OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Town Council Special Meeting to Appoint School Committee Member – December 18, 2023

Town CouncilMonday, December 18, 2023
BodyNorth Kingstown, Rhode Island
SessionTown Council
DateMonday, December 18, 2023
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:20:59

Transcript — Verbatim
0:17

We all set Madam Clerk.

0:19

Okay.

0:20

Welcome everybody to the Monday, November 18th, 2023 meeting of the town council.

0:26

And welcome to the People's House in North Kingstown.

0:29

Let's call this meeting to order.

0:31

Pursuant to Rhode Island General Laws 42-46-6C.

0:36

Notice of this meeting has been posted on the Secretary of State's website.

0:41

I ask everybody's stand and salute the flag.

0:44

Thank you.

0:47

Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

1:05

So thank you, everybody.

1:07

We only have one agenda item as you know.

1:10

It's a special meeting to appoint the new school committee to fill the unexpired term of Jennifer Hoskins, who submitted her resignation effective uh December first.

1:23

By charter, the council has 30 days to fill this position.

1:27

So I know this is a challenging time of the year for everybody.

1:31

I appreciate everyone being here.

1:33

Um and really this is the only time the members of this body were able to come together.

1:38

Uh I want to first start out by thanking Jenny Hoskins for seven years of public service on the school committee.

1:46

Public service in this day and age is challenging.

1:49

It's very challenging.

1:51

We wish her nothing but the best.

1:53

As it relates to the agenda at hand, the town has advertised uh this position to the public.

2:00

It has asked interested parties to file a letter of interest uh with the town clerk by Friday, November uh excuse me, not November, December 15th at 4 p.m.

2:10

Uh no uh we didn't receive any applicants afterwards, but they would not have been considered anyways.

2:16

After that deadline, uh we sent the applicants an email, uh informed them of tonight's meeting, and asked them to speak if they so choose.

2:26

Um initially we had received uh letters of interest from eleven candidates.

2:31

Uh two have since rescinded their candidacy.

2:35

Uh tonight we have two sign-up sheets, one for candidates and one for members of the public.

2:41

Uh I'd like to, or we would like to hear from the candidates first.

2:46

Um we are going to dispense with our traditional three-minute time frame, although we'd ask them to be concise because there are a number of candidates here.

2:54

Uh plus we have a number of um people for the public who want to sign up.

3:00

Um town councillor Matt McCoy had sent a questionnaire to the candidates, which is very helpful.

3:06

They all responded.

3:07

I want to thank them, and we all have that information.

3:11

Um and it's certainly public information.

3:14

We have received uh a number of emails, and I'm gonna turn over Matt momentarily to tell us who who wrote to us.

3:22

Um and I would say to you is if you did write to us, um you know if you want to speak again tonight, that's certainly your right.

3:31

But I would say to you, we have your information from our perspective.

3:35

Um we don't think there's a need, but if you want if you want to speak again, again that's your right.

3:41

But uh I I think that it would be a little redundant.

3:45

Uh with that, uh Matt, if you could uh let the public know uh what type of correspondence we received before uh uh we have public speaking and have the candidates speak, then we'll go right to the candidate speaking.

3:59

Thank you, Matt.

4:01

All right.

4:02

Uh on the behalf of uh candidate Megan Riley.

4:06

We had a total of 33 uh people write uh emails of endorsement, including Courtney Chandler, Ryan Smith, Karen Forbes, Teresa Hirsch, Peter Lucier, Susanna Tingley, Vicky Bennett, Robert and Carol Saborin, uh George Longquist, Joy Cushman, Sue Alexander, Jason Bergenstock, Joan Pacino, Brian O'Dell, Dan and Madeline O'Leary, Mike Raposa, Frank Sullivan, Renee Charlton, Gregory Wallace, uh Janet Sheehan, Karen Salvatore, Gregory Snow, Christina Fry, Cindy Booth, Katie Farroldi, Jennifer Rowland, Mary McComber, Ed Ranahan, Karen Kosminski, Richard Keynes, uh Eric Miller, and Kaylin uh Ariola.

5:09

On behalf of uh candidate Deborah, and I apologize if I mess this up.

5:15

Uh Lu Cosco, uh Kalia Schmir wrote a letter of endorsement on behalf of candidate Robert Jones.

5:24

We got letters, uh emails of endorsement from Kara Martone, Peter Lucier, and Susanna Tingley.

5:33

Um for candidate Jim Sheehan.

5:36

We had email endorsements from Lori Knold, John Machada, Meg Kierr, Melissa Devine, Kay Ho, Peter Cornelian, Katherine Pastory, Seth Meller, Isabella Montini, Kevin Dignan, Kelly Ryan, Melissa Jones, Nancy Sherman, Lisa Garcia, Anthony Toro, Mary Ann Hackett, Mike Donahue, Chris Graham, Tony Silveria, Rob Zimmer, Kathleen Leighton, Serena Mason, Julie McGuire, Pamela Rowland, Jordan Abernaz, Susan Erickson, Robert Severi, Tony Silvery, Tim Warren, Mary Masia, Matthew Erickson, Kathleen Garino, Emily Windsor Zilly, George Brennan, Michael Anderson, Jonathan Gale, Shana and Ray Marzilli, Nicholas Fetty Jr., I think this is Shannon Gale and Shelly Bigelli.

6:46

And then for candidates Sarah Palmer Kelly, Kimberly Haskins, Kelly Ryan, Serena Mason, Jordan Abernas, Chris Graham, Lisa Garcia, Kathleen Leighton, and other correspondents we received, which uh were general in nature, not specific to any particular candidate, uh were from Mary uh Warmbeck, Diane Hill, and Taylor Baltzer.

7:15

And that's pretty much as of about half hour ago when I checked my email last.

7:20

Thank you, Matt.

7:21

I'd like to first ask uh Donna Luco to come to the podium and speak.

7:38

Hi, my name is Donna Lico.

7:39

I live at 62 Edgewood Drive here in North Kingstown.

7:43

Um I'm asking to be considered for appointment to the vacancy on the school committee because I want to make sure the town council has the opportunity to choose a person with the best qualifications to balance the committee so that it may serve the community well.

7:58

I've lived in my home since 2002, and my two adult children completed their entire K-12 education in North Kingstown schools.

8:06

I believe their education prepared them well for adult life.

8:10

Both the quality of their education and the social emotional environment of the schools they were in helped them learn and grow.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Education Funding█████████████████████████████████████████████54%
Public Engagement██████████████17%
Procedural████████████14%
Public Comment████████9%
Capital Improvement Planning███3%
Racial Equity███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Town Council Special Meeting – Appointment of School Committee Member

The North Kingstown Town Council held a special meeting on Monday, December 18, 2023, at 8:00 PM in the Town Hall Council Chambers. The sole agenda item was to fill the unexpired term on the School Committee left by Jennifer Hoskins, who resigned effective December 1, 2023. By charter, the Council has 30 days to make the appointment. Eleven candidates submitted letters of interest; two subsequently withdrew, leaving nine individuals present to speak. The meeting included candidate testimony, public comment, deliberation, and a unanimous vote to appoint James Sheehan.

Appointment of a School Committee Member

  • Candidates’ Presentations: Seven of the nine candidates spoke (one, Crystal Simus, was ill and absent). Each outlined their qualifications, experience, and vision for the role. Key themes included the need for collaboration, transparency, financial oversight, and a viable plan for school facilities after the defeat of a recent bond referendum.

    • Donna Lico: 33-year middle school science teacher; emphasized understanding of educational policy and fiscal responsibility. Supported the role of the School Committee in setting policy and budget to support educators.
    • Sarah Kelly Palmer: Licensed clinical social worker and administrator at a nonprofit; expertise in trauma‑informed care. Advocated for supporting teachers, addressing middle school conditions, and gathering community input on facility solutions.
    • Deborah Lukashko: Retired nurse practitioner with prior Board of Education experience in New Jersey; focused on increasing community participation, transparency, and improving academic proficiency rates (citing 63% reading and 47% math proficiency) and graduation rates (89%). Also stressed fully vetted facility plans.
    • Lee Domaszowicz: Founder of a nonprofit consultancy; emphasized the need for a bond plan that could win voter approval, accountability, and positive community engagement. Noted that no single issue caused the bond’s defeat and that new proposals must address voters’ concerns.
    • Megan Riley: Former Spanish teacher and current substitute in the district; said she helped educate voters about the bond, which she felt lacked transparency. Expressed willingness to collaborate and bring independent thinking to the Committee.
    • James Sheehan: 28‑year teacher in Warwick Public Schools and former Rhode Island State Senator (20 years). Highlighted his legislative experience, including universal all‑day kindergarten and the Promise program. Promised to find common ground on a new middle school and to improve communication and trust.
    • Robert Jones: Eight‑year former School Committee member; stressed financial oversight, noting that North Kingstown’s tax levy increases have been above the state average. Advocated for a holistic infrastructure plan and data‑driven decision‑making. He stated he does not intend to run for re‑election.
  • Public Comments: Approximately seven residents spoke. Opinions were divided: some urged the Council to appoint James Sheehan for his government experience and ability to build consensus; others supported Megan Riley as a way to represent voters who opposed the bond; still others backed Robert Jones for his prior School Committee experience and balanced approach. A few speakers emphasized the need for diversity of thought and collaborative problem‑solving.

  • Council Deliberation and Vote: Councilor Page nominated James Sheehan, citing his teaching background and legislative achievements. Councilor McCoy provided election data: James Sheehan had been repeatedly elected to the State Senate, while Robert Jones had lost his last two School Committee races. Councilors Anderson and Mandel echoed support, noting Sheehan’s proven ability to get things done and his unique overlap of education and policy. President Mancini also supported Sheehan, valuing government experience for practical decision‑making.

    • Vote: The motion to appoint James Sheehan passed unanimously (5‑0). Councilor Mancini administered the oath (not shown in transcript). The meeting adjourned immediately thereafter.

Meeting Transcript

We all set Madam Clerk. Okay. Welcome everybody to the Monday, November 18th, 2023 meeting of the town council. And welcome to the People's House in North Kingstown. Let's call this meeting to order. Pursuant to Rhode Island General Laws 42-46-6C. Notice of this meeting has been posted on the Secretary of State's website. I ask everybody's stand and salute the flag. Thank you. Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. So thank you, everybody. We only have one agenda item as you know. It's a special meeting to appoint the new school committee to fill the unexpired term of Jennifer Hoskins, who submitted her resignation effective uh December first. By charter, the council has 30 days to fill this position. So I know this is a challenging time of the year for everybody. I appreciate everyone being here. Um and really this is the only time the members of this body were able to come together. Uh I want to first start out by thanking Jenny Hoskins for seven years of public service on the school committee. Public service in this day and age is challenging. It's very challenging. We wish her nothing but the best. As it relates to the agenda at hand, the town has advertised uh this position to the public. It has asked interested parties to file a letter of interest uh with the town clerk by Friday, November uh excuse me, not November, December 15th at 4 p.m. Uh no uh we didn't receive any applicants afterwards, but they would not have been considered anyways. After that deadline, uh we sent the applicants an email, uh informed them of tonight's meeting, and asked them to speak if they so choose. Um initially we had received uh letters of interest from eleven candidates. Uh two have since rescinded their candidacy. Uh tonight we have two sign-up sheets, one for candidates and one for members of the public. Uh I'd like to, or we would like to hear from the candidates first. Um we are going to dispense with our traditional three-minute time frame, although we'd ask them to be concise because there are a number of candidates here. Uh plus we have a number of um people for the public who want to sign up. Um town councillor Matt McCoy had sent a questionnaire to the candidates, which is very helpful. They all responded. I want to thank them, and we all have that information. Um and it's certainly public information. We have received uh a number of emails, and I'm gonna turn over Matt momentarily to tell us who who wrote to us. Um and I would say to you is if you did write to us, um you know if you want to speak again tonight, that's certainly your right. But I would say to you, we have your information from our perspective. Um we don't think there's a need, but if you want if you want to speak again, again that's your right. But uh I I think that it would be a little redundant. Uh with that, uh Matt, if you could uh let the public know uh what type of correspondence we received before uh uh we have public speaking and have the candidates speak, then we'll go right to the candidate speaking. Thank you, Matt. All right. Uh on the behalf of uh candidate Megan Riley. We had a total of 33 uh people write uh emails of endorsement, including Courtney Chandler, Ryan Smith, Karen Forbes, Teresa Hirsch, Peter Lucier, Susanna Tingley, Vicky Bennett, Robert and Carol Saborin, uh George Longquist, Joy Cushman, Sue Alexander, Jason Bergenstock, Joan Pacino, Brian O'Dell, Dan and Madeline O'Leary, Mike Raposa, Frank Sullivan, Renee Charlton, Gregory Wallace, uh Janet Sheehan, Karen Salvatore, Gregory Snow, Christina Fry, Cindy Booth, Katie Farroldi, Jennifer Rowland, Mary McComber, Ed Ranahan, Karen Kosminski, Richard Keynes, uh Eric Miller, and Kaylin uh Ariola. On behalf of uh candidate Deborah, and I apologize if I mess this up. Uh Lu Cosco, uh Kalia Schmir wrote a letter of endorsement on behalf of candidate Robert Jones. We got letters, uh emails of endorsement from Kara Martone, Peter Lucier, and Susanna Tingley. Um for candidate Jim Sheehan. We had email endorsements from Lori Knold, John Machada, Meg Kierr, Melissa Devine, Kay Ho, Peter Cornelian, Katherine Pastory, Seth Meller, Isabella Montini, Kevin Dignan, Kelly Ryan, Melissa Jones, Nancy Sherman, Lisa Garcia, Anthony Toro, Mary Ann Hackett, Mike Donahue, Chris Graham, Tony Silveria, Rob Zimmer, Kathleen Leighton, Serena Mason, Julie McGuire, Pamela Rowland, Jordan Abernaz, Susan Erickson, Robert Severi, Tony Silvery, Tim Warren, Mary Masia, Matthew Erickson, Kathleen Garino, Emily Windsor Zilly, George Brennan, Michael Anderson, Jonathan Gale, Shana and Ray Marzilli, Nicholas Fetty Jr., I think this is Shannon Gale and Shelly Bigelli.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com