The special meeting was called to order at 6:07 PM in the Common Council Chambers. The primary agenda items were the presentation of the audited financial statements for fiscal year ending June 30, 2023, updates on finance department staffing, progress on financial close processes, internal controls, and the timetable for procuring audit services for 2025-2026. Council members received detailed information and discussed the city's financial condition, audit findings, and plans for improvement.
The external auditor from CLA (Leslie and Grace Maswita) presented the audit results. The city received unmodified (clean) opinions on both the financial statements and the federal/state single audits. Key financial highlights as of June 30, 2023:
The auditor reported two material weaknesses: (1) timeliness of bank reconciliations, and (2) financial close procedures. There was also a compliance finding for late filing of the financial statements (due December 31, 2023, but issued much later). As a result, the city no longer qualifies as a low-risk auditee for federal single audit, requiring 40% testing instead of 20%. Management letter recommendations included periodic reconciliation of OPEB liabilities, capital asset review segregation of duties, and analysis of general liability reserves.
Finance Director Jonathan Perigini explained that the FY2022 audit took 18 months due to 75% staff turnover, while FY2023 was completed in 6 months. Staffing is now fully in place (as of May 2023), and the bank reconciliation process has been broken up and assigned to multiple staff with checklists. The goal is to have the FY2024 audit issued by December 31, 2024, to regain compliance.
A discussion item. Director Perigini stated the department is now fully staffed after losing high-level staff in 2022. Cross-training and a new checklist system for bank reconciliations have been implemented. Council members debated the distinction between valid reasons and excuses for delays; some stressed the need for timely audits and accountability. The auditor noted significant improvement from FY2022 to FY2023.
These items were discussed together as the findings were identical. Perigini outlined:
The city must notify OPM by June 1, 2025, of the auditor for FY2025. Perigini proposed issuing an RFP by February 1, 2025, to allow time for review by the audit subcommittee and council. The audit committee will vet proposals and recommend to the full council. Council members requested clarity on the committee's role in interviewing firms; Alderman McNamara noted the ordinance defines the committee's authority. The timeline was accepted as a discussion item.
Good evening. I call to order the July 22nd special meeting of the Committee on Administration, Finance, Law and Public Services. The time is now six oh seven p.m. And Miss Clerk, will you please call the roll? Good evening. Good evening. Alderman Connors. Here. Barbosa? Magnamera? Here. Santiago. President. Simpson. Gibson. Here. Bubble. Smedley. Beloin Savitra. And today we'll be seated Alderman Russell. I'm actually an observer. Yes. You're sitting in for Alderman Smedley. Thank you, sir. And Alderman MacAdam. Correct. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Tonight the first item on the agenda is the presentation of the audited financial statement fiscal year ending June 30, 2023. May I have a motion? I make a motion to accept and refer to the full council with a neutral recommendation. Motion to accept and refer with neutral from Alderwoman Belowing Surveyor, seconded by Alderman Russell. All in favor say aye. Oh wait, sorry. Sorry. Apologies. So part of my agenda for this evening is to first start with just talking about the scope of our audit services. What do we do for the city? Then I'm going to talk about the tested programs in the state and federal single audit. Okay. And then um some industry insights um on new GASB standards that are coming down the pike. What do I have? This one. Okay, great. Um, so just to describe to you the scope of our audit services, we do render an opinion on the city's financial statements. And I think it's important to note that I say the city's financial statements. The city's responsible for those financial statements and the numbers in them. We come to audit them and render an opinion on whether or not those numbers are materially um representative of government of generally accepted accounting principles. With that, we also render an in relation to opinion on the schedule of federal awards and state financial statements, which we call the state and federal single audits. So those schedules are in relation to the financial statements as a whole.