OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Redwood City Council Meeting – February 12, 2024: Sequoia Station Update, Public Comments on Ceasefire, Affordable Housing Funding

City CouncilMonday, February 12, 2024
BodyRedwood City, California
SessionCity Council
DateMonday, February 12, 2024
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
1:33

All right, good evening everyone, and welcome to the Redwood City Council meeting of February twelfth.

1:39

I'd like to welcome everyone for joining us today.

1:42

We're continuing to offer in-person and remote options for our city council meetings.

1:46

However, due to recent and continued disruptions during public comment at open meetings throughout our region and state, we've modified our public comment procedures until further notice.

1:57

The city welcomes public comment on topics within the city subject matter jurisdiction, and this can be provided in person during the meeting or by email ahead of the meeting.

2:08

At this time, we are temporarily suspending public comments by Zoom.

2:11

We want to ensure that the city can continue to conduct the city's business in a manner that allows all residents to participate.

2:18

We continue to evaluate our public comment procedures and we'll share updates as necessary.

2:52

Comments that were received by 5 o'clock PM today may be read into the record by the city clerk.

3:10

Excuse me.

3:11

Lastly, if we have a high volume of public comment this evening, we may decrease the time allotted for each comment or limit the total time for public comment.org so that we can see your comments and they will be part of the meeting record.

3:48

I will now turn it over to our city clerk to call the roll.

5:00

Before we go into closed session, I'll ask the public clerk or city clerk if we have any public comment on the item.

5:05

Thank you, Mayor.

5:06

We do have one speaker card, and the speaker is Chris Robell.

5:19

Hi, uh good evening, Council.

5:21

Uh, just I don't have a lot of background on this, obviously, it's closed session, but to the extent this is uh a land acquisition purchase and we are going through tough financial times looking at tax increases for the community, et cetera.

5:33

I would urge um judicious consideration of this, whether this is needed.

5:38

I don't like it, I don't have a lot of details, but if this is Caltrain property, why are we doing it?

5:42

If it's for high speed rail, which seems kind of like a pie in the sky project that'll never happen, why are we doing it?

5:48

So we've got to really prioritize and do belt tightening like all the residents.

5:52

So again, um I might be totally off base, but if that's the if that's the topic, I would request um that you give it a firm no on that one.

6:01

Thank you.

6:04

And no further public comment, Mayor.

6:06

Thank you very much.

6:07

Council will adjourn into closed session.

6:09

We'll be back about hopefully forty-five minutes.

6:11

Thank you, everyone, for your patience.

58:11

Okay, thank you, everybody, for your patience.

58:13

Uh, the council has adjourned its closed session, it has come back into public section public session, and there was no reportable actions taken this evening during our closed session.

58:23

Thank you for your patience.

58:25

The fun part of our agenda is section number five, our presentations and acknowledgments.

58:40

Please check out the Red City Public Library for a wide selection of good reads on African American culture and history.

58:45

And also I recommend a visit to the Dominique Hoskins Black History Museum right here on Jefferson Avenue through February twenty-ninth.

58:53

It's a special year.

59:11

It's the year of the dragon.

59:25

Hope to see all of you there.

1:00:00

Actually, what was Sequoia Station was a car dealership and uh my senior summer in high school, I worked at that car dealership doing odd jobs.

1:00:06

So tonight it's actually really exciting for me, because in my 40-year career of running Hunter Properties, a six-year-old development firm, for me to come back to Revit City and buy an important piece of property like Sequoia Station has been quite exciting.

1:00:21

It's uh in my career, I've developed over 10 buildings in Revit City from shopping centers to self-storage to the box building when we kicked off the initial specific plan.

1:00:33

Um I continue to own 500 Arguello, which is at the north end of the transit district as you redevelop Perry Street and see that vision through.

1:00:43

So as the new owners of the shopping center, really what you'll see us focus on is putting, I don't want to say Humpty Dumpty back together.

1:00:52

But as they started to uh contemplate redeveloping the property, they'll let a number of vacancies uh develop in the property and shopping centers, as we all know that when you have dark storefronts, not our best side of our communities can present themselves.

1:01:06

So you'll see us focus on making the shopping center vibrant, safe, engaging as we work with the planning department and tighten up our own development agreement, being prepared to redevelopment, which we think will be in the next cycle, probably somewhere between five to seven years down the road.

1:01:24

So it's uh it's exciting for me.

1:01:26

Um it's not like in our careers you think about your last project, but I think it might be by the time I get around to redeveloping Sequoia Station in the next uh seven years, by example, probably be time to put me out to pasture.

1:01:39

So uh uh we're looking forward to owning it.

1:01:41

We own it privately.

1:01:42

We don't own it with an institution.

1:01:44

We don't own it with any debt.

1:01:46

We own it as a family.

1:01:48

Um, and we will run it and we'll run it responsibly, and then we'll work with it's a very important piece of property as you finish your your vision.

1:01:56

We've been there for the beginning of this vision uh for the downtown plan.

1:02:00

Um too many nights in high school.

1:02:02

I even went to the Fox Theater, so I won't drag you that far back.

1:02:06

But I will tell you it's something that um, and I mean it with absolute sincerity.

1:02:11

Um it is really important for us to do a great job owning it now, owning it for people that use that shopping center as a daily needs center as a grocery drug store, and also seeing it as the next vision to finish off the downtown.

1:02:26

So I understand the responsibilities that come with it.

1:02:30

By example, we are redeveloping downtown Sunnyvale, which is a million square feet of office, a thousand apartment units, and all the ground floor is retail.

1:02:40

And um, we've invited planning, and we'll get to that when we get further into it, to show another similar-sized project that we're developing.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Comment███████████████████████████████████35%
Land Use Planning███████████████████████23%
Affordable Housing█████████████13%
International Affairs███████████11%
Procedural███████7%
Public Safety████4%
Budget and Fiscal Management████4%
Arts and Culture██2%
Personnel Matters1%
Summary of Proceedings

Redwood City Council Meeting – February 12, 2024

On February 12, 2024, the Redwood City Council held a regular meeting. The meeting included a presentation on the new ownership of Sequoia Station, recognition of participants in a sister-city art contest, extensive public comment on a proposed ceasefire resolution, approval of routine consent items, a public hearing on animal control ordinance adoption, and a staff report on affordable housing funding. The meeting began with a closed session (no reportable actions) and concluded with council member reports and city manager updates.

Consent Calendar

  • Items approved unanimously (6-0, with Vice Mayor Espinosa Garnica absent): Items 7B through 7I (except 7E). These included final acceptance of the 2020–2021 Sanitary Sewer Replacement Project, an ordinance amending water main upgrade standards, a memorandum of understanding for a compost quality improvement campaign, approval of minutes, and claims and checks.
  • Item 7E (Star Elevator services): Approved 5-0 (Vice Mayor absent, Councilmember Aiken recused).
  • Item 7A (Architectural Advisory Committee Work Plan): Pulled for brief discussion. Councilmember Aiken asked staff about objective design standards and the committee’s future role. The council approved the work plan unanimously (6-0).

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Closed session comment: Chris Robell urged the council to be judicious about a potential land acquisition, questioning its necessity given financial constraints.
  • Public comment on ceasefire resolution (not on agenda): 29 speakers (16 in-person, 13 emailed) addressed the council. Speakers expressed both support and opposition to placing a ceasefire resolution on a future agenda.
    • Opponents (pro-Israel perspective): Idan Harel, Valerie Rutenberg, Sophie Berstein, Leah Kruppnik, Dave Bauer, Corinne Feigenberg, Bri Hanney, Irina Krupnik, Tamar, and others argued that a ceasefire resolution would be divisive, outside the council’s purview, and would legitimize Hamas. Several cited rising anti-Semitism and the need to focus on local issues. Some referenced promises made by Councilmember Jeff Gee that a ceasefire would not be considered.
    • Supporters (pro-Palestinian perspective): Jared Peterson, Brandon Henriquez, Laksh, Michelle Riaz, Mary Bernier, Zach Kleiman, and many emailed comments called for a ceasefire resolution, citing the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, the International Court of Justice’s finding of plausible genocide, and the need for the city to stand for human rights. They referenced similar resolutions passed in other Bay Area cities and noted that over two-thirds of Americans support a ceasefire.
  • Public comment on city tax proposals: Chris Robell presented a petition signed by 160 residents alleging the city is providing misleading information about a potential new property transfer tax. He claimed the city’s website states “the city is not considering new taxes” while a consultant is working on the tax. Several emailed comments supported the petition.

Discussion Items

  • Sequoia Station Presentation (Item 5A): Deke Hunter, principal of Hunter Properties, introduced himself as the new owner of the Sequoia Station shopping center. He outlined plans to stabilize the property, fill vacancies, and eventually redevelop the site in alignment with the downtown precise plan, likely within five to seven years. Councilmembers expressed support, noting the need for a safe and vibrant environment. Hunter emphasized his local roots and commitment to responsible ownership.
  • Art Contest Recognition (Item 5B): Barbara Pierce (Redwood City International) and Veronica Scamas (Casa Circolo Cultural) recognized 19 student participants in a sister-city art contest with Zhuhai, China. The theme was “Friendship Around the World.” Two students received awards in person; all will be recognized at the Lunar Festival on February 24.
  • Public Hearing on Animal Control Ordinance (Item 8A): The council adopted an ordinance incorporating the San Mateo County animal control code by reference, with penalties for violations. No public comments were received. The motion passed 6-0.
  • Affordable Housing NOFA (Item 9A): Staff recommended awarding $4,366,460 in two loans to the 1304 Middlefield Road affordable housing project (94 units, 92 affordable). The project scored highest in the NOFA process and is still assembling financing. Councilmembers asked about loan terms, timeline, and marketing for residents with disabilities. The council approved the resolution 6-0, authorizing the city manager to execute loan documents and a budget amendment.
  • Matters of Council Interest (Item 10): Councilmember Raykin reported attending the San Francisco Community Roundtable, which discussed advanced air mobility vehicles. No other reports.

Key Outcomes

  • Closed session: No reportable actions.
  • Consent calendar: Approved all items (7A–7I) with specific votes, including removal of 7E due to Councilmember Aiken’s recusal.
  • Animal control ordinance: Adopted (6-0).
  • Affordable housing funding: Approved $4,366,460 in conditional loans for 1304 Middlefield Road (6-0). A future NOFA round in FY 2024-25 will use remaining RDA funds.
  • Ceasefire resolution: Not on the agenda; the mayor announced it is tentatively scheduled for the March 11 council meeting. No action taken.
  • City manager update: Noted CERP academy (April 3–May 18), President’s Day office closure, and upcoming February 26 meeting agenda (solid waste rates, fee burden analysis, budget update).

Meeting Transcript

All right, good evening everyone, and welcome to the Redwood City Council meeting of February twelfth. I'd like to welcome everyone for joining us today. We're continuing to offer in-person and remote options for our city council meetings. However, due to recent and continued disruptions during public comment at open meetings throughout our region and state, we've modified our public comment procedures until further notice. The city welcomes public comment on topics within the city subject matter jurisdiction, and this can be provided in person during the meeting or by email ahead of the meeting. At this time, we are temporarily suspending public comments by Zoom. We want to ensure that the city can continue to conduct the city's business in a manner that allows all residents to participate. We continue to evaluate our public comment procedures and we'll share updates as necessary. Comments that were received by 5 o'clock PM today may be read into the record by the city clerk. Excuse me. Lastly, if we have a high volume of public comment this evening, we may decrease the time allotted for each comment or limit the total time for public comment.org so that we can see your comments and they will be part of the meeting record. I will now turn it over to our city clerk to call the roll. Before we go into closed session, I'll ask the public clerk or city clerk if we have any public comment on the item. Thank you, Mayor. We do have one speaker card, and the speaker is Chris Robell. Hi, uh good evening, Council. Uh, just I don't have a lot of background on this, obviously, it's closed session, but to the extent this is uh a land acquisition purchase and we are going through tough financial times looking at tax increases for the community, et cetera. I would urge um judicious consideration of this, whether this is needed. I don't like it, I don't have a lot of details, but if this is Caltrain property, why are we doing it? If it's for high speed rail, which seems kind of like a pie in the sky project that'll never happen, why are we doing it? So we've got to really prioritize and do belt tightening like all the residents. So again, um I might be totally off base, but if that's the if that's the topic, I would request um that you give it a firm no on that one. Thank you. And no further public comment, Mayor. Thank you very much. Council will adjourn into closed session. We'll be back about hopefully forty-five minutes. Thank you, everyone, for your patience. Okay, thank you, everybody, for your patience. Uh, the council has adjourned its closed session, it has come back into public section public session, and there was no reportable actions taken this evening during our closed session. Thank you for your patience. The fun part of our agenda is section number five, our presentations and acknowledgments. Please check out the Red City Public Library for a wide selection of good reads on African American culture and history. And also I recommend a visit to the Dominique Hoskins Black History Museum right here on Jefferson Avenue through February twenty-ninth. It's a special year. It's the year of the dragon. Hope to see all of you there. Actually, what was Sequoia Station was a car dealership and uh my senior summer in high school, I worked at that car dealership doing odd jobs. So tonight it's actually really exciting for me, because in my 40-year career of running Hunter Properties, a six-year-old development firm, for me to come back to Revit City and buy an important piece of property like Sequoia Station has been quite exciting. It's uh in my career, I've developed over 10 buildings in Revit City from shopping centers to self-storage to the box building when we kicked off the initial specific plan. Um I continue to own 500 Arguello, which is at the north end of the transit district as you redevelop Perry Street and see that vision through. So as the new owners of the shopping center, really what you'll see us focus on is putting, I don't want to say Humpty Dumpty back together. But as they started to uh contemplate redeveloping the property, they'll let a number of vacancies uh develop in the property and shopping centers, as we all know that when you have dark storefronts, not our best side of our communities can present themselves. So you'll see us focus on making the shopping center vibrant, safe, engaging as we work with the planning department and tighten up our own development agreement, being prepared to redevelopment, which we think will be in the next cycle, probably somewhere between five to seven years down the road. So it's uh it's exciting for me. Um it's not like in our careers you think about your last project, but I think it might be by the time I get around to redeveloping Sequoia Station in the next uh seven years, by example, probably be time to put me out to pasture. So uh uh we're looking forward to owning it. We own it privately. We don't own it with an institution. We don't own it with any debt.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com