OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Redwood City Planning Commission Special Interview Session - May 21, 2024

Planning CommissionTuesday, May 21, 2024
BodyRedwood City, California
SessionPlanning Commission
DateTuesday, May 21, 2024
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
1:34

Thank you for joining us for our May 21st, 2024 Planning Commission special interview session.

1:42

As a reminder, items will be taken in the order in which they are listed on the agenda.

1:47

Before we get started, I wanted to briefly go over the public comment procedures for the meeting for those who may be joining us for the first time.

1:55

Public comments on items not on the agenda will be taken during item number two on the agenda.

2:01

Comments on other items will be taken only when that item is called.

2:06

We are continuing to offer in-person and remote options for our planning commission meetings.

2:11

However, due to continued recent disruptions during public comment at open meetings throughout the region and state, we've modified our public comment procedures.

2:21

The city welcomes public comments on topics within the city's subject matter jurisdiction, and this can be provided in person during the meeting or by email ahead of the meeting.

2:32

At this time we are temporarily suspending public comment provided by Zoom.

2:37

Our public comment procedures are as follows.

2:40

Public comment will be taken in person during the meeting or in advance via email to PC at redwoodcity.org.

2:47

In-person speakers must turn in a speaker card.

2:50

Um comments that were emailed to the uh email address that I mentioned by 5 p.m.

2:56

today may be read into the record.

2:58

And both in-person and emailed comments are subject to the three minute time limit.

3:02

I will now turn it over to staff to call the roll.

3:07

Thank you, Chair Hunter.

3:09

Commissioner Alvarez.

3:10

Here Commissioner Chu here.

3:15

Commissioner Koch?

3:16

Here.

3:17

Commissioner Lazarus?

3:19

Here.

3:20

Vice Chair Shonegaretz?

3:22

Here.

3:23

And Chair Hunter.

3:25

Here for the purposes of this meeting, I'm Sue Xine, the assistant community development director.

3:31

And the Lee is onto this commission.

3:33

Uh attending this meeting with me are Rick Jarvis, our consultant attorney.

3:38

Christina Mateo, admin secretary, and meeting host.

3:42

And that's it for this part of the meeting.

3:45

Okay.

3:45

Thank you.

3:46

Um item number two is public comments on items not on the agenda.

3:50

I have no speak no speaker cards, and I I need to ask if there are any public comments have been received by email.

3:58

We have not received any public comments by email.

4:01

Thank you.

4:02

So now we come to the first of the two uh two interview sessions, and this is always a great pleasure because we get to meet the people who have applied to be active participants in our city.

4:14

Um the first interviews will be for the historic resources advisory committee, followed by the architectural advisory committee.

4:22

Um the planning commission will interview Historic Resources Advisory Committee or HRAC applicants for appointment to two full-term seats.

4:35

The both those seats expire on May 31st, 2027.

4:40

Applicants will get four minutes to answer four questions, uh which uh you have been sent in advance and were able to prepare.

4:48

And we have two applicants.

4:50

Uh the first will be John Goldman, um, who will be uh joining us via via Zoom?

4:56

Is that correct?

4:58

Okay, great.

5:00

Um, and so I'm I'm going to for um for good process here.

5:04

I'm going to read the questions uh publicly.

5:07

Um, and then I would invite uh John to um to have his four minutes.

5:12

So the the questions that you've been asked to respond to are one.

5:17

Please briefly introduce yourself to the Planning Commission and tell us why you have applied for this committee and why you think the HRAC is important to the community.

5:26

Two, what experience and qualifications do you feel you have that would be helpful in committee decisions?

5:33

Three, what do you feel are some of the key considerations when evaluating whether an older structure is worthy of official designation as an historic resource?

5:44

And four, when considering an addition to a historic resource, what are some key considerations for evaluating the project?

5:52

And uh Sue, I think I should I turn it over to you to uh call the interviewees.

5:58

Sure.

5:59

Uh John Goldman is the first one.

6:02

And so we'll just let um you get started.

6:06

Thanks.

6:07

Okay.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Historic Preservation█████████████████████████████████████████████84%
Procedural█████████16%
Summary of Proceedings

Redwood City Planning Commission Special Interview Session - May 21, 2024

The Redwood City Planning Commission held a special interview session on May 21, 2024, beginning at 2:00 PM, to interview applicants for the Historic Resources Advisory Committee (HRAC) and the Architectural Advisory Committee (AAC). No appointments were made during this session; the commission deferred formal appointments until its June 2024 meetings. The meeting was recessed around 6:25 PM before the regularly scheduled 6:30 PM meeting.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • No public comments were submitted in person or by email. The city temporarily suspended public comment via Zoom due to disruptions at other regional meetings but continued to accept in-person and emailed comments, subject to a three-minute time limit.

Historic Resources Advisory Committee (HRAC) Interviews

  • John Goldman: A 24-year Redwood City resident and the current Vice Chair of the HRAC (serving since 2018). Goldman has 27 years of experience in commercial property management and historic restoration. He expressed strong support for the committee's mission and emphasized the importance of practical, real-world experience in providing feasible and constructive input to applicants. He stated he approaches his role without a political agenda and has a genuine passion for architectural and historical preservation.
  • Gary Weber: A 35-year Redwood City resident and fifth-generation Californian. Weber has 40 years of experience in commercial construction project management and five years as an engineer for Daly City Public Works. He is a member of the San Mateo County Historical Association and a docent for the Woodside Store. He expressed interest in preserving historically significant properties and structures.

Architectural Advisory Committee (AAC) Interviews

  • Edward Davidovitz: Holds a BA in Architecture from the University of Chile and has owned a general contracting business in Redwood City for 30 years. He emphasized the role of buildings in defining a city's cultural, historical, and economic character. He expressed a commitment to blending historic architectural appreciation with modern, forward-thinking design to accommodate growth and innovation.
  • Don Ditkins: An Associate Principal at DES Architects + Engineers and a 19-year Redwood City resident. Ditkins has led large projects, including the Design Tech High School. He stressed the importance of design sensitivity to neighborhood context, materiality, streetscape integration, and community dialogue in reviewing projects.
  • John Stewart: A current AAC member seeking reappointment. Stewart founded Stewart Associates Architects in 1982. He discussed the challenges of reconciling the city's preferred architectural styles (Classical, Mediterranean, Craftsman) with contemporary developer proposals, citing examples where modern buildings are proposed with token Mediterranean features. He recommended that the commission appoint all four applicants to fill anticipated vacancies or create an alternate position to ensure quorum.
  • Keith King: Was absent and did not connect to the meeting.

Key Outcomes

  • No appointments were finalized during this special interview session. The Planning Commission will formally appoint members to the HRAC (two seats, expiring May 31, 2027) and the AAC (three seats, expiring May 31, 2028) during its June 2024 meetings.
  • The meeting was recessed for approximately five minutes at 6:25 PM to transition to the commission's regularly scheduled 6:30 PM meeting.

Meeting Transcript

Thank you for joining us for our May 21st, 2024 Planning Commission special interview session. As a reminder, items will be taken in the order in which they are listed on the agenda. Before we get started, I wanted to briefly go over the public comment procedures for the meeting for those who may be joining us for the first time. Public comments on items not on the agenda will be taken during item number two on the agenda. Comments on other items will be taken only when that item is called. We are continuing to offer in-person and remote options for our planning commission meetings. However, due to continued recent disruptions during public comment at open meetings throughout the region and state, we've modified our public comment procedures. The city welcomes public comments on topics within the city's subject matter jurisdiction, and this can be provided in person during the meeting or by email ahead of the meeting. At this time we are temporarily suspending public comment provided by Zoom. Our public comment procedures are as follows. Public comment will be taken in person during the meeting or in advance via email to PC at redwoodcity.org. In-person speakers must turn in a speaker card. Um comments that were emailed to the uh email address that I mentioned by 5 p.m. today may be read into the record. And both in-person and emailed comments are subject to the three minute time limit. I will now turn it over to staff to call the roll. Thank you, Chair Hunter. Commissioner Alvarez. Here Commissioner Chu here. Commissioner Koch? Here. Commissioner Lazarus? Here. Vice Chair Shonegaretz? Here. And Chair Hunter. Here for the purposes of this meeting, I'm Sue Xine, the assistant community development director. And the Lee is onto this commission. Uh attending this meeting with me are Rick Jarvis, our consultant attorney. Christina Mateo, admin secretary, and meeting host. And that's it for this part of the meeting. Okay. Thank you. Um item number two is public comments on items not on the agenda. I have no speak no speaker cards, and I I need to ask if there are any public comments have been received by email. We have not received any public comments by email. Thank you. So now we come to the first of the two uh two interview sessions, and this is always a great pleasure because we get to meet the people who have applied to be active participants in our city. Um the first interviews will be for the historic resources advisory committee, followed by the architectural advisory committee. Um the planning commission will interview Historic Resources Advisory Committee or HRAC applicants for appointment to two full-term seats. The both those seats expire on May 31st, 2027. Applicants will get four minutes to answer four questions, uh which uh you have been sent in advance and were able to prepare. And we have two applicants. Uh the first will be John Goldman, um, who will be uh joining us via via Zoom? Is that correct? Okay, great. Um, and so I'm I'm going to for um for good process here. I'm going to read the questions uh publicly. Um, and then I would invite uh John to um to have his four minutes. So the the questions that you've been asked to respond to are one.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com