OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Metropolitan Council Regular Meeting - September 3, 2024

Metropolitan CouncilTuesday, September 3, 2024
BodyNashville, Tennessee
SessionMetropolitan Council
DateTuesday, September 3, 2024
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
2:06

Uh differently off the start because we have a very special occasion to celebrate.

2:14

And so you can go ahead and get in the queue if you do have an announcement subsequent, and Pro Tem Suara will be back up here on the dais uh for your announcements.

2:24

Um, but uh to get started, um, we have a presentation of a proclamation.

2:31

I would ask all council members if you would please remain seated, and if Miss Roseanne Hayes Shacklet and her family and our uh staff would come to the podium.

2:53

So uh council members, if council members, if you will please stay in your seats, and our staff is gonna our staff is gonna circle around Miss Rosie, um, as is her family.

3:12

And then we'll have a photo opportunity afterwards, okay.

3:16

So, Miss Rosie, you just go ahead and come and stand at the podium because you are you are the star.

3:22

Okay.

4:43

Staff, colleagues, and members of council hold Rosie in high esteem due to her work ethic, her willingness to help everyone, and her longstanding commitment to public service.

5:00

And whereas Rosie is known for her positivity and dedication, she is a consummate professional and an exemplary mother, wife, sister, friend, mentor, and chief of staff.

5:06

And whereas this milestone is not just a testament to her dedication to public service, but also a reflection of the impact that she has had on our community.

5:16

And whereas Rosie's institutional knowledge of Metro Council and Metro government is unparalleled, and some of her stories would make a very good read.

5:26

And whereas it is fitting and proper that the Metropolitan Council extends to Rosie our sincere and grateful appreciation for her dedicated commitment to the Metro Council office and to the citizens of Nashville and Davidson County.

5:41

We celebrate her incredible legacy and look forward to many more years of public service.

5:46

Now, therefore, we, the undersigned council members, and the vice mayor of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County do hereby recognize and congratulate Roseanne Hayes Shacklet on 50 years of public service and wish her continued success, happiness, and good health in the years to come.

6:06

Members, please rise and congratulate Ms.

6:25

Rose.

6:27

Rosie, Rosie.

6:36

If you would like to say anything, and then and then if you'll come down front, we'll kind of do a presentation and photograph with everybody.

6:43

So please go ahead.

6:49

Thank you so much.

6:50

I there's not enough words I can say that I'm so appreciative of I can't talk, but everything that y'all have done for me this last 50 years and um the weekend has been tremendous with my daughter and my husband and all of the people that attended our party.

7:10

Uh uh thank you.

7:11

Um, and the ones that couldn't, I thank you for being a part of it anyway.

7:15

But thank you for everything you've done for me, and thank you for this evening, and I appreciate you all and uh y'all are uh my family friends, and I want to continue that for a long time.

7:27

Thank you so much.

7:33

Members, council members.

7:37

So, council members, if you will all please remain at your desk but turn forward in this room.

7:43

The Metro Photographer is gonna come up here and we're gonna um uh take a picture with Ms.

7:50

Hayes, and he's gonna use his wide angle lens to get all of y'all honoring Ms.

7:56

Hayes.

7:57

Miss Hayes Shackleth.

9:18

Okay, I'm gonna hand the mic back over to uh Pro Tim Swara, um, who has served so capably in this first year.

9:26

Want to express my gratitude to her again.

9:29

Um, and she is gonna uh uh conclude uh the announcements because she won't be with us, I don't think next week.

9:37

So um, and soon we will have a new pro Tim.

9:40

Um but with that um uh please uh stay in place and we'll continue with the announcements in just one minute.

10:12

Oh, that's beautiful.

10:21

All right, thank you, Vice Mayor.

10:25

Councilmember Druffle.

10:29

Recognized.

10:30

Yeah, thanks, Chair.

10:31

Uh we are going to be having a district 23 uh community meeting this Thursday at 6:30 at Brook Hall of Baptist.

10:38

Uh, we're gonna be discussing the transit plan, uh the Brook Hollow uh traffic calming project, uh property taxes next year, and several other things.

10:47

I appreciate you coming.

10:48

Thanks so much.

10:49

Thank you.

10:51

Councilmember Ewing.

10:54

Thank you, Pro Tem.

10:56

Um, I wanted to uh give notice of something a little bit far in advance.

11:02

On Friday, September 27th at 6:30 in Polk Theater at T Pack.

11:07

There will be a show put on by Friends Life Community.

11:11

They support individuals with developmental disabilities and their families in Davidson County.

11:17

This was a production that has been worked on very diligently and with passion by the folks at Friends Life.

11:26

And I encourage everyone to check out the link on T Pac's website and try and make it to this performance.

11:34

It's uh it will bring the audience through a journey of better understanding the personal perspective of the artists with disabilities, while also realizing that they have the same story, but just maybe with a few different details.

11:48

So thanks.

11:49

Thank you.

11:52

Councilmember Bull.

11:54

Thank you, Pro Tim.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural█████████████████████████████████████████████46%
Public Safety████████████████16%
Zoning and Land Use█████████████13%
Public Engagement█████████9%
Environmental Protection████4%
Racial Equity███3%
Budget and Oversight███3%
Personnel Matters██2%
Community Engagement1%
Summary of Proceedings

Metropolitan Council Regular Meeting - September 3, 2024

The Metropolitan Council met on Tuesday, September 3, 2024, at 6:30 PM in the Metropolitan Courthouse with 39 members present (2 absent). The meeting featured a celebration of chief of staff Rosanne Shacklet's 50 years of public service, a rule amendment to restrict public comment to Tennessee residents, public hearings on multiple zoning items, and votes on contentious legislation regarding police department operations.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes of August 20, 2024 were approved.
  • Appointments confirmed unanimously: Jilah Kalil and Shawn Knight (Arts Commission), Patricia Tarquino (Farmers Market Board), David Esquivel (Hospital Authority Board), Dr. Sybrill Brown and Derrick Free (Tourism and Convention Commission). Several other appointments were deferred.
  • The consent agenda (resolutions and ordinances with unanimous committee approval) was adopted by a vote of 36-0-0, including resolutions supporting Athletes Unlimited basketball, library grants, property damage settlements, and multiple infrastructure ordinances.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Robert Wincoop spoke in opposition to BL2024-511 (buffer zones around public buildings), arguing the 1960 civil rights march to City Hall would have violated such a buffer.
  • Jennifer Challos, Executive Director of Cumberland Region Tomorrow, invited council members to the Power of Ten Summit on September 17 and urged support for the upcoming TIP vote on mobility.

Discussion Items

  • Rule 28.1 Amendment (Sponsor: Suara): A substitute was adopted requiring public comment speakers to be Tennessee residents, with an expanded list of acceptable identification. Approved by voice vote with Councilmember Nash voting no; effective in 30 days.
  • BL2024-469 (Police Department Operations, Sponsor: Preptit): After extensive debate, a substitute bill prohibiting Metro public safety employees from participating in hate groups or paramilitary organizations was adopted (voice vote, one no). The bill as substituted then passed first reading by voice majority, moving to committee.
  • BL2024-441 (Algae, Moss, Mildew, Lichen, Fungus, Sponsor: Styles): An amendment was adopted requiring at least 25% algae coverage on a wall for a violation, exempting roofs, and providing resources for seniors/disabled via updated codes abatement letters. The bill as amended was deferred two meetings on a motion by Councilmember Evans-Segall (voice vote).
  • BL2024-458/459 (Mt. View Road SP, Sponsor: Harrell): A late amendment to add a traffic study for an adjacent road was allowed (rules suspended despite committee disapproval), and the bills passed third reading 35-0-0, permitting 92 single-family lots.
  • RS2024-686 (Military training at County Hospital Road): Deferred two meetings to October 1 after Councilmember Kimbrough requested time to inform the Bordeaux community about helicopter exercises.
  • BL2024-486/487 (Ewing Drive SP): Deferred to October 1 public hearing.
  • BL2024-545 (32nd Avenue North zoning): Indefinitely deferred by sponsor.

Key Outcomes

  • Rule 28.1 amended to require Tennessee residency for public comment.
  • BL2024-469 (hate group prohibition for public safety employees) passed first reading and proceeds to committee.
  • BL2024-441 (algae regulation) deferred two meetings.
  • BL2024-458/459 approved on third reading (92 single-family lots at Mt. View Road).
  • Public hearings completed and bills passed second reading for: Gallatin Pike UDO cancellation (BL2024-483), Burkitt Rd SP (BL2024-484/485), Bethwood Dr adjustments (BL2024-488/489), Old Hickory Blvd SP (BL2024-490), Arthur Ave rezoning (BL2024-491), Ewing Dr RM2 (BL2024-492), Bianca Paige Way SP (BL2024-493/494).
  • RS2024-693 (MNPD access to financial database) approved 35-3-0.
  • RS2024-701 (55th Nashville Film Festival) adopted with all voting yes as cosponsors.
  • Nominations for President Pro Tempore: Councilmember Bradford (nominated by Huffman) and Councilmember Sepulveda (nominated by Toombs); election set for September 17.

Meeting Transcript

Uh differently off the start because we have a very special occasion to celebrate. And so you can go ahead and get in the queue if you do have an announcement subsequent, and Pro Tem Suara will be back up here on the dais uh for your announcements. Um, but uh to get started, um, we have a presentation of a proclamation. I would ask all council members if you would please remain seated, and if Miss Roseanne Hayes Shacklet and her family and our uh staff would come to the podium. So uh council members, if council members, if you will please stay in your seats, and our staff is gonna our staff is gonna circle around Miss Rosie, um, as is her family. And then we'll have a photo opportunity afterwards, okay. So, Miss Rosie, you just go ahead and come and stand at the podium because you are you are the star. Okay. Staff, colleagues, and members of council hold Rosie in high esteem due to her work ethic, her willingness to help everyone, and her longstanding commitment to public service. And whereas Rosie is known for her positivity and dedication, she is a consummate professional and an exemplary mother, wife, sister, friend, mentor, and chief of staff. And whereas this milestone is not just a testament to her dedication to public service, but also a reflection of the impact that she has had on our community. And whereas Rosie's institutional knowledge of Metro Council and Metro government is unparalleled, and some of her stories would make a very good read. And whereas it is fitting and proper that the Metropolitan Council extends to Rosie our sincere and grateful appreciation for her dedicated commitment to the Metro Council office and to the citizens of Nashville and Davidson County. We celebrate her incredible legacy and look forward to many more years of public service. Now, therefore, we, the undersigned council members, and the vice mayor of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County do hereby recognize and congratulate Roseanne Hayes Shacklet on 50 years of public service and wish her continued success, happiness, and good health in the years to come. Members, please rise and congratulate Ms. Rose. Rosie, Rosie. If you would like to say anything, and then and then if you'll come down front, we'll kind of do a presentation and photograph with everybody. So please go ahead. Thank you so much. I there's not enough words I can say that I'm so appreciative of I can't talk, but everything that y'all have done for me this last 50 years and um the weekend has been tremendous with my daughter and my husband and all of the people that attended our party. Uh uh thank you. Um, and the ones that couldn't, I thank you for being a part of it anyway. But thank you for everything you've done for me, and thank you for this evening, and I appreciate you all and uh y'all are uh my family friends, and I want to continue that for a long time. Thank you so much. Members, council members. So, council members, if you will all please remain at your desk but turn forward in this room. The Metro Photographer is gonna come up here and we're gonna um uh take a picture with Ms. Hayes, and he's gonna use his wide angle lens to get all of y'all honoring Ms. Hayes. Miss Hayes Shackleth. Okay, I'm gonna hand the mic back over to uh Pro Tim Swara, um, who has served so capably in this first year. Want to express my gratitude to her again. Um, and she is gonna uh uh conclude uh the announcements because she won't be with us, I don't think next week. So um, and soon we will have a new pro Tim. Um but with that um uh please uh stay in place and we'll continue with the announcements in just one minute. Oh, that's beautiful. All right, thank you, Vice Mayor. Councilmember Druffle. Recognized. Yeah, thanks, Chair. Uh we are going to be having a district 23 uh community meeting this Thursday at 6:30 at Brook Hall of Baptist. Uh, we're gonna be discussing the transit plan, uh the Brook Hollow uh traffic calming project, uh property taxes next year, and several other things. I appreciate you coming. Thanks so much. Thank you. Councilmember Ewing. Thank you, Pro Tem. Um, I wanted to uh give notice of something a little bit far in advance.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com