The Napa Planning Commission held a regular meeting on August 19, 2021, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers. The main items were a public hearing on the Soscol Square Shopping Center project and an administrative report on the annual multi-family vacancy rate determination. The commission approved the shopping center with numerous conditions after extensive discussion, and unanimously accepted the 1.7% vacancy rate, which prohibits condominium conversions.
The project proposed a 69,000 sq ft regional shopping center on a 7.02-acre site at 333 & 407 Soscol Avenue. Entitlements requested: Design Review Permit, Use Permit for a drive-through facility, Tentative Parcel Map, and Sign Program. The plan included a 55,000 sq ft Kohl's department store (single-tenant building), a 9,800 sq ft retail building (up to 7 tenants), and a 4,970 sq ft fast-food restaurant with a double-lane drive-through (originally Chick-fil-A, removed as tenant). The site would be subdivided into three parcels with 306 auto and 32 bicycle parking spaces. A class I bike path along Tulocay Creek and public art were proposed. The initial study supported a Mitigated Negative Declaration (comment period ended August 16, 2021).
Key staff presentation (Laurie McNabb, planning consultant):
Applicant team presentation (Kerrick Beauchart, Malcolm Architects; Eric Warkenhagen, Kohl's; Jerry Parko, civil engineer; Doug Frosney, developer representative):
Commission disclosures:
Public hearing closed after no other speakers. Applicant was given 5 minutes for rebuttal (no testimony offered).
Commission Deliberation and Conditions: Key issues raised by commissioners:
Motion and Vote: Vice Chair Oñate made a motion to approve the Mitigated Negative Declaration, Design Review Permit, Use Permit for the drive-through, Tentative Parcel Map, and Sign Program with the following conditions adopted:
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Hurtado.
Roll Call Vote:
Staff (Mike Walker) presented the annual survey of multifamily rental vacancy rate (units over 20). The survey conducted July 19-23, 2021, achieved nearly 90% response. The vacancy rate was determined to be 1.7%, qualifying as a severe rental housing shortage (under 5% threshold), thus no condominium conversion use permits may be processed for the period September 1, 2021 through August 31, 2022. Commissioner Huether noted that despite adding the Braden project (large new complex), vacancy remains extremely low, indicating strong demand. Discussion touched on housing element update (expected in 1-1.5 years) and ongoing efforts to streamline housing production.
Motion to accept the 1.7% vacancy rate was made and seconded, passed 5-0.
It was like first day kindergarten or something. Oh, we're live. Well, good evening, everyone. Um, this is different. Um it's great to be back in chambers. Um, and I would like to welcome everyone here tonight to the regular meeting agenda uh for the planning commission for August 19th, uh 2021. Um and I think our first item is roll call, please. Commissioner Hewther. Present. Commissioner Urtello. Here, Commissioner Masaro. Here, Vice Chair Onate. Present. Chair Kelly. Present. All commissioners present. And do we do the do the flag? Because I don't see that on here. All right, we're gonna pledge uh do the pledge of allegiance. To the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God with liberty and justice for all. Well, we haven't done that in a long time. All right. Let me switch papers here. Um let's see. Item number three is agenda review and supplemental reports. Um the planning commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph Brown Act and pursuant to the city city's rules of order for planning commission meetings. Um staff are this there any changes to tonight's agenda. No, okay. Um commissioners, do you have any proposed changes to the agenda this evening? No. All right, seeing none. Um we will move on to item number four, which is public comment. Um, public comment is an opportunity for anyone here tonight to talk on any item of interest which is not on tonight's agenda. So if you are here for one of the hearings, you will have an opportunity during the hearing to speak. So is there anyone here tonight that would like to speak on anything? All right, seeing none. Um next item is our consent calendar. Um, these are routine items uh which may be approved by a single vote. However, any member of the public or commissioner may remove an item for consideration during the public hearing portion of the agenda. If a member of the public wishes to pull an item from the consent calendar, well, I guess they're not gonna use the raised hand on Zoom. Um I guess you would voice it here in chamber. Um tonight on the consent calendar. Um we have the planning commission meeting minutes from August 5th. Um is there is there uh anyone wishing to pull that item? All right, seeing none, may I have a motion to approve the meeting minutes? Motion to approve, second. There's a motion and a second roll call vote, please. No, no, not roll call, dude. Oh, all right. We're in the flash member.