The Napa Planning Commission met on June 15, 2023, at 13:30 UTC (note: the agenda listed the meeting at 5:30 PM PDT, creating a discrepancy in the recorded time). The meeting covered a consent calendar, a public hearing for a restaurant use permit, and a study session for a major mixed-use development. Commissioners Gordon Huether, Paul Kelley (absent), Bob Massaro (Chair), Alexander Myers, and Beverly Shotwell (absent) were present. Commissioner Huether and Hurtado were present; Kelley and Shotwell were noted absent.
1. 872 Vallejo Street – Stateline Road Smokehouse (PL23-0008) Staff presented a request for a Use Permit and Design Review Permit for a full-service restaurant and bar (exceeding 1,000 sq. ft.) at 872 Vallejo Street, with an open-air smoke yard, off-site parking, and a reduction in required parking from 40 to 20 spaces. The applicant, Daryl Bell and Jeremy Threat, described their vision for an elevated Kansas City barbecue concept serving the community. They noted the building is an adaptive reuse of a dilapidated Quonset hut. Commissioners asked about hours of operation (proposed 9 a.m.–10 p.m., typical 11 a.m.–9 p.m. Thu–Mon), peak customer counts (80–100 transactions per meal), smoke mitigation (enclosed smokers with tall stacks, screened), and art (a mural planned). No public comment was offered. The commission unanimously approved the resolution (motion by Commissioner Hurtado, second by Commissioner Huether).
2. South Oxbow Mixed-Use Pre-Application (PL22-0117) A preliminary review of a 6.7-acre mixed-use development: 130 for-sale residential units (21 townhomes, 109 condos), 170-room hotel, retail/restaurant space, and a riverfront trail. The applicant, Wayne O’Connell (Oxbow Holdings LLC), stated the project is 68% residential and includes 10% inclusionary affordable housing (13 units at 80% AMI). He requested a height waiver (up to 75 feet) and a parking waiver under density bonus law. The architect presented elevations using brick, stone, wood, and stucco, with stepped massing and pedestrian-oriented design. Commissioners and public provided extensive feedback:
Okay, we're good to go. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Welcome to the June 15th meeting of the Napa City Planning Commission. Can I ask you all to silence your telephones? Staff, would you please do roll call? Commissioner Heather. Present. Commissioner Urtelo. Present. Chair Masaro. Present. And Commissioner Kelly and Shotwell noted absent. Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. The Planning Commission conducts all meetings in accordance with the Ralph M. Brown Act in pursuant to the city's rules of order. Staff, are there any changes to this evening's agenda? No changes to the agenda, but there were late communications for items 6A and 8A, which are forwarded on to you, and copies are provided in the back. I received those, and I believe the other commissioners did. Commissioners, any changes to tonight's agenda. Nope. Nope. Very good. Public comment. Public comment provides an opportunity for members of the public to direct to directly address the planning commission on any agenda item that is not on tonight's agenda. So if you would like to um talk to us about anything that we're not going to talk about, which is going to be the um potential restaurant and um the hotel. If you would not like to, if you'd like to talk about anything besides those two, please come to the podium. Okay, very good. Uh consent calendar. These routine items may be approved by a single vote. However, any member of the public or commissioner may remove an item for consideration during the public portion of the agenda. This evening, the only thing there's two things on the consent calendar. One includes the regular meeting meetings of June 1st, and the other is the Brookfield Napa Pipe tentative map. Do we have a motion to approve the consent calendar? Mr. Chair, we kind of need to break those into two because I need to abstain from item A. Thank you. All right, since Commissioner Heather was not here for the minutes. Um Commissioner Hurtado, can you move to approve the minutes, please? So move. And I second that, and so the minutes are approved. Now moving to the consent calendar, having to do with the Brookfield Napa Pipe. May we have a motion to approve that part of the consent calendar. So Chair if I may interrupt before proceeding, I would ask if there's any members of the public that want to speak on that um item since it's a consent hearing and could be pulled upon request. Uh thank you. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to pull the Brookfield Napa pipe from the consent? That means we would hear a staff report and you would have an opportunity to speak on that item.