular Meeting - November 12, 2026

City Council — Thursday, November 12, 2026
BodyNapa, California
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, November 12, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:08

Good evening, everyone.

0:10

Welcome to the November 12, 2026, City of Napa regular meeting for the Cultural Heritage Commission.

0:18

I would like to call this meeting to order and ask Myra to conduct a roll call.

Speaker 2

0:24

Commissioner McKinney?

0:25

Here.

0:26

Commissioner Tweeka?

0:27

Here.

0:28

Vice Chair Asmussen.

Speaker 1

0:30

Here.

Speaker 2

0:30

Chair Owen.

0:31

Oh, I'm sorry, Chair Wesson.

0:33

Here.

0:33

And then I have a Commissioner Van Giza noted as absent.

0:37

Thank you.

Speaker 1

0:39

We will now rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

Speaker 3

0:54

Under God, indivisible Liberty and Justice for All.

Speaker 1

1:02

The Cultural Heritage Commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph M.

1:08

Brown Act, the California Government Code Sections 54950.

1:14

And pursuant to the city's rules of order for Cultural Heritage Commission meetings, policy resolution 10.

1:21

Staff, are there any changes or supplemental reports to this evening's agenda?

Speaker 4

1:26

Yes, so there was a supplemental memo that was sent out on Tuesday about communications received on item 7C.

1:36

Staff is also recommending moving consideration of the September 12th, 2026, CHC meeting minutes to the regular meeting of January 14th, 2027 meeting for edits based off of accuracy on the record.

1:53

And then I will give a brief presentation for item 8A, but recommending moving the fuller presentation until we have a full commission to hear the update.

2:05

At that time, you can also see progression in pictures, so I think it's it'll be more worthwhile.

2:13

But once again, so that's recommending moving the September 12, 2026 CHC meeting minutes to the regular meeting of January 14th, 2027 meeting.

2:26

September 12th.

2:27

Oh yes, September 10th.

Speaker 1

2:36

Okay, thank you.

2:37

Commissioners, are there any proposed changes to this evening's agenda?

Unassigned speaker

2:46

Okay.

Speaker 1

2:47

Public comment provides an opportunity for members of the public to directly address the Cultural Heritage Commission on items of interest not otherwise noted on the agenda.

2:58

Each speaker's comments will be limited to three minutes and will comply with the rules of order of the Cultural Heritage Commission meetings.

3:07

Myra, do we have any members of the public who have provided comment cards or wish to provide public comment on non-agenda items?

3:15

I received no cards.

3:17

Thank you.

3:23

This is consent calendar.

3:24

These routine items may be approved by a single vote.

3:28

However, any member of the public or commissioner may remove an item for consideration during the public hearing portion of the agenda.

3:39

Is there a motion to move item 5A, Cultural Heritage Commission regular meeting minutes for September 12th, 2026 to January 14th, 2027?

Speaker 4

3:52

And that's with the clarity that is September 10th.

Speaker 1

3:59

Do we have a second?

Speaker 3

4:00

I will second.

Speaker 1

4:01

All in favor?

4:03

Aye.

4:04

Opposed?

4:05

No.

4:05

Thank you.

4:07

Is there a motion to approve the consent calendar item 5B, Cultural Heritage Commission regular meeting minutes for July 9th, 2026?

Speaker 3

4:20

I'll make a motion to approve.

Speaker 5

4:22

I'll second.

Speaker 1

4:24

All in favor?

4:25

Aye.

Speaker 5

4:25

Aye.

Speaker 1

4:26

Aye.

4:27

Thank you.

4:29

There are no consent hearings.

4:32

Public hearings and appeals.

4:34

These are items that are formally presented to the Cultural Heritage Commission and provide an opportunity for members of the public to comment.

4:43

Applicants or appealants are allowed 10 minutes to present testimony at the beginning of the public hearing.

4:52

And if needed, five minutes to present rebuttal at the end of the public hearing.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Historic Preservation█████████████████████████████████████████████71%
Procedural███████████18%
Legal Defense███4%
Public Engagement██3%
Engineering And Infrastructure█2%
Mills Act█1%
Downtown Development█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Cultural Heritage Commission Regular Meeting - November 12, 2026

The Cultural Heritage Commission of Napa, California, held a regular meeting on November 12, 2026, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers. The meeting included approval of consent calendar items, three public hearings, and an administrative report. Key actions included forwarding recommendations on a Mills Act contract, a Certificate of Appropriateness, and an update to the Historic Resources Inventory, as well as a status update on the Thomas Earl House.

Consent Calendar

  • Item 5A: The Cultural Heritage Commission regular meeting minutes for September 10, 2026, were moved to the regular meeting of January 14, 2027, for edits based on accuracy. The motion passed unanimously.
  • Item 5B: The Cultural Heritage Commission regular meeting minutes for July 9, 2026, were approved unanimously.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Item 7C (Historic Resources Inventory Update): John Aaron Beattie, owner of 226 First Street, requested a 60-day continuance to research the historical significance of his property before its removal from the Historic Resources Inventory (HRI). He cited connections to early Napa families and potential overlooked historical value. The commission noted the request and discussed how to handle it.

Discussion Items

  • Item 7A – Mills Act Contract for 1423 Seminary Street: Staff presented the application for a Mills Act contract to encourage preservation of a Craftsman-style home (circa 1920) within the Calistoga Avenue Historic District. Owner John Zimmerman expressed commitment to preserving the property and outlined planned repairs, including window replacement with all-wood installation. The commission voted unanimously to forward a recommendation to City Council to approve the contract, determine CEQA exemption, and authorize the Community Resources and Development Director to execute the contract.
  • Item 7B – Certificate of Appropriateness for 1484 Calistoga Avenue: The application sought approval for modifications to a Queen Anne Cottage (circa 1895) in the Calistoga Avenue Historic District, including basement conversion and rear two-story enclosed porch. Owner Lauren Debo and architect Paul Kelly presented. Discussion covered the front stair railing design, a proposed metal handrail for safety, and inconsistencies in window glazing specifications. Commissioner Wesson noted the need to restore missing trim on a lower front window to match adjacent properties. The commission approved the resolution with a condition requiring the front window trim to extend to the bullseye rosette (as shown on 1484 Calistoga Avenue) and clerical edits as recommended by staff. Motion passed unanimously.
  • Item 7C – Historic Resources Inventory Update (Citywide): Staff proposed removing 31 misclassified properties from the HRI that had been incorrectly designated as local landmarks under a superseded NCP (Neighborhood Conservation Property) designation, redesignating four properties as listed resources, and making clerical updates (including removal of lawfully demolished properties). Commissioner Tuikka suggested a need for a comprehensive future update. Public comment from John Aaron Beattie raised concerns about 226 First Street. The commission voted to forward the recommendation to City Council with the addition that the eligibility of 226 First Street be determined based on research information submitted to the council. Motion passed unanimously.
  • Item 8A – Thomas Earl House Status Update (1221 Seminary Street): Staff provided a brief update, noting that the property owner and contractor have begun foundation work on one of the cottages after a building permit extension was granted. Commissioners expressed concern about historical materials exposed to weather and potential deterioration. Staff committed to tracking progress and providing a fuller presentation at the January 14, 2027 meeting. No formal action was taken; the item was moved to the next meeting.

Key Outcomes

  • Consent Calendar: September 10, 2026 minutes moved to January 14, 2027; July 9, 2026 minutes approved.
  • Item 7A (Mills Act): Unanimous vote to forward recommendation to City Council for approval of the contract, CEQA exemption, and execution authorization.
  • Item 7B (Certificate of Appropriateness): Approved with condition to restore front window trim to match bullseye rosette and clerical edits. Motion passed unanimously.
  • Item 7C (HRI Update): Forwarded to City Council with recommendation to approve the update, including removal of 31 properties, redesignation of four properties, and further evaluation of 226 First Street based on submitted research. Motion passed unanimously.
  • Item 8A (Thomas Earl House): Status update received; fuller presentation scheduled for January 14, 2027.

Meeting Transcript

Good evening, everyone. Welcome to the November 12, 2026, City of Napa regular meeting for the Cultural Heritage Commission. I would like to call this meeting to order and ask Myra to conduct a roll call. Commissioner McKinney? Here. Commissioner Tweeka? Here. Vice Chair Asmussen. Here. Chair Owen. Oh, I'm sorry, Chair Wesson. Here. And then I have a Commissioner Van Giza noted as absent. Thank you. We will now rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. Under God, indivisible Liberty and Justice for All. The Cultural Heritage Commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph M. Brown Act, the California Government Code Sections 54950. And pursuant to the city's rules of order for Cultural Heritage Commission meetings, policy resolution 10. Staff, are there any changes or supplemental reports to this evening's agenda? Yes, so there was a supplemental memo that was sent out on Tuesday about communications received on item 7C. Staff is also recommending moving consideration of the September 12th, 2026, CHC meeting minutes to the regular meeting of January 14th, 2027 meeting for edits based off of accuracy on the record. And then I will give a brief presentation for item 8A, but recommending moving the fuller presentation until we have a full commission to hear the update. At that time, you can also see progression in pictures, so I think it's it'll be more worthwhile. But once again, so that's recommending moving the September 12, 2026 CHC meeting minutes to the regular meeting of January 14th, 2027 meeting. September 12th. Oh yes, September 10th. Okay, thank you. Commissioners, are there any proposed changes to this evening's agenda? Okay. Public comment provides an opportunity for members of the public to directly address the Cultural Heritage Commission on items of interest not otherwise noted on the agenda. Each speaker's comments will be limited to three minutes and will comply with the rules of order of the Cultural Heritage Commission meetings. Myra, do we have any members of the public who have provided comment cards or wish to provide public comment on non-agenda items? I received no cards. Thank you. This is consent calendar. These routine items may be approved by a single vote. However, any member of the public or commissioner may remove an item for consideration during the public hearing portion of the agenda. Is there a motion to move item 5A, Cultural Heritage Commission regular meeting minutes for September 12th, 2026 to January 14th, 2027? And that's with the clarity that is September 10th. Do we have a second? I will second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? No. Thank you. Is there a motion to approve the consent calendar item 5B, Cultural Heritage Commission regular meeting minutes for July 9th, 2026? I'll make a motion to approve. I'll second.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com