0:59 Good evening and welcome to the June 2nd Naperville City Council meeting.
1:14 Please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance.
1:20 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands.
1:27 One nation under God.
1:40 As many of you know, our electric department director Brian Groth was recently involved in a serious accident.
1:48 And tonight our professional staff and council members and even some members of the public are wearing green ribbons as a symbol of solidarity and support.
1:57 This is our way of sending Brian strength to his family and letting them know that we keep them in our thoughts daily, and we want them to know Naperville as a community is standing with him through his road to healing.
2:14 Next, the first item on our agenda is awards and recognitions, and Councilman McBroom is the mayor pro tem tonight, he will be presenting.
2:31 So if we go to the members of uh Naperville Neighbors United and supporters, come on out.
3:11 Whereas, Juneteenth commemorates June 19th, 1865, the day enslaved African Americans in Galveston, Texas, were informed of their freedom, making the defining moment in our nation's history and the ongoing pursuit of liberty and justice for all.
3:26 And whereas Juneteenth is both celebration of freedom and time of reflection, honoring the resilience, achievements, and enduring contributions of African Americans who have helped shape and strengthen our nation and communities, and whereas the city of Naperville recognizes the importance of fostering a welcoming and inclusive community where people are respected, valued, and encouraged to build understanding through dialogue and shared experiences.
3:50 And whereas Naperville Neighborhood United remains committed to bringing the community together through cultural awareness, connection, and civic engagement, and invites residents and visitors alike to attend the two thousand twenty-six Juneteenth celebration on Saturday, June thirteenth, two thousand twenty-six at twelve p.m.
4:09 at Rotary Hill, featuring music, food, cultural experiences, storytelling, and family activities that honor the meaning and legacy of Juneteenth and whereas Juneteenth served as a reminder of the importance of unity, equality, and continued progress as we work together to build a stronger and more connected community for future generations.
4:28 Now, therefore, I, Mayor Scott Worley, mayor of the City of Naperville, do hereby proclaim June nineteenth, two thousand twenty-six as Juneteenth day in the city of Naperville, and encourage all residents to recognize and honor this important day through reflection, service, and community engagement.
4:45 Good evening, everyone.
4:58 On behalf of Naperville Neighbors United, thank you to everyone who joined us on stage today.
5:05 Those in attendance this evening and those watching from home as we come together to recognize and honor Juneteenth.
5:12 The proclamation we just heard reflects an important and painful chapter in our nation's history.
5:18 Juneteenth is not only about what happened in 1865, it is also about what we choose to do with history today.
5:26 History should not divide us.
5:29 It should teach us, challenge us, and inspire us to build a stronger community.
5:35 Juneteenth provides an opportunity to learn from one another.
5:39 A strong community is built not by thinking alike, but by learning to listen, respect and grow together.
5:48 That why that is why recognizing Juneteenth continues to matter.
5:54 At Naperville Neighbors United, we believe communities are strongest when people engage with one another in a spirit of understanding, respect, and connection.
6:05 Our mission is to create opportunities for those conversations and connections to happen.
6:11 Thank you for joining us in honoring Juneteenth, and we hope you will join us on Saturday, June 13th from 12 to 3 at Rotary Hill as we celebrate freedom, culture, community, and connection.
7:04 Our next item is public forum.
7:06 I'd like to remind everyone of the citizen participation rules in the city's municipal code for speaking at city council meetings.
7:13 Speakers are asked to present their comments in a respectful and courteous manner.
7:18 Speakers should stay on topic and be cognizant of their words.
7:22 Personal attacks on council members, staff, other speakers, or members of the audience are not allowed.
7:28 If inappropriate language or comments are expressed during this meeting, you will be asked immediately to stop commenting.
7:35 Also, for audience members, there is no cheering and no jeering.
7:39 Actions such as applauding, cheering, finger snapping, booing, or any other noises during or at the conclusion of any remarks made by any speaker are not allowed.
7:48 If this occurs, you will be asked immediately to stop.
7:50 And if it continues to persist, I will recess the meeting until the audience abides by the rules in our city code.
7:56 No speaker should ever feel intimidated by the crowd.
8:00 Audience disruption is meant to intimidate those speaking, and I will not allow it in the chambers.
8:05 Audience members with signs.
8:06 The signs must not block any other audience members' view.
8:10 Speakers are given three minutes to address the city council to help speakers stay within the three-minute time frame.
8:15 We have a timer located over on the side dies to your right.
8:21 It gives the visual cue when the three minutes are expiring.
8:24 This helps speakers conclude their comments in a timely manner without being cut off.
8:28 The timer will buzz when it hits zero, and we will alert the speaker that their time is up.
8:32 If a speaker's name is called and they are not in the room, we will move on to the next speaker and we will not go back.
8:39 Speakers are encouraged to remain in council chambers until the conclusion of public forum in the event council members want to ask follow-up questions.
8:48 So when your name is called, please come and have a seat in the first row.
8:53 Schatz, please call the speakers.
8:56 We have two speakers in public forum this evening.
8:58 The first speaker is John Doyle, followed by Derek Adam Hoover.
9:08 All right, thank you.
9:09 Uh John Doyle, Naperville resident.
9:11 Uh welcome to week three of my series on affordable electricity.
9:15 And today we're going to be talking about the anatomy of affordability.
9:20 Now I've been saying that this is a solved problem, and it is, and all of the solutions happen to share a single common quality.
9:29 And that is customers and/or kilowatt hours are somehow differentiated with the goal of specific customers paying relatively less than others.
9:40 That's the only secret to solving affordability.
9:45 If you go into the next rate study trying to solve affordability with a flat rate, we'd be the very first utility successful at doing so.
9:53 No one's been able to make this work because the math simply just isn't mathing.
9:58 Up on the screen is some basic calculations showing that a person making minimum wage has $936 a year to spend on electricity for it to be affordable with a modest and realistic use as low as 550 kilowatts hours per month.
10:12 That would cost 1,095 in April, thus being unaffordable.
10:17 Even if they somehow managed to get LI Heap Assistance, which isn't a guarantee, the benefit for gas heated homes in this case wouldn't be enough to cover the 3% threshold.
10:28 I'd also like to point out that minimum wage is almost double the federal poverty level, and we have close to 5% one in 20 households living under poverty.
10:37 You cannot solve affordability with a flat rate.
10:40 You cannot solve it by solve by purchasing cheaply, and our existing assistance program is not enough to help everyone who needs it.
10:48 You can, however, address this in the upcoming rate study.
10:57 Affordability is a policy choice, and it's a solved problem.
11:01 I will be back next session to talk about my personal favorite rate structure, which is an inclining block rate as it allows you to also bake in conservation signals.
11:14 The next speaker is Derek Adam Hoover.
11:22 Um just giving you a quick update on SB 336.
11:25 Um to date, I've only now gotten one email back from one senator, and it's an automated email, just acknowledging the fact that a voicemail's been sent.
11:34 They've went and done a vote without any public discourse.
11:38 I know they're supposed to, technically, by law, they don't.
11:41 Um, I've reached out to my union attorneys, and I've encouraged them to send a letter or file a complaint to get all voting stopped until some public discourse and at least my 50-60 emails I've sent now to be acknowledged.
11:55 They won't even acknowledge the fact that the city attorney took the time to write the amendment that we were gonna pass.
12:01 Um, haven't reviewed it, haven't looked at it.
12:03 They basically said that they talked with other communities, not this one, but they talked to other communities and got their input on what those communities thought would be the best course of action, which was this ridiculous SB 336, which is gonna ban e-bikes basically for everybody unless you want to title plate and insure them, which is simply at this point looking like a money grab.
12:24 I don't see any thing in this bill that is actually protecting the public that's doing anything to take e-bikes out of the hands of irresponsible riders who are gonna continue to ride irresponsibly.
12:34 Um, so again, I'm urging all of you here.
12:36 Anyone you know, please reach out.
12:38 I'm gonna have my union attorneys do the best they can.
12:41 I'm on a limited constraint with how much resources I have.
12:44 I've only got about 12 hours left to use my attorneys for the year.
12:48 Like to save that for other things, but I'm gonna use it.
12:50 It's all the benefits I have.
12:52 Um, that's about it on that.
12:55 Chief Ayers, I'd like to thank you for Monday.
12:58 Um, what this community did coming together and protecting us was fantastic.
13:02 I made sure my kids were unfortunately nowhere near downtown the whole day, so that they weren't anywhere near their falderall.
13:08 And you proved why my whole issue with SB336 is that you guys aren't being acknowledged.
13:14 The voice of this city should have a lot of weight in the state, and I don't see them doing that.
13:20 I don't see them making any effort to reach out to you guys.
13:22 I don't know if anyone has been reached out to, but I doubt it.
13:25 And I'm gonna continue to stomp the floor and use every extra hour I have and everything I can do.
13:31 If it passes, I'm gonna be in defiance of it, and I'm gonna continue to file legal legislation, whatever I can do, and I'm asking the city to stand by me and do whatever you can do to see to it that they at least acknowledge the fact that what they're doing is not gonna solve the problem.
13:43 I'm for having an e-bike bill.
13:45 I actually think the state bill doesn't go far enough.
13:47 Like I've stated before, but what they're doing, taking it out of my children's hands so that we can't ride together like a good family is ridiculous, and it's not gonna stop people who ride irresponsibly from stop riding irresponsibly.
13:59 So thank you for that.
13:59 Chief Ayers, again, thank you for Monday.
14:02 I know every day we're safe at this time.
14:08 That was the final speaker.
13:59 All right, next is council public forum.
14:12 As a reminder for the code, council members have three minutes to speak during public forum and can speak up to two times.
14:18 Um I want to start with uh Chief Aries and ask you to uh uh share with the public um your feelings on on what transpired last night and the work our police department did in the downtown.
14:34 Am I on a timer or so a couple weeks ago our folks and some great members in our community shared a flyer with us about uh teen takeover trend that was due to happen yesterday evening.
14:48 Um so we started planning for that.
14:52 As I've explained to the media recently, this is not something new we've been dealing with.
14:55 This is the third year now of teen takeovers, not only in our community but throughout the country, and through that time we've learned a lot through experience.
15:05 So we put a good plan together.
15:07 We're blessed with great men and women at the police department.
15:09 There was a great plan in place.
15:11 We had a lot of resources down there to maintain a high level of visibility.
15:15 So those that did come down and want to follow the rules and the laws felt safe and protected.
15:20 Um and I sent a lot of messaging out that we want families, kids, adults, everybody in our downtown, and really anywhere in our city, and they need to celebrate and have fun lawfully.
15:32 And anybody that wasn't gonna follow our laws, any laws, was going to be held accountable because one of the things we've learned in the last three years is the softer, kinder warning approach with some of the disrespect we face, just isn't working to get the compliance we were looking for.
15:49 So we've taken a zero tolerance approach, and I mean to any violation that is occurring during these teen takeovers, and that has had a great deterrent effect for those that are looking to violate the laws.
16:01 So yesterday evening, uh, was mostly a peaceful event.
16:07 Unfortunately, there were nine arrests for everything from battery to disorderly conduct to giving us fake names.
16:14 Uh, there were a lot of traffic citations written uh for everything from fire lane violations to other issues with poor driving.
16:23 Um thank you to all the community members that said thank you to our folks.
16:27 Those are stressful and difficult long evenings for our police officers, but the amount of emails I received today for thank yous just for the fantastic job, those officers that were down with down there uh working and some of the disrespect they were subject to by our young people, which was super disappointing to hear.
16:47 Um, but they maintained that level of professionalism that we expect out of our police officers and did a fantastic job down there uh last night.
16:54 So super proud to lead those men and women and thank you to everyone for their support and working with us on this.
17:02 If these trends keep coming, we will continue to plan accordingly.
17:05 And we want people again, please come.
17:08 Please enjoy our downtown.
17:09 Please spend lots of money in our downtown.
17:11 But do it responsibly, because if you don't, we will hold you accountable.
17:16 Well, and thank you, Chief.
17:17 We we got lots of phone calls today here at the mayor's office, lots of emails from thankful community members, um, businesses in the downtown, um, who were very complimentary of everything they observed, saw, and were we part of, specifically with the professionalism of how you attempted to de-escalate um everything without having to make any sort of issuance of a citation or arrest.
17:43 And obviously, in some cases that worked.
17:46 Otherwise, there would have been far more arrests and citations throughout the evening.
17:50 So, again, thank you for all the commitment from the police department.
17:53 We expect it to continue and be consistent throughout the summer.
17:56 The equipment violations on vehicles that we we've focused on in the past, that's also an issue that we we expect, and uh uh I I know that you are focused on uh throughout our city.
18:07 So, on behalf of uh myself and and I'm sure many other council members here as well, uh, we appreciate your work, the police department's work, and our community members' work because public safety, this is this is not a police job, this is a city job, and a city consists of everybody from the business community to the residents to our police, our firefighters, you name it, they're all part of the solution.
18:29 Um, everything that comes together to keep our city safe, that is a true community working together.
18:41 Any other councilman for council public form?
18:46 Seeing none moving on the consent agenda.
18:50 We have a motion to use the omnibus method to approve the consent agenda.
18:54 I'm move to use the omnibus omnibus method to approve the consent agenda.
19:00 All those in favor sign aye.
19:03 Motion passes zero.
19:06 We have a motion to approve the consent agenda.
19:09 Mayor, move to approve the consent agenda.
19:14 Schatz, please read the consent agenda.
19:17 Approval of the May 19, 2026 regular city council meeting minutes.
19:21 Approval of city council meetings schedule for June, July, and August 2026.
19:25 Approval of appointments to the sister cities commission.
19:28 Approval of the award of the cooperative procurement for dump trucks with plows to JX Truck Center for an amount not to exceed $661,100.63 cents.
19:38 Approval of the award of the cooperative procurement for Dark Trace Enterprise Immune System and Antegena to SHI International Corporation for an amount not to exceed 226, 830.2 cents for a one-year term.
19:53 Approval of the award of the cooperative procurement for trailer mounted trash pump to Thompson Pump for an amount not to exceed 107,250.
20:02 Approval of the award of the cooperative procurement for managed system studies plan to Gray Bar for an amount not to exceed 114,500 for a five-year term.
20:10 Approval of the award of the cooperative procurement for janitorial supplies to WW Granger for an amount not to exceed 180,000 for one year term.
20:19 Approval of the award of the cooperative procurement for Cisco BOIP phone system, flex calling in UCCX to Sentinel Technologies for an amount not to exceed $317,774.19 cents for a three-year term.
20:34 Approve the award of option year three to the contract for janitorial services to citywide building maintenance for an amount not to exceed six hundred and eighty thousand dollars for one year term.
20:43 Approval of the award of change order number one to the contract for sanitary sewer mainline cleaning to hair construction for an amount not to exceed 224,000, 829.54 cents.
20:55 Approval of the award of change order number one to option year three to the contract for fire and security alarm, fire suppression and extinguisher maintenance services to Fox Valley Fire and Safety Company for an amount not to exceed one hundred thousand dollars, passing the ordinance to establish temporary traffic controls and issuing a special event permit for the Water Street Art Fair event scheduled on Sunday, July 12, 2026, passing the ordinance to establish temporary traffic controls and issuing a special event and amplifier permit for the 2026 Naperville Neighborly Days scheduled on Sunday, August 9, 2026.
21:28 Adopting the resolution approving the wetland credit agreement and payment of $22,000 to Mill Creek Wetland Bank for an off-site wetland mitigation for the 87th Street Bridge Reconstruction over Springbrook Creek Project and adoption of the resolution authorizing execution of a collective bargaining agreement between the city of Naperville and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 196.
21:50 We have a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda as read.
22:00 I motion passes 80.
22:05 Item J1 and J2 are the public hearing for the program year 2025 community development block grant consolidated annual performance evaluation report and a recommendation to accept the report.
22:17 The public hearing for the program year 2025 community development block grant, CDBG consolidated annual performance evaluation report, is now open.
22:26 Anyone who wishes to speak may come forward.
22:30 Don't all come at once.
22:33 Councilman White might have a motion to close the public hearing.
22:36 Um yes, Mayor, I I did have a question.
22:38 I don't know if it should be part of the public hearing or not when it comes to Go ahead.
22:41 Someone can come up.
22:47 Miranda might want to.
22:50 A great job with this.
22:52 Um I do have a question that question though.
22:55 Uh, in your opinion, do you feel like we're maximizing the use of this grant or are we or are we potentially leaving money on the table or because we're not applying for as much as we could.
23:07 And if so, I'd like to see if there's anything we can do to encourage uh more uh people to apply for the for the CDBG.
23:17 Yes, this is uh Miranda Barfis.
23:19 I'm the community grants manager for the city of Naperville.
23:22 Um, I think we are maximizing our CDBG grant.
23:25 Um I'd be happy to welcome any new applicants um that do um want to apply for pre-meeting is really recommended because there are a lot of federal restrictions with this money.
23:36 A lot of it um needs to be focused on capital projects that benefit low and moderate income individuals.
23:41 Um, but there are a lot of wonderful uses that we would love um to be able to apply for this grant.
23:47 So um new applicants are always welcome to contact me, um, but I do believe that every year we uh maximize this grant as we allocate every available dollar.
23:56 Okay, yeah, and and to that point you you feel like we're uh we're marketing it well enough that people know about it in your opinion.
24:07 Um we um always fold this into our social service grant, which is extremely popular, extremely competitive.
24:13 Um, lots of uh nonprofit organizations come and apply for that as well.
24:17 So I think it's a nice fold in so that they can hear all about CDBG as well, of if they have any applicable projects.
24:26 Councilman White might have a motion to close the public hearing.
24:30 I move to close the public hearing.
24:31 Council McKelly, second Kelly.
24:34 All those in favor sign aye.
24:38 Motion carries eight zero.
24:41 The public hearing is now closed.
24:45 Mayor, move to accept the program year 2025 community development block grant, consolidated annual performance evaluation report.
24:55 We have a motion and a second on J2.
25:12 Item L1 is recommendation to pass the due process and municipal property ordinance.
25:17 There were six positions of support and ten written comments posted to the website.
25:21 There are 11 speakers.
25:24 Start with the first speaker.
25:26 The first four speakers are Karen Peck, Diana Torres Hawkin, Mandy Hazinga, and Tim Kane.
25:33 As a reminder, the same rules apply from public forum.
25:35 And as your names have been called, please move to the front roll.
25:42 Peck, you'll be up first.
25:51 Thank you to members of council.
25:55 Our city staff and attorney deSanto for working with Almus, the Alliance of Latinos motivating action in the suburbs and allies to create a meaningful and legally binding Naperville due process and municipal property use ordinance.
26:12 Through this ordinance, the city of Naperville reaffirms its commitment to upholding the constitutional rights guaranteed by the first, fourth, and fourteenth amendments to the United States Constitution.
26:25 The ordinance comprises recitals or statements of reasoning.
26:30 The ordinance integrates that reasoning into the text to make the ordinance legally binding.
26:36 There are those who say ICE can do whatever they want and you can't stop it.
26:43 Every day, more and more Americans are demanding accountability in the face of federal lawlessness, demanding oversight, and refusing to accept ICE behavior as normal.
26:57 Ice staging and processing is a step before a detainment, where currently court cases are focused on extensive human rights abuses of residents and of U.S.
27:09 This ordinance allows our city to legally say no to staging and processing on our municipal properties.
27:19 This ordinance confirms that we'll there will be documentation of any illegal behaviors.
27:26 In passing the ordinance, Naperville joins cities and states across the nation in using legally binding home rule laws to communicate and to make transparent what the city can and cannot do.
27:42 Thank you again, Naperville city staff, attorney deSanto, and the Naperville City Council for thorough and respectful work with our community.
27:52 This process has demonstrated the best of what a local government, elected officials, and an engaged community can accomplish.
28:01 I respectfully ask again for your votes tonight to pass the Naperville due process and municipal property use ordinance.
28:13 The next speaker is Diana Torres Hawken, followed by Mandy Heisenka.
28:19 Mayor Wherley and City Council members.
28:21 My name is Diana Torres Hawkin, and I'm a founder and vice president of Almas, Alliance of Latinos Motivating Action in the Suburbs.
28:28 And I'm here tonight speaking on behalf of our organization and the community members we serve.
28:32 I'm also a resident of Naperville.
28:34 Anmas was founded because we believe every resident in this community deserves to be feel that their local government sees them, hears them, and operates with clarity and accountability on their behalf.
28:45 That is not a political statement, that is a civic one, and it is exactly what brings us here tonight.
28:50 Much of the public conversation surrounding this ordinance had centered on whether formal policy is still needed when training and administrative guidance already exists.
29:00 Policy and administrative guidance are not competing approaches.
29:05 Guidance tells staff what to do today.
29:07 Policy creates the public standard that endures across administrations, across staff changes, and across time.
29:13 One without the other leaves a gap.
29:16 We also want to be clear, symbolic does not mean meaningless.
29:19 Public ordinances establish expectations, create a record of community values, and give residents a framework they can point to and hold their government accountable against.
29:29 That matters, especially now when so many residents are simply seeking clarity.
29:35 We recognize the ordinance before you tonight is narrower than what some residents originally envisioned.
29:40 It is focused primarily on municipal property, constitutional protections, and local governance authority.
29:47 While more limited in scope, we believe it still establishes something important: a clear public consistent framework for how city property and resources are used, and a commitment to documentation and transparency when questions arise.
30:05 From the beginning, we've called for balanced approach, formal policy working alongside communication, education, training, implementation guidance, and continued community engagement.
30:15 We are asking you to adopt both tonight.
30:18 Naperville is home to families, young people, workers, and neighbors who are watching how this community chooses to show up for them.
30:25 Transparency, accountability, and clear public policy are not burdens on good governance, they are the foundation of it.
30:32 We respectfully and wholeheartedly urge this council to adopt the Naperville Due Process and Municipal Property Ordinance.
30:38 Thank you so much for your time.
30:42 The next speaker is Mandy Heizenko, followed by Tim Kane, Mary Ashna, Sarah Haviz, and Jesse.
30:50 I am Rav Ryan Mandy Heizinga, Minister of DuPage Unitarian Universalist Church.
30:55 Today I am here speaking on my own behalf as a resident in Naperville, a partner of an Afro-Latino-Puerto Rican person, a parent of two D203 children who are mixed race, including African, Latinae, indigenous, and fourth generation Dutch immigrant.
31:13 I am also speaking in it as a minister in the Unitarian Universalist tradition whose legacy of justice reaches deep and wide in this nation and beyond our borders.
31:24 Despite the very obvious tactics to muddy the water around responsibility between state, city, and federal government, in the hopes of inciting fear and garnering support in the guise of reason and rationality, there's actually nothing at all confusing about this moment or this ordinance.
31:45 The founding documents of this nation are abundantly clear that due process for all people residing on this land is necessary.
31:55 There's no ambiguity about where the responsibility for due process begins and ends.
31:59 We are all responsible for ensuring that access to due process is afforded to all and not through a state of incarceration and fear.
32:10 What makes this particular decision difficult isn't where the responsibility begins or ends.
32:17 It is what a people of conscience, integrity, and moral fortitude are to do when those at the highest levels of our government choose to go against the founding principles that they are required to uphold.
32:30 The answer to this question is more than a practical argument about jurisdiction, it is a moral question about not only upholding our nation's founding documents, but also who we are as a people.
32:44 Not only now, but who we aspire to be.
32:48 Passing this ordinance is not simply a logistical question, but a moral one.
32:54 This past fall, when ICE entered Chicago before any ordinances or statements were made by our local officials, the actions of ICE agents in Chicago supported by federal authorities gave rise to hate.
33:08 As he walked to work one morning, my partner was attacked and punched in the face by a man harassing a woman and infant, telling them and my partner to go back to the country from whence they came.
33:20 When people in authority choose to take a stand, a stand on the side of this nation's founding documents to protect the people that they are elected to serve, citizen or not, it is a message that hate and violence is not welcome here.
33:35 It will not be tolerated, and that holds power.
33:39 I wish to live in a city, a state, a nation, and a world in which my elected league leaders are unambiguous about upholding the worth and dignity of all people in the face of hate, even in the face of powerful tyrants.
33:56 The next speaker is Tim Kane, followed by Mary.
34:02 My name is Tim Kane.
34:03 I'm not a resident of Naperville, but I am here again tonight because I shop here and I spend time here and I care about this community.
34:10 Whether in person or through media coverage this past year, many of us have with this and heard the stories today of the chaos and fear ICE can bring into any community.
34:19 We've seen neighbors torn from their families for a civil infraction on par with a speeding ticket, not a crime.
34:26 But for them, the consequence isn't a fine.
34:29 It's being taken from their kids, their job, and their home.
34:33 At the last meeting, Mayor Worthy raised concerns about this ordinance putting police in a difficult position.
34:39 But from what I've seen, it is ICE's lawless, reckless behavior putting them in the position, not an ordinance.
34:45 I don't doubt that Naperville's police officers navigate competing pressures and hard calls every single day.
34:52 And if conflicts with federal immigration enforcement are genuinely too difficult to manage, that is a problem worth confronting directly, not a reason to leave everyone without guidance.
35:04 I also read where a council member labeled the people who had showed up to advocate for this ordinance, activists, as though that's a derogatory term, as though speaking up for your neighbors is something to be ashamed of.
35:17 These are caring community members participating in their government, defending their rights and demonstrating their principles.
35:24 That same member also warned that this opens a door that can't be closed.
35:29 And while I find that to be more of a slippery slope fallacy than a policy argument, let's talk about the door.
35:36 Is it the door that throughout our country's history has opened to people coming here for a better life?
35:42 Is it the same door that the federal government is trying to close against the will of most Americans?
35:47 To me, that is a door worth fighting to keep open.
35:51 Maybe parts of the ordinance are symbolic, but we started this meeting the way we always do.
35:57 We stood, looked at the flag of the United States of America and pledgedge to it.
36:02 That flag is also a symbol.
36:04 If you took one star away from it, it would look like we lost something as a country because symbols mean something.
36:10 They tell people who we are, and this ordinance can do the same thing.
36:15 At the end of the remarks earlier this evening, it was said that we all play a role in public safety.
36:22 Tonight, this council has the opportunity to take a stand for the safety of Naperville's immigrant community, and I hope you do so.
36:32 The next speaker is Mary, followed by Ashna Sarah Haviz.
36:39 Mary Ann Curtis here.
36:40 I don't know how I signed up only as Mary, but Mayor Worley and members of the council, I'm happy to be here this evening.
36:46 Could you get a little closer for the microphone for us?
36:52 Mayor Worley and members of the council.
36:55 My name is Mary Ann Curtis.
36:56 I'm a Naperville resident, and I'm here to speak in support of the ordinance.
37:01 I respect the work of Almas, Alliance of Latinos motivating action in the suburbs, and their due diligence with other community members to work with the city of Naperville to bring the ordinance forward.
37:16 I'm here to emphasize the importance of education and coalition building in defense of immigrants and others under assault by Homeland Security and ICE.
37:27 I believe that Native Americans, immigrants from around the world, and black workers in particular, are the heartbeat of our nation and the U.S.
37:37 working class that built this country and continue to labor for its unity and continuity against many odds.
37:47 I want to focus on the ordinances where as is five and six and their vital importance for today's movements for social change, building confidence in youth and the working class, while continuing to insist and persist on the responsibility and accountability of elected officials.
38:11 I'm going to skip to just the first amendment because I look at time is running out.
38:16 First Amendment, freedom of religion, speech, and the press, the right of assembly and petition.
38:23 In Minneapolis, you will recall Homeland Security violated the right to express political dissent without fear of government retaliation when ICE murdered Renee Good and Alex Creti.
38:36 When immigrant defenders protested in the city, it was occupied by federal agents, troops, and they were expelled only after community groups organized a general strike with labor.
38:52 Leftists and others with skills of organizing resistance are targeted as anti-American, anti-capitalist, and anti-Christian, whether they hold those beliefs or not.
39:04 So I'm here to speak in my last 35 seconds in defense of the First Amendment, the right to assembly, and the part the um this the second, the whereas I spoke to on the accountability and responsibility of our city officials.
39:22 I think this will help, and I'm hope the ordinance will also set an example for the public schools, public libraries, public residences, that they too should look at their space and um what they want to do.
39:38 So thank you for considering this, and you all have a good evening.
39:46 The next speakers are Ashna Sarah Haviz, followed by Jesse Evangeline Topete and Lauren Raise You.
39:56 My name is Ashna, and I'm a born and raised Naperville resident.
40:00 I attended Kingsley Elementary, Madison Junior High, and then graduated from NCHS.
40:05 I then went to NIU and then the University of Kansas, where I received my master's in social work, only to come back home to Naperville because I wanted to work and give back to my own community.
40:15 In addition to being here tonight, because Naperville is my home, I am also proud to be part of the team at Southwest Suburban Immigrant Project.
40:23 We are a nonprofit community-based organization that has been protecting and advancing immigrant rights for over 16 years.
40:31 In 2010, together with Mayor Pradle, SSIP hosted its first annual event here in downtown Naperville called Day of the Immigrant, where we celebrated diversity and the contributions of immigrants to the Southwest suburbs.
40:44 It was clear then, as it is clear tonight, that immigrants, like my own parents who immigrated here from Bangladesh in 1979, make our communities beautiful and strong.
40:55 I have never spoken at a city council meeting before, but this conviction brings me here today.
41:01 And because I have been deeply concerned about the unlawful presence of ICE in our community.
41:06 In my drive to work, I very often hear reports of honest, hardworking people, whether local or passing through, being targeted by ICE enforcement.
41:15 My team at SSIP is constantly fielding calls and working with families who are experiencing detention and deportation.
41:23 Trust and clarity encourages people to access vital everyday spaces, request important services, report crimes, and participate in civic life without fear.
41:33 It also allows city employees and workers to feel more empowered and ready to act accordingly with Naperville's values if and when incidents inevitably occur.
41:43 The city of Naperville is able to make a choice tonight that will send a loud and resounding message to us and everyone who knows Naperville.
41:51 We are a city that reflects the values of inclusion, dignity, and respect for all community members who live here.
41:58 And I very much want it to continue to be that way.
42:02 As a lifelong Naperville resident, I urge you to vote yes today on this ordinance.
42:08 Thank you for your time and consideration.
42:12 The next speaker is Jesse, followed by Evangeline Topete.
42:21 Good evening, Mayor, Council members, and fellow residents.
42:24 My name is Jesse Gutierrez.
42:26 I'm a candidate for DePage County Board, District 6.
42:30 I'm also a veteran of the U.S.
42:32 Navy and a resident of West Chicago.
42:35 However, I'm here tonight in support of the proposed due process and municipal property ordinance.
42:41 At its core, this ordinance is not about politics.
42:45 It's about the fundamental American principle that every person deserves due process under the law.
42:52 Our constitution guarantees that government action should be guided by fairness, accountability, and respect for individual rights.
43:00 Those values are not partisan.
43:04 Naperville has long prided itself on being a welcoming, safe, and inclusive community.
43:10 You are a city made stronger by people from diverse backgrounds who contribute every day as neighbors, business owners, workers, parents, and volunteers.
43:20 This ordinance reinforces the idea that local governments should focus on serving all residents while respecting the legal protections that our country was founded on.
43:29 The proposal also provides clarity regarding the use of municipal resources and property.
43:35 Taxpayer-funded local government should remain focused on local priorities, public safety, infrastructure, economic development, and quality of life.
43:44 Establishing clear policies helps ensure that city personnel can carry out their responsibilities consistently and transparently.
43:52 Importantly, trust between residents and local government is essential to public safety.
43:58 Communities are strongest when people feel comfortable reporting crimes, cooperating with law enforcement and participating in civic life without fear or uncertainty.
44:08 Policies that straightened that strengthen that trust ultimately benefit everyone who calls Naperville home.
44:16 Reasonable people may have different opinions on immigration policy at the federal level.
44:22 However, the discussion tonight is about what kind of community Naperville wants to be.
44:27 What kind of leader Naperville wants to be?
44:30 I believe Naperville, Naperville should continue to be a community that values due process, transparency, accountability, and respect for the rule of law.
44:38 I encourage the council to move forward and demonstrate Naperville's commitment to those principles.
45:02 My family has long, long roots here in America.
45:09 We didn't cross the border, the border crossed us.
45:17 The next speaker is Evangeline Chopete, followed by Lauren Reis Yu, Marilyn Schweitzer, and Luke Galloway.
45:23 And if you've heard your name called, please move to the front row.
45:27 Good evening, Mayor and City Council members.
45:30 My name is Evangeline Topete, and I am a high school student engaged locally in Naperville and the surrounding suburbs.
45:36 And tonight I'm speaking on behalf of the Alliance of Latinos Motivating Action in the Suburbs, Almas.
45:42 A couple weeks ago, I had the privilege of stepping into this building alongside Mayor Worley, members of Almas, and fellow young people for a grand capstone ceremony.
45:51 As I sat in these seats behind me and saw the intermingling between city officials and the next generation of Naperville residents, parents, professors, entrepreneurs, and perhaps even officials, I felt not only profound gratitude, but also inspiration.
46:07 Because every time a young person gets to see public policy in action, it ensures that our voices are heard and included.
46:15 This past year, my AP English class had an assignment to write an open letter.
46:20 And with that came the opportunity to ask questions of our local officials.
46:24 What struck me was how many of my peers kept asking the same question.
46:28 What does our local government do?
46:31 And how does it impact me?
46:34 This ordinance is a firm answer to that question.
46:37 It demonstrates how the leaders that residents, families, and young people look up to can bridge the gap between policy and implementation, ensuring we not only understand what happens in these rooms, but how it carries forward when we go home.
46:54 Some have asked whether a formal ordinance is still needed when training and administrative guidance already exist.
47:01 As a young person, I say yes, because policy creates the standard that said guidance is built on.
47:09 Clear, formal policy is what ensures transparency, consistency, and accountability across administrations and over time.
47:19 As someone constantly confronted with perspectives that often lack accuracy and consistency, I can confidently say that these conversations matter because they shape how my peers and I understand civic engagement.
47:34 For we are paying attention.
47:37 To support this ordinance is to show young people everywhere that you are listening and that you care about how we carry these cities' values forward.
47:47 On behalf of this community and the next generation, I respectfully urge you to adopt the ordinance and continue supporting communication, training, public education, implementation guidance, and community engagement alongside it.
48:05 The next speaker is Lauren Reis Yu, followed by Marilyn Schweitzer.
48:12 The next speaker is Marilyn Schweitzer, followed by Luke Galloway.
48:16 Okay, so to be clear, I'm Marilyn Schweitzer.
48:20 Community trust matters.
48:22 Community trust is key to public safety.
48:25 Former police chief Dial brought community policing to Naperville in the 1990s.
48:31 That philosophy recognizes that police departments need to develop relationships with the citizens they serve.
48:38 The police simply cannot create effective, efficient public safety operations on their own.
48:44 Having the trust of the community is key.
48:48 Immigration and custom enforcement recruitment materials have created the perception of imagery and rhetoric associated with white supremacy ideology.
48:57 Whether inadvertent or not, these materials have contributed to an environment in which bias-motivated violence becomes more likely endangering the public, ICE personnel, and local law enforcement.
49:11 To be clear, this bias can operate in both directions.
49:14 It can be used to justify actions against non-white individuals and to justify actions against law enforcement at any level.
49:22 Compounding these concerns are reports and documented instances of inadequate warns and the lack of due process in enforcement actions.
49:31 None of this contributes to the safety of our community.
49:36 I recognize fully the difficulty municipalities have in addressing these perceptions and their repercussions.
49:42 However, I support the proposed Naperville due process and municipality property ordinance as one step our community can take to affirm our values, establish clear administrative procedures, and collect data.
49:58 I appreciate the support the ordinance has received, and I also welcome thoughtful discussion of other approaches that could help restore trust and reduce threats to public safety.
50:09 Thank you very much.
50:12 The final speaker is Luke Galloway.
50:17 Hello, Neighborville City Council.
50:19 I want to speak in support of the passage of the Naperville due process and municipal property ordinance, which the community has been advocating for.
50:26 I'm not from Naperville, however, I'm close with many affected community members.
50:30 I support and serve within community organizations, and I'm a conscientious member of the public and state university student here to empower you as city council members to do the right thing.
50:39 I prepared a statement for you tonight.
50:41 The passage of Agenda Item 26-0673 will signify that the city supports all residents, regardless of their status in this country.
50:49 We've all seen the unjustifiable, unconscionable, and aggressive actions of unaccountable external actors occurring across our state.
50:57 People are organizing for their safety.
50:59 Your obligation as a city council member of any city council is to the public you serve, which is why you should vote yes on passing the ordinance.
51:07 This is a matter of public safety.
51:09 I've heard some of the opposition from the first reading, and I would like to advise those who are opposed that this is not a political statement, but a public, practical, and existential affirmation of the community we're all working to uphold.
51:21 And if the city council refuses to act, it would lower public safety.
51:25 As city council members and community leaders and council members, all of us in this room are community leaders.
51:30 We have an obligation to the public and our public advocacy organizations.
51:34 Their voices often represent a much wider shared sentiment.
51:37 This is a welcoming community, one which acknowledges that we stand with all community members and that all community members contribute to making the city great.
51:44 The people who share their culture and make the city more vibrant, the people who serve in the city's workforce, the people constructing roofs in residential areas.
51:52 What we should not welcome or acquiesce to or allow to be staged on our streets, using city property is aggression and intolerance.
51:59 With what I've said standing at this podium, and with what I said in my stronger written comment and consideration, I truly think that each of you wants what is best for the city.
52:09 The conversation appears to be centered around whether existing state policy is enough.
52:12 I feel that given the enforcement realities, we should strive for instructive protections.
52:16 The way to be part of that vision is supporting this ordinance.
52:19 The public will remember those who stood up in solidarity, and the public will remember those who were scared and chose to hesitate on endorsing safety, sanctity, and human dignity.
52:29 Please vote accordingly.
52:35 Councilman White, I'd like to get a motion and a second, and then we'll open up discussion on the ordinance.
52:48 Mayor move to pass due process and municipal property ordinance.
52:54 We have a motion and a second.
52:56 Is there any discussion?
53:05 So we all know how the vote is going on this, so we should have some final comments because I've been very vocal on it.
53:14 And um hopefully we can get back to actual city business soon.
53:18 Um, you know, first we should be honest about what's happening here.
53:22 Uh, we have a legal opinion, you can accept all of it or or none of it, um, but you can accept parts of it and not the conclusion.
53:31 And the conclusion of that legal opinion was that this ordinance is symbolic and declarative.
53:38 So, for being honest, that's what it is.
53:40 Um, it's political signaling.
53:44 And uh on a national issue from the dice, and we should just be all aware of what that precedent sets.
53:50 Um, you know, I want to also remind people that political signaling is not cost-free.
53:56 Uh, just to remind everyone, you know, it wasn't long ago that the political fashion was a lot of anti-police rhetoric.
54:04 Um, I know a lot of people want to memory hold that like it didn't happen, but it happened.
54:09 And a lot of that rhetoric was very inflammatory.
54:13 Um, you know, we were told police were such a problem that we needed laws to protect the public from the police.
54:20 Um, you know, we've we've we framed the police as bad guys, and that's had consequences.
54:25 Um, you know, when elected officials frame law enforcement as the enemy, what effect does that have on law enforcement encounters?
54:33 Does it increase tensions?
54:35 Does it lower tensions?
54:37 Does it make a tragedy more likely, less likely?
54:41 So look, my personal feelings.
54:44 You some of you might be surprised on my opinions on federal uh immigration policy.
54:50 Um, you know, politicians for decades have failed the country on this issue.
54:54 I think there's room for nuance and good faith disagreement on it, but I was not elected to codify my personal feelings into municipal declarations.
55:05 Um, and that's my concern.
55:06 I think some of my colleagues might be um being naive about the consequences, uh, that there aren't any.
55:13 Uh, this ordinance is built on the premise that federal immigration enforcement presents a unique threat to Naperville requiring a municipal response.
55:22 I disagree with that premise.
55:23 Um, you know, people have the right to hold that view, but if symbolic statements from elected officials matter, which a lot of supporters here believe they do, then we can't pretend those statements are consequence-free.
55:34 Uh when elected officials repeatedly uh categorize certain law enforcement agencies as something residents should fear, distrust becomes the predictable result.
55:46 And when you have distrust increase, the risk of confrontation increases with it.
55:52 And we've seen that.
55:53 We've seen the result of it.
55:54 I mean, we see it in real time.
55:55 We see it in our own town, we saw it last night.
55:58 Chief just talked about it.
56:00 Um, so there's a lot of downstream effects here that we could go on and on about.
56:04 This one probably bothers me the most.
56:06 Um, you know, if this ordinance contributes to making even one encounter uh more tense, uh more dangerous, more confrontational than you know, the consequences of the symbolic uh vote tonight are not symbolic.
56:22 Thank you, Councilman Halzar.
56:25 Um, definitely surprised to hear some of those comments from my colleague who was a reminder a year ago proposed a symbolic ordinance about immigration and then appeared on Fox News on a national platform to talk about this issue.
56:39 So he has either lost his memory or lost his mind.
56:43 Mayor, that's he's out of line.
56:46 That was that was that was not true.
56:48 Councilman, which county serious order, let's have a word.
56:54 You allowed that last year.
56:55 Councilman Hallzer, you're coming after me.
57:02 Can you complete your your statement?
57:05 So after that ridiculous trade last year, uh now we're all being lectured on this topic.
57:11 Um, as I stated before, this is a matter of a statement of our community's uh principles.
57:17 Um we see the constitution being violated in a system with separation of powers.
57:26 Uh it is important that to the maximum extent of the law, we state where our community stands, and uh when we see our residents um in harm's way, Naperville is gonna stand up for their rights.
57:43 Well, I want to begin with what isn't in question tonight, and that is that Naperville welcomes people, and it's the expectation that we treat everyone who lives here with respect.
57:54 That's who we are, and that's not what is on the table tonight.
57:58 What is on the table is whether this is a proposed ordinance that is good policy, and I don't think it is.
58:05 Let's start with what it does.
58:07 Our own professional staff told us this week that it doesn't stop a single federal agent from doing anything.
58:14 The ordinance sets up an internal process to write down when we notice our property being used in a certain way.
58:20 It carves out criminal enforcement and anything done with a warrant, and it says over and over again that we'll act only to the extent that the law allows.
58:30 The people who drafted it, they know that the law leaves us very little room.
58:34 So what we have in front of us is an ordinance that does almost nothing.
58:39 I also want to note how we got here.
58:41 This was largely a submitted ordinance, and our police department had little if any opportunity to weigh in on how it was put together.
58:49 So when we're talking about our own property and asking our officers and our employees to live with the result, the people who do this work every day should have a real seat at the table before it reaches us, not after.
59:03 That's my first problem.
59:05 We'd be passing something that sounds like it does a lot, and it does almost nothing.
58:59 People will not read the carve-outs.
59:12 They'll read the headline, and we'll have told them that the council acted when the council didn't change much of anything.
59:20 I don't like selling the public a gesture and calling it action.
59:25 And here's the part I can't get passed.
59:28 This ordinance reaches our parking lots, our buildings, our parks, and the rest of our facilities.
59:34 A person who served their time for a violent felony can walk into any of those spaces tomorrow.
59:42 They can park in our downtown deck, they can sit in our public buildings, and there is nothing we can do to stop them because it's public property and they have the right to be here.
59:52 A registered sex offenders free to use almost all that same property, too.
59:58 Illinois carved out one narrow exception, keeping child sex offenders out of parks, and even that took state criminal law and years of court fights to hold up.
1:00:07 Everywhere else this ordinance touches, they remain welcome.
1:00:11 So we can't keep a convicted violent felon or a registered sex offender out of our own public property, but tonight we're telling people we can keep out a federal officer whose authority the Constitution itself places above ours.
1:00:27 The supremacy clause isn't a technicality.
1:00:31 It's a reason this ordinance is written full of except when the law says otherwise clauses.
1:00:38 And let me say a word about the agency behind this.
1:00:40 This ordinance never names it, it just refers to civil immigration enforcement.
1:00:45 But the agency that does that work is ICE, and ICE does far more than immigration.
1:00:50 It's investigative arm, Homeland Security Investigations, or HSI, works some of the darkest cases in law enforcement.
1:00:58 Child pornography, the sexual exploitation and trafficking of children, the predators who hunt our kids online.
1:01:05 HSI also breaks up of the fraud rings that drain our seniors' savings, the work that happens right here in Naperville and across DuPage and Will Counties, often without word to our police department.
1:01:16 So this is not an agency doing, this is one agency that's doing very different things, and someone standing in a parking lot has no way to tell which one is in front of them.
1:01:28 Think about what we're asking of our own people.
1:01:30 What they do or don't do in that moment, somebody is going to be unhappy with them, and they'll be the ones standing there to take it.
1:01:37 That's not fair to hand them, and it isn't their job.
1:01:41 So this isn't about immigration, and it isn't about taking sides.
1:01:44 It's about whether we pass laws that do real things or laws that just make a statement.
1:01:50 And I'd rather tell our residents the truth and lose the headline than pass something hollow and try to call it leadership.
1:01:57 So that's where I am, and I'll be voting no on this ordinance tonight.
1:02:01 Councilman White.
1:02:04 Yeah, I'm, you know, I'm hearing a lot of, you know, angst against this not from the uh audience here.
1:02:14 Um but just to be clear, I mean, this doesn't surpass any federal authority.
1:02:21 The federal government can do what they're allowed to do.
1:02:24 So it's not doing that, does not have our local law enforcement confronting federal agents.
1:02:35 Basically, we are recording what we anticipate or what we may think may be violating the ordinance.
1:02:44 What is the worst thing that can happen?
1:02:46 Well, maybe it wasn't uh immigration enforcement authorities there, so we were wrong.
1:02:54 As I look at this, that's about the worst that can happen to this.
1:02:59 I just don't think that we're I I don't sound like we're we're sounding the alarms, and I just don't think uh those alarms uh it just doesn't warrant it.
1:03:09 Um again, we we will record what we see.
1:03:14 Any employee can do it, can do that, and they should do that, and then I'll the city manager and they will work out those particular uh policies within those departments and how that can be done.
1:03:24 I just don't see that being the issue, being a major issue.
1:03:29 I think Maryland, uh Marilyn, you you nailed it, okay?
1:03:29 This all comes down to trust.
1:03:35 As we talk about our law enforcement, we have the greatest, and I'm not even exaggerating, the greatest law enforcement public safety folks in this country.
1:03:45 Chief, uh I tell you that all the time.
1:03:47 Uh Chief Pugnitis, same thing.
1:03:50 Okay, but folks understand this.
1:03:52 Our police, our public safety, they respond to what's has already happened.
1:03:58 90% of the calls that they go on, they're responding to what has already occurred.
1:04:05 Okay, what makes Naperville the safest city in America is our community, our values, the trust that Marilyn talked about that's built within our community because we we talk to each other.
1:04:20 We report things when we see them.
1:04:22 When we break down that trust, that's when you're going to, in my opinion, when we'll start seeing issues when it comes to public safety, because you all are the ones who are reporting these things, and this really falls right in line with that.
1:04:35 So I will be supporting this ordinance because I think it addresses those particular uh things that I mentioned.
1:04:47 I think the discussion up here on the dais is a reflection of the arguments that are happening across our nation, and all of that is due to our varied lived experiences.
1:05:00 I think you might perceive this as not holding value if you live a life where this hasn't threatened your livelihood or your day-to-day living.
1:05:12 However, if you do come from a community where recent behavior has made you question whether you should leave your home, what type of documentation you should carry, which members of this dais have already revealed that they are con they they have to question and think about, then only then can you truly appreciate the value of this ordinance?
1:05:36 This ordinance is not merely symbolic, it is symbolic.
1:05:41 It does reaffirm our commitment to due process and the constitution.
1:05:45 It is sending a clear message that all of our residents are valued and respected and have a right to feel safe.
1:05:52 But it is also concrete and based on data and facts.
1:05:55 In speaking with the chief um a few weeks ago or a month ago, I can't remember, many months ago, actually, he shared that once upon a time, federal agencies would give our police officers a heads up that they would be arriving here.
1:06:12 That's not happening anymore.
1:06:15 Things have changed, our community is telling us that they do not feel safe.
1:06:21 This ordinance is in response to clearly communicate that they belong.
1:06:26 Yes, that's symbolic, but also concretely, we are asking for documentation.
1:06:32 We are asking our staff to come up with what's the appropriate sustainable procedure to make those documentations.
1:06:40 So to me, having come from an immigrant family, having that unique lived experience, I hold value in this.
1:06:50 When I hear this, it has value.
1:06:53 I can I can see why someone may not see that, but it's equally important for them to understand that our lived experience shape our perception of how we value this ordinance, and that's why I'll be supporting it.
1:07:08 Alright, we have a motion on a second on L1.
1:07:25 Motion passes 6-2.
1:07:29 I am M1 is a recommendation to approve the cooperative procurement for two IBM Maximo to Starboard Consulting for an amount not to exceed 1,240,934 and forty thousand nine hundred and thirty-four dollars and twelve cents for a three-year term.
1:07:42 There is one speaker, John Doyle.
1:07:50 Alright, John Doyle, Naperville resident, thank you.
1:07:53 Uh what's on the screen is an excerpt from the background section of this agenda item uh where the staff has named a few specific utilities that use this software and use that as justification for moving forward.
1:08:03 Uh when I saw that list, I'll be honest, I just just couldn't help myself.
1:07:59 So let's go through some other things these utilities are doing.
1:08:11 Uh Denton municipal, their purchase power portfolio is 100% renewable thanks to a climate plan they adopted in 2018, and they run a declining block rate with a seasonal differential.
1:08:24 City of Lakeland actually offers three different rate structures depending on what's best suits you a three-tier inclining block rate, a time of use rate, and a peak demand rate.
1:08:36 Kansas City BPU is 48% renewable and like Denton, they've run a seasonal differential and declining block rate.
1:08:44 And lastly, Austin.
1:08:46 Uh widely recognized as the gold standard for municipal rate design.
1:08:50 They have a four-tier inclining block rate.
1:08:52 World class affordability program funded by a customer assistance surcharge.
1:08:57 They have an energy efficiency surcharge that funds all of their sustainability grants.
1:09:05 So they let their customers pay an extra surcharge to send a hundred percent of their bill to a wind farm instead.
1:09:13 Somehow they managed to all do this while having significantly lower median household incomes and significantly higher poverty rates than we do, and none of them are members of full requirement joint action agencies.
1:09:26 So, yes, please continue looking at these cities, especially Austin, as examples of mature proven solutions for municipal electric utilities, just like this problem that implementing IBM Maximo solves, all of our other problems have already been solved too.
1:09:40 We just need you to pick one.
1:09:46 Councilman White, may have a motion on M1.
1:09:50 I move to approve the award of cooperative procurement 26-129 IBM Maximo to Starboard Consulting for an amount not to exceed one million two hundred and forty thousand nine hundred and thirty-four dollars and twelve cents and for a three-year term.
1:10:05 Councilman Kelly, second Kelly.
1:10:07 We have motion and a second on M1.
1:10:11 Any discussion, Councilman Sayed?
1:10:14 Truly on the microphone.
1:10:26 Motion passes 80.
1:10:28 Councilman White.
1:10:30 I moved to approve the award of bid 26-079 fire station number four.
1:10:35 Improvements to Cando and construction incorporated for an amount not to exceed $2,898,000 plus a 3% contingency.
1:10:45 Councilman Kelly.
1:10:47 A motion and a second on M2.
1:11:00 Motion passes 80.
1:11:02 Councilman White.
1:11:04 I moved to approve the award of bid 26-007 2026 streets resurfacing program local to K5 Construction Corporation for an amount not to exceed $5,005.65 plus a 3% contingency.
1:11:23 Councilman Kelly.
1:11:25 We have a motion and a second on M3.
1:11:36 Motion passes eight zero.
1:11:38 Councilman White.
1:11:40 I move to approve the award of cooperative procurement 26-142.
1:11:44 VMware annual maintenance renewal to the redesign group for an amount not to exceed one million four hundred and forty-one thousand one hundred and seventy dollars and for a three-year term.
1:11:56 Councilman Kelly.
1:11:57 We have a motion and a second on M4.
1:12:11 Councilman White, M5.
1:12:13 I move to approve the award of cooperative procurement 26-131.
1:12:17 New and replacement personal computers to Amazon.com.
1:12:22 CDS Office Technologies and Insight Public Sell Sector for an amount not to exceed 1,190,675.
1:12:31 Councilman Kelly.
1:12:33 Motion and a second.
1:12:34 Councilman Eat Housear, did you have a question?
1:12:37 Thank you, Mayor.
1:12:38 Krieger, I was hoping that you could explain what the sort of bundling process is for when you have these these large procurements.
1:12:52 With the cooperative procurements, a um uh public entity um will uh enlist interest from others and open it up um to all vendors, uh, which typically because of the significance of the volumes, uh, the vendors are uh more likely to accept uh much lower margins, and that is where we see most of the value coming from our cooperative purchases.
1:13:18 And mayor could ask a follow up to that.
1:13:20 Yes, but just to put that in in sort of uh simple terms, um the typical bidder here is bundling services from a whole bunch of different vendors like Amazon CDW, all these others, correct?
1:13:33 Uh that that is correct.
1:13:34 Okay, and so um my uh feedback slash question would be in the future, is it possible to write these requests out to these um these bundlers, if you will, in a way to encourage them to use local companies in their bids as opposed to you know just shopping it out to Amazon nationally?
1:13:58 I know that when we do individual procurements, that's what we do, but is there a way that we could work that into the the procurement process in the future?
1:14:06 Krieger, um for uh for lower smaller bids, yes.
1:14:10 Um for the much larger kind of national bids, likely not, because um we do not uh set the specifications or requirements for the national ones.
1:14:20 Um but uh all of our staff for the low dollar bids um are encouraged to uh use local bidders.
1:14:27 Okay, thank you, Mr.
1:14:29 So we have a motion and a second on M5 roll call.
1:14:34 Orley, yes, Gibson, aye.
1:14:36 Jane, aye, Kelly, McBroom, aye.
1:14:41 Motion passes eight zero.
1:14:45 Our final item tonight is uh new business.
1:14:48 Is there a minor new businesses for items?
1:14:50 The council's asking staff to bring back on a future agenda or for motions to reconsider a past city council votes.
1:14:55 Does anybody have any new business?
1:14:57 Seeing none, may I have a motion to adjourn?
1:15:00 Motion to adjourn.
1:15:00 Second Kelly, all those in favor sign aye.
1:15:03 Opposed, motion passes eight zero.
1:15:05 We are adjourned, yes.