The Napa Planning Commission met on May 4, 2023, at 5:30 PM in the City Hall Council Chambers. The meeting included approval of prior minutes, two administrative reports on the Brookfield Napa Pipe residential designs and the City's Residential Design Guidelines, and public comment. No formal votes were taken on the reports; the discussion focused on design review processes, objective standards, and future planning.
Brookfield Homes (Napa Pipe Blocks 16, 19, & 22) – Administrative Report: Staff presented an overview of the first three residential blocks at Napa Pipe, comprising 79 single-family homes (28 on Block 16, 28 on Block 19, 23 on Block 22) using the “single-family micro lot” typology from the Napa Pipe Design Guidelines. Key discussion points included:
Residential Design Guidelines Overview – Administrative Report: Staff provided a comparative overview of the current (2004) subjective Residential Design Guidelines and the state’s push for objective design standards (quantitative, prescriptive rules). Key points included:
As far as you know, Patty Ricky's coming. Correct. He still has a whole minute. Probably open a side door for you. Ricky. Not yet. No review. Good evening. Welcome to the May 4th City of Napa regular session of the Planning Commission. Staff, would you please do roll call? Commissioner Healer. I have to be official. Present. Commissioner Kelly. Present. Vice Chair Shotwell. Present. Chair Masaro. Present. And uh Commissioner Hurtado is absent at the moment. Pledge of allegiance, please. Pledge of allegiance to the five of the United States of America. And to the public undergoing so the chair requests that the warrior game be put up on that monitor. Are you stating a time limit for the meeting? Yeah. Okay. Um the planning commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph M. Brown Act. And we're very good at following that. Staff you have any changes to this evening's agenda. No changes. Commissioners, any changes. I see no public, therefore we have no public comment today. Consent calendar. The only item on the consent calendar today is the minutes from the regular meeting of April 20th. Is there a motion to approve the consent calendar as submitted? So moved. Do we have a second? Second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. There is no opposition. There are no public hearings tonight. Moving right along. We have administrative reports. Administrative report items include reports and recommendations from the city staff that do not require a public hearing prior to the action by the Commission. The Commission may take action if the agenda description provides for it. Only the planning commission may authorize public input for these items. Tonight we have two very important ones the Brookfield Napa Pipe Subdivision Administrative Report and the Residential Design Guidelines.