OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Powell, Ohio/City Council & Boards
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Powell City Electric Aggregation Information Session – August 5, 2026

City Council & Boards — Wednesday, August 5, 2026
BodyPowell, Ohio
SessionCity Council & Boards
DateWednesday, August 5, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 48:09

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it
0:32

Good evening, everyone.

0:33

We're gonna try to start right on time and get you guys out here in a good fashion.

0:39

My name is Genevieve Costanzo, and I'm a relationship manager with NOPAC.

0:44

Tonight, what we're going to do is we're going to go over what brought us here today, which is we're gonna start with talking a little bit and quickly about deregulation, then we're gonna talk about NOPAC, and then I'm gonna talk about some of the most common questions that typically arise, hopefully answering your questions.

1:04

And at the end, um I promise you that I'm gonna stay here, and if your question was not answered in this presentation, I will be here until every single person's question is answered to your satisfaction.

1:16

So thank you again so much for letting me be here, and we're gonna continue on down.

1:23

Um before we start and get into how NOPAC came into your community, we're gonna look back at Ohio and deregulation.

1:33

Ohio is one of 14 states in the United States that deregulated energy.

1:38

They did this in two the year 2000.

1:41

What that means is that they separated the supply portion of your bill from the utility portion.

1:49

You have a choice in your suppliers.

1:52

You have no choice in your utility.

1:55

The suppliers are responsible for going to the market and securing a good rate for your electricity for your kilowatts per hour.

2:05

The utility is responsible for all the wires that you see for your bill for gatekeeping your account.

2:14

We as NOPAC have no information about your account.

2:18

Um, but the utility has to do all that.

2:21

Again, the utility is decided upon where you by where you live.

2:26

You have no choice in your utility, but you do have a choice in your supplier.

2:34

So we're gonna go to the next one.

2:36

Um, as I mentioned, the utility delivers the energy, manages the pipes and wires, and they are responsible fully for your bill.

2:46

They send the bill and they um create the bill every month.

2:51

You cannot choose your utility.

2:56

So, what your energy supplier does is it secures the energy you uses and negotiates the rate for that energy.

3:03

So typically, I mentioned that, or I just said in Ohio, we are deregulated.

3:09

That gave you the option of over a hundred different suppliers.

3:14

Every day there's um you could go to Apples to Apples, which is Ohio Energy Choice.com, and you could get your choice of over a hundred different suppliers to choose from the supply is notated here on the next slide.

3:33

I apologize.

3:35

Now, on your bill, this is kind of important.

3:38

On your bill, the blue part is your supply.

3:41

So you could see here that this customer used 933 kilowatts per hour, and her supply total was 127 dollars.

3:51

But that wasn't her bill.

3:52

Her bill total is 230 dollars.

3:56

Why?

3:56

Because again, you cannot choose your utility, and all of their charges per month are low are denoted in the raspberry section of this bill.

4:07

In one sense, what I tell a lot of my customers is that you actually have almost two different bills in one on your monthly electric bill.

4:32

Right away, just kind of set the level and say you only have control over one part.

4:38

It's very simple.

4:39

The one line, the kilowatt that you used times your rate.

4:43

Everything else in your bill, we have no agency over at all.

4:48

That that's a key term.

4:51

Next one, please.

4:53

So, as I mentioned, there's many different suppliers to choose from in Ohio.

5:00

And what it can definitely does promote competition, but it also can be confusing.

5:06

Next slide.

5:07

What they found out is early on in the beginning of 2000s, so maybe 2002, 2003, there was a lot of almost predatory sales tactics going on.

5:20

People would be knocking on doors and not be actual forthcoming about who they were.

5:26

They may have actually slammed some, you know, slammed some accounts, which means they would take their account and enroll them in their program.

5:35

We were finding that this was happening a lot.

5:37

And unfortunately, the people that were really getting hit were the elderly people.

5:44

So at that point, and recognizing the predatory environment.

5:49

Nope was formed by a group of mayors and managers in Northeast Ohio who wanted to make sure that all of their communities had the option, and all of the people had the option of getting some benefit from deregulation.

6:03

Next slide, please.

6:05

NOPEC is different than all of the other suppliers that you see listed on Ohio Energy Choice.gov.

6:16

We are a council of governments.

6:19

We are member driven.

6:20

We have a board of directors that are made up of a volunteer group of unpaid representatives from each county that we represent.

6:29

We do not have shareholders that are kind of that are looking to see if we make a profit because we don't.

6:35

We are subject to the same auditing that your local government is each year.

6:40

We are subject, we are subject to FOIA.

6:43

Huge, huge huge freedom of information out.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Energy Management█████████████████████████████████████████████84%
Public Engagement█████████16%
Summary of Proceedings

Powell City Electric Aggregation Information Session

On August 5, 2026, at 6:00 PM, the City of Powell hosted an information session in Council Chambers at 47 Hall Street to educate residents about the city's new electric aggregation program with NOPEC (Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council). The session was led by Genevieve Costanzo, a relationship manager at NOPEC, who presented on Ohio's deregulated energy market, NOPEC's structure as a nonprofit council of governments, program rates, and how residents can opt out or choose alternative rate options.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Several residents asked questions about the program's opt-out nature, the process for switching suppliers, and how to verify their current supplier.
  • A resident expressed concern about whether the program's automatic enrollment is fair, questioning the opt-out model; Costanzo explained that opt-in programs historically fail to reach critical mass.
  • Another resident, citing experience in Concord Township, supported the opt-out model, noting that about 80% of Ohio utility customers stay with their default supplier.
  • A resident asked about administrative overhead costs; Costanzo noted NOPEC's budget is transparent and available on its website, and offered to look up the specific figure after the meeting.
  • A resident asked whether NOPEC advocates for consumers against data centers; Costanzo described NOPEC's advocacy branch and cited a $265 million rebate won against Enbridge.
  • A resident asked about the reliability of the power supply; Costanzo clarified that AEP remains the utility and handles all billing and reliability.

Discussion Items

  • Ohio Deregulation Context: Costanzo explained that Ohio deregulated energy in 2000, separating supply from utility delivery. Residents have a choice in supplier but not utility.
  • NOPEC Background: Formed by mayors and city managers in the early 2000s to combat predatory sales tactics, NOPEC is a council of governments with an unpaid board, no shareholders, and is subject to FOIA and annual audits.
  • Rate Options: NOPEC offers a standard program rate (currently 9.99 cents/kWh for Powell through December 2026), a 12-month fixed rate (10.599 cents/kWh), a 24-month fixed rate (10.899 cents/kWh), and a variable rate (6% less than AEP's price to compare). A green energy option is also available with a small upcharge.
  • Enrollment and Opt-Out: Residents are automatically enrolled unless they already have a supplier, are on a PIP program, or have previously opted out. Opt-out letters are required by law every three years (electric) or two years (gas). Residents can opt out at any time by calling 1-855-NOPEC-01; the hard opt-out deadline for Powell is August 12 or 13, 2026.
  • Supply and Market: NOPEC's energy supply partner is NextEra Energy, chosen via RFP, with a nine-year contract. The program rate follows the market; a chart showed NOPEC's rate has been consistently below AEP's price to compare for the past two years.
  • Data Centers: Costanzo stated that data centers are driving electric price increases since 2024, and NOPEC is advocating for ratepayers against utility tariff increases.

Key Outcomes

  • No votes or formal decisions were taken; the session was informational.
  • Residents were encouraged to contact NOPEC's call center (1-855-NOPEC-01) or visit nopec.org for account-specific questions, rate options, or to opt out.
  • Costanzo provided her email to attendees for follow-up questions, emphasizing she would stay until all questions were answered.
  • The program will take effect after the opt-out deadline, with residents who take no action remaining enrolled in the standard program rate.

Note: The agenda included a presentation titled "Powell City New Aggregation and Community presentation.pdf" but the minutes were not available; all details are derived from the raw transcript.

Meeting Transcript

Good evening, everyone. We're gonna try to start right on time and get you guys out here in a good fashion. My name is Genevieve Costanzo, and I'm a relationship manager with NOPAC. Tonight, what we're going to do is we're going to go over what brought us here today, which is we're gonna start with talking a little bit and quickly about deregulation, then we're gonna talk about NOPAC, and then I'm gonna talk about some of the most common questions that typically arise, hopefully answering your questions. And at the end, um I promise you that I'm gonna stay here, and if your question was not answered in this presentation, I will be here until every single person's question is answered to your satisfaction. So thank you again so much for letting me be here, and we're gonna continue on down. Um before we start and get into how NOPAC came into your community, we're gonna look back at Ohio and deregulation. Ohio is one of 14 states in the United States that deregulated energy. They did this in two the year 2000. What that means is that they separated the supply portion of your bill from the utility portion. You have a choice in your suppliers. You have no choice in your utility. The suppliers are responsible for going to the market and securing a good rate for your electricity for your kilowatts per hour. The utility is responsible for all the wires that you see for your bill for gatekeeping your account. We as NOPAC have no information about your account. Um, but the utility has to do all that. Again, the utility is decided upon where you by where you live. You have no choice in your utility, but you do have a choice in your supplier. So we're gonna go to the next one. Um, as I mentioned, the utility delivers the energy, manages the pipes and wires, and they are responsible fully for your bill. They send the bill and they um create the bill every month. You cannot choose your utility. So, what your energy supplier does is it secures the energy you uses and negotiates the rate for that energy. So typically, I mentioned that, or I just said in Ohio, we are deregulated. That gave you the option of over a hundred different suppliers. Every day there's um you could go to Apples to Apples, which is Ohio Energy Choice.com, and you could get your choice of over a hundred different suppliers to choose from the supply is notated here on the next slide. I apologize. Now, on your bill, this is kind of important. On your bill, the blue part is your supply. So you could see here that this customer used 933 kilowatts per hour, and her supply total was 127 dollars. But that wasn't her bill. Her bill total is 230 dollars. Why? Because again, you cannot choose your utility, and all of their charges per month are low are denoted in the raspberry section of this bill. In one sense, what I tell a lot of my customers is that you actually have almost two different bills in one on your monthly electric bill. Right away, just kind of set the level and say you only have control over one part. It's very simple. The one line, the kilowatt that you used times your rate. Everything else in your bill, we have no agency over at all. That that's a key term. Next one, please. So, as I mentioned, there's many different suppliers to choose from in Ohio. And what it can definitely does promote competition, but it also can be confusing. Next slide. What they found out is early on in the beginning of 2000s, so maybe 2002, 2003, there was a lot of almost predatory sales tactics going on. People would be knocking on doors and not be actual forthcoming about who they were. They may have actually slammed some, you know, slammed some accounts, which means they would take their account and enroll them in their program. We were finding that this was happening a lot. And unfortunately, the people that were really getting hit were the elderly people. So at that point, and recognizing the predatory environment.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com