The Napa Planning Commission held a special meeting on March 8, 2021, via Zoom to continue its review of the draft Land Use Plan for the Napa 2040 General Plan update. The meeting focused on the Big Ranch Road area, key corridors (Trancas, Jefferson, Soscol-Lincoln, Soscol-Imola), downtown Napa and the Oxbow district, build-out projections, and several individual property requests. No formal actions were taken; the commission provided considerations to be forwarded to the City Council for further policy direction.
The commission considered the proposed medium density residential (8-18 du/ac). Staff noted the site is within the RUL and would require circulation improvements (e.g., Trower Avenue extension). Commissioners supported medium density with flexibility, emphasizing need for a master-planned approach, feathering density toward edges, and preserving gateway character. Several public comments opposed the density, but the majority of commissioners (Massaro, Hurtado, Heuther, Oñate, and Kelly) favored medium density to address housing needs, while acknowledging potential for future site-specific plans.
Staff proposed retaining commercial clusters near the freeway, creating a medical/wellness hub around Queen of the Valley Hospital (business professional designation with 1.2 FAR), and allowing mixed-use in between. Commissioners supported the plan but emphasized safe pedestrian/bicycle connections and urged retention of existing retail tax base. Commissioner Oñate suggested considering mixed-use high density for larger parcels like the Staples site.
Envisioned as a walkable "locals main street" with focused mixed-use development, active ground floor uses, and enhanced bike/pedestrian infrastructure. Commissioners (Massaro, Heuther, Oñate, Hurtado, and Kelly) generally supported higher densities and mixed-use but recommended: (1) expanding the depth of mixed-use designations to allow larger redevelopment sites; (2) splitting the corridor into two segments (north of Lincoln and south of Lincoln) due to distinct character; (3) avoiding encroachment on historic neighborhoods west of Jefferson; (4) exploring potential housing on the Caltrans yard and DT Davis school site.
The area includes industrial uses, the city corporate yard, flood-prone areas, and existing hotels. Commissioners discussed: (1) supporting a mix of uses, including potential housing on the corporate yard site along Lincoln; (2) rejecting a continuous river trail on the east side due to private property constraints; (3) favoring hospitality commercial only where it currently exists; (4) general support for the proposed land use designations.
Preserving auto row, redesignating South Napa Marketplace as mixed-use, and improving streetscape and river connectivity. Commissioners commended the plan, noting it enhances the southern gateway into Napa. Commissioner Hurtado queried coordination with Napa Valley College on housing opportunities. Commissioner Kelly suggested studying a potential overhead crossing to connect to the college.
The commission discussed the existing Downtown Specific Plan (2012) and the ULI recommendations for the Oxbow. Staff indicated that a full Downtown Specific Plan update would follow the general plan adoption. Commissioners supported treating the Oxbow as a distinct subdistrict with its own planning criteria. Concerns were raised about parking constraints inhibiting housing development, the need for locals-first policies, and the potential for a future housing overlay. Chair Kelly emphasized the importance of revisiting the Downtown Specific Plan to encourage housing.
Consultant Rajiv provided projections: ~4,000 new housing units (above 3,200 in pipeline), ~10,700 new jobs, and ~15,900 new residents (20% increase). Commissioners noted that projections are planning tools and actual development will depend on market forces. Commissioner Massaro clarified that the plan allows but does not compel growth. Commissioner Hurtado asked about pandemic impacts; staff noted that industrial land preservation was a key goal.
Is Ricky here. We are now live. Commissioner Hurtado, could I get you to turn on your audio and video? There. All right, we are live. Everybody's saddled up, ready to do this again. Okay, good evening, and welcome to the March 8th, 2021 City of Napa special meeting of the Planning Commission. Our first item is roll call. I would like to call this meeting to order and ask staff for roll call, please. Commissioner Hurtado. Present. Commissioner Masaro. Chair. Commissioner Heuther. President. Vice Chair Unyate. Here. And Chair Kelly. President. All commissioners are present. Present accounted for. Tonight's meeting will focus on the general plan update. During the previous two meetings of the commission, we reviewed the proposed land use designation descriptions consisting of density and FAR. And at our last meeting, we reviewed the draft land use plan for three areas in West Napa. At this evening's meeting, the commission will be focused on reviewing the big ranch road area, the key down the key corridors through the city, downtown Napa, and other specific sites. Staff, can you please explain to our viewers how the public will participate in the meeting this evening? Thank you, Chair Kelly. For each section of the agenda, when public comment is asked for, members of the public who wish to speak on the item should use Zoom's raise your hand button to indicate that they would like to speak. This appears as an on-screen button for those who've joined the teleconference online. For those members of the public who've joined the meeting by calling into the teleconference from their telephone, they should push star nine to indicate that they wish to speak when the item of interest comes up. And if there were members of the public who submitted email comments with 500 words or less to planning before the start of the meeting and requested that the comments be read at the meeting, staff will read these comments into the record when the item is called. Thank you, Aaron. Um, so moving on, item number three is agenda review. And I want to let everyone know the planning commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph M. Brown Act and pursuant to the city's rules of order for planning commission meetings. And due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the commission will conduct this meeting as a teleconference in accordance with the governor's executive orders. Staff, are there any changes to this evening's agenda? No, there are not. Commissioners, any proposed changes. Very good. So our next item is public comment. Public comment provides an opportunity for members of the public to directly address the planning commission on items of interest not otherwise on tonight's agenda. For members of the public who are here to comment on the general plan, we will accept comment during that item rather than now. Aaron, are there any members who have the right hands raised or wish to comment? Uh yes, Chair Kelly. We have one hand raised, and I'm not sure if Mr. Jacobson wants to make general public comment or speak about the general plan, but I'm going to allow him to talk. And Jay, you are now able to unmute yourself and address the planning commission. Thanks, Aaron. Can you hear me?