OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Personnel and Public Employees Committee Special Meeting – Oct 30, 2017

Personnel and Public Employees CommitteeMonday, October 30, 2017
BodySacramento, California
SessionPersonnel and Public Employees Committee
DateMonday, October 30, 2017
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
9:07

Ready when you are.

9:09

Okay, we'll call the we'll call the meeting of the personnel and public employees committee of October the thirtieth to order.

9:18

With the clerk, please call the role.

9:20

Member Ashby?

9:22

Member Warren?

9:24

Member Hansen?

9:25

Here.

9:25

Chair Carr?

9:26

Here.

9:27

We have a quorum.

9:28

If you're here and not a candidate to speak before the commission, you'll need to fill a speaker slip from the back window and turn into the assistant clerk.

9:35

If you need an assisted listening or speaking device, you would also see the assistant clerk.

9:39

This has been a meeting is being recorded and streamed.

9:42

This is the time to turn all of your devices to silent or vibrate, please.

9:58

Almost all of whom are very, very qualified.

10:01

It's going to make our job difficult uh on this committee.

10:05

Uh I also want to thank you for your flexibility.

10:08

This meeting was originally scheduled for a nine, but because of quorum issues, we had to push it back to ten.

10:15

Our other choice was to cancel the meeting altogether and uh reschedule for another date.

10:21

And because we knew that would bring hardship to many of you, we decided to just push it back for an hour.

10:28

Um because of the number of candidates, depending on the uh will of the other committee members, we may take a stretch break uh at some point during the uh hearings.

10:39

So, with that being said, is anyone have anything else to add?

10:43

Let's begin.

10:44

So, our one and only item today is to conduct interviews for the Sacramento Ethics Commission.

10:48

So I have a brief announcement I'll make, and then as we call your name in alphabetical order, you'll come and step down to the podium and you'll be given two minutes to answer the questions that are on the screen behind me.

10:58

And when you have finished um your that portion of your interview, we're gonna ask you to step to your right to see Katea, and she's going to take a picture of you, which we'll include um in the future staff reports.

11:08

Um, for the members today, as you know, this is an inaugural committee.

11:11

This is the um very first appointments made for five seats, and we have no previous um appointees.

11:18

We do have um several, or excuse me, three, several withdrawals that I will not be calling today.

11:23

Byron Miller, Craig Siegel, Michael Fluke all expressed a desire um to withdraw after the agenda packet was produced, with one of them moving outside of the jurisdiction making him ineligible.

11:36

Michael Flute.

11:37

Brian Miller.

11:38

I'm sorry, Byron Miller.

11:41

Craig Sigal and Michael Fluke.

11:46

Okay.

11:49

Please call the first person.

11:50

Adrian Rosemand.

11:55

Alexander McKay.

12:05

Good morning.

12:06

My name is Alexander McKay, and my interest in serving in this commission is to continue giving back to the Sacramento community.

12:12

When I first came to Sacramento, I had the opportunity to volunteer with nonprofit that helped victims of crime get the resources to put their lives back on track and become members of the Sacramento community.

12:23

I later helped with a nonprofit organization that advocated for the International Criminal Court and helped bring speakers to the Sacramento area to explain how work here in Sacramento can have an impact on international criminal justice and help improve the world by large.

12:37

I'm qualified for this commission due to my experience in law.

12:40

I'm currently a practicing attorney and regularly apply facts and argument to statutes in order to get legal remedies for my clients.

12:48

Additionally, I do have some experience adjudicating these issues.

12:58

My job was to listen to facts and arguments by people trying to have parking citations dismissed, and then applied those arguments and facts to the citations themselves to see if they were entitled to dismissal of the citation.

13:12

I'd like to use this experience and continue giving back to the community.

13:17

Thank you.

13:18

Thank you, Alexander.

13:20

Alvin Block.

13:31

My name is uh A.

13:32

G.

13:32

Block, and I'm a longtime resident of Sacramento.

13:36

Um my reasons for doing this are similar in that um I'd like to give back to a community that has been very good to me over the past years.

13:49

And um I've also been fascinated with the behavior of public officials.

13:57

It's something as a journalist, a long-time journalist uh here in Sacramento, a political reporter that I studied for many years and reported on, investigated for many years.

14:07

Um I've always been fascinated with the sort of the place where the letter of the law and the spirit of the law often collide and the complex issues that that are created by that.

14:20

Um as I said, uh I'm a journalist and uh retired now.

14:26

I also worked at the University of California for many years uh as the associate director of the university's uh center here in Sacramento.

14:36

And just throw a little monkey wrench into this right at the beginning.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Ethics Commission█████████████████████████████████████████████85%
Procedural████8%
Community Engagement███6%
Public Comments1%
Summary of Proceedings

Personnel and Public Employees Committee Special Meeting – October 30, 2017

A special meeting of the Personnel and Public Employees Committee was held on Monday, October 30, 2017, beginning at 10:02 a.m. in the City Hall Council Chamber. The meeting was called to order by Chair Larry Carr after a one-hour delay due to quorum issues. The sole agenda item was to conduct interviews of applicants for five seats on the newly created Sacramento Ethics Commission. No appointments were made; nominations were continued to the next meeting. The committee heard from 31 applicants (with three withdrawals) and one public speaker.

Discussion Items

  • Interviews for the Sacramento Ethics Commission (File ID 2017-01287) – The committee conducted interviews for Seats A, B, C, D, and E of the inaugural Ethics Commission. Applicants were called in alphabetical order (by first name) and given two minutes each to answer questions. Among the 31 candidates who appeared, three had withdrawn prior to the meeting (Byron Miller, Craig Siegel, and Michael Fluke). The committee also heard from a wide range of qualified individuals, including attorneys, former FPPC staff, journalists, educators, and community volunteers. Several candidates disclosed potential conflicts of interest (e.g., a son who interned at City Hall, a father working for a political law firm, employment at the FPPC that would end soon). Councilmember Ashby noted that the commission's creation was a long process and thanked the applicants. Chair Carr emphasized that selections would be based on qualifications and representation of the city's diversity.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Paula Lee, representing the League of Women Voters, publicly thanked all candidates for applying and commended the council for establishing the commission.

Key Outcomes

  • No appointments were made – The committee accepted the interviews and will continue discussion and nominations at the next scheduled meeting (date not specified).
  • Chair Carr and Councilmember Ashby encouraged all applicants, especially those not selected, to apply for future openings on the commission or other city boards.
  • The meeting adjourned at 11:26 a.m.

Candidates Interviewed (in order of appearance)

Alexander McCabe, Alvin Block, Amanda Kelly, Andrea Jaramillo, Blayne (BJ) Flora, Cameron Demetre, Caroline Hostetler, Deanna Adams, Deirdre Lopez, Derek Cressman, Diane Elizabeth Sheffield, Emelyn Rodriguez, Eric Rivera-Jurado, Gloria Magana, Jennifer Harmon, Lexi Purich Howard, Linda McAtee, Linda Ng, Mariah Cook, Marina Perez, Mary-Beth Moylan, Monica Baumann, Nancy Coleman Chavez, Pat Cruz, Rhonda Rios Kravitz, Sarah Ream, Scott Arrants, Sharon Victor, Susan Underwood, Tim Matalka, and Virginia Fair-Amitani.

Meeting Transcript

Ready when you are. Okay, we'll call the we'll call the meeting of the personnel and public employees committee of October the thirtieth to order. With the clerk, please call the role. Member Ashby? Member Warren? Member Hansen? Here. Chair Carr? Here. We have a quorum. If you're here and not a candidate to speak before the commission, you'll need to fill a speaker slip from the back window and turn into the assistant clerk. If you need an assisted listening or speaking device, you would also see the assistant clerk. This has been a meeting is being recorded and streamed. This is the time to turn all of your devices to silent or vibrate, please. Almost all of whom are very, very qualified. It's going to make our job difficult uh on this committee. Uh I also want to thank you for your flexibility. This meeting was originally scheduled for a nine, but because of quorum issues, we had to push it back to ten. Our other choice was to cancel the meeting altogether and uh reschedule for another date. And because we knew that would bring hardship to many of you, we decided to just push it back for an hour. Um because of the number of candidates, depending on the uh will of the other committee members, we may take a stretch break uh at some point during the uh hearings. So, with that being said, is anyone have anything else to add? Let's begin. So, our one and only item today is to conduct interviews for the Sacramento Ethics Commission. So I have a brief announcement I'll make, and then as we call your name in alphabetical order, you'll come and step down to the podium and you'll be given two minutes to answer the questions that are on the screen behind me. And when you have finished um your that portion of your interview, we're gonna ask you to step to your right to see Katea, and she's going to take a picture of you, which we'll include um in the future staff reports. Um, for the members today, as you know, this is an inaugural committee. This is the um very first appointments made for five seats, and we have no previous um appointees. We do have um several, or excuse me, three, several withdrawals that I will not be calling today. Byron Miller, Craig Siegel, Michael Fluke all expressed a desire um to withdraw after the agenda packet was produced, with one of them moving outside of the jurisdiction making him ineligible. Michael Flute. Brian Miller. I'm sorry, Byron Miller. Craig Sigal and Michael Fluke. Okay. Please call the first person. Adrian Rosemand. Alexander McKay. Good morning. My name is Alexander McKay, and my interest in serving in this commission is to continue giving back to the Sacramento community. When I first came to Sacramento, I had the opportunity to volunteer with nonprofit that helped victims of crime get the resources to put their lives back on track and become members of the Sacramento community. I later helped with a nonprofit organization that advocated for the International Criminal Court and helped bring speakers to the Sacramento area to explain how work here in Sacramento can have an impact on international criminal justice and help improve the world by large. I'm qualified for this commission due to my experience in law. I'm currently a practicing attorney and regularly apply facts and argument to statutes in order to get legal remedies for my clients. Additionally, I do have some experience adjudicating these issues. My job was to listen to facts and arguments by people trying to have parking citations dismissed, and then applied those arguments and facts to the citations themselves to see if they were entitled to dismissal of the citation. I'd like to use this experience and continue giving back to the community. Thank you. Thank you, Alexander. Alvin Block.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com