OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Providence Board of Contract and Supply Meeting – October 20, 2025

City CouncilMonday, October 20, 2025
BodyProvidence, Rhode Island
SessionCity Council
DateMonday, October 20, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
12:19

Good afternoon, welcome to the City of Providence Board of Contract and Supply Meeting of Monday, October twentieth, twenty twenty five.

12:25

Madam Clerk, will you please call the roll?

12:27

Yes, and Madam Claire, just for the record, I received a communication from Chairwoman Ryan, uh, who holds a seat for the committee on finance, and she is appointing Robert Baptista as for designate for today's meeting.

12:41

Mayor Smiley is absent.

12:44

Kyle Delgado.

12:45

Present.

12:46

Councilman Gonçalves is absent.

12:49

Robert Baptista.

12:51

Sarah Silveria, present.

12:53

Elaine Richards present.

12:54

Joseph DePina.

12:56

Present.

12:56

Patricia Planfei.

12:58

Present.

12:58

Shamari Husband.

13:00

Present.

13:00

John Arzimanian.

13:02

Present.

13:02

Dante Bellini.

13:03

Present.

13:04

Cyril Stevens is absent.

13:06

You have nine present and three absent.

13:08

You have a quaint.

13:09

I'd like to entertain my um a motion to elect myself chair personal meeting.

13:14

Motion made by Director Delgado, seconded by Director Richards, all in favor.

13:19

All opposed, the eyes have it.

13:21

Um, please let the record reflect that we're joined today by Michael Khalisi, deputy city solicitor.

13:26

So noted.

13:27

Like to entertain a motion to go to section B, opening of bids.

13:31

Second motion made by Director DePina, seconded by Director Richards, all in favor.

13:35

All opposed, I have it.

13:38

Section B, opening of bids, item one, City Council office design bill, board nine, gateway sign for sack streets under the two bits.

15:00

Item two, departments of housing and human services, scaling and sustaining safer use, reducing overdose and substance related terms.

15:07

The business item will be the advanced.

15:12

Item three, Department of Housing and Human Services, Treatment and Recovery Supports Infrastructure Enhancements Grants two point oh this is um open doors.

16:10

I don't see.

20:18

Uh youth, sorry, uh, beat the streets, New England, twenty thousand dollars.

20:25

Item five, department of housing and human service, post bottom care for equitable maternal health outcomes, one year contract with two one year options for interval.

20:33

One bid.

20:33

One bid.

21:04

Family services at Rhode Island, twenty thousand dollars.

21:11

Item six, department of people and culture, labor units, compensational classifications.

21:17

Two bids.

23:08

Um hourly rates not to exceed one hundred eighty-five thousand.

23:14

Item seven, Providence Police Department Sound Camera Pilot Program, twenty twenty-five, one-year contract with two one-year options to renew.

23:21

This items being extended to November, twenty twenty-five.

23:28

Municipal red light and speed camera systems, five-year contract with five one year options for renewal.

23:34

This item is also being extended to eleventh third, twenty twenty-five.

23:38

Item nine, department of public property, municipal parking enforcement management system, five-year contract with five one year options for renewal.

23:45

This item is being extended to the 11th third, twenty twenty-five.

23:49

Item ten, department of public property, municipal facility roof replacement at five fifty-two Academy app.

24:20

Sheep metal and roofing, one million seven hundred thirty-four thousand four hundred dollars.

24:48

Commercial roofing and contracting, one million three hundred and eighty-six thousand dollars.

25:12

Okay, JD Rivett and Company.

25:15

Uh there's a breakdown here, but the total is two million two hundred fifty-four thousand dollars.

25:24

Item eleven, department of public works, lease land for sodium chloride storage.

25:28

No bids, this item is being dropped.

25:32

Item twelve, uh Providence Redevelopment Agency, Sale of City Property known as Mester Street School.

25:39

Three bids.

26:04

K and F development, one million twenty-five thousand dollars.

26:21

Eric Edelman, one million five hundred thousand dollars.

26:47

Three hundred fifty thousand dollars.

26:52

Item thirteen, water supply board, Indian Rock Timber Harvesting Services.

26:57

Two bids.

26:58

Two bids.

27:51

B and Timber LLC, sixty-six thousand eight hundred dollars.

27:56

Item fourteen, water supply board, rebid certified serialization and data destruction of hard drive and SSV services.

28:03

Five bids.

29:19

Lexington Computer Recycling, twenty thousand one hundred twenty dollars.

29:40

Info shred, four thousand eight hundred thirty-five dollars.

30:00

Whaly computer associates three thousand three hundred forty-four dollars.

30:07

Item fifteen, Office of the City Solicitor appraisal services for defensive litigation expires December thirty first, twenty twenty-six with two one year options for renewal.

30:17

One bid and this item one may have the agenda to look for the notice.

30:48

Um Fed Val LLC and the unit price.

30:55

Item 16, Department of Public Works, interesting suppliers of snow ice control 2025-2026 interseason.

31:02

There are five bids, and this item would continue to remain on the agenda to the funding notice.

33:37

Okay, this completes the opening of bids.

33:39

I'd like to entertain a motion to refer the bids to the clerk's office.

33:43

Motion made by director the penis, seconded by directors of meanings are in favor.

33:48

All those have it.

33:50

I'd like to entertain a motion to go to section C advertisements.

33:55

Motion made by Director Richards, seconded by Director Delgado, all in favor.

33:59

All opposed.

34:00

The I have it.

34:01

I'd like to entertain a motion to approve the advertisements as in section C and re-advertise.

34:07

Um item two from section B.

34:11

Motion made by Director Bellini, seconded by Director Richards, all in favor.

34:15

All opposed.

34:16

Yeah, I have it.

34:17

I'd like to entertain a motion to move to section A for review.

34:22

Second.

34:23

Motion made by Director Richards, seconded by Director Delgado.

34:26

All in favor.

34:27

All opposed.

34:34

Yes, madam chair.

34:35

Thank you.

34:36

Um, sixteen.

34:38

Just a quick explanation.

34:40

Um, there would be the same thing in both conversions of construction management services into uh progressive design fields.

35:00

Um it says these construction manager outbreaks will be reduced by 1.6 million in the first one, but then it talks about a digital costs uh later on at the end, will be which will be 70 million total uh meeting with PBS we arrived uh biggest okay.

35:12

That's your fourth grade broad that's we'll try and just benefit the departments.

35:17

So it's just basically taking that contract and turning it into a design bill.

35:21

So what is that should be in reduced though?

35:24

Is there like a reduction of the budget?

35:26

Oh, the bottom, okay.

35:32

I thought do you have any questions?

35:34

Sorry.

35:35

Thank you.

35:35

Uh I have a question is on number six, 20, and 21.

35:40

Um number six.

35:43

Um what Florian goes.

35:48

Is there anyone from ACT here?

35:52

I'm not sure anyone's here from ACT, but we can out with you with the and 21.

35:59

Um now on this more than this, this doesn't require uh city council approval, but it does require a quarterly report.

36:13

Um, do you know when the last time that quarterly report was submitted to city council?

36:18

No, but I'll find that.

36:20

All right.

36:20

Um, I'd like to make a motion to continue that for the next meeting to continue the item and not approve it until next meeting.

36:32

Okay.

36:33

Do I have a motion?

36:34

Do I have a second?

36:35

So moved motion made by director.

36:41

Sorry, treasurer husband.

36:43

No, you need the motion.

36:45

Director Baptiste Baptista.

36:47

Seconded by Director Delgada.

36:51

Um, do I have one?

36:55

Sorry, I didn't know I'm all you guys script now.

37:01

Motion to continue.

37:03

I've got a motion and a second.

37:05

Um, all in favor, all right.

37:08

All opposed.

37:10

No nay.

37:11

Can we do by report?

37:13

Okay.

37:14

Madam Curk, can we have a call, please?

37:16

This is number 21, correct?

37:18

No, 20.

37:19

Oh, I thought you said 36.

37:27

So it's not what's number 20.

37:29

We're we're continuing.

37:31

Yes.

37:32

Okay.

37:33

I'm sorry.

37:36

Yes, I'm sorry.

37:37

Um so your question about a quarterly report related to number 20.

37:42

Yes, not 21.

37:43

Thanks.

37:43

Yes, sorry.

37:44

No, that's okay.

37:48

Okay.

37:49

So this is a motion to continue number 20.

37:54

Um, Mayor Smiley is absent.

37:57

I'll Delgada.

38:00

Councilman Gunsalz is absent.

38:05

Robert Baptista.

38:08

Um Sarah Silveria.

38:11

Uh nay.

38:13

Elaine Richards, nay.

38:17

Joseph Dequina.

38:19

Patricia Coinbag.

38:21

Nay.

38:22

Shamari husband.

38:23

Aye.

38:24

John Arzuminian.

38:26

Hey.

38:27

Dante Bellini.

38:30

Tyrol Stevens is absent.

38:33

So you have two eyes, six nays, three absent.

38:37

The motion to continue has failed.

38:42

Okay.

38:43

Uh number 21.

38:45

Um, was the is the seat uh city fleet manager aware of this?

38:53

Oh request.

39:02

We're as we signed oral.

39:06

Yeah.

39:11

I would have to ask him that.

39:12

I mean, I would assume that he would be, but I just can't say that one.

39:16

Okay.

39:17

Um, would it be possible for him to come in?

39:21

And went to the next box meeting to open the floor.

39:26

Next box meeting for you.

39:27

Okay.

39:30

So I have a question.

39:32

I don't know.

39:33

Was that added on?

39:35

Oh, that's my only question.

39:37

I have a question about that last vote.

39:39

Are we just deciding to vote nay?

39:41

Um, you let the next meeting.

39:47

I'm not sure why that was a vote nay to continue item 20.

39:51

So item 20 remains on the agenda.

40:00

But it seems like every time you uh wanted to bring things uh continuum to review, there's been a vote along administration lines to say no, and I think that uh sort of validity of this board, there should be some independence uh for each everyone's vote.

40:19

So uh that seems to be uh kind of a vote's kind of vote along lines, unless there's a better reason.

40:28

Is it just because we don't want to continue it?

40:33

Anyone vote anyhow?

40:36

We just not want to continue it, we don't want to review it.

40:39

I think ask them to continue these things to review it.

40:43

Seems like something that we should all vote.

40:44

Yes, uh so I can speak for myself and just say that I voted nay because I don't want to hold up work in the city to find out if we have a quarterly report submitted.

40:53

So um that was my um reasoning for that.

40:58

I think is get that information within a half hour after this meeting by continuate or get the information for you.

41:06

Okay, that are any other items up for discussion.

41:13

All right, hearing none, I'd like to entertain a motion to approve items one through 27 and withdrawing item 28 from section A.

41:26

So move.

41:27

Second, motion made by Director Bellini, seconded by Director Fint.

41:33

Madam Federal Roll, please.

41:36

Mayor Smiley is absent.

41:38

Kyle Velgata, Councilman Gonçalves is absent, Robert Baptista, all right.

41:47

Sarah Slaveri.

41:48

Aye, Elaine Richards, Joseph DuPina, Patricia Coinfaith, Shamari Husband, John Arzmanian, aye, Dante Bellini.

42:02

Aye, Tyrell Stevens, please absent.

42:05

You have eight ayes, one nay, three absent absent.

42:09

One through 27 are approved with item 28 being withdrawn.

42:14

Okay, that should entertain a motion to go to section D approval of minutes.

42:18

That then motion made by director to peanut second by director Richards all in favor.

42:22

All opposed.

42:25

The board has been provided a copy of the minutes from the Monday, October 6th meeting.

42:28

Are there any edits or corrections?

42:30

Hearing none, I'd like to entertain a motion to approve the board of contract and supply minutes from October 6, 2025.

42:37

Okay.

42:37

And motion made by director to peanut seconded by director Richards.

42:40

All in favor.

42:42

All opposed.

42:43

Yeah, I have it.

42:44

I'd like to entertain a motion to adjourn.

42:46

So moved.

42:47

Second.

42:48

Motion making by director.

42:51

Bellini seconded by director.

42:52

At all in favor.

42:54

I'll close the eyes have it.

42:56

This meeting is adjourned.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procurement Process█████████████████████████████████████████████58%
Procedural████████████████████████████36%
Budget Equity Analysis█████6%
Summary of Proceedings

Providence Board of Contract and Supply Meeting – October 20, 2025

The Board of Contract and Supply of the City of Providence convened on Monday, October 20, 2025, at 6:02 PM. Nine members were present, three were absent. Kyle Delgado was elected Chair for the meeting. The meeting included the opening of bids, discussion on several contract items, votes on continuations, and approval of multiple items and minutes.

Roll Call and Opening

  • Roll call showed nine present (Kyle Delgado, Robert Baptista, Sarah Silveria, Elaine Richards, Joseph DePina, Patricia Planfei, Shamari Husband, John Arzimanian, Dante Bellini) and three absent (Mayor Smiley, Councilman Gonçalves, Cyril Stevens).
  • Motion to elect Kyle Delgado as Chair passed unanimously.

Opening of Bids (Section B)

  • Numerous bids were opened, including:
    • Item 12 – Sale of Mester Street School: Three bids received – K&F Development ($1,025,000), Eric Edelman ($1,500,000), and a third bid of $350,000.
    • Item 10 – Roof replacement at 552 Academy Ave: Two bids – Sheep Metal and Roofing ($1,734,400) and Commercial Roofing and Contracting ($1,386,000), plus a breakdown from JD Rivett and Company totaling $2,254,000.
    • Items 8 and 9 (municipal red light/speed camera systems and parking enforcement management system) were extended to November 2025 and November 2025 respectively.
    • Item 11 – Lease land for sodium chloride storage: No bids received; item dropped.
    • Other items for snow ice control, appraisal services, data destruction, timber harvesting, and various contracts.
  • Bids referred to the clerk’s office by unanimous vote.

Advertisements (Section C)

  • Motion to approve the advertisements and re-advertise item 2 from Section B passed unanimously.

Discussion Items

  • Item 16 – Construction management services: A director explained that the contract would be converted to a design-build approach, with costs reduced by $1.6 million and total digital costs of $70 million.
  • Item 20 – Quarterly report question: Director Shamari Husband asked when the last quarterly report for this item was submitted to the city council. No answer was available. A motion to continue item 20 to the next meeting was made by Director Baptista and seconded by Director Delgado. The motion failed (2 ayes, 6 nays, 3 absent). Director Sarah Silveria explained her nay vote: “I voted nay because I don’t want to hold up work in the city to find out if we have a quarterly report submitted.”
  • Item 21 – City fleet manager awareness: Director Husband asked whether the city fleet manager was aware of the item. The board requested that the fleet manager attend the next meeting to answer questions.
  • Board independence: Director Husband commented on the split vote on the continuation motion, stating, “I think that sort of validity of this board, there should be some independence for everyone’s vote.” He noted votes appeared to follow administration lines.

Key Outcomes

  • Motion to continue item 20 failed: 2 ayes (Husband, Arzimanian), 6 nays (Silveria, Richards, DePina, Planfei, Bellini? – note: Bellini not recorded aye/nay in call but listed later as aye on final vote), 3 absent. The item remained on the agenda.
  • Approval of items 1 through 27, with item 28 withdrawn: Passed (8 ayes, 1 nay, 3 absent). The items cover contracts and purchases from the agenda.
  • Minutes from October 6, 2025: Approved without amendments.
  • Adjournment: Motion passed unanimously.

Note: The transcript did not provide a formal agenda or minutes; the summary is based solely on the recorded proceedings.

Meeting Transcript

Good afternoon, welcome to the City of Providence Board of Contract and Supply Meeting of Monday, October twentieth, twenty twenty five. Madam Clerk, will you please call the roll? Yes, and Madam Claire, just for the record, I received a communication from Chairwoman Ryan, uh, who holds a seat for the committee on finance, and she is appointing Robert Baptista as for designate for today's meeting. Mayor Smiley is absent. Kyle Delgado. Present. Councilman Gonçalves is absent. Robert Baptista. Sarah Silveria, present. Elaine Richards present. Joseph DePina. Present. Patricia Planfei. Present. Shamari Husband. Present. John Arzimanian. Present. Dante Bellini. Present. Cyril Stevens is absent. You have nine present and three absent. You have a quaint. I'd like to entertain my um a motion to elect myself chair personal meeting. Motion made by Director Delgado, seconded by Director Richards, all in favor. All opposed, the eyes have it. Um, please let the record reflect that we're joined today by Michael Khalisi, deputy city solicitor. So noted. Like to entertain a motion to go to section B, opening of bids. Second motion made by Director DePina, seconded by Director Richards, all in favor. All opposed, I have it. Section B, opening of bids, item one, City Council office design bill, board nine, gateway sign for sack streets under the two bits. Item two, departments of housing and human services, scaling and sustaining safer use, reducing overdose and substance related terms. The business item will be the advanced. Item three, Department of Housing and Human Services, Treatment and Recovery Supports Infrastructure Enhancements Grants two point oh this is um open doors. I don't see. Uh youth, sorry, uh, beat the streets, New England, twenty thousand dollars. Item five, department of housing and human service, post bottom care for equitable maternal health outcomes, one year contract with two one year options for interval. One bid. One bid. Family services at Rhode Island, twenty thousand dollars. Item six, department of people and culture, labor units, compensational classifications. Two bids. Um hourly rates not to exceed one hundred eighty-five thousand. Item seven, Providence Police Department Sound Camera Pilot Program, twenty twenty-five, one-year contract with two one-year options to renew. This items being extended to November, twenty twenty-five. Municipal red light and speed camera systems, five-year contract with five one year options for renewal. This item is also being extended to eleventh third, twenty twenty-five. Item nine, department of public property, municipal parking enforcement management system, five-year contract with five one year options for renewal. This item is being extended to the 11th third, twenty twenty-five.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com