OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

20th Regular Meeting of the Metropolitan Council of Nashville – August 6, 2024

Metropolitan CouncilTuesday, August 6, 2024
BodyNashville, Tennessee
SessionMetropolitan Council
DateTuesday, August 6, 2024
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
0:03

Will the meeting please come to order?

0:05

Today is Tuesday, August 6th, 2024.

0:09

This is the 20th regular meeting of the current term of the Metropolitan Council of Nashville in Davidson County.

0:16

Will all members of the council, as well as the public, please rise for the invocation and remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:23

The invocation is being offered this evening by the Reverend Jonathan Trees.

0:28

He is the pastor of Grace Church of the Nazarene and the guest of District 15 Council member Jeff Gregg.

0:35

Uh your recognized Pastor Trees.

0:38

Let us pray together.

0:40

Almighty God, we thank you for creating each of us in this room.

0:43

Each of us are precious to you and have been created to fulfill your purpose through your calling.

0:50

And I thank you tonight for these your servants, our mayor, Vice Mayor Henderson, our civil leaders, as well as our city council members.

0:58

We thank you for the calling that you have given every one of them to be good stewards of creation, to assist and love the neighbor as ourselves and to govern others towards that end.

1:10

Thank you for the gift of city.

1:13

Thank you for this city of Nashville, whose rich history of river, rail, and interstate, interstate trade, education, revivalism, musical expression has made her successful for generations.

1:25

Thank you for the pioneers that she has fostered with freedom to dream, like the medical vision of Dr.

1:31

Keith Johnson, founder of DCI, or like those who here humbly assist the dreams of others through their council's directives.

1:39

Like King David prayed, may they defend the afflicted among the people, save the children of the needy.

1:44

May you offer these leaders through their portion of power, the gifts to bless the city.

1:50

And like the prophet Jeremiah, that your blessing accompany kings who defend the rights of the poor and the needy.

1:56

Like your servant Joseph, ruler of Egypt, grant to them the leadership towards prosperity and wisdom pertaining to resources.

2:04

And like the Amaya, allow the deeds to construct a functional structure of safety and provision.

2:11

Like the Apostle Paul, may we realize that we are to cherish government and respect its leadership.

2:17

Like the ruler Esther, may your leadership notice the gaps and surrender to sacrifices that accompany such a standard of leadership.

2:25

And like Ruth, may their motives derive from love and loyalty to blending community.

2:30

Like Solomon, may wisdom be their strength today that builds a city for future generations to enjoy.

2:37

We pray that we would have eyes to see how our lives reflect you when we are all working for common good to respond to those who are vulnerable among us, allowing your kingdom come in Nashville as it is in heaven.

2:50

And like Barnabas, son of encouragement, may we spur one another forward to unity through the sharing of our resources.

2:58

May Nashville be a place where the weak and the strong find the renewal of spirit.

3:03

And finally, I ask that you would protect these leaders and this city from the brokenness of classism, racism, and violence, that she may reflect the God of image, the God of love, the God of grace, the God of unity, and as we pursue peace with all, and as far as it depends on us, may we live at peace with everyone in Jesus' name, Amen.

3:28

Amen.

3:31

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.

5:00

The last day to register to vote in the November 5th election is October the 7th, and early voting will begin October 16th.

5:05

At our last meeting, this council voted unanimously to put the Choose How You Move Transportation Improvement Program on Nashville's November 5th ballot, and the election commission also affirmed that ballot language this week.

5:17

Tonight, this body will decide if that same ballot will also include charter amendments.

5:23

Today was the first day back to school for Metro Nashville schools.

5:27

So a special thank you to Nashville's teachers at all of our schools across the city and best wishes to those uh children and families.

5:35

It's an exciting and sometimes bittersweet and stressful time of year.

5:39

Uh back to school time is also road safety reminder time.

5:43

When we ask all Nashvilleans to renew their focus on safe driving.

5:47

If you're a driving parent late to school uh for drop-off or pickup, please don't speed through the neighborhood.

5:54

If traffic is backed up near your local school in the next few weeks, please do not honk and swerve and turn around in frustration.

6:02

Vehicles are increasingly bigger, taller, heavier, often purchased with the intent of protecting the young people inside them.

6:10

This has the very negative side effect of making the young people and all people outside of vehicles walking and biking, even more vulnerable and less safe.

6:21

We have school zones for a reason.

6:23

Slow down in them.

6:25

Observe crossings, stop for people in or at the edge of a crosswalk.

6:29

Whether you are on a two-lane or a four-lane road, never pass a car stopped at a crosswalk or a school bus along the road with its stop sign out.

6:40

We are all a part of a slowly improving transportation system.

6:44

Nashvilleans will have an opportunity in November to vote for dedicated funding to deliver the increased safety we all need, hopefully more quickly, consistently, and broadly.

6:54

People speeding and people driving distractedly kill people too often.

7:00

We've had several roadway fatalities in the last week here in Nashville, and we must never normalize these roadway fatalities or forget that we all have a crucial part to play in reducing them.

7:10

Slow down and keep your eyes on the road at all times so we can keep each other safe.

7:17

Lastly, this evening is the national night out against crime on the first Tuesday in August across the country.

7:24

This vent is always on a council meeting night.

7:26

Um so we are sorry to miss being with our communities and law enforcement officers and encourage you to connect with them and your neighbors and local businesses, building community and having more folks out, walking, biking, shopping, interacting, keeps eyes on the street and helps reduce crime in our community.

7:45

Without objection, uh we will suspend the calling of the roll and ask the Kirk to record the names of all members that are present throughout the meeting.

7:59

Okay, properly moved and seconded without objection.

8:02

The minutes of the meeting of July 16th are approved.

8:05

Uh, Mr.

8:06

Clerk, are there any messages from the mayor?

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Zoning and Land Use█████████████████████████25%
Procedural███████████████████████23%
Charter Amendments███████████████████████23%
Public Engagement████████8%
Public Safety███3%
Youth Programs███3%
Transportation Safety██2%
Community Engagement██2%
Education Funding██2%
Summary of Proceedings

20th Regular Meeting of the Metropolitan Council of Nashville and Davidson County – August 6, 2024

The Metropolitan Council met on Tuesday, August 6, 2024, for its 20th regular meeting. The meeting included a mayor's message on $149 million in tax anticipation notes, confirmations of board appointments, public comment, numerous zoning public hearings, debate on proposed charter amendments, and passage of several resolutions condemning hate and honoring community members. The meeting adjourned around 10:30 PM local time.

Consent Calendar

  • Approved resolutions RS 2024-611 through RS 2024-635 (except those pulled) and ordinances BL 2024-471, 473, 474, 475 on second reading, and BL 2024-391, 418, 419, 442–447 on third reading. Items were recommended unanimously by committees.
  • Confirmation of Arts Commission appointee Myra Yu and Procurement Standards Board appointee Kim Sampson passed (with one abstention on Yu).

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Alex Cohn (Jewish resident) spoke in support of Resolution 2024-638, condemning the verbal assault on children by a Nazi hate group, urging enforceable consequences.
  • Julie Coner (child of Holocaust survivors) spoke in support of the same resolution, emphasizing the need to stand against hate.
  • Nicole Williams supported charter amendment lowering the age to run for council, urging the council not to defer the work of the Charter Revision Committee.
  • Trent Benge (multimedia specialist) also supported lowering the age limit, arguing youth should have a voice in legislation.
  • Davy Tucker (MHRC) spoke in support of BL 2024-476, requesting annual council review of Metro Arts fund allocation criteria.
  • Pastor Derek Bozeman (Vice President of Nashville Peacemakers) thanked the council for the resolution on the Nazi incident and urged continued action to prevent conflict.
  • Herberto Sanchez (North Nashville resident) supported the resolution and suggested better police training and laws against terroristic hate groups.
  • Kevin Sis (property owner/developer) spoke in support of zoning changes at Pettus Road (BL 2023-56/57/58/59), noting 95% community support after extensive meetings.
  • Rose Schmillen, John Huckabee, Kendra Schinkel (residents of Warbler Way) opposed the same zoning changes, citing traffic, loss of open space, and lack of notification.
  • Craig Clark (architect, District 5) requested deferral of East Bank sub-district zoning (BL 2024-452) over concerns about building heights and floor plates.
  • Casey Keister (Meritage Homes) spoke in support of BL 2024-458/459 (Mount View Road development), citing community outreach and housing needs.
  • Residents Benita Payne and Daryl Polis opposed the same project, citing traffic and flooding concerns.
  • Cheryl Mays (School Board member) spoke in support of BL 2024-466, authorizing purchase of land for a new elementary school in Antioch, citing 115% capacity in elementary schools.

Discussion Items

  • Charter Amendments (RS 2024-599): The council debated three proposed charter amendments. After discussion:
    • Charter Amendment 1 (finance director succession) was amended with proposed amendment 2 (formatting and clarifying ballot language) and approved (27+ votes).
    • Charter Amendment 3 (lowering age to run for council from 25 to 18 via “qualified voter” language) was amended with proposed amendment 3 (formatting) but the amended charter amendment failed to reach 27 votes.
    • Charter Amendment 4 (no September council meetings) was approved (32 in favor, 6 against, 1 abstention) and added to the resolution.
    • The overall resolution, as amended with Amendments 1 and 4, was then deferred to January 20, 2026 (motion passed, simple majority).
  • Resolution 2024-637 (condemning attempted assassination of former President Trump and all political violence) passed after a substitute was introduced and approved.
  • Resolution 2024-638 (condemning July 2024 Nazi hate group verbal assault on children) passed unanimously with 31 co-sponsors and additional members added.
  • Resolution 2024-640 (honoring Randy Rayburn) passed with co-sponsors added.
  • Resolution 2024-644 (recognizing Roberts Western World's 25th anniversary) passed with co-sponsors.
  • BL 2024-466 (new elementary school in Antioch) passed second reading and was re-referred to committees for third reading.
  • Numerous zoning bills on second and third reading were approved, including BL 2023-56/57/58/59 (Pettus Road), BL 2024-448/449/450 (Hickory Hollow Mall redevelopment), BL 2024-452 (East Bank sub-district), BL 2024-458/459 (Mount View Road), and BL 2024-472 (easement abandonment).

Key Outcomes

  • Charter Amendment Resolution deferred: The overall resolution containing charter amendments on finance director vacancy and no September meetings was deferred to January 20, 2026.
  • Resolutions condemning hate and violence passed: RS 2024-638 (Nazi hate group) and RS 2024-637 (political violence) both adopted.
  • Board confirmations: Myra Yu (Arts Commission) and Kim Sampson (Procurement Standards Board) confirmed.
  • Zoning approvals: Several large-scale developments approved on second and third reading, including Pettus Road (230 multifamily units + fire station), Hickory Hollow Mall (mixed-use), and Mount View Road (92 single-family lots).
  • New elementary school in Antioch: Option agreements for land purchase approved; further committee review before final vote.
  • No September meetings charter amendment added to ballot measure before deferral: The amendment would have eliminated regularly scheduled September council meetings.
  • Late-filed resolution on political violence passed: Condemns all political violence and specifically the attempted assassination of former President Trump.

Meeting Transcript

Will the meeting please come to order? Today is Tuesday, August 6th, 2024. This is the 20th regular meeting of the current term of the Metropolitan Council of Nashville in Davidson County. Will all members of the council, as well as the public, please rise for the invocation and remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance. The invocation is being offered this evening by the Reverend Jonathan Trees. He is the pastor of Grace Church of the Nazarene and the guest of District 15 Council member Jeff Gregg. Uh your recognized Pastor Trees. Let us pray together. Almighty God, we thank you for creating each of us in this room. Each of us are precious to you and have been created to fulfill your purpose through your calling. And I thank you tonight for these your servants, our mayor, Vice Mayor Henderson, our civil leaders, as well as our city council members. We thank you for the calling that you have given every one of them to be good stewards of creation, to assist and love the neighbor as ourselves and to govern others towards that end. Thank you for the gift of city. Thank you for this city of Nashville, whose rich history of river, rail, and interstate, interstate trade, education, revivalism, musical expression has made her successful for generations. Thank you for the pioneers that she has fostered with freedom to dream, like the medical vision of Dr. Keith Johnson, founder of DCI, or like those who here humbly assist the dreams of others through their council's directives. Like King David prayed, may they defend the afflicted among the people, save the children of the needy. May you offer these leaders through their portion of power, the gifts to bless the city. And like the prophet Jeremiah, that your blessing accompany kings who defend the rights of the poor and the needy. Like your servant Joseph, ruler of Egypt, grant to them the leadership towards prosperity and wisdom pertaining to resources. And like the Amaya, allow the deeds to construct a functional structure of safety and provision. Like the Apostle Paul, may we realize that we are to cherish government and respect its leadership. Like the ruler Esther, may your leadership notice the gaps and surrender to sacrifices that accompany such a standard of leadership. And like Ruth, may their motives derive from love and loyalty to blending community. Like Solomon, may wisdom be their strength today that builds a city for future generations to enjoy. We pray that we would have eyes to see how our lives reflect you when we are all working for common good to respond to those who are vulnerable among us, allowing your kingdom come in Nashville as it is in heaven. And like Barnabas, son of encouragement, may we spur one another forward to unity through the sharing of our resources. May Nashville be a place where the weak and the strong find the renewal of spirit. And finally, I ask that you would protect these leaders and this city from the brokenness of classism, racism, and violence, that she may reflect the God of image, the God of love, the God of grace, the God of unity, and as we pursue peace with all, and as far as it depends on us, may we live at peace with everyone in Jesus' name, Amen. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. The last day to register to vote in the November 5th election is October the 7th, and early voting will begin October 16th. At our last meeting, this council voted unanimously to put the Choose How You Move Transportation Improvement Program on Nashville's November 5th ballot, and the election commission also affirmed that ballot language this week. Tonight, this body will decide if that same ballot will also include charter amendments. Today was the first day back to school for Metro Nashville schools. So a special thank you to Nashville's teachers at all of our schools across the city and best wishes to those uh children and families. It's an exciting and sometimes bittersweet and stressful time of year. Uh back to school time is also road safety reminder time. When we ask all Nashvilleans to renew their focus on safe driving. If you're a driving parent late to school uh for drop-off or pickup, please don't speed through the neighborhood. If traffic is backed up near your local school in the next few weeks, please do not honk and swerve and turn around in frustration. Vehicles are increasingly bigger, taller, heavier, often purchased with the intent of protecting the young people inside them. This has the very negative side effect of making the young people and all people outside of vehicles walking and biking, even more vulnerable and less safe. We have school zones for a reason. Slow down in them. Observe crossings, stop for people in or at the edge of a crosswalk. Whether you are on a two-lane or a four-lane road, never pass a car stopped at a crosswalk or a school bus along the road with its stop sign out. We are all a part of a slowly improving transportation system. Nashvilleans will have an opportunity in November to vote for dedicated funding to deliver the increased safety we all need, hopefully more quickly, consistently, and broadly. People speeding and people driving distractedly kill people too often.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com