Peekskill Planning Commission Meeting – August 12, 2025
Peekskill Planning Commission Meeting – August 12, 2025
The Peekskill Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Tuesday, August 12, 2025, at 7:30 PM in the Common Council Chamber. The agenda included a presentation on a cumulative environmental impact report for waterfront transit-oriented development, a status update on the Broad Howard mixed-use project, continued public hearings, new public hearings, a SEQRA review, and several votes on site plan approvals and recommendations to the Common Council.
Consent Calendar
- Extension of Final Site Plan Approval (P25-031): Michael Vara, owner of a single-family dwelling lot at 1763 Park Street, was granted a one-year extension to begin construction on both subdivided lots. The motion passed unanimously.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Westchester Sports Arena (P25-030): No members of the public spoke.
- Grand Street Cannabis (P25-029): Multiple residents from nearby properties (601, 605, 625 Roosevelt Avenue, 531 Smith Street) expressed strong opposition, citing concerns over odors, health impacts from emissions, proximity to schools and parks, inadequate notification, and negative effects on neighborhood character. One speaker (Chapman Manzer) voiced support, stating he knew the applicants and believed the odor mitigation would work.
Discussion Items
- Cumulative Environmental Impact Report (CEIR) for Waterfront TOD: Sarah Yaekel of BFJ Planning presented the proposed scope of a cumulative study for three city-owned parking lots east of the Metro-North tracks. The study will cover approximately 276 residential units, 11,000 sq ft commercial, 125 hotel rooms, and 372 parking spaces. The commission discussed including downtown retail competition, connectivity to downtown, and design recommendations. A public hearing on the report outline is scheduled for September 9, 2025, with written comments due by that date. A public information meeting will be held September 6, 2025.
- Broad Howard LLC Status Update: Chuck Lesnick provided an update on the proposed 3.5-story mixed-use residential building on North Broad, Main, and Howard Streets. He reported progress on negotiations for a PILOT, pursuit of low-income housing tax credits, brownfields credits, lot consolidation, and collaboration with the city on a DRI award. Construction is expected to begin in late 2026, with remediation starting earlier. The project may require another extension as variances have expired.
- Joseph G. Thompson Architect – Proposed Five-Story, 41-Unit Residential Building (P24-038): A presentation was given for a new building on the northwestern corner of Main and Water Streets in the WF2 Waterfront District. The project seeks a bonus height special permit and includes 41 units, underground and surface parking, and improvements to Main Street. The commission discussed parking (19 spaces needed from city lot), floodplain compliance, traffic, and connectivity. The board declared itself lead agency for SEQRA review.
Key Outcomes
- Marco Mandra Woodworking Business (Z25-005/P25-016): The public hearing was closed, and final site plan approval was granted with conditions, including submission of a revised facade rendering for review offline. The building will feature aluminum composite panels and restored brick, with deliveries via backing down Woodlawn Street.
- Robin Urbina – Conversion of Interior Garage to Office/Retail/Residential (Z25-006/P25-011): The public hearing was closed, and final site plan approval was granted. Conditions require sprinklering the ground floor and making the new ground-floor apartment ADA adaptable.
- Westchester Sports Arena (P25-030): The commission declared itself lead agency and issued a negative declaration under SEQRA. The public hearing remains open until final site plan approval, pending Common Council action on a special permit.
- Grand Street Cannabis (P25-029): Following a public hearing, the commission voted (4-1) to forward a positive recommendation to the Common Council to approve the special permit for a cannabis cultivation facility at 710 Washington Street. The public hearing remains open for further comment.
- Minutes: The minutes from the May 13, 2025 meeting were deferred to the next meeting.
- Meeting Adjourned at approximately 10:45 PM.
Meeting Transcript
Commission meeting for today, Tuesday, August 12th. We're gonna start off the agenda. We have a presentation that the city from the city considering waterfront transit-oriented development. So this is just a presentation for the board members. We could have some questions. It's not open to the public right at the moment, but there will be a time for input later on. But so call up whoever's doing it first. Yeah, I wanted to say just a couple of words of explanation and introduction, and then I'll I'll um get uh Sarah's setup. So um as we've discussed the city's, you know, interested in redeveloping three of the city owned uh commuter parking lots on the waterfront um for housing and mixed use. As a part of that, the city has um engaged BFJ planning to help us conduct a cumulative study of the cumulative impacts of the develop overall developments. Um and this is just to say that we're looking at the the bigger picture. And e before each development comes in before the planning commission, they'll have to conduct their own individual um site plan review. Um excuse me, environmental review. I wanted to make that very clear to you and to everyone watching. Um we will have uh public events, including a public hearing before the planning commission for people to comment on the scope. Right now we're really just looking at the scope, basically. What are we going to study? Not the results of the study, but what are we going to study? Um and we'll be having an event in early September that we're inviting everyone to come and just learn more about the project and and learn more about the environmental review. So I'm gonna introduce uh Sarah Yaekel, who's a principal at BFJ Planning, who's leading our our um planning study here, our environmental review, and I'm gonna get her set up on the laptop. So bear with me. You can probably get in there. Oh, good. Why is that? Can you minimize that strip? Sure. Possibly. Thanks. Thanks, Carol. Good evening, Chair Stern, members of the planning commission. As Carol said, my name is Sarah Yegel. I'm a principal with BFJ planning. We've been retained by the city to assist in the cumulative review of the environmental impacts associated with the three transit-oriented development sites. Um tonight I'm just going to walk you through a document that you all have uh received in your packets, which is the report outline, the proposed report outline for the cumulative environmental impact report. We're at the very preliminary stages of this study and are really in the process of scoping out the table of contents to make sure that all of the issues that you would like addressed in the study, that the uh common council would like addressed in the study as well as the public are included in this document. So I'm gonna start with just a quick introduction of our team, talk a little bit about the proposed project for those watching at home or in the audience, uh, get into what is this cumulative environmental impact report, the purpose, the contents, and then a little bit of a just a status update on some traffic and parking work that we've done to date and talk about next steps. Uh so again, BFJ planning is the prime consultant on this project. I'll be joined by Emily Tolbert as project manager, our traffic engineer George Ackmar, and then Nick Sidera, our project planner. We're also in jo uh joined in this effort by Urbanomics who specialize in socioeconomic and demographic analysis. They'll be providing uh in-depth analysis of socioeconomic and fiscal impacts related to the projects. And then finally, we're joined by Ramble, who are an international engineering firm specializing in infrastructure and climate adaptation and resiliency. Given the waterfront location of these sites, we thought that that was critically important to have on the team uh that special expertise. So uh I think you may be familiar, I believe you probably are familiar with these, but the city is looking to redevelop um three city-owned parking lots east of the Metro North Railroad tracks. You can see the locations uh on the map there. And the city issued an uh a request for expression of interest for parking lot redevelopment and is currently negotiating with three private development groups for the redevelopment. And at some point in the future, we'll be working through conditional dispositions of those lands, and ultimately probably zoning text or map changes and site plan approval before your board. The cumulative development that we're looking at for these three sites is approximately 276 residential units, approximately 11,000 square feet of ground floor commercial, 125 hotel rooms, and 372 parking spaces. So these would be across the three sites, and is really the foundation of this cumulative study. So what is a cumulative environmental impact report? As I said last night to the common council, as a term that I uh I coined.
openpublica.com