San Diego Audit Committee Meeting - September 21, 2016
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
San Diego Audit Committee Meeting - September 21, 2016
The Audit Committee of the City of San Diego met to discuss the monthly activity report of the City Auditor, follow-up on the street preservation ordinance audit, a performance audit of pedestrian safety programs, and a performance audit of the San Diego Housing Commission. All items were approved and forwarded to the City Council. The meeting also included a closed session to evaluate the City Auditor's performance.
Monthly Activity Report
- City Auditor Mr. Luna presented the monthly report, noting two audit reports issued since the last meeting: one on the Housing Commission and one on pedestrian safety. He also reported one audit in report writing (Central Stores Inventory Audit for FY2016) and several audits in progress, including IT audits (Excel implementation, SAP user access), San Diego Convention Center, Development Services Department (Expedite Permitting Program), street light maintenance, and the Capital Improvement Program. A new IT auditor, Jenny Song, was introduced.
Follow-Up to Street Preservation Ordinance Audit
- Hassan Youssef (Deputy Director, Transportation & Stormwater Department) presented the update. Of 13 total audit recommendations and committee requests, 10 were completed, and 3 remain in progress. Completed: establishment of quality assessment process for street crews, PUD waiver procedure, centralized SharePoint site, enhanced training, process for monitoring street damage fees, and procedures for assessing fees. In progress: expediting street pavement equipment (expected by February 2017) and hiring (11 of 12 positions filled; one code compliance position being interviewed). The committee requested a written update in January 2017. No formal vote was needed; the committee thanked staff.
Performance Audit of Pedestrian Safety Programs
- Andy Hanao (Supervising Senior Performance Auditor) and Danielle Novikowski presented the audit. Key findings: From 2001-2015, over 8,000 pedestrians were injured and 270 killed; 66 pedestrians were killed from 2013-2015, the highest in any three-year period since 2001. Economic costs estimated at $134 million over three years (excluding pain/suffering). The audit made 18 recommendations, all accepted by management. Recommendations include: using data to target high-collision intersections, enforcing driver violations that cause most pedestrian injuries (e.g., failing to yield - only 0.34% of citations), making targeted enforcement highly visible, developing a citywide pedestrian safety campaign, creating a Vision Zero website, and establishing performance measures.
- Public Comments & Testimony:
- Kim Heinley (Bayside Community Center) urged implementation of recommendations, highlighted a recent fatal hit-and-run in Linda Vista.
- Tootie Thomas (El Cajon Boulevard BIA) requested action at high-danger intersections, noting a recent fatality.
- Kathleen Ferrier (Circulate San Diego) supported the audit, emphasized prioritizing high-risk intersections and equity in low-income areas.
- Anastasia Brewster (City Heights CDC) stressed proactive data-driven improvements before tragedies, urged inclusion of equity in prioritization, and recommended diversion programs for enforcement.
- Discussion included responses from Stacey Lumetico (Assistant COO), Captain Ramos (SDPD), Linda Moravian (Transportation Engineering), and Katie Keach (Communications). The motion to accept the report and forward to City Council passed unanimously.
Performance Audit of San Diego Housing Commission
- Chris Kaim (Supervising Auditor) presented the audit, which focused on affordable housing production and cost-effectiveness. Findings: The Housing Commission produced approximately 3,300 affordable units over six years but lacks overall production targets and does not compare costs effectively. Recommendations included setting targets, benchmarking unit costs, and improving loan monitoring. All five recommendations were agreed to.
- Debbie Rouane (Housing Commission) thanked auditors and clarified that residual receipt loans do not involve interest payments due; unpaid amounts accrue and are collected at refinance or sale. The article in the Union Tribune was criticized as misleading. The motion to accept the report and forward to City Council passed unanimously.
Key Outcomes
- Monthly activity report: accepted by unanimous consent.
- Street preservation audit follow-up: noted progress; no formal vote needed.
- Pedestrian safety audit: motion to accept and forward to City Council passed unanimously.
- Housing Commission audit: motion to accept and forward to City Council passed unanimously.
- The committee then moved to closed session to evaluate the City Auditor's performance, with no public report of actions taken.
Meeting Transcript
Well, we do have one notable absence. Mr. Veldivia won't be here today, but we do have quorum with committee members Alan Spencer and Tom Hebrin. We've got Rolando Charvel from the Mayor's Office, Lisa Byrne with the IBA, Mara Elliott with the City Attorney's Office, Council Member Zap, our City Auditor, Mr. Luna is attendance, and Riley with committee consultant. Looks like everybody but Mr. Valdeebi is here. Seeing none, that'll be passed by unanimous consent. Do we have any non-agenda today? I don't see Martha Welch in the audience in the audience. We're good to go. All right. Committee members, mayor, independent budget analysts. Uh any comment from anybody here? Any continuances, anything like that need to be requested before we get going on to our first item. Seeing none, that takes us on to our first item, which is the monthly activity report from Mr. Luna, our city auditor. I'm here to present our monthly activity report since our last meeting. Um since we've last met, uh we've issued two audit reports, both of which will be heard um later this morning. This includes the housing commission, which is our second audit report on the housing commission, and then our pedestrian safety audit. In terms of audits that are in report writing, we have one, which is the annual Central Stores Inventory Audit for fiscal year 2016. We'll be issuing that report by the end of the month. We're just awaiting for the response from management. With regards to audits that are in progress, this includes two IT audits. Um this is one that deals with the Excel implementation, and the second one deals with SAP user access. Um three other audits that we have in progress include the San Diego Convention Center, Development Services Department, the Expedite Permitting Program, and finally the street light maintenance. This includes our audit of the Capital Improvement Program. This next slide shows um our audits that are in the approved work plan but have not commenced. This includes economic development department, business industry and incentive program, our audit of the park and recreation department, um, an audit of the stormwater division of the Transportation of Stormwater Department, Office of the City Attorney, Office of the City Controller Grant Management, and finally developing services develop and impact fees. Also, like at this time, I'd like to introduce a new staff member. We had an opportunity to hire a second IT auditor. So I'd like to introduce Jenny Song. Um she was recently graduated from NYU University with a degree in computer science. She was working on Wall Street and working for Berkshire Capital Securities and also Deutsche Bank. She was in the process of relocating from New York to the San Diego area, and we're really fortunate to have her here. So welcome, Jenny. And that concludes my presentation. Great, thank you for the presentation and welcome to the team, Jenny. I hope you're enjoying the weather, even though it's unusually damp today. All right, that takes us on to our next item, which is item number two, follow up to the performance audit of the street preservation ordinance. All right, you all want to introduce yourselves for the record, and you're welcome to start any time. Good morning, uh committee chair, honorable committee members. My name is Hassan Youssef. I'm a deputy director in the Transportation and Stormwater Department. And with me here today is Christy Reeser, Deputy Director Street Division, and Isam Haresh, Deputy Director, Public Utilities Department. And also in the audience is Greg Hopkins, Deputy Director of Development Services Department. Next, please. This morning, we will provide the committee with an update on our efforts to implement the street preservation ordinance audit recommendations. In addition, we will report on the status of the request made by the audit committee members during the discussions of the audit report back in March 2016. The street preservation audit involved several departments, including the Transportation and Stormwater Department, the Public Utilities Department, the Development Services Department, and the Public Works Department.
openpublica.com