Sacramento County Planning Commission Meeting: August 26, 2026 - Fence Appeal and Kill Floor Use Permit Decisions
Sacramento County Planning Commission Meeting - August 26, 2026
The meeting began with the swearing-in of new Commissioner Alma Munoz. The commission heard three items: a routine consent item, a contested fence appeal, and a contested kill floor use permit appeal. Key outcomes included unanimous approval of the pick and pull permit, denial of the fence appeal (upholding the fence), and denial of the kill floor appeal (upholding the use permit) after a 2-2 tie vote triggered a zoning code provision.
Consent Calendar
- PLMP 2025-00203 (Pick and Pull) – Approved unanimously without discussion. The item involved a use permit and variance amendment for a property at 8640 Antelope North Road. No public comments were received.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Item 2 (Fence Appeal): Appellant Marie Barkovsky, the adjacent neighbor, argued that the seven-foot solid fence impedes visibility when backing out of her driveway and violates the Carmichael Colony neighborhood preservation area’s open character. She noted the fence was built before the permit was approved. Three public commenters supported the appeal, emphasizing the neighborhood’s semi-rural character and the importance of enforcing zoning rules. The applicant, Lauren and John Morgan, stated they relied on their contractor and the county permitting process, and that they intend to soften the fence with greenery.
- Item 3 (Kill Floor Appeal): Appellant Tanya Silva, chair of the Rio Linda CPAC, requested denial of the use permit, citing concerns about compatibility, traffic, odor, groundwater, and the lack of a per-day slaughter limit. She noted that the CPAC and Agricultural Advisory Committee both unanimously recommended denial. Fourteen public commenters spoke, all opposed to the project. They raised issues including water contamination, airborne diseases, reduced property values, noise, and the scale of operations (30 slaughters per week). The applicant, Bahadur Amiri, defended his project, stating it complies with AR-5 zoning and CDFA regulations, and that the slaughter will occur inside an insulated building with sealed waste tanks.
Discussion Items
- Item 2 (3031 Wilkins Way Fence Appeal): The commission reviewed the administrative hearing officer’s approval of a minor use permit for a seven-foot solid fence in the front yard setback. The fence is set back 13 feet 8 inches from Wilkins Way. Staff recommended denying the appeal. The appellant argued the fence reduces visibility and safety, and that the county’s process was flawed. The applicant stated they obtained a building permit for the pool and fence, but later learned a minor use permit was needed. After discussion, the commission voted to deny the appeal, adopting the findings in the staff report, thereby upholding the fence permit.
- Item 3 (Green Farm Kill Floor Appeal): The project involves converting a 365-square-foot barn into a kill floor on a 20-acre parcel in the AR-5 zone. The zoning administrator approved a use permit with conditions including a maximum of 30 slaughters per week, Monday–Saturday 9 a.m.–5 p.m., and requirements for waste containment and CDFA licensing. The CPAC appealed, seeking restrictions or denial. Staff recommended denying the appeal. Commissioners debated the project’s compatibility with the growing residential area, the adequacy of the 30-per-week cap, and the applicant’s preparedness. The vote resulted in a 2-2 tie (Commissioners Verga and Rockenstein in favor of denying the appeal, Chair and Commissioner Munoz in favor of granting the appeal). A motion to continue the item failed 2-2, and a motion to deny the appeal (i.e., approve the project) also failed 2-2. Under Zoning Code Section 613 D.3, a tie vote means the matter is denied, which was interpreted as the appeal being denied. Therefore, the use permit remains in effect.
Key Outcomes
- Item 1 (Pick and Pull): Motion to approve staff recommendation passed unanimously.
- Item 2 (Fence Appeal): Motion to deny the appeal and adopt staff findings passed unanimously (4-0). The fence permit remains in effect.
- Item 3 (Kill Floor Appeal): After a 2-2 tie vote, the zoning code provision resulted in the appeal being denied. The use permit for the kill floor stands, subject to the original conditions.
Note: The transcript references the meeting date as August 24, 2026, but the provided date is August 26, 2026. This summary uses the provided date.
Meeting Transcript
Good evening, everyone. Um welcome to the August 24th Planning Commission hearing. Um Madam Clerk, if you could please call the roll. Absolutely. Member Verga. Here Rockenstein? Munoz? Here. And chair and Vice Chair Devlin? Here. And let the record state that Member Borja is currently absent. All right. If you'd all please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. Madam Clerk, could you please read uh the meeting announcement, please? Of course. The county fosters public engagement during the meeting and encourages public participation, civility, and the use of courteous language. The commission does not condone the use of profanity, vulgar language, gestures, or other inappropriate behavior, including personal attacks or threats directed toward any meeting participant. Seating may be limited and available on a first come, first served basis. To make an in-person public comment, please complete and submit a speaker request form to the clerk. Each individual will be invited to the podium to make a comment. Members of the public may send a written comment, which is distributed to commission members and filed in the record. Contact information is optional and should include the meeting date and agenda off agenda item number to be sent as follows. Email a comment to board clerk at SACCounty.gov. Mail a comment to 700 H Street Suite 2450, Sacramento, California, 95814. And that concludes the announcement. Thank you. Do we have a swearing in to begin? Or sweet. Okay. Yes, we do. Um so for our addenda um agenda that we submitted. Um member Alma Munoz will be getting sworn in by assistant um clerk of the board, Manuel Gonzalez. Test. Thank you. Good evening. I am Manuel Gonzalez, assistant clerk of the board of supervisors, and I will be serving slowing in the first supervisor district representative Alma Munoz. Uh Member Munoz, if you can approach electoral, you are hereby being sworn in for the Sacramento County Planning Commission. Alma Munoz, do you solemnly swear that you will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California against all enemies, foreign and domestic, that you will bear true and faithful allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California? That you take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. That you will well and faithfully discharge the duties of upon which you are about to enter. I do. You are hereby sworn in before me, Manuel Gonzalez, this 24th day of August 2026. Congratulations. Thank you. Thank you. Well, with that, are we ready to begin? Okay. Um Madam Clerk, if you would please call the first item. Item number one is PLMP 2025-00203, pick and pull.
openpublica.com