Payson Town Council Special Meeting on Town Manager Employment and Personnel Policies - June 30, 2026
Payson Town Council Special Meeting – June 30, 2026
The Payson Town Council held a special meeting on June 30, 2026, at 5:00 p.m. in the Town Hall Council Chambers. The meeting was called to discuss the Town Manager’s employment, personnel policies, and pending litigation related to the former Economic Development Director. After a motion to enter executive session (4–1, with two abstentions), the council recessed at 5:09 p.m., reconvened at 6:30 p.m., and adjourned at 6:40 p.m. No formal action was taken following the executive session.
Discussion Items
- Executive Session Motion and Vote: Council Member Scott Nossek moved, and Council Member Dallin Haws seconded, to enter executive session for all three agenda items (A.1, A.2, A.3). Mayor Stephen Otto expressed objection, stating he did not want to be unable to discuss matters publicly afterward. The Town Attorney noted that Town Manager Darren Coldwell had been given 24-hour notice and did not request public discussion. The vote was 4–1 in favor: Vice Mayor Susan Tubbs and Council Members Brett Flaherty, Dallin Haws, and Scott Nossek voted yes; Mayor Stephen Otto voted no; Council Members Charlie Bell and Jim Ferris abstained.
- Town Manager’s Report (After Executive Session): Mr. Coldwell explained the hiring process for former Economic Development Director Greg Martinez. He stated that every required step was followed: advertising, selection of top three candidates, interviews by himself, the Deputy Town Manager, and the Human Resources Director. A background check revealed no charges (only accusations), and Mr. Martinez’s employment ended after he was placed on administrative leave and subsequently resigned. Mr. Coldwell emphasized that the resignation occurred before a newspaper article was published.
- Council Comments: Multiple council members expressed support for Mr. Coldwell, stating that the meeting was intended to answer questions raised by a newspaper article and social media. They affirmed that his actions followed town policies and that he retained their confidence.
Key Outcomes
- No Formal Action Taken: After the executive session, the council directed that no additional action be taken regarding the Town Manager’s employment or the other agenda items.
- Council Support for Town Manager: Council members publicly stated their full support for Mr. Coldwell and expressed appreciation for his handling of the situation.
- Future Personnel Process Improvement: Council members noted that suggestions discussed during the session would help improve safety and health in town departments moving forward.
Meeting Transcript
Oh oh my goodness, we have overperformers. I guess I don't know what I'm prepared for, but I call a special meeting of the common council of town of pace into order June 30th, 2026 at 5 p.m. Uh Megan, would you give us the roll call? Let the record reflect that all council members are present. And we have no call to the public, special meeting. Purpose of the meeting, A1 discussion and possible action, including consultation with the town attorney for purpose of discussing or considering of the town manager's employment, including but not limited to his response, not limited to his hiring practices, employee screening, and performance of administrative responsibilities. The town council may vote to discuss this matter in executive session pursuant to ARS 38-431.03 paragraphs A one and three. Uh we do all of these together. Yeah, Mayor and Council, I suggest just one motion for all three items, just so you're not back and forth. Okay. A two is discussion with the town attorney for legal advice regarding the town's personnel policies, including hiring policies, practices, and the use of background checks. The town council may vote to discuss this matter in executive session pursuant to the same ARS that I just read. A three discussions, possible action with the town attorney regarding any pending or contemplated litigation related to complaints involving the former economic development director. The town council may vote to discuss this matter in executive session pursuant to ARS 38-4313, section A3 through and four. Uh I would entertain a motion to retire to executive session. I'll make a motion that we move to executive session for A1, E2, and A3. Transparency, transparency. I second the motion. Do we do any discussion? Yes. Order. Signs down, you can have signs, but you can't block anybody's view. So uh all right. Uh so mayor and council, so just so just as a matter of just also clarity. So we can go to executive session for these. There is the possibility of public action that can be taken following e-session. So you could you may come out and and take action. Okay. And yes. I I object to the executive session. Um all that we know some of us may know. We go in the executive discuss uh uh session, it's gonna be discussed, and then we're gonna come out and regardless of what the vote is or what happens, actions, we're not gonna be able to talk about it. But even though we know, I would like to think that maybe we ask Darren Caldwell since it's his, you know, the I think the attacks are the fronts are on him, he can decide whether or not it's a public thing or not. As far as executive session, I do not want to go in there, and I may refuse to go in there because I don't want to be hamstrung order hamstrung, you know, with what I can explain and discuss later on. So can I well I was gonna say mayor count so you have a motion and a second, so you can certainly vote no. I mean, I think I you would probably want to take the vote, and then we can make a determination from there of how to proceed. I I want to hear from Darren. How about if we go into executive session? I get directive to what I can say in public since it is a personnel issue, and then I'll come out and tell you guys everything. Yeah, but how long I yeah, I I want to be able to talk about this outside. When we go in there, whatever's discussed, I can't I can't talk about. Yeah, and I think it's important that these issues, these things need to be aired further at please. We have a motion and a second, so you just need to vote. Maybe there's other discussion. Any other comments? Oh well, I I do he brought up an interesting question here. What happens if all council members do not go into executive session? What what's the some of its personnel and can't be discussed in public? I mean, you are essentially putting the town in a precarious situation, possibly. I mean, if we're going to be talking about explain precarious situation, can we please we have we're trying to hear legal advice?
openpublica.com