The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission held a special budget hearing on February 2, 2024, to review the Power Enterprise and CleanPowerSF fiscal year 2024-25 and 2025-26 operating and capital budgets, as well as the 10-year capital plan. The meeting included a response to a prior commissioner's question on contracting out, a detailed presentation by Assistant General Manager Barbara Hale, and extensive commissioner discussion on workforce vacancies, recruitment challenges, climate adaptation, and major capital projects.
Overview and Context
Budget Drivers and Position Requests
Commissioner Questions on Communications and Adaptation
Capital Projects (Hetchy Power and CleanPowerSF)
Cordia Franchise and Treasure Island Updates
Commission is called to order. This is the uh last of the meetings of the last and continuation of the la of the uh budget hearing. Um so can we have a roll call, please? President Paulson. Here. Vice President Rivera. Commissioner Jamy. Yeah. Commissioner Maxwell. Commissioner Stacy? Here. You have a quorum. All present. Okay. So I'd like to announce that the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission acknowledges that it owns and are stewards of the unceded lands located within the ethno historic territory of the Moekla Olonee tribe and other familiar descendants of the historically federally recognized Mission San Jose Verona Band of Alameda County. The SFPUC also recognizes that every citizen residing within the Greater Bay Area has and continues to benefit from the use and occupation of the Muekla Wellone tribe's aboriginal lands since before and after the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission's founding in 1932. It is vitally important that we not only recognize the history of the tribal lands on which we reside, but also we acknowledge and honor the fact that the Mooleca Aloney people have established a working partnership with the SFPUC and our productive and flourishing members within the many grade area San Francisco Bay Area communities today. So let's call the first item number three, which is a summary of the budget hearings. And if there are any questions. Donna, can you read it officially? Yes, item number three is a summary of budget hearing questions. Okay. Madam Secretary, um, there was one question that came up uh last week uh last meeting from um Commissioner Maxwell that I wanted to address, and it had to deal with the issue of um contracting out and correlation of um uh staff vacancies. Um I just want to make clear that there is no correlation between contracting out and staff vacancies. Consultants are not replacing silver service staff, but are at most augmenting PUC staffing and only for specific approved reasons. To receive an exception to the general rule that services are to be provided by employees, there are specific specific criteria that are applied. A documented procedure, notice to our labor partners and oversight by the city's civil service commission. Anyone looking to contract work out must answer whether civil service classes can perform the work. Reasons to allow generally fall into three categories. Number one, immediate needs and emergencies to address unanticipated or transitional situations or emergency situations, two, short-term or capital projects for projects requiring diverse skills, expertise or knowledge, and three, as needed, intermittent or periodic services when services are required sporadically or during peaks in workload. With the exception of infrastructure, which, due to the nature of its work, uses many professional services contracts. The amount of contracts in the agency is very small. Looking at the ratio of professional service, this is consultants to PUC staff, is about 13 percent for the water enterprise, 7 percent for wastewater, and 9 percent for power. Infrastructure has a clear process to work through contracting needs to ensure that the SFPUC gets the expertise it needs to deliver on its projects, but still ensures city workers perform as much work as possible. Of those, only a very small fraction of these are actually doing work that city staff could do, but we contract out due to vacancies. For wastewater, it's nine staff, five of which are in the collections systems division, and four in the planning and regulatory compliance division. For power, it's four staff, which forms a high voltage crew, not a professional services contract. And for water, it's 34, six of which are at uh uh city distribution division, and 28 are at Hetchethi Water and Power. Bottom line, there is a process, very well defined and public, with notice to our labor partners, and our numbers show that it is used very sparingly. The contract, the contract form is posted for all union classifications related to the scope of work, and unions have an opportunity to review and object to the posted form. So I know that we have uh Wendy Macy, our Chief People Officer here to answer any questions, but I wanted to make sure that we answered that question about correlation up front so that we could uh ensure that um you were confident that most of the work being done here is being done by our city staff. Thank you, Mr. Herrero, for that clarification and for the fast answer and uh Commissioner Maxwell uh comment. I know that you had initiated that uh question. Yes. Thank you, and I'm glad to hear it. And I am also, and again, thank you for um responding so quickly. I know that uh as I was coming up here today, it's it's clear that uh the entire city coalition from all departments, you know, all city employees are in bargaining right now as we speak. And I know that the issue is that people are uh very always very nervous that you know you know with layoffs and budget crunches that people are going to get squeezed out, and it's glad to be reminded that this city does have a policy about contracting out. It's very specific in which city workers I prioritize.