OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Sacramento Community Police Commission Meeting – November 23, 2015

Community Police Review CommissionMonday, November 23, 2015
BodySacramento, California
SessionCommunity Police Review Commission
DateMonday, November 23, 2015
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
0:01

Sacramento community police commission to order.

0:05

First, we will start with uh roll call.

0:09

Les Simmons.

0:11

Here.

0:12

Betty Williams.

0:17

Awesome Elkara.

0:19

Here.

0:21

Kathy Tower.

0:23

Rosalind Van Buren.

0:25

Here.

0:27

Bill Knowlton.

0:28

Here.

0:30

Ernest Zuwazi.

0:32

Present.

0:33

Mariana Sabiano here.

0:36

Clifton Roberts?

0:37

Here.

0:39

Rick Jones.

0:40

Here.

0:41

And Tim Davis.

0:43

Here.

0:44

We have a quorum.

0:47

So let's move through the agenda.

0:51

We do not have any items.

0:54

Well, let's see.

0:55

We first of all we have the welcoming remarks.

1:00

There are no items on the consent calendar.

1:02

So we're going to start with Jovon Aggie from the mayor's office.

1:11

We had a better relationship than that, it's actually AG.

1:14

AG?

1:14

Yes.

1:15

My bad.

1:16

Well, it's my pleasure to be here this evening.

1:18

Uh, Francine, member of the commission, my name is Joe Vaughn A.

1:21

G.

1:22

I'm the community relations director for Mayor Johnson.

1:25

Um, in his absence, he wanted me to let you all know that he's thankful for your time and commitment this evening to this issue.

1:30

Um, the work that you all are doing is vitally important, um, which you may or may not know that it's part of an officer next door initiative that it was launched earlier this year that focuses on four areas.

1:39

First being training, second being diversity, engagement, and then accountability with the Sacramento Police Department.

1:46

The work that you all are doing as this commission falls under the accountability component and has two focus areas bias free policing and then strengthening community police relations.

1:56

And so the mayor and council are looking forward to the work that you all are going to be doing and providing recommendations to the council on what are those metrics that can be assessed to ensure that we're making progress in those areas.

2:07

So again, thank you for your effort on this.

2:10

This isn't an easy issue.

2:11

It's something that is hurting many cities, states across this country, but at the same time we know that you all are competent people that can are up for the task.

2:19

So thank you for your time this evening.

2:23

Next, we would like to invite the city manager John Shirley to come up and say a few welcoming remarks.

2:29

Mr.

2:29

Shirie.

2:33

Good evening and welcome everybody.

2:35

I want to start off by uh just noting for Bill that you're actually sitting in the hottest seat up there.

2:42

Uh as you know, I regularly sit there.

2:45

So anyway, uh good evening, everybody, and and uh I want to add my words of welcome to that of the mayor and all the members of the city council and thank you for agreeing to take on uh this uh this duty, and I guess I should add volunteer duty uh being on our uh police commission.

3:07

Uh to me, uh we have been fortunate here in Sacramento in that we have not had some of the incidents that have made national news headlines and continue to be uh of concern in this country.

3:26

Uh but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen here, because it certainly could.

3:33

And uh what it further indicates is that uh our city council and our police department are not content to be complacent.

3:43

We always think we can do better.

3:46

We always think that there is uh area to improve our police community relationships.

3:56

We always think that somehow we can do better in terms of communicating, somehow we can be better at making sure that incidents that have happened in other parts of the country don't happen here in Sacramento.

4:13

And we're asking you to help us achieve that.

4:17

I think this is a great move in terms of of uh putting our racial profiling commission kind of to rest, and in effect, putting together this police commission, which will have which has a broader charge and a greater ability to cover more issues and to make input on a variety of subjects, not just racial profiling as the former commission did.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural████████████████████████████28%
Community Engagement█████████████████████21%
Community Policing██████████████14%
Police Policy Review████████████12%
Brown Act Compliance███████7%
Legal█████5%
Public Comments████4%
Homelessness███3%
Education Policy███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Sacramento Community Police Commission Meeting

Date: Monday, November 23, 2015
Time: 6:00 PM – 7:11 PM
Location: Sacramento City Hall, Council Chambers, 915 I Street, NCH

Present: Les Simmons (Chair, pro tem), Clif Roberts (Vice-Chair, pro tem), Basim Elkarra, Betty Williams, Bill Knowlton, Cathy Thao, Dr. Ernest Uwazie, Mariana Sabeniano, Rick Jones, Rosalyn Van Buren, Tim Davis (SPOA)
Staff: Francine Tournour (Director, Office of Public Safety Accountability), Matthew Ruyak (Assistant City Attorney), Phoebe Schueler (City Clerk’s Office)
Guests: Mayor Kevin Johnson, City Manager John Shirey

Consent Calendar

  • No items. The consent calendar was empty.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Ross Hendrick (public comment on matters not on the agenda) – Comments received and filed. (Note: The agenda listed the speaker as “Ross Hendrickx,” but the minutes record “Ross Hendrick.”)

Discussion Items

  1. Welcoming Remarks – Mayor Kevin Johnson and City Manager John Shirey

    • Received and filed. Both officials welcomed the commission and emphasized the importance of improving community-police relationships and public safety.
  2. Commission Scope / Ordinance Review

    • Presented by Assistant City Attorney Matthew Ruyak. He outlined the purpose of the commission as defined in the ordinance: to provide recommendations to the mayor and city council on bias-free policing. He noted that attorney Jeff Massey would regularly assist the commission. Item received and filed.
  3. Brown Act Training

    • Presented by Phoebe Schueler from the City Clerk’s Office. (Discrepancy: The agenda listed the contact as Wendy Klock-Johnson, but the minutes and subsequent training were delivered by Phoebe Schueler. The training covered the Brown Act requirements for open meetings.) Received and filed.
  4. Member Introductions

    • Each commissioner introduced themselves. Item received and filed.
  5. Selection of Commission Chair and Vice-Chair

    • Motion: Bill Knowlton/Mariana Sabeniano to elect Clif Roberts as Chair. Failed (vote not recorded in minutes).
    • Substitute motion: Betty Williams/Basim Elkarra to re-open nominations. Passed (7 yes: Simmons, Williams, Elkarra, Thao, Uwazie, Sabeniano, Jones; 4 no: Van Buren, Knowlton, Roberts, Davis).
    • Election of Chair: Les Simmons was elected Chair (motion by Betty Williams/Basim Elkarra; exact vote not separately recorded, but subsequent vice-chair vote indicates Simmons as Chair).
    • Election of Vice-Chair: Clif Roberts was elected Vice-Chair (motion by Basim Elkarra/Betty Williams; passed unanimously with 11 yes votes: Simmons, Williams, Elkarra, Thao, Van Buren, Knowlton, Uwazie, Sabeniano, Roberts, Jones, Davis).

Key Outcomes

  • Chair: Les Simmons elected as Chair of the Sacramento Community Police Commission.
  • Vice-Chair: Clif Roberts elected as Vice-Chair.
  • No other actionable items – all discussion items were received and filed.
  • Public comment from Ross Hendrick was received and filed without further action.
  • Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 7:11 PM.

Note: There is a discrepancy in the meeting records regarding the Brown Act training presenter. The agenda indicated Wendy Klock-Johnson, but the minutes and actual presentation were by Phoebe Schueler. Additionally, the public comment speaker was spelled “Hendrickx” on the agenda but “Hendrick” in the minutes.

Meeting Transcript

Sacramento community police commission to order. First, we will start with uh roll call. Les Simmons. Here. Betty Williams. Awesome Elkara. Here. Kathy Tower. Rosalind Van Buren. Here. Bill Knowlton. Here. Ernest Zuwazi. Present. Mariana Sabiano here. Clifton Roberts? Here. Rick Jones. Here. And Tim Davis. Here. We have a quorum. So let's move through the agenda. We do not have any items. Well, let's see. We first of all we have the welcoming remarks. There are no items on the consent calendar. So we're going to start with Jovon Aggie from the mayor's office. We had a better relationship than that, it's actually AG. AG? Yes. My bad. Well, it's my pleasure to be here this evening. Uh, Francine, member of the commission, my name is Joe Vaughn A. G. I'm the community relations director for Mayor Johnson. Um, in his absence, he wanted me to let you all know that he's thankful for your time and commitment this evening to this issue. Um, the work that you all are doing is vitally important, um, which you may or may not know that it's part of an officer next door initiative that it was launched earlier this year that focuses on four areas. First being training, second being diversity, engagement, and then accountability with the Sacramento Police Department. The work that you all are doing as this commission falls under the accountability component and has two focus areas bias free policing and then strengthening community police relations. And so the mayor and council are looking forward to the work that you all are going to be doing and providing recommendations to the council on what are those metrics that can be assessed to ensure that we're making progress in those areas. So again, thank you for your effort on this. This isn't an easy issue. It's something that is hurting many cities, states across this country, but at the same time we know that you all are competent people that can are up for the task. So thank you for your time this evening. Next, we would like to invite the city manager John Shirley to come up and say a few welcoming remarks. Mr. Shirie. Good evening and welcome everybody. I want to start off by uh just noting for Bill that you're actually sitting in the hottest seat up there.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com