OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Oxford, Ohio/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Oxford City Council Regular Meeting - July 21, 2026

City Council — Tuesday, July 21, 2026
BodyOxford, Ohio
SessionCity Council
DateTuesday, July 21, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Unassigned speaker

0:21

Oh, wait, this is the matter.

Speaker 1

0:24

Welcome back, Chief.

0:26

JJ.

0:28

Welcome back.

0:29

Sounds like you had a great adventure.

Speaker 2

0:34

Yes.

0:41

We're reprimanded for election affairs.

0:44

There will be more coming out.

0:47

Nothing that likely made a difference, but all of them that are anti-democratic.

Speaker 1

0:51

Yeah, bright

Speaker 2

0:51

remote

Speaker 1

0:52

is not going to be.

0:57

Pennsylvania should be hampton.

Speaker 3

0:59

Okay, it's 7 30, so I think we should go ahead and get going.

1:02

So uh Miss Barber, you recall the role.

Speaker 4

1:04

Mr.

1:05

Bracken?

1:06

Here.

1:06

Ms.

1:06

Franklin?

1:07

Here.

1:08

Miss French?

1:08

Here.

1:09

Miss Arnellis.

1:10

Here.

1:10

Mr.

1:11

Snavely?

Speaker 3

1:11

Here.

Speaker 4

1:12

Mayor Smith?

Speaker 3

1:13

Here.

1:13

All right, we will now do the Pledge of Allegiance if you would like to join

Unassigned speaker

1:16

us.

Speaker 5

1:20

Congratulations to the flag

Unassigned speaker

1:22

of

Speaker 5

1:22

the United States of America

Unassigned speaker

1:24

and to

Speaker 6

1:25

the Republic

Unassigned speaker

1:26

for

Speaker 6

1:26

which it stands one

Speaker 7

1:30

individual with liberty and justice for all.

Speaker 3

1:38

All right, may I have a motion to approve the agenda?

Speaker 8

1:40

So moved.

1:41

Second.

Unassigned speaker

1:42

Moved by Vice Mayor French, second by Councilor Arnellis.

Speaker 3

1:45

All those in favor, please say aye.

1:47

Aye.

1:48

Opposed?

1:49

Great.

1:50

We will start with public participation tonight.

1:53

And we'll go straight to public comments.

1:55

So anyone wishing to address council about items that are not on the agenda or on the consent agenda.

2:00

Please come forward at this time and state your name and address for the record.

Speaker 9 · Possibly Linda Musmisi Kimball

2:13

It's nice to see you all again.

2:16

Linda Musmisi Kimball, 724 Melinda Drive.

2:21

This past year of reports, accounts, and records have shown just how dangerous automated license plate readers are.

2:30

Flock safety's products have reportedly been used, misused, and abused in immigration enforcement, abortion monitoring, repeated incidents of stalking, and the flock cameras have experienced major cybersecurity breaches and error-prone technology that has led to real harm.

2:53

Flock has rightfully earned the public's anger.

2:58

After learning about the use of these AI cameras in their communities, and to date there are 115,490 of them in 6,000 communities in the country.

3:11

Thousands of people across the country have demanded that ALPRs be removed.

3:17

In the growing movement to de-flock, more than 87 communities have either canceled or deactivated their cameras from the surveillance technology.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural██████████████████████22%
Public Safety████████████████████20%
Affordable Housing███████████████15%
Public Engagement████████8%
Community Engagement████████8%
Civil Liberties██████6%
Engineering And Infrastructure██████6%
Transportation Safety█████5%
Budget Equity Analysis███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Oxford City Council Regular Meeting - July 21, 2026

The Oxford City Council held its regular meeting on Tuesday, July 21, 2026, at 7:30 PM at the Courthouse. Mayor Michael Smith presided. All council members were present except Jim Vinch (excused). The meeting included public comments on surveillance technology, adoption of resolutions for water treatment plant financing and mutual police aid, and second readings of several ordinances, including contentious charter amendments regarding the Mile Square. The meeting adjourned at 9:09 PM.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes from July 7, 2026, City Council Meeting – Approved unanimously (voice vote).

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Linda Musmeci-Kimball (724 Melinda Drive) – Expressed strong opposition to the continued use of Flock Safety automated license plate readers (ALPRs). Cited reports from the Electronic Frontier Foundation and ACLU alleging misuse in immigration enforcement, abortion monitoring, stalking, and data breaches. Stated that 87 communities have deactivated Flock cameras and that the contract was signed without sufficient community engagement. Urged Council to initiate a broader public discussion on surveillance and public safety.
  • Janice Dutton (302 West Vine Street) – Also spoke against Flock Safety, sharing personal experiences with traffic stops to contrast officer judgment with automated technology. Referenced Institute for Justice and ACLU reports of false matches leading to innocent individuals being detained at gunpoint. Noted Flock's claimed 93% plate capture accuracy (7% error rate) and argued that even a small error rate leads to thousands of dangerous encounters. Urged Council to reconsider the partnership, increase transparency, limit data sharing, and refer the issue to the Police Community Relations and Review Commission (PCRRC).
  • Kevin McKeehan (2126 Dana Drive) – Former Charter Review Commission member. Expressed disappointment that the three-dwelling-unit prohibition removal was separated from other charter amendments, but supported its placement on the ballot. Argued that land-use decisions belong in zoning code, not the charter, and that retaining the prohibition could limit affordable housing opportunities like Clarence Place.
  • Janice Dutton (second appearance) – Spoke in opposition to the charter amendment removing the three-dwelling-unit restriction in the Mile Square. Argued that the original charter restriction was enacted because residents lacked confidence in zoning regulations alone. Claimed that zoning changes and variances are too easily obtained and that increased density would lead to more student-oriented housing, not affordable housing. Urged Council not to advance the amendment to the ballot.

Discussion Items

  • Resolution 7841: Payment to Ohio Water Development Authority ($283,846) – Authorized the city manager to submit payment for administrative charges on a $20 million loan for water treatment plant membrane softening improvements. The loan includes $4 million in principal forgiveness and a blended interest rate of 2.51% over 30 years. Annual payments of $953,576.92 begin January 1, 2029. Adopted unanimously (voice vote).
  • Resolution 7842: Butler County Mutual Police Aid Agreement – Authorized the city manager to enter into an updated mutual aid agreement with Butler County law enforcement agencies. Chief Jones explained that the agreement supplements and essentially replaces the 2022 agreement, clarifying roles for specialized operations (SWAT, OVI task force, drone, K9). Council members raised concerns about vague language regarding task forces and control over assisting agencies. After discussion, the resolution was adopted unanimously (voice vote).
  • Ordinance 3870 (First Reading): Parking Code Amendment – Introduced an ordinance repealing and replacing Section 351.03 to prohibit parking on driveway aprons (area between sidewalk and street) in the Mile Square. Chief Jones presented photos showing blocked sidewalks and traffic hazards. Public comment from Janice Dutton supported the change due to repeated driveway blockages. The ordinance will return for second reading in August.
  • Ordinance 3870 (Second Reading, as amended): Charter Amendments (6 items) – Authorized placing six charter amendments on the November 3, 2026 ballot, including removal of utility user liability section, updating initiative/referendum filing, city manager residency, replacing Civil Service Commission with Personnel Appeals Board, revising recall process, and removing bond requirement. Council amended the ballot language to specify "recall" in item five. Adopted 6-0 (roll call).
  • Ordinance 3871 (Second Reading): Charter Amendment – Remove Three-Dwelling-Unit Prohibition – A separate ballot issue to eliminate the charter restriction limiting dwellings to three units per lot in the Mile Square. Debate was extensive: Councilman Snavely opposed, citing citizen distrust of zoning changes and risk of student housing; Councilors French, Franklin, Ornelas, Bracken, and Mayor Smith supported, arguing for housing flexibility and trust in zoning process. Community Development Director Sam Perry noted the restriction hinders redevelopment. Adopted 5-1 (Snavely dissenting).
  • Ordinance 3872 (Second Reading): Easement with Talawanda School District – Authorized an easement for construction of the Amtrak passenger rail platform. No public comment. Adopted 6-0.
  • Ordinance 3873 (Second Reading): Easement for OATS Trail Phase VI – Authorized easement with Maple Knoll Communities for trail construction. No public comment. Adopted 6-0.
  • Ordinance 3874 (Second Reading): Easement for OATS Trail Phase V – Authorized easement with Clawson Properties I, LLC. Council noted temporary vs. permanent easement. Adopted 6-0.
  • Ordinance 3875 (Second Reading): Appropriation for BUT-Oxford Amtrak Station – Authorized appropriation of property interests from Ledger, LLC for the Amtrak station project. Law Director noted ongoing negotiations and potential mediation. Adopted 6-0.
  • Ordinance 3876 (Second Reading): Supplemental Budget Ordinance – Amended FY 2026 budget to include $50,000 from OPOA settlement funds for the cold shelter. Adopted 6-0.

Key Outcomes

  • Resolutions Adopted:
    • Resolution 7841 (Water treatment plant payment) – Voice vote, all ayes.
    • Resolution 7842 (Mutual police aid agreement) – Voice vote, all ayes.
  • Ordinances Adopted (Second Reading):
    • Ordinance 3870 (Charter amendments, 6 items) – Roll call 6-0.
    • Ordinance 3871 (Remove three-dwelling-unit prohibition) – Roll call 5-1 (Snavely no).
    • Ordinance 3872 (Talawanda easement) – Roll call 6-0.
    • Ordinance 3873 (OATS Phase VI easement) – Roll call 6-0.
    • Ordinance 3874 (OATS Phase V easement) – Roll call 6-0.
    • Ordinance 3875 (Amtrak station appropriation) – Roll call 6-0.
    • Ordinance 3876 (Supplemental budget) – Roll call 6-0.
  • First Reading Introduced: Parking code amendment (Ordinance 3870) – will return for second reading in August.
  • Flock Safety Discussion Postponed: Council delayed further debate to the August 18 meeting to allow the PCRRC to meet on August 6 and formulate a recommendation. Chief Jones requested direction on presenting findings; the city manager noted the current contract can be terminated at its end in February 2027.
  • Announcements: City received a $250,000 federal grant for special event safety barricades; water treatment plant project estimated completion by January 2028; property revaluation in Butler County showed median increase of 19% overall, 15% in Oxford; uptown restroom expected to open before end of July.

Meeting Transcript

Oh, wait, this is the matter. Welcome back, Chief. JJ. Welcome back. Sounds like you had a great adventure. Yes. We're reprimanded for election affairs. There will be more coming out. Nothing that likely made a difference, but all of them that are anti-democratic. Yeah, bright remote is not going to be. Pennsylvania should be hampton. Okay, it's 7 30, so I think we should go ahead and get going. So uh Miss Barber, you recall the role. Mr. Bracken? Here. Ms. Franklin? Here. Miss French? Here. Miss Arnellis. Here. Mr. Snavely? Here. Mayor Smith? Here. All right, we will now do the Pledge of Allegiance if you would like to join us. Congratulations to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one individual with liberty and justice for all. All right, may I have a motion to approve the agenda? So moved. Second. Moved by Vice Mayor French, second by Councilor Arnellis. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? Great. We will start with public participation tonight. And we'll go straight to public comments.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com