Salem Planning Board Meeting – September 9, 2025: Depot Village Master Plan, Bank of America, Subdivisions & Site Plans
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Salem Planning Board Meeting – September 9, 2025
The Salem Planning Board met on September 9, 2025, at 7:00 PM (estimated) to conduct a public hearing on the Depot Village Master Plan, review a controversial site plan for a Bank of America drive-thru, approve a lot consolidation/line adjustment, and approve a new retail/office building at Scottish Highlands. The board also discussed a potential food truck at the Masonic Lodge and other administrative matters.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Chris To Harlem (18 Keanti Drive) spoke in support of the Depot Village Master Plan but raised three concerns: 1) after-hours use (loitering, substance use, noise) – requested clear park hours, locked restrooms, and a safety plan; 2) musical instruments – asked that they be placed away from residences (northern side of parcel) to avoid noise disturbance; 3) food trucks – sought clarification on whether they would be continuous or event-based, citing potential generator noise, cooking odors, and evening operations. He emphasized his support for the park but requested that quality of life for nearby residents be respected.
Discussion Items
- Depot Village Master Plan: Craig Brubaker (Community Development Program Manager, co-chair of Depot Village Advisory Committee) presented the conceptual plan, developed with Tyne Bond and public input. The plan aims to create a vibrant town center with a veterans plaza, passive recreation, a playground, musical instruments, a potential caboose/historical display, community gardens, food truck areas, and a restroom/rental building. The plan is phased and contingent on a land swap with Liberty Utilities. The board discussed parking reduction (member noted maintaining parking due to uncertainty about nearby lot ownership), ADA accessibility, and the need to fence the playground from traffic. The board voted unanimously to adopt the plan.
- Bank of America Site Plan (69 Central Street): Staff (Jacob Lafontaine) reported that most third-party review comments were satisfied, but a remaining dispute involved the applicant’s refusal to include detectable warning plates on curb ramps (ADA requirement). The applicant argued for continuity with existing Tuscan Village North ramps (no warning plates) and cited maintenance issues. Staff recommended a condition that the applicant’s engineer certify the ramp detail as ADA-compliant. The board discussed the cost difference (minimal) and accepted the condition. The board unanimously approved the plan with nine conditions.
- Swayze Family Camp Subdivision (205-207-209 Shore Drive): Kurt Meiser (Mysa Brem Corporation) proposed consolidating three undersized lots into two, with a lot line adjustment. The plan will require ZBA variances for setbacks. Staff noted that the existing dwelling at 207 Shore Drive must be raised before the plan can be recorded. The board voted to hear in one hearing and grant conditional approval with five conditions.
- Turner Homestead Range at Scottish Highlands (72 Brady Ave): George Chadwick (Bedford Design) presented a proposal to replace an existing single-story building with a two-story retail/office/utility building. The building fits within the existing slab, parking is adequate (31 spaces, 10 required), and septic is already improved. Impact fees of $3,060 (road) and $648 (public safety) apply. The board unanimously approved with four conditions.
- Food Truck at Masonic Lodge (Main Street): Staff brought up a request from the Masonic Lodge to allow a food truck to be parked on their property from April to November, possibly 24/7 (though not open all hours). The board expressed concerns about traffic circulation, accessibility (via piano building lot), and potential nuisance. Staff will work with the applicant on hours and outdoor seating, and may bring it back for board review.
- Other Updates: Staff noted that the BJ’s development is still under third-party review; the cigar bar/kennel zoning amendment is tabled for legal refinement; and a comprehensive zoning update (including site plan/subdivision regulations) is planned, possibly with a consultant.
Key Outcomes
- Depot Village Master Plan: Adopted unanimously (motion by member, seconded).
- Bank of America Site Plan: Conditionally approved unanimously (9 conditions), including engineer certification of ADA compliance for curb ramps, future extension of Brunello Road shown on plan, impact fees, and sign compliance.
- Swayze Family Camp Subdivision: Granted conditional approval in one hearing (5 conditions), including raising existing dwelling before recording.
- Turner Homestead Range at Scottish Highlands: Approved conditionally (4 conditions), including impact fees and staff approvals.
- Food Truck Request: Staff will continue to gather information (hours, seating) and may bring back for board consideration; no formal action taken.
- Minutes of August 26, 2025: Tabled.
- Staff reported that the board vacancy for alternate members remains open.
Meeting Transcript
Good evening. I would like to call the September 9th, 2025 meeting of the planning board to order. Please rise to the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands. One nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. My name is Joe Fioli serving as chairman tonight, members of the planning board sitting tonight to my right, Bianca Carlson. Good evening, Sam. Sean Lewis. To my left, uh Town Council Rhett Paul Pelletier. Good evening, Salem. Jim Harvey. Good evening. And Damon Norcross. Hello. With us tonight and the from the planning department is Planning Director Jacob Lafontaine. The agenda for tonight is as follows. We have a public hearing for the presentation and adoption of the Depot Village Master Plan. We have minutes for August 26, 2025. We're going to table. One item of old business, that's Bank of America site plan. It's a public hearing for a 5,685 square foot bank with drive-thru at 69 Central Street. Two items in new business, Swayze Family Camp Subdivision Plan. That's a preliminary hearing for a lot consolidation and line adjustment at 205-207 and 209 short drive. And second item of new business is the Turner Homestead Range at Scottish Highlands Site Plan. It's public hearing for a new two-story retail office in utility building at 72 Brady Ave. Any withdrawals tonight? No withdrawals, Mr. Chair. Thank you. With that, we'll go to open up the public hearing for presentation on the depot village master plan. Good evening, members of the planning board. My name is Craig and Brubaker. I'm the community development program manager. I'm also one of the co-chairs of the Depot Village Advisory Committee. So the Depot Village Advisory Committee is a town committee that reports to the town council that consists of numerous representatives from the town council, the budget committee, the chamber, Friends of the Salem Bike Ped Corridor, the Rec Committee, and then various uh veterans and historical groups. The committee was formed several years ago from the town council in order to look at the town and state-owned publicly owned parcels to look at potential recreational or community development opportunities that exists on those sites. So in late 2024, the committee uh had some funds uh through the 2024 budget. Uh we contracted with Tyne Bond to go through this process uh of this project and ultimately develop this final conceptual master plan that will be presented to you tonight. Uh in early 2025, the committee met several times to kind of get input from all these different groups uh and kind of formulate this final plan. So we started off with a site walk in January uh on this on the site. Uh we looked at the different uh opportunities there. We met in the the chamber building and kind of envisioned what we would look at from there. Tie and bond developed three conceptual site alternatives and then further condensed that down into two and one based off of committee and public feedback that we received, and then ultimately prepared a final preferred alternative based on further input from VAC. Uh the final project renderings and uh plan was presented to DVAC on May 21st, 2025, and the committee unanimously voted to recommend the plan. So some of the guiding principles that guided the development of this conceptual plan was kind of looking at what opportunities uh presented itself, particularly with the the purchase of the former China Star lot for recreational opportunity as well as the uh parcels that have been acquired over the years from the town and from the state with the depot intersection improvements and these opportunities that have come up really as an opportunity to define the depot as an attractive space as a town center that's kind of identified in the townwide master plan, uh one of those poly cent polycore centered uh centers in the town of Salem. And then consistent with long-standing plans, what does it look like for uh a park in that uh area, etc. etc. So the one of the main guiding principles of this plan was to maintain the veterans plaza design, which was generously donated by several veterans' groups, uh making that a focal point of the uh depot area, uh as well as that the space to the east of the plaza maintained as a passive recreation space, uh as well as the the building in the depot that houses the chamber, keeping that as a historical uh keeping deference to that historical nature of that building uh and making sure nothing uh obfuscates the the frontage of that. Uh as well, we wanted to create a hub of activity along the rail trail. So the rail trail is one of the great amenities of Salem, especially for it in terms of recreation.
openpublica.com