OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Nashville Metro Council Meeting - October 15, 2024

Metropolitan CouncilTuesday, October 15, 2024
BodyNashville, Tennessee
SessionMetropolitan Council
DateTuesday, October 15, 2024
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

House Conference on Citizen Diplomacy seeks to foster friendship and understanding between the United States and other nations through person to person diplomacy and the celebration of cultural diversity and whereas in alignment with this vision, the citizens of Nashville, Tennessee, and Kamakura, Japan, have committed to working together to cultivate mutual understanding and ensuring the future peace and freedom through the creation of global friendships, and whereas in recognition of Nashville's growing importance to the presence of Japanese businesses in our region, the Japanese government relocated the consulate from New Orleans to Nashville in 2008.

0:44

And whereas one of the primary goals of the first Consul General of Japan in Nashville, the Honorable Hiroshi Sato, was to establish a sister city relationship between Japan and Nashville to foster cultural exchanges.

1:00

And whereas between 2008 and 2014, several cultural and business leadership exchanges took place between Nashville and Kamakura, the hometown of Consul General Sato, and whereas Kamakura became Nashville's eighth sister city in September of 2014 at a signing ceremony in Komakura between Carl Dean, mayor of Nashville, and Takashi Matsuo, mayor of Kamakura, attended by Nashville and Kamakura leaders, and whereas since Nashville and Kamakura city partnership was formulated.

1:46

Thereby enhancing mutual respect and understanding between the two cities.

1:50

And whereas the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County through the Metropolitan Council officially recognizes and supports this ongoing partnership with the aspiration that it will continue to strengthen and foster lasting friendships between the citizens of Nashville and Kamakuta while encouraging cooperative across various sectors, including music, culture, the arts, education, and governance.

2:11

Now, therefore, may it be resolved by the council of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County.

2:18

Yay.

2:22

And I'd love to bring up Mina Johnson, who is the current uh board president of Sister Cities of Nashville to say a few words.

2:34

Thank you, Councilman Babo, and thank you, uh Suara, and thank you, Council Lady Awena.

2:40

And I am so excited to take uh this council member with me to Kamakura this Saturday.

2:46

And Councilmember and Madame Pro Tem, thank you very much for the recognition and continuous support.

2:52

And many council members I know are interested to joining uh Kamakura.

2:57

So I'm sorry you cannot come this time, but please join next time.

3:01

I'm looking forward to showing around.

3:03

Thank you again.

3:04

Appreciate it.

3:05

Thank you.

3:07

All right.

3:10

All right.

3:11

Um, if there are any council members who have any announcements, please start getting in the queue.

3:20

Are you able to get in the queue?

3:21

No.

3:22

All right.

3:22

So we're raising hands.

3:23

First one up is Councilmember Preptee.

3:29

Uh Councilmember Prepti, you are recognized.

3:31

Thank you, Madam Pro Tim.

3:33

Um for uh District 25 residents this Saturday.

3:37

I will be holding office hours at the well from 8:30 until noon.

3:43

So please feel free to come out, ask me questions and get some more information.

3:47

Also, I would like to share for Nashville Davidson County residents uh uh uh at the end of the day.

3:53

As a whole, um, this Wednesday, tomorrow is the start of early voting.

3:59

Um, and one of the things that we are aware of, and and in my role as the rules confirmation and public elections committee chair um is we are actively monitoring any possible acts of violence or uh intimidation around voting or at the polling sites.

4:14

So if at any moment you feel as if you um are seeing, witnessing or experiencing any acts of violence or intimidation at the polling places, please reach out to your council member who will then correspond directly with MNPD, who's doing the work to make sure that they have continuing situational awareness of everything going on around our elections.

4:33

So rest assured that your institutions have your best interest at heart and want to make sure that you have every opportunity to participate in our democracy.

4:40

So thank you, Madam Pro Tim.

4:42

Thank you, Councilmember Preptee.

4:44

Councilmember Toombs, you are recognized.

4:49

Thank you, Madam Pro Tim.

4:51

Um next Tuesday, October 22nd at 6 p.m.

4:54

is the monthly District 2 community meeting.

4:57

Uh it is in the William D.

5:00

Boldenhamer building, which is where the North Precinct is, 2231, 26th Avenue North.

5:04

There's also a Zoom option, Tiny URL.com, backslash Capital D, the number two, Capital O, Capital C, Capital T, 22, Capital N, Capital D.

5:19

D2, October 22nd.

5:22

And there will also be a separate rezoning community meeting on Tuesday, October 29th at 6 p.m.

5:29

at Casa de Dios on Dickerson Pike to discuss the rezoning project at 520 Ewing Drive.

5:36

Thank you, Councilmember Toomes.

5:39

Councilmember Kuppen, you are recognized.

5:43

Thank you so much, uh Pro Tem.

5:46

A couple things.

5:47

Um, a little bit of sad news.

5:49

We did have a uh a house fire in Salem Town um Thursday evening.

5:53

Uh many thanks to the mayor who stopped by um to to make sure everything was okay.

5:58

Um, but the uh the family did have the family of three did have their house destroyed and are left with nothing but the clothing that they were wearing when they left the house.

6:06

Um they're longtime residents of Salem Town and native Nashvilleans.

6:10

Um they're staying with near nearby with extended family.

6:13

Um, but you can uh Venmo at Salemtown underscore neighbors or go to the Salemtown Neighbors.org uh website to consider donating um to support them.

6:24

They need uh they need a lot of assistance at this time, so everything helps.

6:27

Um, as Chair Prep T shared, early voting is tomorrow.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural█████████████████████████████████33%
Pending Litigation██████████████████18%
Public Safety█████████9%
Public Engagement███████7%
Community Engagement███████7%
Zoning and Land Use█████5%
Parks and Recreation████4%
Technology and Innovation████4%
Public Health██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Nashville Metropolitan Council Meeting - October 15, 2024

The Metropolitan Council of Nashville and Davidson County held its 25th regular meeting on Tuesday, October 15, 2024, at 6:30 PM in the Historic Metro Courthouse. The meeting included elections, confirmations, public hearings, resolutions, and ordinances on second and third reading. Key actions included the failure of a $150,000 settlement for Jonathan Saad, approval of a $125,000 settlement for Beth York, deferral of the Fusus surveillance contract, and passage of several zoning changes.

Consent Calendar

  • Approved unanimously (32-0): Multiple resolutions and ordinances, including grants for the WIC program, opioid abatement, air quality monitoring, HIV/AIDS programs, library services, park improvements, and various infrastructure agreements. Also approved were zoning changes on second and third reading (e.g., BL2024-526 through BL2024-547, BL2024-551, BL2024-552, BL2024-556-558, BL2024-581).
  • Note: BL2024-504 (stormwater easement repeal) was later rescinded and withdrawn.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Nicole Williams (Nashville resident) spoke in opposition to two items:
    • RS2024-708 (Jonathan Saad settlement): Urged council to ask more questions, citing ongoing dysfunction at Metro Arts and alleged inappropriate conduct.
    • BL2024-478 (Short-term rental ordinance): Expressed concern that the ordinance as drafted could be preempted by the state.

Discussion Items

  • RS2024-792 – Fusus Surveillance Contract Amendment: A resolution to approve Amendment No. 3 to a sole source contract with Fusus, LLC for surveillance technology. After a public hearing where Nicole Williams spoke in opposition, the council voted to defer the item two meetings (to November 19, 2024) with a re-referral to committees. A motion for a one-meeting deferral failed 15-20. A subsequent public hearing was scheduled for the November 19 meeting.
  • RS2024-708 – Jonathan Saad Settlement: A resolution to settle claims for $150,000 from the $3 million Arts Commission fund. After extensive debate, the resolution failed with a vote of 7 in favor, 16 against, and 11 abstaining. Opponents cited concerns about the merits of the case, the amount compared to a wrongful death settlement, and a desire to litigate rather than settle.
  • RS2024-774 – Beth York Settlement: A resolution to settle a wrongful death claim for $125,000 from the Self-Insured Liability Fund. A motion to defer one meeting failed by voice vote. The resolution was adopted 33-0. Metro Legal noted that the family would receive more than $125,000 due to a global settlement involving Wellpath.
  • RS2024-746 – ARP Funds Reallocation: Approved as amended (30-0). The amendment extended contracts through February 28, 2025, and appropriated additional funds to Agape ($22,500), Sexual Assault Center ($105,000), and National Children's Alliance ($104,000).
  • RS2024-779 – EPA Grant for Air Quality: Adopted as substituted (32-0). A late-filed housekeeping substitute was approved to correct the grant description.
  • BL2024-478 – Short Term Rental Ordinance: Amended and passed on second reading by voice vote. Amendments clarified documentation categories and removed a reference to state law.
  • BL2024-535 – Couchville Pike Rezone (R20 to SP): Passed on third reading 30-1 (one no vote from Councilmember Porterfield).
  • BL2024-548/549/550 – White Bridge Pike Mixed-Use Development: Passed on third reading 30-1 after adoption of an amendment with additional conditions (screening, traffic signals, dog run relocation, etc.).

Key Outcomes

  • Elections:
    • Councilmember Sepulveda elected to the Contract and Compliance Board (non-voting member).
    • Ann Barnett and Dontai Gleaves elected to the Contract and Compliance Board (community members).
    • Jayla Thomas elected to the Housing Trust Fund Commission after two rounds (23-12 over Gloria Hausser).
  • Confirmations (unanimous):
    • Fabian Bedne, Michael Iadevaia, Matt Neal, Alfredo Pena III to the Contract and Compliance Board.
    • Norah Buikstra and Seema Prasad to the Convention Center Authority.
    • Jenneen Reed as Metropolitan Director of Finance.
  • Deferrals:
    • RS2024-792 (Fusus) deferred to November 19, 2024, with a public hearing at that time.
    • RS2024-776 (Opioid Abatement Grant) deferred one meeting by rule.
    • RS2024-791 (Police safety survey platform) deferred one meeting by rule.
    • BL2024-469 (criminal participation of employees) deferred one meeting.
    • BL2024-553 (fire prevention code) indefinitely deferred.
    • Appointments of Jerry Pentecost (Auditorium Commission) indefinitely deferred and Frank Stevenson (Hospital Authority Board) deferred one meeting.
  • Withdrawals:
    • BL2024-504 (stormwater easement repeal) was rescinded from consent and withdrawn.
  • Resolutions adopted:
    • RS2024-801 (Honoring Kris Kristofferson) – adopted unanimously with all affirmative votes as co-sponsors.
    • RS2024-803 (Nashville Public Library Literary Award Gala 20th anniversary) – adopted.
    • RS2024-804 (American Baptist College 100th anniversary) – adopted as substituted.
    • RS2024-805 (Nashville Fire Department EMS 50 years) – adopted.
    • RS2024-806 (National Coming Out Day) – adopted.

Meeting Transcript

House Conference on Citizen Diplomacy seeks to foster friendship and understanding between the United States and other nations through person to person diplomacy and the celebration of cultural diversity and whereas in alignment with this vision, the citizens of Nashville, Tennessee, and Kamakura, Japan, have committed to working together to cultivate mutual understanding and ensuring the future peace and freedom through the creation of global friendships, and whereas in recognition of Nashville's growing importance to the presence of Japanese businesses in our region, the Japanese government relocated the consulate from New Orleans to Nashville in 2008. And whereas one of the primary goals of the first Consul General of Japan in Nashville, the Honorable Hiroshi Sato, was to establish a sister city relationship between Japan and Nashville to foster cultural exchanges. And whereas between 2008 and 2014, several cultural and business leadership exchanges took place between Nashville and Kamakura, the hometown of Consul General Sato, and whereas Kamakura became Nashville's eighth sister city in September of 2014 at a signing ceremony in Komakura between Carl Dean, mayor of Nashville, and Takashi Matsuo, mayor of Kamakura, attended by Nashville and Kamakura leaders, and whereas since Nashville and Kamakura city partnership was formulated. Thereby enhancing mutual respect and understanding between the two cities. And whereas the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County through the Metropolitan Council officially recognizes and supports this ongoing partnership with the aspiration that it will continue to strengthen and foster lasting friendships between the citizens of Nashville and Kamakuta while encouraging cooperative across various sectors, including music, culture, the arts, education, and governance. Now, therefore, may it be resolved by the council of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County. Yay. And I'd love to bring up Mina Johnson, who is the current uh board president of Sister Cities of Nashville to say a few words. Thank you, Councilman Babo, and thank you, uh Suara, and thank you, Council Lady Awena. And I am so excited to take uh this council member with me to Kamakura this Saturday. And Councilmember and Madame Pro Tem, thank you very much for the recognition and continuous support. And many council members I know are interested to joining uh Kamakura. So I'm sorry you cannot come this time, but please join next time. I'm looking forward to showing around. Thank you again. Appreciate it. Thank you. All right. All right. Um, if there are any council members who have any announcements, please start getting in the queue. Are you able to get in the queue? No. All right. So we're raising hands. First one up is Councilmember Preptee. Uh Councilmember Prepti, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Pro Tim. Um for uh District 25 residents this Saturday. I will be holding office hours at the well from 8:30 until noon. So please feel free to come out, ask me questions and get some more information. Also, I would like to share for Nashville Davidson County residents uh uh uh at the end of the day. As a whole, um, this Wednesday, tomorrow is the start of early voting. Um, and one of the things that we are aware of, and and in my role as the rules confirmation and public elections committee chair um is we are actively monitoring any possible acts of violence or uh intimidation around voting or at the polling sites. So if at any moment you feel as if you um are seeing, witnessing or experiencing any acts of violence or intimidation at the polling places, please reach out to your council member who will then correspond directly with MNPD, who's doing the work to make sure that they have continuing situational awareness of everything going on around our elections. So rest assured that your institutions have your best interest at heart and want to make sure that you have every opportunity to participate in our democracy. So thank you, Madam Pro Tim. Thank you, Councilmember Preptee. Councilmember Toombs, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Pro Tim. Um next Tuesday, October 22nd at 6 p.m. is the monthly District 2 community meeting. Uh it is in the William D. Boldenhamer building, which is where the North Precinct is, 2231, 26th Avenue North. There's also a Zoom option, Tiny URL.com, backslash Capital D, the number two, Capital O, Capital C, Capital T, 22, Capital N, Capital D. D2, October 22nd. And there will also be a separate rezoning community meeting on Tuesday, October 29th at 6 p.m. at Casa de Dios on Dickerson Pike to discuss the rezoning project at 520 Ewing Drive. Thank you, Councilmember Toomes. Councilmember Kuppen, you are recognized. Thank you so much, uh Pro Tem.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com