Redwood City Council Meeting: May 8, 2023 - Downtown Plan Amendments, Police Study, and Proclamations
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Redwood City Council Meeting: May 8, 2023
The Redwood City Council held a hybrid meeting on May 8, 2023, starting at approximately 6:00 PM. The agenda covered proclamations for Mental Health Awareness Month and Jewish American Heritage Month, a study session on proposed amendments to the Downtown Precise Plan (DTPP) and General Plan (including the gatekeeper process and affordable housing options), a presentation and discussion of a Police Operations and Data Analysis report by the Center for Public Safety Management (CPSM), and a public hearing on the 2023-2027 Consolidated Plan and 2023-24 Annual Action Plan for CDBG and HOME funds. The council also approved the consent calendar and several motions.
Consent Calendar
- Award of the 2022-23 Water Main Replacement Project (Redwood Village and Hillcrest Pressure Reducing Valve Station).
- Resolution opposing initiative 21-0042A1 (Taxpayer Protection and Government Accountability Act).
- Housing and Human Concerns Committee FY 2023-24 funding recommendations for the Human Services Financial Assistance Program and Life Moves Redwood Family House.
- Agreements for on-call engineering and transportation services.
- Approval of claims and checks for May 8-22, 2023.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Ray Fowler opposed the Longfellow Redwood Life Project, arguing promised public benefits ($385 million) are unattainable, citing concerns about traffic, job quality, and affordable housing feasibility.
- Brent Adams criticized recent road improvements on Hopkins Avenue, calling speed bumps excessive and planning wasteful.
- Chris Rasmussen (Chair, San Mateo County Behavioral Health Commission) thanked the city for the Mental Health Month proclamation and invited participation.
- Adrian Brandt (Caltrain Advisory Committee member) alerted the council to increased gate downtime at Whipple and Brewster crossings due to new train detection circuits and urged coordination with Caltrain.
- Juan Venegas (NorthCal Carpenters Union) urged the inclusion of labor standards (apprenticeship, healthcare, local hire) in future projects.
- Andrea Osgood (Eden Housing) expressed support for gateway projects and the land donation strategy, highlighting benefits for deeper affordability.
- Molly Naper (MidPen Housing) stressed the need for a clear land reverter option and a predictable fee-out alternative to enable affordable housing development.
- Marcelina (resident) opposed off-site relocation of affordable housing to areas like 920 Shasta, arguing it isolates low-income families from transit and amenities.
- Ken Chan (Housing Leadership Council) supported clear objective standards, a fee-out option, and land reverter amendments.
- Richard Pierce (Legion Post 105) requested the council consider the unique delays faced by the 651 El Camino project due to city requests for property changes affecting Caltrain.
- Henry Sears (Tishman Speyer) supported the land dedication concept and noted the 609 Price site’s proximity to transit.
- Clara Jackal (RPAC member, speaking as individual) urged investment in human services over technology and recommended caution on new spending, emphasizing harm reduction over clearance rates.
Discussion Items
- Study Session: Downtown Precise Plan and Gatekeeper Process – Staff presented proposed amendments including: (1) approval process requiring City Council final action for large projects; (2) allowing R&D laboratory uses as conditional uses in the Downtown General and Transit districts, limited to BSL-1/2; (3) changes to vehicle parking ratios (removing minimums); (4) affordable housing obligations through land donation or a “land reverter” option, with criteria such as minimum 1-acre site and 110% of required units. Councilmembers expressed support for R&D lab uses, emphasized preserving housing downtown, raised concerns about land reverter risks, and supported requiring council approval for gatekeeper projects. Several asked for clear prioritization of community benefits and concurrent delivery of affordable housing.
- Police Operations & Data Analysis Report – CPSM consultant Jared Burguan presented findings: Redwood City PD is professional but faces staffing challenges with a 47% patrol ratio (target 60%), high overtime, and 54 recommendations including strategic planning, civilianization, body-worn camera audits, crime analyst position, traffic data-driven enforcement, and addressing minimum staffing. Chief Moholland noted 10 recommendations already in progress. Council discussed overtime mitigation, civilianization, traffic enforcement data, and community input for the strategic plan. They voted to direct staff to develop an implementation plan by November 1, 2023.
- Consolidated Plan & Annual Action Plan – Staff presented the 2023-2027 Consolidated Plan (priorities: affordable housing, mental health, infrastructure, youth activities) and 2023-24 Action Plan, with $5,227,000 in combined CDBG and HOME funds. The Housing and Human Concerns Committee recommended renewal funding for several programs and approved Habitat for Humanity for home rehabilitation loans. Council adopted the resolution and authorized funding agreements unanimously.
Key Outcomes
- Consent calendar approved unanimously.
- Study session: No formal action; council provided direction on R&D lab uses, affordable housing options, and the gatekeeper process to inform future environmental review and ordinances.
- Police report: Motion passed unanimously to direct staff to evaluate recommendations and return with an implementation plan by November 1, 2023.
- Consolidated Plan: Resolution adopted and motion to authorize funding agreements passed unanimously.
- Council also received committee updates (Governance Subcommittee, Communications Subcommittee) and city manager updates on police advisory committee recruitment, Hopkins traffic calming project resumption, and bollard installation on Theater Way.
Meeting Transcript
Good evening, everyone. Welcome to our May 8th council meeting here in Redwood City. I'd like to call our meeting to order. Thank you for joining us this evening and giving up a little bit of the warriors game. Uh here's this basketball game tonight, isn't there? Hopefully, thirty points come our way and on our side tonight. We tonight we are holding our meetings in a hybrid format with both in-person and virtual participation. Items will be taken in the order they are listed on the agenda. With our hybrid meeting format, the public comment procedures are as follows. Speaker cards are located at the back table in the council chambers and must be turned into the city clerk at the dais. Please be sure to indicate the agenda item number you wish you wish to speak on. Virtual attendees who have joined us by Zoom will be called after the in-person comments have been given. Detailed instructions for public comment will be provided on the screen when the time for public comment begins. And we really welcome information from the community that will help us with understanding what has happened. So we invite members of the community if they have any information regarding the case to please contact Detective James Schneider at 650 780 7607. Now, because this is not on our agenda this evening, um, unfortunately I am not able to take any other questions. The City Council is not able to discuss this further this evening. Um, but we did want to make sure you knew and that the public knew we would be providing updates as soon as we have anything substantial to share. Thank you. Thank you, City Manager Stevens and Diaz, and I want to thank our law enforcement and our law enforcement partners that responded to the incident yesterday, and it is an active and ongoing investigation, so the public's help is much needed. Thank you. On to item number five is our presentations and acknowledgments, and we have two for this evening. The first one is a proclamation recognizing mental health awareness month. In the month of May, we recognize several events that are near and dear to the Redwood City community. The first recognition this evening is the Mental Health Mental Health Awareness Month, a national awareness campaign which aims to fight stigma, educate the public, and advocate for policies that support the millions of people in the United States affected by mental illness. To honor Mental Health Awareness Month in Redwood City, stop by Courthouse Square later tonight. Courthouse Square is illuminated in Lime Green during the month of May. On behalf of the City Council, I'd like to present the following proclamation recognizing Mental Health Mental Health Awareness Month to the National Alliance on Mental Illness, often known as NAMI of Sam Mateo County. I'll just read a couple of the excerpts from our proclamation. Whereas every day, millions of people face stigma related to mental health and substance abuse conditions and may feel isolated and alone, going years before receiving any help. And whereas mental health and substance use conditions are treatable health conditions, and people who have mental health and substance use conditions can recover and lead full and meaningful lives. And whereas the National Alliance on Mental Illness, NAMI, is dedicated to improving the quality of life for people with mental illness and their families through support, education, and advocacy. Now therefore, be it resolved that as Mayor of Redwood City on behalf of the City Council and the people of Redwood City, we do hereby recognize May 2023 as Mental Health Month in Redwood City to encourage the community to join us in celebrities this year's campaign. More than enough is a reminder that you are inherently worthy of life, love, and healing. I like now to welcome NAMI's executive director, Robert Taylor, to accept this proclamation and say a few words. Robert, if you join me at the Discovery. Hello. All right, there we are. Hi, uh my name is Robert Taylor. I am the executive director at uh NAMI National Alliance on Mental Illness. Actually, it's a new position for me, and I'm absolutely thrilled to be joining such a wonderful organization. Um, you know, our mission is dedicated to providing services to those uh individuals and people uh with mental illness and their families through, and I think Mr. Mr. Mayor, uh Mr. G mentioned that through education support and advocacy. Uh we have a variety of programs that that help those that are struggling with mental illness and their families. Um, and we continue and we want to continue to grow those programs so we can continue to serve more individuals because I think as we all know, mental illness is a is a growing epidemic here in the not only in San Mateo County but the nation as a whole. So we're uh we're poised to continue to do more so we can we can meet the challenge that's uh that that's facing all of us here in the community. So thank you very much for the proclamation and uh look forward to working very closely with uh with Redwood City and and the officials here and and the individuals as well as San Mateo County as a whole. So thank you very much.
openpublica.com