Pre-Agenda Interviews for HRC & Public Art/Civic Design Appointments – March 11, 2026
Pre-Agenda Interviews for Historic Review Commission and Public Art & Civic Design Commission Appointments
The City Council Committee on Hearings and Policy convened at 1:30 PM on March 11, 2026, to conduct pre‑agenda interviews for seven nominees to the Historic Review Commission (HRC), the Public Art Committee, and the Civic Design Committee. The session featured candidate introductions, discussion of preservation philosophy, and councilmember questions regarding balance, community engagement, and the risk of weaponizing historic designations.
Discussion Items
- Historic Review Commission nominees (4 positions):
- K. Chase Patterson (term ending 2027) – Lifelong Pittsburgher, CEO of Urban Academy; stressed that preservation and progress can coexist, and that historic buildings are “opportunities to connect the past to the future.”
- Catherine Blauvelt (term ending 2029) – Librarian with expertise in rare books and architectural history; described her passion for Pittsburgh’s diverse architecture and her family’s daily use of historic buildings.
- Luna Fruendsgaard (term ending 2029) – Design principal at Indivina Associates Architects; highlighted experience repurposing historic structures (Terminal Building, Gulf Tower) while respecting architectural integrity.
- Martha Isler (term ending 2028) – Secretary of CCAC Board of Trustees, 43‑year Squirrel Hill resident; led restoration of the Neal Log House (c. 1795) and raised over $300,000 for its historic preservation.
- Public Art Committee nominee:
- Emily Stedge (term concurrent with Mayor) – Director of Education & Communications at Pittsburgh Center for Arts and Media; emphasized community arts education and the power of public art to break down boundaries.
- Civic Design Committee nominees (2 positions):
- James Hill (term concurrent with Mayor) – Lifelong Pittsburgher, worked at Cultural Trust and city; focused on the civic role of public buildings (fire stations, parks) in shaping neighborhood identity.
- Kendall Soler (term concurrent with Mayor) – Interior design director at Shelton Design, master’s from Chatham; interested in balancing preservation with modern function, and in underutilized industrial spaces.
Councilmember Questions and Dialogue:
- Councilmember Strasberger asked how nominees weigh architectural significance versus historical events inside a building. Nominees generally agreed on a case‑by‑case approach, guided by staff recommendations and community input.
- Councilmember (likely Warwick) raised concerns about the “weaponization” of the HRC to block housing or development. Nominees stressed using clear guidelines, avoiding political use, and ensuring that preservation does not lead to long‑term vacancy.
- Councilmember Woolworth discussed the tension between rigid historic standards and practical reuse (e.g., replacing wood windows with vinyl to reduce costs). Nominees favored flexibility and common sense, and noted that the 1979 regulations may need updating.
- Councilmember Warwick referenced the East Carson Street Historic District and the “volcano” restaurant project that was killed, leaving a vacant building. Nominees acknowledged the double‑edged sword of preservation.
- Councilmember (Strasberger) asked about equitable community engagement, especially when only a loud minority shows up. Nominees emphasized the need to discern genuine community support from organized opposition.
- Councilmember Woolworth also asked about making city processes more accessible to artists. Emily Stedge advocated for transparent funding and community education.
Key Outcomes
- All seven nominees completed their pre‑agenda interviews; each interview was formally recorded as “Held” in the minutes.
- Councilmembers expressed appreciation for the nominees’ qualifications and commitment.
- No votes were taken during the interviews; formal appointment resolutions are expected to be advanced to a future Council meeting.
- Notable interruption: a tornado warning alert sounded during Councilmember (Strasberger’s) questioning, briefly pausing the proceedings.
Meeting Transcript
Good afternoon and welcome to the pre-agenda interview for Wednesday, March 11, 2026 for the Historic Review Commission. The Public Art Committee and the Civic Design Committee, we're going to take the Historic Review Commission first. If the clerk will please read the title of the bills. Bill 131, resolution appointing Catherine Blavelt as a member of the Historic Review Commission for a term to expire January 1st, 2029. Bill 132, resolution appointing Kay Chase Patterson as a member of the Historic Review Commission. For a term to expire January 1, 2027. Bill 133, resolution appointing Luna Froonsgard as a member of the Historic Review Commission for a term to expire January 1, 2029. And Bill 134, resolution appointing Martha Eisler as a member of the Historic Review Commission for a term to expire January 1, 2028. Bill 147, resolution appointing Emily Stigge as a member of the Public Art Committee of the Public Art and Civic Design Commission for a term concurrent with that of the mayor. Bill 148, resolution appointing James Hill as a member of the Civic Design Committee of the Public Art and Civic Design Commission. Four term concurrent with that of the mayor. And Bill 150, resolution appointing Kendall Solar as a member of the Civic Design Committee of the Public Art and Civic Design Commission for a time concurrent with that of the mayor. Thank you. For the record, we are currently joined by Councilman Schrosberger, although I suspect other members will uh trickle in shortly. With that, what I would like to do is open it up to our nominees. If you would please introduce yourself, tell us who you are, tell us why you're willing or want or wanting to serve on this important commission. Um, and then we'll turn it over to members for questions, and we were also joined by Councilman Warwick. So we'll start with Mr. Paterson. Uh thank you, Council President. My name is Chase Patterson, and I'm honored to be considered for appointment to the Pis Pittsburgh Historic Review Commission. I am a lifelong Pittsburger, uh having never lived anywhere else, and I'm proud of it. Uh my understanding of neighborhoods and the importance of place began early in my life. I grew up in Beachview where my mother still lives today, and my uncles and aunts lived uh when they were very young as well. And some of my earliest memories of community and place um come from places like John's Drugstore, the Neighborhood Foodland, St. Catherine's, and the Carnegie Library. Uh those places were more than buildings for me and more than storefronts. They were anchors for our daily life. Uh places where my family gathered and the spirit of our community was felt. And so watching Beachview evolve over the years has taught me that neighborhoods change. But the physical spaces within them carry the memory of the people who built and sustained them. And so that's a lessons that I've that I've learned in my career, and for nearly a decade serving as a CEO of the Urban Academy in Larmer, I first stepped into leadership there, and many of my advisors encouraged us to tear down our school building. But what I understood then was something that I've learned, and that is that place and preservation and the future are all intertwined. And so I believe that the bones of buildings carry the stories of neighborhoods. And my experience has shaped my perspective deeply. And so I believe that historic buildings and historic places are not obstacles to progress. They're opportunities to connect the past to the future. And so when preserved thoughtfully, they provide cultural continuity, identity, and the dignity that communities need and deserve. So if confirmed, which I hope to be, I would approach this role with humility, thoughtful judgment, and deep respect for the neighborhoods whose stories are written all across the history of Pittsburgh. This is a city that has always reinvented itself, and the work of this commission helps to ensure that as we grow, we do not lose sight of where we've come from. So thank you all for your consideration. I look forward to your questions, and I would be honored to serve. Thank you, members of the council. My name is Catherine Blavelt, and I'm honored to be considered for appointment for the Historic Review Commission. I am a librarian with 10 years of professional experience in Rare Books Special Collections and Research Services. Before that, I spent two years managing the Rare Books and Special Collections Department, re-establishing public access to the collection and directing the conservation lab at the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh Main Branch. Prior to Pittsburgh, I spent six years at the New York Public Library's Stephen A. Schwartzman building where I worked in both the General Research Division and the Art and Architecture Division. I hold a Master's of Library and Information Science with a certificate in special collections from the University of Illinois Urban Champaign. Throughout my career, I've been I have been drawn to architectural history.
openpublica.com