OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/New Rochelle, New York/Meeting Portal
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

New Rochelle Planning Board Meeting – September 22, 2026

Meeting Portal — Tuesday, September 22, 2026
BodyNew Rochelle, New York
SessionMeeting Portal
DateTuesday, September 22, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:42:12

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it
1:00

Good evening.

1:02

Welcome to the uh September 22nd, 2026 Planning Board Meeting of the City of New Rochelle.

1:09

There will be two portions to this meeting.

1:11

The first portion of the meeting will be open to public comment.

1:15

Applicants will be invited to the podium to present their application, and planning board members will then have the opportunity to ask questions of each application.

1:26

Applicants will address each of those in turn.

1:29

There will be then an opportunity for public comment.

1:32

If any member of the public would like to comment, you will be given three minutes to do so.

1:38

If you would like to comment, please fill out the white comment card and state your name and address for the record.

1:46

The second portion of the meeting will address referrals and administrative items that are not open to public comment.

1:53

Of course, you are welcome to stay during that portion of the meeting.

2:03

Sure.

2:06

Here.

2:07

Isabel Cuala Marquez is out.

2:09

Sylvia Hamer?

2:10

Here.

2:11

Doug Houston?

2:12

Here.

2:13

John Lancer.

2:14

Here.

2:14

Kate Mercado is out.

2:17

Christine O'Connell?

2:18

Yeah.

2:19

And staff members with us today.

2:21

Jeff Bream, Deputy Corporation Counsel.

2:23

Paul Vaca, Commissioner of Buildings, Kevin Cain, Directing of Director of Planning and Sustainability.

2:30

And myself, Benito Saiha, board clerk.

2:36

Thanks, Mr.

2:39

There are no minutes to approve, so we'll go right into the first item, first application.

2:48

And this again, this is the public hearing portion of the meeting.

3:48

They love the neighborhood and they love their neighbors.

4:21

So that's existing.

4:26

A new farmhouse style, two-story residence.

4:39

I would, you know, talk about that a little bit.

5:00

Um a James Hardy board and batten siding that um will be uh trimmed with AZAC trim for soffits, uh around windows, balasters, uh railings, uh, you know, uh anything of that nature.

5:11

And um we're going to be using some real wood columns on the front and back porches along with composite decking, along with uh metal sanding seam roof on over the front porch, and uh um the uh eaves over the garage, the the small uh awnings over the garage, um double hung windows, and there's some 400 double hung windows, that's our standard, and uh it's I think uh asphalt shingle roof, like I said on the major part of the house, and uh uh uh anything else that's compliant to what we have listed here.

5:56

So um we can go site plan wise we're following all the planning board and building uh building department rules with setbacks and uh uh protecting deep uh the highway signage and um anything else that's needed by the town, we are definitely you know doing everything we need to be doing here.

6:25

So um landscaping uh and also uh you know, within a where within all of our setbacks, etc.

6:37

First floor, open plan, garage, a nice open dining room, there's uh guest room and bath, second floor, uh the master bedroom, their son's bedroom, an office space, etc.

7:00

Unfinished basement at the moment, and then finish it down the road, and let me see.

7:08

Is that it?

7:10

Yes, so uh storage area above the garage, nice large garage, uh opening to crestwood.

7:22

We're cutting a new a new curb cut to custwood and uh putting a new driveway, uh asphalt with anyway, um trying to think of anything else that's really can you go back to the basement plan?

7:38

Of course, of course.

7:39

One, two, right, yes.

7:43

Uh-huh.

7:45

Okay.

7:45

Um I know it's unfinished.

7:48

And you said you may try to finish it in the future.

7:51

Um you you might want to put escape well in now while you're building the home instead of having to go through that later.

8:01

What are the we actually had a uh Billco door and uh in the original uh proposal, but due to setbacks where we had it, we had to remove it.

8:12

I mean, we can you definitely you know discuss that with the clients.

8:17

I know that Greg really wanted one.

8:19

Okay.

8:20

So but uh we were trying to stay, like I said, within all our setbacks and not have to go through a ZBA or anything like that yet before this, so that was the reason.

8:32

But it's a great idea.

8:33

If it's if the escape well is just a row of block and it's underground, most of it's underground, then it's it doesn't count in the setbacks.

8:45

All right.

8:45

So it's more of a window well.

8:48

Yes.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Zoning And Land Use████████████████████████████████████36%
Affordable Housing███████████████15%
Procedural███████████11%
Parking Management██████6%
Engineering And Infrastructure█████5%
Public Transportation█████5%
Transportation Safety████4%
Retail Development███3%
Public Health███3%
Summary of Proceedings

New Rochelle Planning Board Meeting – September 22, 2026

The New Rochelle Planning Board met on September 22, 2026, at 12:00 PM for a regularly scheduled meeting. The meeting consisted of a public hearing portion for two applications and an administrative portion covering four additional items, including presentations, referrals, and a code amendment. Board members present: Isabel Cuala Marquez (out), Sylvia Hamer, Doug Houston, John Lancer, Kate Mercado (out), Christine O'Connell. Staff present: Deputy Corporation Counsel Jeff Bream, Commissioner of Buildings Paul Vaca, Director of Planning and Sustainability Kevin Cain, and Board Clerk Benito Saiha.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Charlene Claxton (126 Church Street, New Rochelle) expressed concern about traffic congestion on Church Street due to parking garage backups, valet slowness, and lack of enforcement. She also noted potential issues with food delivery trucks for the proposed Toast Coffee & Kitchen at 50 Clinton Place, given limited street space. The applicant acknowledged the concerns and noted coordination with RXR for loading dock use.

Discussion Items

  • PB 2026-1 – Site Plan Approval for New Residence at 8 High Ridge Road: The applicant presented a proposal for a new two-story farmhouse-style residence (board and batten siding, AZAC trim, metal roof on porch, asphalt shingle main roof). Existing single-story ranch to be demolished. New curb cut being relocated from High Ridge Road to Crestwood Avenue. Impervious surface increase of 269 sq ft (from 3,206 to 3,475 sq ft) triggers one required tree; applicant proposed two red maples. Board discussed egress window, collar ties, and zoning compliance. Public hearing: no public comments. Conditions of approval read and accepted. Vote: unanimous (all ayes) for site plan approval.
  • PB 2026-2 – Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for Toast Coffee & Kitchen at 50 Clinton Place: Applicant Mark Blair and CEO Terry Scarlatus proposed an interior build-out and outdoor dining for a breakfast/lunch/brunch concept (5,000 sq ft, 140 seats total). Hours initially stated 8 AM to 10 PM but clarified as 8 AM to 3 PM, with potential seasonal extension for “golden hour.” Grease exhaust louver location justified to avoid property lines and residential windows; interior pollution control unit required. Parking: no off-street parking required in district; nearby garages available. Public comment from Charlene Claxton (traffic concerns). Conditions added: applicant must use loading dock for food deliveries. Votes: unanimous for site plan approval and special permit approval.
  • PB 192026 – Presentation for Affordable Senior Housing at 50 Lockwood Avenue: For presentation only; no vote. Applicant Janet Garris introduced a joint venture (PRC and Community Builders) proposing an 89-unit affordable senior housing building (9 stories, all-electric, solar PV, bioswale). Unit mix: 24 studios, 64 one-bedrooms, 1 two-bedroom (superintendent). Site includes 31 parking spaces, 4 EV charging stations, and a public plaza. Board discussed community center programming, accessibility for paratransit, shared parking, and potential seating areas. Applicant noted church salvage and will incorporate artifacts. Next steps: more comprehensive presentation and public hearing next month.
  • Administrative Amendment for Shady Glen Court Condominiums: Applicant Robert Sansiel requested approval to revise parking layout from 20 approved spaces to 22 spaces (tandem) at 10 Shady Glen Court. Original plan had oversized 11-ft-wide spaces; re-striping allows 22 compliant spaces. Vote: unanimous approval.
  • BAZ Referral – 777 Webster Avenue Subdivision: Applicant Jessica Zalin requested area variances to subdivide two tax lots (Lot 25 and Lot 27) for future single-family and two-family dwellings. Nine variances requested, primarily lot dimension and frontage variances. Attorney argued contextual compatibility: adjacent lots have similar non-conformities (e.g., 32 of 33 parcels on the same block have non-compliant lot widths). Board noted the significant number of variances but found the development pattern contextual. Vote: motion for neutral recommendation to the Board of Zoning Appeals (all in favor).
  • City Council Referral – Proposed Amendments to Chapter 331 (Site Plan Amendments): Staff proposed creating a new “administrative amendment” category for changes between minor and substantial, with a fee equal to 50% of the original application fee. Board discussed cost proportionality. Vote: unanimous positive referral to City Council.

Key Outcomes

  • 8 High Ridge Road – Site Plan Approved: Unanimous (all ayes). Conditions include DPW permits, sidewalk replacement, and maintaining address 8 High Ridge Road.
  • 50 Clinton Place – Site Plan and Special Permit Approved: Unanimous for both. Conditions include DPW permits, fire department compliance, and use of loading dock for food deliveries.
  • Shady Glen Court – Administrative Amendment Approved: Unanimous.
  • 777 Webster Avenue – Neutral Referral to BAZ: Unanimous motion to provide neutral recommendation.
  • Chapter 331 Amendments – Positive Referral to City Council: Unanimous.
  • Next Meeting: PB 192026 (50 Lockwood Avenue) will return for public hearing and potential vote next month.

Meeting Transcript

Good evening. Welcome to the uh September 22nd, 2026 Planning Board Meeting of the City of New Rochelle. There will be two portions to this meeting. The first portion of the meeting will be open to public comment. Applicants will be invited to the podium to present their application, and planning board members will then have the opportunity to ask questions of each application. Applicants will address each of those in turn. There will be then an opportunity for public comment. If any member of the public would like to comment, you will be given three minutes to do so. If you would like to comment, please fill out the white comment card and state your name and address for the record. The second portion of the meeting will address referrals and administrative items that are not open to public comment. Of course, you are welcome to stay during that portion of the meeting. Sure. Here. Isabel Cuala Marquez is out. Sylvia Hamer? Here. Doug Houston? Here. John Lancer. Here. Kate Mercado is out. Christine O'Connell? Yeah. And staff members with us today. Jeff Bream, Deputy Corporation Counsel. Paul Vaca, Commissioner of Buildings, Kevin Cain, Directing of Director of Planning and Sustainability. And myself, Benito Saiha, board clerk. Thanks, Mr. There are no minutes to approve, so we'll go right into the first item, first application. And this again, this is the public hearing portion of the meeting. They love the neighborhood and they love their neighbors. So that's existing. A new farmhouse style, two-story residence. I would, you know, talk about that a little bit. Um a James Hardy board and batten siding that um will be uh trimmed with AZAC trim for soffits, uh around windows, balasters, uh railings, uh, you know, uh anything of that nature. And um we're going to be using some real wood columns on the front and back porches along with composite decking, along with uh metal sanding seam roof on over the front porch, and uh um the uh eaves over the garage, the the small uh awnings over the garage, um double hung windows, and there's some 400 double hung windows, that's our standard, and uh it's I think uh asphalt shingle roof, like I said on the major part of the house, and uh uh uh anything else that's compliant to what we have listed here. So um we can go site plan wise we're following all the planning board and building uh building department rules with setbacks and uh uh protecting deep uh the highway signage and um anything else that's needed by the town, we are definitely you know doing everything we need to be doing here. So um landscaping uh and also uh you know, within a where within all of our setbacks, etc. First floor, open plan, garage, a nice open dining room, there's uh guest room and bath, second floor, uh the master bedroom, their son's bedroom, an office space, etc. Unfinished basement at the moment, and then finish it down the road, and let me see. Is that it? Yes, so uh storage area above the garage, nice large garage, uh opening to crestwood. We're cutting a new a new curb cut to custwood and uh putting a new driveway, uh asphalt with anyway, um trying to think of anything else that's really can you go back to the basement plan? Of course, of course. One, two, right, yes. Uh-huh. Okay. Um I know it's unfinished. And you said you may try to finish it in the future. Um you you might want to put escape well in now while you're building the home instead of having to go through that later.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com