OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Porterville, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Porterville City Council Special Meeting - September 17, 2026: District 3 Vacancy Interviews and Appointment

City Council — Thursday, September 17, 2026
BodyPorterville, California
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, September 17, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:00

Invocation if anyone would like to give

Unassigned speaker

0:02

one.

Speaker 1

0:06

Salute.

0:07

Pledge.

Speaker 2

0:08

I pledge a little bit of the flag of the United States of America.

0:13

And to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God.

0:18

Indivisible rule.

Speaker 3

0:19

Liberty and justice for all.

Speaker 4

0:35

Holy and gracious God.

0:37

We thank you for your presence always and everywhere, and particularly tonight in this city council chamber.

0:45

Be with our elected representatives with city staff and with all who have come to participate in the governance of Porterville.

0:54

We ask for courage, stability, steadiness, and peace for all who have come to speak, and for receptive minds and hearts and all who are gathered to listen.

1:05

We ask for your justice, fairness, and wisdom to be at work tonight in this chamber as our council members complete the process of filling the open seat on our council.

1:15

Protect each of us from becoming disoriented by our own small needs and selfish goals.

1:21

Embolden each of us to speak and act with clarity needed in difficult times.

1:26

Protect our community from the judgment warranted when we turn our backs on those in need, or on the land, water, and many peoples of this precious valley where you have brought us together in the nick of time.

1:40

Forgive our city its sins and shortcomings where we fall short, help us to do better, and where we have sinned, help us to repent and to reconcile with those we have sinned against.

1:50

We ask these things in the name of the one who can go where we cannot go and complete what we cannot complete.

1:57

Thy will be done.

1:58

Amen.

Unassigned speaker

2:02

Okay,

Speaker 1

2:02

I've not seen anyone else.

2:04

Please be seated.

2:12

Moving on to oral communication, this is the opportunity opportunity to address the council on any matter listed under schedule matters.

2:19

Unless additional time is authorized by the council, each speaker shall be limited to three minutes.

2:24

The total time for public comments shall not exceed one hour.

Speaker 5

2:30

As the council considers the vacant district three seat, I encourage you to follow a fair opening.

2:36

Diane.

2:37

As the council considers filling the vacant district three seat, I encourage you to follow a fair, open and transparent process.

2:44

Tim Vanny was considered was a candidate in the most recent district three election, and voters had an opportunity to consider him and cast votes for him.

2:53

That is relevant information the council must weigh alongside the qualifications and community service of every eligible applicant.

3:00

Because council members have emphasized the importance of elections.

3:04

Please explain how the voters' previous choices factor into this appointment.

3:08

Whatever decision you make, district three residents deserve a clear process and a representative committed to serving the entire community.

3:16

As a district three resident, I am asking you to support

Unassigned speaker

3:20

and

Speaker 5

3:20

appoint Tim Banne to fill the seat vacated by Councilmember Reevas.

3:24

Tim is a proven community volunteer.

3:26

His record demonstrates the commitment, responsibility, and understanding of District Three that this position requires.

3:32

Appointing the candidate who most recently sought and earned votes for this seat is the fairest and most evidence-based option available.

3:39

It respects District Three voters while recognizing Tim's established record of community service.

Speaker 1

3:45

Thank you, Bear.

Speaker 3

3:52

Jean Valpiel, do you have my address and information?

3:55

I can't expand on what Karen just said.

3:59

But I do want to remind you, you do say repeatedly, people should have the choice to choose what they want in their district.

4:08

And you even have a vote coming up on a proposition that you want to pass.

4:13

So I ask you, look in your heart, follow what you advise us, and just pick Tim Vanny tonight because he came so close, just a handful of votes away from Mr.

4:28

Rivas.

4:28

Therefore, he's clearly someone that that district wants.

4:33

Thank you.

Speaker 1

4:34

Thank

Unassigned speaker

4:35

you.

Unassigned speaker

4:48

Do you candidates agree the flock cameras are a violation of the Constitution and our individual liberties, knowing that the federal Supreme Court ruled the acquisition of cell site location information and location history qualify as Fourth Amendment searches.

Speaker 6

5:03

Location history is what these cameras collect.

5:06

Furthermore, will you agree to do your due diligence the next time a new policing technology comes to this council that could violate the rights of your constituents?

5:16

This was obviously not done with Flock, and if it wasn't for Chief Raider, our contract would be even more detrimental to our rights as it had little to no safeguards in place.

5:26

Hopefully, more thought was put into the drones program.

5:30

Will you look at more alternatives to crime reduction than more guns, more surveillance, and more police?

5:36

Plenty of programs exist in cities with far higher rates of violent crime that have greater crime reduction stats.

5:44

There are alternatives to flock that still involve ALPR cameras.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Community Engagement███████████████████████████████████35%
Procedural██████████████████████████████30%
Homelessness█████████9%
Public Safety██████6%
Budget Equity Analysis██████6%
Miscellaneous████4%
Economic Development████4%
Fiscal Sustainability███3%
Youth Programs█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Porterville City Council Special Meeting - September 17, 2026: District 3 Vacancy Interviews and Appointment

The Porterville City Council held a special meeting on September 17, 2026, at 5:30 PM, primarily to conduct public interviews of three applicants for the vacant District 3 City Council seat and to appoint a candidate to fill the vacancy. The vacancy was created by the resignation of Councilmember A.J. Rivas on August 21, 2026. The council received applications from Michael Carley, Darrin Crowell, and Tim Vanni.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Multiple public speakers expressed support for Tim Vanni, citing his recent candidacy for the same seat (finishing just a handful of votes behind Mr. Rivas), his community service, Olympic background, and status as a "non-controversial person" who could bring the community together. Speakers included Diane, Jean Valpiel, Mr. Walker, Karen Anderson, Thail Silly, Paul Flores (via phone), and Susan Ginoco.
  • Several speakers argued that appointing the candidate who most recently sought and earned votes for the seat was the fairest and most evidence-based option.
  • Gerald Duran argued that the council should treat the vacancy as a new decision, separating the previous election from the current appointment. He noted that before the 2024 elections, both Mr. Rivas and Mr. Crowell considered running, and this history is relevant context. He also raised a broader question about whether such vacancies should be filled by appointment or special election.
  • Kirk Williams spoke in favor of Darrin Crowell, describing him as a "peacemaker" with wisdom and quality character.
  • Marie Wagstaff spoke in support of Michael Carley, highlighting his "practical wisdom," courage, honesty, and years of service at Porterville College.
  • Greg Shelton argued against the logic of automatically appointing the person who finished second in the previous election, referencing past appointments that did not follow that pattern. He also criticized the process as favoring candidates who had never run for office.
  • Jesse Vasquez opposed Tim Vanni, stating Vanni had called him a Nazi on social media and accusing him of being connected with "PCAN" and a corrupt chamber of commerce. He provided paperwork to the council.
  • One speaker asked candidates about Flock cameras and constitutional liberties, urging due diligence on policing technology.

Discussion Items

  • Interview Process: The city manager outlined the process: each applicant was given up to five minutes for an opening statement, followed by questions from each council member. The order of applicants was randomly determined: Michael Carley first, Darrin Crowell second, Tim Vanni third. Each council member asked the same question to all three applicants, with the order of answers rotating.
  • Opening Statements:
    • Michael Carley emphasized his 26 years at Porterville College, service on the county redistricting advisory committee, board service for Valley Adult Day Services, and the importance of listening to community input and balancing competing interests.
    • Darrin Crowell highlighted his lifelong residence in Porterville, work with adults with developmental disabilities, experience in probation (including opening a juvenile boot camp), and focus on service and compassion.
    • Tim Vanni stressed his Olympic journey, community support, coaching at Porterville High School, refusal to take campaign donations, and love for his country and community.
  • Question 1 (Councilman Green): What is the role of city council—to set policy or manage the city?
    • Carley: The role is to set policy, not run day-to-day operations; the city manager handles daily work. He emphasized hiring the best city manager.
    • Crowell: The role is more than just setting policy; it involves listening to the people, discussing thoroughly, and following up on policies.
    • Vanni: The council sets policy and together moves the city forward, listening to residents to find a clear direction and general consensus.
  • Question 2 (Councilman Beltran): With limited city funds, how would you decide what to spend money on while ensuring taxpayers get the most value?
    • Crowell: Prioritize by talking to citizens, understanding needs versus wants, and examining where funds are going before prioritizing.
    • Vanni: Balance the budget, prioritize public services, utilities, and infrastructure; be a "saver" and seek block grants.
    • Carley: Listen to the community and staff, balance competing interests, be creative with resources like grants, but don't spend money the city doesn't have.
  • Question 3 (Vice Mayor McCurdy): Tell us about a time you brought people with different viewpoints together to solve a problem. What role did you play and what was the outcome?
    • Vanni: As president of an HOA, passed special assessments for a new roof and siding; as chair of a CIF coaches board, set criteria for seeding wrestlers.
    • Carley: Chaired the college's strategic planning committee, gathered input from faculty, staff, administrators, and students across the college to create a strategic plan focused on student success.
    • Crowell: Coordinated the evacuation of 80–90 juvenile offenders during a wildfire, working with the sheriff's department, school superintendent, and probation staff to safely relocate them.
  • Question 4 (Mayor Meister): What is the financial summary of the city and what are the priority projects?
    • Carley: Noted high tax rate but limited revenue, unfunded pension liabilities, tight budget; emphasized need for economic development and diversification, repaving streets, and several projects (library, community center). Could not provide specific department budgets.
    • Crowell: Estimated 30% of budget for police, 15% for fire; prioritized public safety, expansion of city to bring in big businesses (Costco, etc.) to generate revenue; mentioned Newcomb expansion and library as priority projects.
    • Vanni: Could not provide annual budget figures; prioritized public safety, infrastructure (roads), community center, library, homeless services, and bringing in new businesses to grow the tax base.
  • Additional Question (Mayor Meister, regarding homeless along the Tule River in District 3):
    • Crowell: Advocated a multi-pronged approach: offer services, engage social workers and medical professionals for mental health and addiction treatment, incentivize businesses to hire, and enforce laws for those who refuse help.
    • Vanni: Called for compassion, use of existing services (Porterville Rescue Mission, Navigation Center, Family Crisis Center), and giving a "hand up" through jobs or mental health support.
    • Carley: Stated homelessness is not solvable in a two-year term; must balance enforcement with compassion, address addiction, mental health, and high housing costs; warned about potential flooding from predicted El Niño and need for safe shelter.

Key Outcomes

  • Appointment of Darrin Crowell: The council voted by roll call to appoint Darrin Crowell to fill the vacant District 3 City Council seat. The vote was 2-1 with one abstention: Councilmember Green (yes), Councilmember Beltran (no), Vice Mayor McCurdy (yes), Mayor Meister (abstained, citing support for Measure V and the principle of election vs. selection).
  • Swearing-In: Mr. Crowell was sworn in immediately after the vote by City Clerk, taking the oath of office.
  • Comments from New Councilmember: Mr. Crowell stated he will do his best, eschewing politics and left/right divisions, to make Porterville "the greatest city in the world."
  • Next Meeting: The meeting adjourned to the regular meeting of October 6, 2026, at 5:30 PM.

Meeting Transcript

Invocation if anyone would like to give one. Salute. Pledge. I pledge a little bit of the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God. Indivisible rule. Liberty and justice for all. Holy and gracious God. We thank you for your presence always and everywhere, and particularly tonight in this city council chamber. Be with our elected representatives with city staff and with all who have come to participate in the governance of Porterville. We ask for courage, stability, steadiness, and peace for all who have come to speak, and for receptive minds and hearts and all who are gathered to listen. We ask for your justice, fairness, and wisdom to be at work tonight in this chamber as our council members complete the process of filling the open seat on our council. Protect each of us from becoming disoriented by our own small needs and selfish goals. Embolden each of us to speak and act with clarity needed in difficult times. Protect our community from the judgment warranted when we turn our backs on those in need, or on the land, water, and many peoples of this precious valley where you have brought us together in the nick of time. Forgive our city its sins and shortcomings where we fall short, help us to do better, and where we have sinned, help us to repent and to reconcile with those we have sinned against. We ask these things in the name of the one who can go where we cannot go and complete what we cannot complete. Thy will be done. Amen. Okay, I've not seen anyone else. Please be seated. Moving on to oral communication, this is the opportunity opportunity to address the council on any matter listed under schedule matters. Unless additional time is authorized by the council, each speaker shall be limited to three minutes. The total time for public comments shall not exceed one hour. As the council considers the vacant district three seat, I encourage you to follow a fair opening. Diane. As the council considers filling the vacant district three seat, I encourage you to follow a fair, open and transparent process. Tim Vanny was considered was a candidate in the most recent district three election, and voters had an opportunity to consider him and cast votes for him. That is relevant information the council must weigh alongside the qualifications and community service of every eligible applicant. Because council members have emphasized the importance of elections. Please explain how the voters' previous choices factor into this appointment. Whatever decision you make, district three residents deserve a clear process and a representative committed to serving the entire community. As a district three resident, I am asking you to support and appoint Tim Banne to fill the seat vacated by Councilmember Reevas. Tim is a proven community volunteer. His record demonstrates the commitment, responsibility, and understanding of District Three that this position requires. Appointing the candidate who most recently sought and earned votes for this seat is the fairest and most evidence-based option available. It respects District Three voters while recognizing Tim's established record of community service. Thank you, Bear. Jean Valpiel, do you have my address and information? I can't expand on what Karen just said. But I do want to remind you, you do say repeatedly, people should have the choice to choose what they want in their district. And you even have a vote coming up on a proposition that you want to pass. So I ask you, look in your heart, follow what you advise us, and just pick Tim Vanny tonight because he came so close, just a handful of votes away from Mr. Rivas. Therefore, he's clearly someone that that district wants. Thank you.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com