OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Oxford, Ohio/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Oxford City Council Meeting - August 18, 2026: Flock Camera Contract Terminated, Multiple Resolutions Passed

City Council — Tuesday, August 18, 2026
BodyOxford, Ohio
SessionCity Council
DateTuesday, August 18, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:00

To go ahead and call the meeting to order.

0:02

Ms.

0:02

Barber, will you please call the role?

Speaker 2

0:06

Mr.

0:06

Vinch.

Speaker 1

0:07

Here.

Speaker 2

0:08

Mr.

0:08

Bracken.

0:09

Here.

0:09

Miss Franklin.

0:10

Here.

0:11

Miss French?

0:12

Here.

0:12

Miss Ornellis.

0:13

Here.

0:14

Mr.

0:14

Snavely.

Speaker 3

0:15

Yes, I'm here.

Speaker 2

0:16

Mayor Smith.

Speaker 1

0:17

Here.

0:18

We will now do the Pledge of Allegiance if you would like to join us.

Speaker 4

0:27

The United States of America.

0:32

One nation.

0:36

And justice for all.

Speaker 1

0:44

Alright, we have a motion to approve the agenda.

Speaker 5

0:47

So moved.

0:48

Second.

Speaker 1

0:51

All those in favor, please say aye.

0:53

Aye.

0:54

Opposed.

0:55

All right.

0:56

We will move straight into public participation.

0:59

And tonight we have a report from Miss Emily Lake Dee from the Oxford Senior Center.

Speaker 6

1:09

Hello, City Council.

1:11

Thank you so much for giving me this time to share what we've been up to.

1:18

Giving away all the stuff.

1:19

So Oxford Seniors.

Speaker 7

1:21

We have been in existence since

Speaker 6

1:23

1953, and our current facility since 1982.

1:28

Our mission is supporting seniors and strengthening community.

1:33

So I'm gonna share some updates.

1:35

The city budget is kind enough to give us financial support every year.

1:40

So I'm gonna focus on the programs that we do get that support from the city for.

1:45

And then I'm also gonna talk about some other things that have been going on.

1:49

It has been a great year.

1:51

So first of all, the big news the thing that we are incredibly excited about is finally the last thing I said last time I presented to city council almost exactly a year ago was we're gonna get these vehicles.

2:05

So things can move slowly.

2:08

Governments can shut down more than once, but yes, just a few weeks ago, we finally got two new fully accessible vehicles funded not only by federal transportation funds, but also by a number of community organizations and donors.

2:25

So I think a few of you came to that event.

2:30

We had a lot of people here to celebrate.

2:32

One of them is a mod 2026 modified minivan with a rear entry ramp, and the other one is a modified Ford van with an electric wheelchair lift.

2:44

We had a ton of people there to celebrate.

2:46

The salesman was there, and he looked at me and he said, I have never seen anything like this in all my years of selling these vehicles.

2:54

And I said, Well, then you're doing it wrong.

2:57

I said, every single person here has contributed to making this happen, and also we might help them or a loved one with these vehicles.

3:05

So we are delighted to have them right there.

3:07

Is my lead driver Chris in the scrubs and our newest um driver Jack?

3:13

So those are some of the faces.

3:14

I have a bunch of other drivers, but those are some of the faces you're gonna see if you need our help to get to a physical therapy appointment or a haircut.

3:23

Um, since last year, and all of my numbers are going to be essentially since I last presented.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Technology and Innovation██████████████████████████████████34%
Public Safety███████████████████19%
Parks and Recreation██████████████████18%
Procedural███████████████15%
Public Engagement████4%
Arts And Culture███3%
Economic Development███3%
Homelessness█1%
Environmental Protection█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Oxford City Council Regular Meeting – August 18, 2026

The Oxford City Council met on Tuesday, August 18, 2026, at 7:30 p.m. at the Courthouse. Key actions included the termination of the Flock Group, Inc. automated license plate reader (ALPR) agreement after extensive public comment and council debate, approval of a parking space rental to Miami University, acceptance of a $250,000 ODNR grant for a synthetic play field, and adoption of a mural recommendation. The consent agenda and two second-reading ordinances were also approved unanimously.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes of the August 4, 2026, City Council meeting were approved.
  • Environmental Commission Report for August 5, 2026, was received.
  • Four resolutions related to police property disposition (surplus property, unclaimed property, contraband, firearms/ammunition) were approved unanimously.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Oxford Seniors Center Annual Report (Emily Liechty, Executive Director): Presented a detailed update on programs and services from August 2025 to present. Highlights included: 6,869 rides provided to 230 individuals; 984 individuals received outreach support; 401 people received insurance counseling during Open Enrollment, resulting in over $385,000 in savings; 12,819 home-delivered meals and 2,137 congregate lunches served; 1,327 days of care through the Community Adult Day Service; 25 weekly activities with 1,276 active participants and average daily attendance of 51; partnerships with 16 organizations including free COVID test distribution (300), free gun locks (75), free tax returns (259), and community meals (approx. 200 per Monday night). Recognized Sabrina Jewell as Ohio OSHIIP Coordinator of the Year.
  • Mr. Allan Winkler (925 Cedar Drive): Spoke on behalf of the Oxford Community Arts Center, requesting a written statement of support from City Council to present to Miami University's Board of Trustees regarding a lease revision needed to qualify for historic tax credits (approximately $3.5 million). The Arts Center had received $100,000 from the State of Ohio.
  • Ms. Ann Fuehrer (Dana Drive): Emphasized the role of city commissions (PCRRC, Housing Advisory Commission) in bridging residents and government. Discussed affordable housing concerns: more than half of Oxford renters are housing-burdened, recent $100/month rent increase at Miami Mobile Home Park, and challenges of eviction. Encouraged public education and development of emergency shelter in partnership with Sheltering Oxford.
  • Ms. LaTricia Hillman (820 Clover Circle): Spoke during the Flock item as chair of PCRRC, summarizing the commission's August 6 meeting and its 5-1 vote to recommend continued use of ALPR technology with additional safeguards (transparency portal, reduced sharing, training, audits, legal review of contract). Emphasized the recommendation was not a blanket endorsement.
  • Dr. Woods Hayes (614 S. Locust St.): Opposed Flock, arguing the nationwide database of 80,000 cameras creates a surveillance network beyond local control. Cited false positives, constitutional challenges, and the inability of local restrictions to prevent federal access. Requested termination of the contract.
  • Ms. Lisa Biales (6317 Buckley Rd.): Challenged claims about Flock's accuracy and security, citing examples of unauthorized access and potential misuse (stalking, tracking reproductive healthcare). Argued the system could be used to track people, not just vehicles, and requested contract termination.
  • Mr. Timothy Ritze (6563 Stillwell Becket Rd.): Framed objections as four constitutional questions about warrantless tracking, general surveillance, retroactive justification, and contracting with private entities to bypass the Bill of Rights. Urged termination and a permanent ban on similar tracking networks.
  • Ms. Elizabeth Wardle (22 Lantern Ridge Rd.): Argued Flock is a private, for-profit company that controls data beyond local control. Cited reports of federal access without local knowledge, questioned evidence of crime reduction, and raised concerns about false alerts and infrastructure costs. Described the camera network as a "geofence" around Oxford.
  • Mr. Steve Sullivan (104 Marti Ct.): Distinguished ALPR systems from red-light cameras, arguing Flock collects information on innocent people. Cited examples of data used to infer activities like marijuana purchases or reproductive healthcare, and questioned the trustworthiness of private data storage and two-factor authentication.
  • Ms. Jordan Gresham (6095 Contreras Rd.): Opposed cameras, questioning accuracy (citing a 71% failure rate in Roseville, CA), rejecting the left-right political divide, and arguing Flock constitutes mass surveillance with potential for abuse (stalking by officers).
  • Ms. Janis Dutton (302 W. Vine St.): Cited a Texas constable shutting down Flock cameras, argued Oxford's cameras record First Amendment activity, and stated proposed safeguards are inadequate because the City loses control after data is shared.
  • Mr. Juan (Oxford Commons): Expressed shared concerns about civil liberties and living under a surveillance state, requesting removal of cameras.
  • Mr. Evan Pitts (305 Ericson Dr.): With professional IT experience, categorized concerns into four areas: constitutional privacy, Flock's data protection, misconduct by users, and technological failures. Argued the architecture prevents local ownership and data cannot be reformed through safeguards.
  • Ms. Linda Musmeci-Kimball (724 Melinda Dr.): Referenced City Council Resolution No. 3935 (August 2003) affirming civil rights, argued Flock is part of a national mass-surveillance system, and stated no number of band-aid measures change the fundamental threat to privacy. Requested termination.

Discussion Items

  • Resolution A – Flock Group, Inc. Agreement (ALPR Cameras): Assistant City Manager Jessica Greene presented staff report and PCRRC recommendations. After extensive public comment, Council debated options. Councilor Snavely proposed an amendment to terminate the agreement (change title, strike whereas clauses, replace Section 1). The amendment passed 5-2 (Snavely, Franklin, French, Ornelas, Vinch in favor; Bracken, Mayor Smith opposed). The main motion (resolution as amended to terminate) passed 6-1 (all except Bracken). Council discussion included trust in OPD but distrust of Flock, concerns about data control, and the weight of potential crime-solving vs. privacy risks. Vice Mayor French noted the decision was not easy but believed Oxford is not the community for this technology. Councilor Bracken expressed concern about ending the contract without restrictions vs. having restrictions. Ultimately, the contract will be terminated at the earliest date allowed by law.
  • Resolution B – Parking Space Rental to Miami University (77 spaces on South Campus Avenue): Chief Jones presented. Councilors Snavely and French expressed frustration that Miami University did not consult the City about the arena project causing the parking need. Despite concerns, the resolution passed 3-0 (Snavely, French, Ornelas; other four recused due to Miami employment). Council requested that Miami be informed the approval was grudging.
  • Resolution C – ODNR Grant for Synthetic Play Field: Parks Director Chad Smith reported the City was selected for a $250,000 capital improvement grant for a synthetic turf field at Oxford Community Park. Passed 7-0.
  • Resolution D – Mural at 909 S. Main Street: Assistant City Manager Greene presented the Public Arts Commission recommendation for a mural by Key Detail, tied to the upcoming Amtrak station. Passed 7-0 after positive public comment.
  • First Reading – Ordinance for Utility Easement with Duke Energy for EV Fast Chargers: Service Director Dreisbach explained the need for an easement for a pad-mounted transformer to power six Level 3 chargers (two at municipal building). First reading; will return in September.
  • First Reading – Zoning Code Amendment (Uptown District Retail Services): Community Development Director Perry described text amendment to allow retail services up to 20,000 square feet as a permitted use (excluding restaurants/bars over 10,000 sq ft). First reading; will return in September.
  • Second Reading – Annexation Petition (Ambassadors’ Pointe Community Church, 6.753 acres): No changes from first reading; map provided. Passed 7-0 on roll call.
  • Second Reading – Supplemental Budget Ordinance No. 5 (FY2026): Finance Director Ridenour noted one change: added $10,000 in revenue/grants from Butler County Metro Parks and Parks for Community Foundation for netting at the Tri-Ballfield. Passed 7-0 on roll call.

Key Outcomes

  • Flock Camera Contract Terminated: Council voted 5-2 to amend the resolution to termination, then 6-1 to adopt the amended resolution. The City will end its agreement with Flock Group, Inc. at the earliest legal date. No alternative vendor or permanent ban was adopted, but further discussion may occur.
  • Parking Rental Approved: 77 city parking spaces on South Campus Avenue rented to Miami University for $101,640 per semester (based on $12/day per space). Passed 3-0 with four recusals.
  • ODNR Grant Application Authorized: City Manager authorized to apply for and accept $250,000 for synthetic play field at Oxford Community Park. Unanimous.
  • Mural Approved: Resolution accepting Public Arts Commission recommendation for mural at 909 S. Main Street by Key Detail. Unanimous.
  • Two Ordinances Adopted (Second Reading): Annexation of 6.753 acres (Ambassadors’ Pointe) and supplemental budget amendments both passed unanimously.
  • Two Ordinances Introduced (First Reading): EV charger easement and zoning code text amendment will be considered for final adoption in September.
  • Public Support Requested: Council agreed to consider providing a written statement of support for the Oxford Community Arts Center's lease revision request to Miami University, as requested by Mr. Winkler.

Announcements & Communications

  • Council and staff made brief remarks. Upcoming meetings noted, including a Capital Improvement Plan Work Session on September 14 and next regular meeting on September 15.

Meeting Transcript

To go ahead and call the meeting to order. Ms. Barber, will you please call the role? Mr. Vinch. Here. Mr. Bracken. Here. Miss Franklin. Here. Miss French? Here. Miss Ornellis. Here. Mr. Snavely. Yes, I'm here. Mayor Smith. Here. We will now do the Pledge of Allegiance if you would like to join us. The United States of America. One nation. And justice for all. Alright, we have a motion to approve the agenda. So moved. Second. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed. All right. We will move straight into public participation. And tonight we have a report from Miss Emily Lake Dee from the Oxford Senior Center. Hello, City Council. Thank you so much for giving me this time to share what we've been up to. Giving away all the stuff. So Oxford Seniors. We have been in existence since 1953, and our current facility since 1982. Our mission is supporting seniors and strengthening community. So I'm gonna share some updates. The city budget is kind enough to give us financial support every year. So I'm gonna focus on the programs that we do get that support from the city for. And then I'm also gonna talk about some other things that have been going on. It has been a great year. So first of all, the big news the thing that we are incredibly excited about is finally the last thing I said last time I presented to city council almost exactly a year ago was we're gonna get these vehicles. So things can move slowly. Governments can shut down more than once, but yes, just a few weeks ago, we finally got two new fully accessible vehicles funded not only by federal transportation funds, but also by a number of community organizations and donors. So I think a few of you came to that event. We had a lot of people here to celebrate.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com