The City of Napa Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, August 5, 2021, beginning at 5:30 PM via teleconference due to the COVID-19 pandemic, in accordance with the Governor's executive orders. All five commissioners were present: Chair Paul Kelley, Vice Chair Reed Oñate, Commissioner Gordon Huether, Commissioner Ricky Hurtado (who joined later), and Commissioner Bob Massaro. The commission took action on two public hearing items: a use permit allowing on-street parking for residential conversions in the Young Building, and a recommendation to the City Council for the Western Meadows subdivision. Both items were approved unanimously (5-0). The meeting was adjourned after staff and commissioner comments.
Staff presented a request to authorize the use of on-street parking in the Downtown to satisfy parking requirements for converting three existing commercial condominium units on the second floor of the Young Building (801 & 809 Coombs Street and 1220 Third Street) into three residential condominiums. The condo conversion is permitted by right, but residential uses trigger parking requirements under the Downtown Specific Plan. The applicant requested a Use Permit (allowed for developments of three or fewer units) to use on-street parking. Staff noted that the project would need approximately five parking spaces (based on 1.3 spaces per three-bedroom unit) and that 21 on-street spaces are adjacent to or across from the building. These spaces are limited to two-hour parking on weekdays from 8 AM to 6 PM; residents would use nearby parking facilities during the day. Staff also noted that guest parking is not required because the building is not within 200 feet of a residential neighborhood, and that if the space remained commercial, approximately 20 spaces would be required, so the conversion reduces parking demand.
Public comment: None were offered.
Commission questions and comments included inquiries about parking permit programs, future parking management, and the precedent for downtown housing. All commissioners expressed support, noting the project aligns with the goal of encouraging housing downtown. The commission voted 5-0 to adopt the resolution determining the project is exempt from CEQA and approving the Use Permit, with a condition that CC&Rs notify future owners of parking limitations and the non-exclusive nature of the on-street spaces.
The commission considered a request to subdivide a 7.56-acre parcel at 1044 Borrette Lane into 12 single-family residential lots (with a private street and five flag lots) at the north end of Borrette Lane. The project also includes the creation of a mitigated negative declaration (MND). The hearing had been continued from a prior meeting (note: the agenda states the item was continued from June 17, 2021, while staff referred to the Planning Commission's July 1, 2021 hearing) to allow the applicant to provide exterior elevations matching the renderings. The applicant returned with new drawings and voluntarily agreed to apply wildland-urban interface (WUI) building standards (California Building Code Chapter 7A) even though the site is not in a WUI area.
Public comments and testimony:
Applicant response: Randy Gillardi, the applicant, stated the project follows the General Plan and zoning, with no variances, and includes fire-hardened construction and four accessory dwelling units (ADUs), though not subsidized affordable units. He disputed the redwood tree distance (engineering says 6–7 feet, not 2 feet), expressed willingness to add a stop sign and provide screening trees for the Burkes, said that pricing is unknown, and noted fire-hardening measures and water conservation.
Commission discussion: Commissioner Massaro requested conditions including WUI compliance (already in Condition 14), an arborist report for the redwood tree, and screening trees for the Burkes. Commissioner Hurtado asked about the legal status of the access lawsuit, traffic impacts, and the potential for fewer units. Staff responded that there is no legal barrier to proceeding; the access issue will need resolution before the final map, and the city could seek eminent domain, which would only acquire a public right-of-way over the Reeds' property within the existing easement. Engineering staff estimated 120 vehicle trips per day (12 in peak hours), below the threshold for a traffic impact report. The initial study found no significant environmental impacts. Commissioner Oñate noted the property is zoned for up to 15 lots and supported the project with additional conditions. Commissioner Huether said the commission follows the General Plan and zoning, and that the houses represent high-quality design. The commission voted 5-0 to forward a recommendation to the City Council to adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration and approve the Design Review Permit, Use Permit, and Tentative Subdivision Map, with conditions: (1) submission of an arborist report at construction drawing submittal; (2) planting of screening trees to address the Burkes' view; and (3) staff review of a stop sign and downlighting.
That is we are now live. Oops, the button. I'm gonna say 527. Nope. 975. Wow. Right. All right. So you you should have got at least everybody to guess, and then somebody won a prize. Yeah, like a little raffle or something. Recording in progress. That's your warning. All right. Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the August 5th, 2021 City of Napa regular meeting for the Planning Commission. Use your microphone all cotton in it or something. No. I got it all turned up. Okay. Okay, sorry about that. I will proceed. Uh Commissioner Heather. What? Oh, yes, present. Commissioner Hertato. I believe uh indicated he might be a little bit late, so we will give them a few more minutes. Commissioner Masaro. Present. Vice Chair Onyate. Here. And Chair Kelly. Present. As noted, uh Commissioner Hurtato will be a few minutes late. All right, thank you. Um staff, can you please explain to our viewers how the public will participate in this meeting this evening? Certainly. Thank you, Chair. For each section of the agenda, when public comment is asked for, members of the public who wish to speak on an item should use Zoom's raise your hand button to indicate that they would like to speak. This appears as an on screen button for those who have joined the teleconference online. For those members of the public who have joined the meeting by calling into the teleconference from their phone, they should push star and indicate that they wish to speak when the item of interest comes up. If there are members of the public who submitted email comments with 500 words or less to planning staff prior to the start of the meeting and requested that those comments be read at the meeting, staff will read these comments into the record when the item is called. Item number three, agenda review and supplemental reports. The planning commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph and Brown Act and pursuant to city rules of order for planning commission meetings. And due to the COVID 19 pandemic, the commission will conduct this meeting as a teleconference in accordance with the governor's executive orders. And hopefully this will be the last one. Staff, are there any changes to this evening's agenda? No. Okay, and I I see Commissioner Hurtato. Note him present, please. Thank you. Do we noted commissioners?