Public Meetings - San Francisco, California

The San Francisco Planning Commission met Thursday, November 12, 2026, with President Campbell, Vice President Koppel, and Commissioners Chavez, Chen, McDonald, and McGarry present. Commissioner So was absent. Speakers were allowed up to three minutes, with project sponsors allowed five minutes. The Commission acted on continuances, consent calendar items, and six regular calendar items, including an office development authorization, three conditional use authorizations, a residential merger, and removal of an unauthorized dwelling unit. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (55-59 Bemis Street, discretionary review) was withdrawn because the discretionary review application had been withdrawn. - Item 2 (451 Kansas Street and 450 Rhode Island Street, conditional use authorization) was continued to February 11, 2027, by a unanimous 6-0 vote. - Consent Calendar Items 3 and 4 (2241 Market Street conditional use authorization; 684-688 Guerrero Street condominium conversion subdivision) were approved unanimously, 6-0, after no public requests were made to pull them from consent. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke during general public comment. - For 44 Laidley Street, a neighboring resident opposed the project, stating that the existing house was affordable housing that would be lost, that the area is an earthquake/landslide hazard zone with one of the city's steepest slopes, that a five-story building would be out of character for the neighborhood, and that the adjacent 15-foot retaining wall should receive a formal structural reevaluation before any construction. - For 1170 Sacramento Street, the Commission received 102 letters in support and 20 letters in opposition. The Knob Hill Condominium Association's corporate counsel opposed the merger, arguing the shear wall is common-area property, not solely owned by the applicants; the building completed a $13 million voluntary seismic retrofit in 2021; and cutting the wall could affect the building's structure and set a precedent. An attorney for resident Mrs. Grossman also opposed the merger, citing loss of a housing unit and seismic concerns. A resident neighbor said the existing elevator and rear-door routes between the units were sufficient and safe, and the association's design review architect suggested adjusting the rear fire doors as an alternative. Supporters, including friends, relatives, and a family friend reading a letter from architect Andrew Skirman, described the family's intergenerational caregiving needs, the difficulty of moving small children through heavy doors, and prior approved openings or mergers in the same building. Discussion Items - 462 Bryant Street (Items 8a/8b): Staff recommended approval of a large project authorization and office development authorization for a six-story, 51,355-square-foot vertical addition to the existing one-story building at 462 Bryant, within the Central SoMa Mixed Use Office district and SoMa Pilipinas Cultural District. The proposal included 49,995 square feet of new office allocation under the small-cap program, a new 1,660-square-foot PDR space, a green roof, and decks. Staff stated the allocation would use about 8% of the roughly 642,140 square feet of small-cap office space available as of October 17, 2026, and that the project was fully code compliant with no exceptions requested. No public comments were received. Commissioners praised the design collaboration and the voluntary PDR space, and the motion to approve passed unanimously, 6-0. - 44 Laidley Street: Commissioner McDonald recused herself because she owns property within 500 feet. Staff recommended approval of a conditional use authorization to demolish an existing two-unit building and construct a five-story, two-unit building on a steep 3,888-square-foot lot in MTC Tier 3. The minimum density for the tier is 50 dwelling units per acre, requiring four units, so the project needed a CUA for fewer units. Staff noted the existing legal basement unit had substandard floor-to-ceiling height and that the new units would meet current codes. The neighboring resident opposed the proposal. Commissioner Chen commented that the situation reflected a mismatch between the 40-foot height limit and the four-unit density requirement and suggested policy review. The Commission approved the CUA 5-0, with Commissioner McDonald recused. - 701 Scott Street: Staff recommended approval of a conditional use authorization to remove the group housing/nursing home authorization on a single-family home, legalize the property's use as a single-family residence, and add an 845-square-foot basement accessory dwelling unit under state law. Staff reported the group housing had not operated since around 1976 and the property had been used as a single-family home for about 50 years. No public comments were received. The Commission approved the motion unanimously, 6-0. - 85 Liberty Street: Staff recommended denial of a conditional use authorization to remove an approximately 550-square-foot unauthorized ground-floor unit. Staff found tenancy had existed from about 2012 to 2021, that the unit had a possible legalization path through DBI or state ADU programs, and that removal would result in the loss of viable housing stock. The project sponsor argued legalization would cost $350,000-$500,000, require shoring and temporary relocation of three families, and raise fire egress concerns. An owner said the unit was discovered during soft-story work and that the tenant was moved to another unit. The Zoning Administrator explained that if the CUA was denied, the unauthorized unit would remain a required violation to abate. The Commission denied the CUA 5-1, with President Campbell voting no. - 1170 Sacramento Street, Units 11C & 11D: Staff recommended denial of a conditional use authorization to merge two adjacent dwelling units into one six-bedroom, 5,426-square-foot unit with a fire-rated door, citing the loss of an independent family-sized unit amid the city's housing shortage and noting that a high-value exemption was removed from the code in 2020. The project sponsors, George and Dolly Chamas, said they were long-term residents raising grandchildren and needed the opening for intergenerational caregiving, that no tenants were displaced, and that the units would retain separate doors, kitchens, titles, and HOA interests. Opponents cited shared ownership of the shear wall, the building's recent $13 million seismic retrofit, and precedent. During deliberation, the Commission discussed whether conditions could restore the units upon future sale. The Commission approved the merger 5-1, with Commissioner Chen voting no, adding a condition that the units be restored to two independent dwelling units with two full kitchens upon future sale, a reporting requirement, and a finding encouraging the sponsors to reach a similar private agreement with the HOA. Commission and Department Matters - The Planning Director announced a citywide email outage, renewed payment phishing scams affecting planning customers, and the retirement of Deborah Dwyer, a senior environmental planning leader with 20 years at the department. The Director read a proclamation honoring Ms. Dwyer, and Commissioners thanked her. - Staff reported that the Historic Preservation Commission did not meet the prior day and there was no Board of Appeals report. At the Board of Supervisors, 20 landmark designations passed on first read, the rooftop-restroom height limit exemption passed second read, Castro and North Beach historic district initiation resolutions were adopted, a 90-day extension for the Fugazi building landmark designation was adopted, and three MILS Act contracts were introduced. Key Outcomes - Continued 451 Kansas Street/450 Rhode Island Street to February 11, 2027 (6-0). - Approved 2241 Market Street and 684-688 Guerrero Street on consent (6-0). - Approved the 462 Bryant Street large project and office development authorization (6-0). - Approved the 44 Laidley Street conditional use authorization (5-0 after Commissioner McDonald's recusal). - Approved the 701 Scott Street conditional use authorization (6-0). - Denied the 85 Liberty Street conditional use authorization (5-1; Commissioner Campbell dissenting). - Approved the 1170 Sacramento Street conditional use authorization (5-1; Commissioner Chen dissenting) with conditions.

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, November 12, 2026, at 10:00 AM (estimated) in City Hall. Chair Danny Sauter presided, joined by Vice Chair Bilal Mahmood, Supervisor Alan Wong, and District 7 Supervisor Mira Melgar. The committee considered three agenda items: a liquor license application, a hearing on rental scams, and a hearing on illegal dumping enforcement. Liquor License Issuance – 77 Cambon Drive – Bark 77 - Presentation: Officer Brendan Erickson (SFPD liaison) initially reported the location as a low-crime area but corrected to a high-crime area (86 police reports in 2025, exceeding the citywide high-crime threshold of 81). The California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) recommended approval with conditions. - Supervisor Position: Supervisor Melgar, in whose district the site lies, opposed the license, citing ongoing crime (stabbings, shootings, human trafficking) and inadequate police staffing. She noted the shopping center (Park Merced) has been a hotspot for police calls. - Public Testimony: Patrick Kelly, a neighbor, opposed the license, reporting two recent shootings and a stabbing. He also alleged the applicant failed to properly notify tenants as required by California law. The applicant, Firgo McAlaney, supported the license, arguing an active business would improve security and that they had cooperated with police. - Committee Action: Chair Sauter moved to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that issuance would not serve public convenience or necessity. The motion passed unanimously (3–0: Sauter, Mahmood, Wong). Hearing on Rental Scams - Presentations: Amanda Free (Chief Assistant Treasurer) presented data showing 65,000 rental scams nationally with $65 million in losses, though San Francisco-specific numbers are hard to isolate. She highlighted sophisticated scams targeting vulnerable populations and outlined the Stop Scams SF program. Assistant DA Matthew McCarthy explained prosecution challenges: scams often involve overseas networks, fake identities, and rapid money movement. SFPD confirmed that reporting can be done at stations or via non-emergency numbers. - Public Testimony: Lauren Rice, a registered nurse, described nearly losing $18,600 to a scam that copied a legitimate Zillow listing onto Craigslist. Jenny Ristow (Compass Family Services) noted that Spanish-speaking clients frequently encounter scams on Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist, often paying application fees for fake listings. Other speakers emphasized the impact on people exiting homelessness. - Committee Action: Supervisor Wong and others thanked participants. The committee voted to hear and file the hearing (3–0). Hearing on Illegal Dumping Enforcement Efforts - Presentations: Ramses Alvarez (Public Works Community Engagement Manager) detailed the scale of illegal dumping: 175,000 annual 311 calls, with cleanup costs ranging from $430 (small pile) to $15,000 (large pile). The Outreach and Enforcement Team (currently 3 field coordinators, down from 6) issued 472 citations in FY25-26, totaling $128,000, but only $47,000 was collected. Staffing vacancies are being filled (4 new hires approved). New tools include SB 1218 (booting vehicles of repeat offenders) and a cost-recovery ordinance allowing full cleanup charges. A pilot license-plate reader program in District 10 showed that video evidence is needed for citations; Public Works is updating its surveillance technology policy. Recology (Kevin Flanagan) described six cleanup zones and additional afternoon/evening routes. - Public Testimony: John Ellis (Resident Advisory Board) supported enforcement and urged better data sharing. Another speaker highlighted safety hazards (e.g., refrigerators with doors that can trap children). - Committee Action: Supervisor Wong asked about contractor accountability and cultural norms. Chair Sauter inquired about the status of camera deployment and the Bayview dumpster pilot. The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair (3–0). Key Outcomes - Liquor License: Denied. The clerk will prepare a resolution of non-approval for the full Board of Supervisors (December 1, 2026 agenda). - Rental Scams: Hearing heard and filed. The Treasurer’s Office will continue cross-departmental coordination and public education. - Illegal Dumping: Hearing continued to allow tracking of progress on staffing, camera technology, and enforcement tools. Public Works expects to hire four additional outreach coordinators and finalize a surveillance technology policy.

The San Francisco Port Commission convened on November 10, 2026, to address a full agenda including approval of prior minutes, executive session actions, the executive director’s report, a consent calendar, and two major informational presentations on dredging and El Niño preparations. Public comment focused on concerns about the Pier 68 solicitation and lack of community engagement on promised park benefits. The commission approved all consent items and the parking rate amendment, and commissioners discussed strategies for engaging newly elected officials and honoring veterans. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2654 – Accepted a $235,813 grant from FEMA (port match $78,605) for CCTV and passenger screening equipment replacement at the James R. Herman Cruise Terminal. Unanimously approved. - Resolution 2655 – Approved a six-month extension to the Down Market Delay for Phase 1 of the Pier 70 28-Acre Site Project, with delegated authority to the Executive Director for two additional six-month extensions. Unanimously approved. - Resolution 2656 – Approved a Memorandum of Understanding with SF Public Works for no-cost use of a portion of Pier 94 to stage debris boxes for El Niño storm response. Unanimously approved. - Resolution 2657 – Approved travel for the Commission President to attend the 2026 California Ocean Summit in Santa Barbara, December 9-11, 2026. Unanimously approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Sara Swett (Dogpatch resident, board member of Dogpatch & NW Potrero Hill Green Benefit District, member of Dogpatch Neighborhood Association, founder of Swimmable San Francisco Bay) voiced strong concerns about the proposed Pier 68 solicitation, stating that it moves forward without meaningful community engagement and fails to account for previously promised public benefits. She emphasized that the solicitation area includes roughly four acres originally intended as Crane Cove Park Phase 2, with shoreline restoration, native landscaping, trails, and rehabilitation of Buildings 109 and 110. She noted that in 2015, the commission approved the park project, but in December 2021, via a consent calendar item, commissioners were told Phase 2 was no longer planned. She highlighted unfinished public benefits at Phase 1: fully accessible restrooms open same hours as other city parks, swimming access per BCDC permit, removal of water hazards, and restoration of historic crane tops. She also cited an unresolved $2.7 million sediment cap cost. She urged the commission to ensure any Pier 68 solicitation includes Crane Cove Park Phase 2, addresses unfinished benefits and environmental remediation, and involves meaningful community engagement through organizations like Dogpatch Neighborhood Association, Potrero Boosters, and the Green Benefit District before proceeding. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A) – Executive Director Michael Martin reported on the Golden State Valkyries’ victory parade along the Embarcadero, which drew an estimated 400,000 people; described the port staff’s role in coordinating logistics. Announced the opening of Everett Jones Barbecue at Fisherman’s Wharf and the Alcatraz Landing cafe (Il Puerto) developed with Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy and Buen Rayo Hospitality Group. Provided a “five-pack” of Waterfront Resilience Program updates: an El Niño community education event on Nov. 14, participation in SFMTA’s Embarcadero Connectivity Plan open houses (Dec. 8-9), youth career exploration programs (Bay Spark and Ignite Worldwide), community engagement for Fisherman’s Wharf Forward (550+ public participants), and release of an RFP for engineering/design firms for the northern and southern waterfront resilience plan areas. Also announced an art unveiling on Friday for “Nuclear Neural” at Bayview Gateway Park. Commissioners commended the parade and the resilience work; Commissioner Adams recommended sending letters to newly elected Congressman Scott Wiener and Governor Becerra to advocate for port priorities. Vice President McNeely suggested also reaching out to the Lieutenant Governor and Treasurer-elect. - Parking Rate Amendment (Item 11A) – Kimberly Beale, Assistant Deputy Director for Real Estate, requested approval to add monthly parking stall rates inadvertently omitted from the 2026-2028 Parameter Rates for 401 Terry Francois Boulevard, Pier 50 Shed A, Pier 50 Apron, and Pier 26, and clarified that a lower rate for improved land/sidewalk space applies only to tenants paying percentage rent. The amendment was unanimously approved as Resolution 2658. - Dredging Program Informational (Item 12A) – Zach Adamy, Maritime Dredge Program Manager, presented an overview of the port’s dredging program, explaining the need to maintain navigable depths for cruise, cargo, fishing, and recreational vessels. He noted that cruise operations support over 1,500 local jobs and generated $319 million statewide in 2025. The port holds a 10-year maintenance permit covering six locations. Sedimentation rates at Pier 27 and Pier 35 have increased dramatically—from 1.6–2.6 feet per year pre-2023 to 4.85–5.41 feet per year since 2023, largely due to increased rainfall and wind/wave action. The port now surveys every three months (was 1–2 times per year) and has increased permitted depth at Pier 27 from 35 to 37 feet. Dredging is scheduled for Pier 27 twice in 2026. Only 40% of dredged material can go to beneficial reuse (currently only Montezuma site in Solano County), 40% to deep ocean disposal, and 20% in-bay. Beneficial reuse is the most expensive option. The port plans to release an RFP in February/March 2027 to attract more dredging contractors and explore partnerships with smaller ports to improve competition and pricing. Commissioners discussed the need for multiple beneficial reuse sites and federal/state funding offsets, and noted that dredged material is not suitable as fill for the resilience program. - El Niño Preparations Informational (Item 13A) – Matthew Bell, Chief Harbor Engineer, and Megan Wallace, Deputy Director of Finance and Administration, presented the port’s preparations for the 2026-27 El Niño, citing record-high sea surface temperatures and NOAA forecasts. The port has deployed seasonal coastal defenses—HESCO barriers and muscle walls—at four low-lying locations: Pier 45, the Ferry Building area (Mission and Embarcadero low points and exposed shoreline south to Pier 14), Pier 80, and Pier 96. Barriers will be installed by Nov. 21 for the Thanksgiving high-tide window; they are expected to remain through spring. High-capacity pumps will manage water seepage. The city and state have declared emergencies; the port obtained HESCO barriers at no cost from the California Department of Water Resources. The port is also documenting pre-event conditions for potential insurance claims and tracking all expenses for possible future FEMA or Cal OES cost recovery. Total upfront cost is projected at up to $6 million, funded from port reserves (maintenance, resilience, finance/administration, maritime, and real estate funds). Staff plan to return in early 2027 for a supplemental appropriation to replenish these funds. Commissioners expressed confidence in the preparations but raised questions about tenant outreach, non-English speakers, and long-term sustainability. Commissioner Adams suggested seeking philanthropic or private-sector contributions, though President Engblom noted legal and equity concerns about private funding for public safety functions. Executive Director Martin acknowledged that if El Niño events become the new normal, the port lacks recurring funding for annual defenses, and future conversations on financing—including partnerships—will be critical. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approval of minutes for October 20, 2026 meeting. - Closed session action reported: Appointment of Crazia Tanno Lee as Assistant Port Director and Chief Operating Officer. - Resolutions 2654, 2655, 2656, and 2657 adopted unanimously. - Resolution 2658 adopted unanimously to amend 2026-2028 Parameter Rates. - No votes taken on informational items (12A, 13A); material was received and filed. - Commissioner Adams’ recommendations to send congratulatory letters to Congressman-elect Scott Wiener and invite Governor Becerra to the port, and to engage with new state and federal leaders, were recorded as new business. - Adjournment in memory of veterans past and present in honor of Veterans Day, approved unanimously.

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, beginning at 10:15 a.m. The meeting included a special appearance by Mayor Daniel Lurie, approval of routine items, several new ordinances, recognition of community leaders and veterans, and extensive public testimony, particularly regarding the Crocker Amazon Park renovation project. Consent Calendar - Items 2–5 were approved unanimously (11 ayes). These included a $540,000 de-appropriation and appropriation for District 7 projects, a planning code height limit exemption for required rooftop restrooms, a landmark designation for the Jefferson Airplane House, and an administrative code disclosure of tenant protections. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers opposed the Crocker Amazon Park renovation plan proposed by the Giants Community Fund and Rec & Park, citing concerns over artificial turf (PFAS, lead contamination, heat island effect), removal of approximately 90 mature trees, increased fencing, and loss of natural grass and flexible community space. Speakers urged adoption of the “People’s Plan,” which preserves natural grass, trees, and open access. A petition with hundreds of signatures was presented. - Leah McGeever spoke about transphobic abuse and urged the board to materially support the trans community. - Yahya Buzaid (CAIR SF Bay Area) supported resolutions recognizing Native American Heritage Month and Sikh Awareness and Appreciation Month, emphasizing solidarity with indigenous and Sikh communities. - Destiny Santana called for a ninth hearing on SFPD’s response to sexual assault cases, noting that of 157 inactive cases only eight were cleared and two led to convictions. - Georgia Shutish read a letter to Mayor Lurie asking for a carve-out of the Ellis Act for San Francisco and showed an example of tenant displacement. - Honest Charlie Bodkin celebrated the passage of Props B and C (affordable housing funding) and urged the board to allocate transfer tax proceeds to housing. - A caller (Claudine) alleged misuse of power and lack of transparency at the Rent Board, requesting oversight. - Other speakers addressed police accountability, the removal of peer counselors from street crisis response teams, and the need for veterans’ housing. Discussion Items - Mayor’s Appearance (2:00 p.m. Special Order): Mayor Lurie announced a comprehensive ethics code for city contracting and a $100 million donation from Brian Chesky for parks, with an initial $39 million for five projects. He answered questions from Supervisor Fielder (District 9) regarding community ambassador funding (acknowledging a $9.25 million private and $3 million state commitment) and from Supervisor Chen (District 11) about Crocker Amazon Park. Chen expressed concerns that the current design does not reflect community priorities—specifically natural grass, tree preservation, reduced fencing, and inclusive user guidelines. Mayor Lurie detailed design changes including 4.8 additional acres of open space, 196 new trees, and commitment to further engagement. - Microenterprise Home Kitchen Operations (Item 7): Supervisor Fielder introduced minor non-substantive amendments requested by the Department of Public Health. Supervisor Melgar spoke in support, noting the ordinance supports immigrant women and single mothers. The amended ordinance passed on first reading. - Landmark Designations (Items 14–32): Nineteen ordinances designating individual landmarks (e.g., Transamerica Pyramid, Vesuvio Cafe, Finocchio’s) were passed on first reading. - Recognitions (2:30 p.m. Special Order): The board recognized Onlock (55 years of senior services), the Veterans Affairs Council, Navy veteran Dennis McAuley, World General newspaper (50th anniversary), neighborhood volunteer Kevin Grail, and retiring Domestic Violence Consortium Executive Director Beverly Upton. Multiple supervisors spoke in praise of each honoree. - Committee of the Whole (3:00 p.m.): A hearing on updates to DOJ recommendations regarding police reform was initially filed, then rescinded for public comment (none offered), and subsequently filed. Supervisor Dorsey thanked Supervisor Walton for his leadership on police reform. - Cannabis Equity Transfers (Item 35): An ordinance authorizing posthumous transfer of equity applicant status passed on first reading. - Ban on Lockable Butane Lighters (Item 36): Passed on first reading. - Street Name Change (Item 52): Resolution of intention to rename Cesar Chavez Street to “Las Campesinas Street” adopted. - Ellis Act Relocation Payments (Item 51): Ordinance increasing relocation payments following Ellis Act evictions passed on first reading. - Sikh Awareness Month (Item 57): Severed for comments; Supervisor Mahmoud spoke about Sikh history in San Francisco and rising anti-Sikh hate crimes. Resolution adopted. - National Veterans and Military Families Month (Item 59): Initially adopted, then vote rescinded for Supervisor Wong to speak; he emphasized support for veterans and their families. Resolution adopted. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously. - Rent Relief Appropriation (Item 6): $3.94 million from General Reserve for rent relief support services passed (required 8 votes, passed unanimously). - Immigration Legal Services (Item 8): $1.765 million appropriation passed on first reading. - SFO Lease Agreements (Items 9–11): Three resolutions approving 14-year concessions (coffee, gourmet market) with minimum annual guarantees ranging from $90,000 to $456,000 adopted. - Homeless Services Contracts (Items 12–13): Amendments to Larkin Street Youth Services ($14.9M) and Bayview Hunters Point Foundation ($25.7M) adopted. - Landmark Designations (Items 14–32): All 19 ordinances passed on first reading. - Historic District Initiations (Items 33–34): Castro Historic District and North Beach Historic District resolutions adopted. - Cannabis Equity (Item 35), Butane Lighter Ban (Item 36), SFMTA Surveillance Report (Item 37), and Appointments (Items 38–40): All approved. - Committee Reports (Items 42–52): Including Rec & Park surveillance policy, union MOUs (extending terms to 2031, wage increases, no-layoff clause through 2029), Ellis Act relocation increase, and street name change resolution—all passed. - Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 56–59): Native American Heritage Month, Sikh Awareness Month (adopted after severance), Fugazi Building 90-day extension, and Veterans Month (adopted after rescission and comments). - In Memoriams: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Bruce Fisher (Huckleberry Youth Programs), Judge John Dearman (civil rights pioneer), and Claude T. Everhart (community activist and former deputy mayor). Note on Crocker Amazon Park: The board took no direct vote on the park plan; however, Supervisor Chen and Mayor Lurie agreed to continued dialogue. Public testimony strongly opposed the current design and supported the People’s Plan.

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, covering quarterly reports on water and wastewater capital programs, an update on the General Manager selection, approval of the Warnerville-Newark Transmission Expansion Project (WAN-TEP) configuration, and a contract award for Moccasin Dam improvements. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - The consent calendar was approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment and Report of the General Manager (Items 4 and 5): - Francisco da Casta criticized water quality in reservoirs and operations. - Mike Black expressed strong support for CleanPowerSF and electrification efforts in San Francisco. - Dave Warner critiqued commission governance, stating the board is "too deferential to staff," citing the approval of a 12.5% water rate increase. He recommended hiring a board governance expert. Later, during the GM report, he proposed three requests for the 10-year capital plan: 1) presenting multiple capital spending scenarios with 20-year affordability outlooks; 2) lower-cost alternatives for projects over $100 million; and 3) having the CFO comment on large project decisions. - An additional speaker critiqued spending on water capital projects, stating the water is ultimately "polluted" and that "water is life" is not being respected. - General Manager Selection Process (Item 7): - A public speaker criticized the selection process, comparing it to Washington, DC politics, and stated the new general manager should be "very, very talented and have institutional experience," expressing a preference for an engineering background. - Warnerville-Newark Transmission Expansion Project (Item 8): - A speaker from the room critiqued the presentation as unclear and questioned the role of CAISO. Remote caller Yervan spoke in favor of the project, citing wildfire prevention and grid reliability. Peter Dreckmeyer of the Tuolumne Rivers Alliance expressed confidence in staff but urged the commission to hold workshops to build trust and noted that SFPUC declined to participate in a Palo Alto water study session. - Items 5C, 6, 9: No public comment. Discussion Items - Water Enterprise CIP & Water System Improvement Program (Items 5a/5b): - Katie Miller presented the combined Q1 FY 26-27 reports. The program now encompasses 51 projects. $359 million was spent over the past year, the highest level since 2014. Combined water program spending reached $471 million. A net cost increase of approximately $21 million was forecast. Key milestones included completion of the San Antonio Pump Station Motor Control Center, the Town of Sunol pipeline replacement, and the Geary Boulevard sewer and water work. - Wastewater Capital Programs (Item 5c): - Bessie Tan presented the Q1 FY 26-27 report covering 123 projects. Commissioner Thurlow inquired about the Lower Alamany stormwater project, which received no bids initially and then a very high second bid, with Tan noting the project is "not affordable" at the current bid price. Commissioner Stacy asked about cancelled/deferred projects (Tennessee Pump Station, Davison, Pine Lake), which Tan explained are under review or in a pre-planning phase. Notable progress was reported on the Channel Force Main project (90% complete) and the Southeast Plant Nutrient Reduction Project with PCL Jacob Engineering. - Update on General Manager Selection Process (Item 7): - Staff provided a brief verbal update stating "the process is still moving forward." No further details were provided during the meeting. - Warnerville-Newark Transmission Expansion Project (WAN-TEP) (Item 8): - Adam Azurkowitz requested approval of Alternative B2 and authorization to apply to CAISO for Participating Transmission Owner (PTO) status. The project replaces 100-year-old 115 kV lines with a 230 kV line over 70 miles. Commissioner Thurlow questioned the risk of CAISO not approving cost recovery; Azurkowitz noted the approval was for further analysis, with cost recovery expected over more than 10-15 years. Commissioner Stacy asked about necessary associated upgrades (Lines 5/6) and the impact of PTO status, which allows others to use the lines but shifts some compliance to CAISO. Stacy also asked about load losses in a report table, which staff agreed to follow up on. - Award of Moccasin Dam Long-Term Improvements Contract (Item 9): - Jimmy Lang requested approval to award a CMGC contract to the Myers-Sukut Joint Venture for $85.1 million total not-to-exceed, with $2.7 million authorized for pre-construction services. The project addresses flood risks revealed during a 2018 event by building a new side-channel spillway. Commissioner Arce disclosed that Myers and Sons has a seat on his employer's board of directors. Key Outcomes - Item 3 - Minutes: Approved (4-0). (Commissioner Arce stepped away for this vote.) - Item 6 - Consent Calendar: Approved (5-0). - Item 8 - WAN-TEP Alternative B2: Approved (5-0). Staff are authorized to continue planning with the B2 configuration and to submit an application to CAISO for participating transmission owner status. - Item 9 - Moccasin Dam Contract: Approved (5-0). Contract HH-1020 was awarded to the Myers-Sukut Joint Venture. Only pre-construction services were authorized; staff will return for construction authorization following environmental and Division of Safety of Dams (DSOD) review.

The San Francisco Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Shimon Walton and joined by Supervisor Matt Dorsey and later President Rafael Mandelman, met on Monday, November 9, 2026, to consider three agenda items: exempting Port of San Francisco resilience projects from fiscal feasibility requirements, establishing a private right of action for tourist hotel violations of the Healthy Buildings Ordinance, and making appointments to the Immigrant Rights Commission. All votes were unanimous. Port of San Francisco Resilience Projects Exemption (Agenda Item 1) - Presentation: Helen, an analyst with the Port’s Waterfront Resilience Program, presented Ordinance 261087, which would exempt certain port capital improvement projects addressing flooding, sea level rise, and seismic risks from the requirement to submit a fiscal feasibility study (Chapter 29 of the Administrative Code) before initiating environmental review. She noted that the program meets Chapter 29 criteria (projects $25 million, $1 million in public funds) and that preparing each compliance report takes 6–9 months, while each year of delay could add $31–$110 million in present value costs. Similar exemptions were granted to SFMTA and SFPUC in 2018. The port has already completed extensive cost-benefit analyses via the 2020 Embarcadero Seawall Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment and a July 2026 flood study. Next steps include submitting a CEQA application by the end of the year. - Speaker Support: Supervisor Matt Dorsey, co-sponsor, emphasized that strengthening the seawall is an existential, life‑safety imperative and that the exemption removes unnecessary delay without sacrificing accountability. He noted that Chapter 29 was designed for discretionary projects, not necessary resilience work. - Public Comment: One speaker supported the exemption but asked the committee to ensure data and figures on long-term program costs remain publicly available to uphold accountability. - Key Outcomes: The committee voted unanimously (Dorsey, Mandelman, Walton all aye) to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Private Right of Action for Tourist Hotel Violations of the Healthy Buildings Ordinance (Agenda Item 2) - Presentation: Supervisor Shamann Walton (on behalf of Supervisor Chen, who presented) introduced Ordinance 241212, which would create a private right of action allowing tourist hotel employees or their unions to file civil lawsuits against hotels that violate cleaning and disease prevention standards (the Healthy Buildings Ordinance, passed in 2020). The amendment would require a credible finding by the Department of Public Health before a suit could proceed. Supervisor Chen requested the file be duplicated: the original to advance with a positive recommendation, and the duplicate to be held for further amendments. - Debate: Supervisor Dorsey expressed general support for enforcement but noted concerns about private rights of action. He moved to amend the ordinance by deleting language on page 9 (lines 14–20) regarding factors courts may consider for civil penalties. The amendment passed unanimously. President Mandelman supported moving the original forward while allowing continued conversations with stakeholders. - Public Comment: Speakers included Alex Bash (CEO, Hotel Council of San Francisco), who noted the industry has not yet recovered and asked for time to negotiate a compromise; Lizzie Tapia (President, Unite Here Local 2), who emphasized the need to enforce existing law; and several hotel workers who described the physical toll of cleaning rooms left unscheduled for days. The San Francisco Labor Council supported the bill, while San Francisco Travel asked for a reasonable response period for hotels. An individual speaker supported the enforcement mechanism and urged DPH to use data for accountability. - Key Outcomes: The committee unanimously approved the amendment, then unanimously voted to forward the original ordinance (as amended) to the full board with a positive recommendation. The duplicate file was continued to the call of the chair for further work. Appointments to the Immigrant Rights Commission (Agenda Item 3) - Presentation: The committee considered five seats (one term ending June 6, 2027; two ending June 6, 2028; and two ending June 6, 2029). Four applicants appeared: Cesar Moreno (new applicant, seat 2), Laura Padilla (reappointment, seat 5), and two absent but supported reappointments—Jesse Ruiz Navarro (seat 1) and Adubu Traoré (seat 9, requiring a residency waiver). Supervisor Chen expressed support for the three reappointments, citing their diverse perspectives from youth, the African diaspora, and the trans Latino community. - Public Comment: John Ellis (speaking individually) urged the commission to use data to solve cross‑agency document deadline problems. Sarah Souza, chair of the Immigrant Rights Commission, spoke in support of the reappointments, noting their work on economic opportunity, health access, and human rights. - Key Outcomes: The committee unanimously voted to reappoint Jesse Ruiz Navarro to seat 1, appoint Cesar Moreno to seat 2, reappoint Laura Padilla to seat 5, and reappoint Adubu Traoré to seat 9 (with a residency waiver), and forward these appointments to the full board with a positive recommendation.

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and joined by Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Matt Dorsey, met on November 9, 2026. The committee advanced two items to the full Board with positive recommendations: a resolution of intention to rename Cesar Chavez Street to "Las Campesinas Street" and an ordinance to increase Ellis Act relocation payments by 25%. Consent Calendar There were no items on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1: Street Name Change to Las Campesinas Street - Supporters of the name selected by the working group included Susanna Rojas (Executive Director, Calle 24 Latino Cultural District), Annie Rivera (Executive Director, Galería de la Raza), Vanessa Cuyer (youth activist), and a District 11 representative. They argued that Las Campesinas honors the collective legacy of Latina farmworkers, represents a movement rather than an individual, aligns with the city's mandate to recognize women's contributions through public naming, and is a step toward healing for survivors of sexual violence. - Opponents and those requesting a delay included Scott Kravitz (resident and business owner on the street), Zach Aaron (resident), Andrew Boxley (representing 220 residents), and Leanne Speta (former teacher). While broadly supporting the principle of renaming the street, they strongly opposed the specific name "Las Campesinas." They cited inadequate outreach to directly affected residents and businesses, a lack of transparency regarding the survey data breakdown for street stakeholders, and practical concerns about the name's length for daily use, delivery, and emergency services. Several speakers requested the committee delay the vote and suggested simpler alternatives such as "Dahlia Street" or "Esperanza Street." Item 2: Ellis Act Relocation Payments - John Ellis (Supportive Housing Providers Network Resident Advisory Board) supported the spirit of increasing payments but urged the city to publish data on what happens to displaced tenants and ensure support services follow them. He felt the proposed amounts were insufficient given his own experience moving from an SRO. - Glenn (member of the public) strongly supported an increase but characterized the proposed 25% boost as "too little," citing a recent example where a tenant's staff took six months to find an apartment. He urged the committee to raise the amounts further to prevent displacement into homelessness. Discussion Items Item 1: Resolution of Intention - Street Name Change (Cesar Chavez Street to "Las Campesinas Street") - Supervisor Jackie Fielder (District 9) introduced the item, framing it as a necessary step to address the sexual violence allegations against the original namesake while uplifting the collective legacy of women leaders in the farmworker movement. She outlined the legislative process, including a subsequent ordinance requiring DPW outreach to residents. - Assessor-Recorder Joaquin Torres (Working Group Co-Chair) detailed the six-month community process. He stated that the working group established four guiding principles: honoring Latino heritage and immigrant contributions, centering the lived experiences of survivors and women, recognizing the labor and farmworker movement, and focusing on a movement rather than an individual. He reported that public input (771 survey responses, 72% selecting a primary option) showed Las Campesinas as the clear leading choice, receiving nearly twice the support of the alternatives (Dahlia, Army Street, CISPuede). He confirmed that the Department of Emergency Management assured the group there would be no logistical problems with the name for 911 dispatch. - Oscar Grande (Planning Department) corroborated the survey methodology and results, noting that the initial in-person meeting was poorly attended, prompting extended online and direct outreach. - Bevan Dufty read a statement from former Supervisor Susan Leal (Working Group Co-Chair) expressing full support for Las Campesinas, which she said honors the "nameless and faceless women" who work in the fields. - Supervisor Chen praised the process and added herself as a co-sponsor of the resolution. - Chair Melgar noted the process was less contentious than the 1995 renaming, confirmed her personal support for the name, and reminded speakers that the decision rests with the Board of Supervisors, not solely with street residents. Item 2: Ordinance - Ellis Act Relocation Payments Increase - MOHCD Director Dan Adams presented the ordinance. He provided market context: a 2.6% rental vacancy rate (down from 9% during the pandemic), significant rent growth (a one-bedroom unit shifting from affordable at 95% AMI to needing 140% AMI), and an upward trend in eviction filings. The proposal increases the base relocation payment by 25%, from roughly $11,000 to $13,888 per eligible tenant, with a household cap of $41,664 and an additional amount of over $9,000 for elderly and disabled tenants. The increase is justified by the 2022 study's omission of certain costs (like rental application fees and temporary housing) and recent inflation. - Supervisor Chen expressed strong support, agreeing that the adjustment better reflects the true costs of displacement. - Chair Melgar thanked the Mayor's office for addressing the urgency of the housing crisis, noting she had no further questions. Key Outcomes Item 1: Las Campesinas Street Renaming - Vote: The committee voted 3-0 (Melgar, Chen, Dorsey) to send the resolution of intention to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with a positive recommendation. This begins the formal process, which will require a subsequent ordinance and a Department of Public Works outreach campaign to residents on the street. Item 2: Ellis Act Relocation Payments - Vote: The committee voted 3-0 (Melgar, Chen, Dorsey) to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with a positive recommendation.

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on November 5, 2026, to deliberate on a wide-ranging agenda including significant policy amendments to demolition protections in Priority Equity Geographies (PEGs), the first approval of a legal adult sex venue since the code was updated in 2022, a dwelling unit merger, and a discretionary review concerning a residential addition. The meeting featured extensive public testimony and robust commissioner debate on balancing housing production with tenant protections and neighborhood equity. Key outcomes included a split vote on the PEG SUD demolition ordinance and a divided vote on the discretionary review case. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (2024-007978CUA): Conditional Use Authorization to legalize a Formula Retail Cannabis Retail use at 3326 Mission Street. - Item 2 (2026-005028CUA): Conditional Use Authorization for a new Massage Establishment at 4444 Geary Boulevard, Suite 210. - Item 3 (2026-008445PCA): Planning Code Amendment to extend eligibility for unpermitted residential yard structures. - Action: All items on the Consent Calendar were approved unanimously (7-0). Commission and Department Matters - Minutes: Draft minutes from October 8 and October 15, 2026, were adopted unanimously (7-0). - Director's Announcements: Director Rich Phillips announced that voters approved Measure F, enabling the merger of the Planning and Building Departments. A joint budget is being prepared, and fee surpluses may allow holding fees steady. The permit center will be closed on November 11th. - Zoning Administrator Report: Corey Teague reported on a Board of Appeals case (3829 25th Street) where an appeal of a permit suspension for unauthorized demolition was denied, requiring the project to return to the Commission for a Conditional Use Authorization. - Historic Preservation Commission & Board of Supervisors: Staff reported on recent landmark designations, including the passage of the Jefferson Airplane House designation on first read. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish criticized the Section 317 demolition calculations for not being stringent enough. Zachary Frial (SOMCAN) presented survey data showing 58.5% of respondents are cost-burdened. Emily Mock (CPA) read a letter from a high school student supporting Supervisor Chen's ELI housing legislation. - Item 8 (PEG SUD): Numerous community members and organizations (CPA, SOMCAN, YCD, REP SF, SFCAD) testified in strong support of Supervisor Chen's legislation. Speakers shared personal stories of living in crowded Chinatown SROs and facing displacement, arguing that a citywide standard is not equitable for the PEGs. - Item 9 (40 12th St): Jonathan Ohinaga (Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District) spoke in strong support of the adult sex venue, citing neighborhood vitality and queer cultural healing. - Item 11 (3832 18th St): Georgia Shutish commented on the tension between state laws SB 423 and SB 79. Discussion Items - Item 8: Residential Demolition in the Priority Equity Geographies Special Use District (PEG SUD) Supervisor Chan introduced the ordinance, emphasizing that 52% of the city's low-income renters live in PEGs. The proposal would use geographically specific CHAS data, requiring approximately 69% of replacement units to be affordable (with 41% set aside for Extremely Low-Income households). It also proposed a 7-year lookback and adding 30 blocks to the SUD. Planning staff recommended disapproval unless modified, citing concerns over housing feasibility, conflict with recent inclusionary housing reductions, disincentivizing rental housing, weakening the right of return for moderate-income tenants, and the operational challenges of placing ELI units in market-rate buildings. Commissioners debated deeply. Commissioner So argued the proposal could displace moderate-income families. Commissioner Chavez emphasized the housing element's equity goals. Commissioner McDonald supported continuing the conversation. Vote: The Commission voted 5-2 to adopt a recommendation for disapproval unless modified, encouraging the Board of Supervisors to increase protections for extremely low-income tenants. Commissioners Chavez and McDonald dissented. - Item 9a & 9b: 40 12th Street - Adult Sex Venue Staff presented the history of LGBTQ+ bathhouses and the 2022 code amendment. The project, Sanctum Baths, received unanimous support. The Zoning Administrator agreed to grant a variance for reduced street visibility. Vote: Conditional Use Authorization approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 10: 301 Mission Street - Dwelling Unit Merger The project legalized a historic merger of two penthouse units. The owner relied on assessor records when purchasing the single merged unit. Vote: Approved 6-1 with Commissioner So dissenting. - Item 11: 3832 18th Street - Informational Presentation An informational presentation for a housing project under SB 423. No action was taken. - Item 12: 3837 18th Street - Discretionary Review (DR) A DR was filed over a third-floor addition. The project sponsor made several concessions through staff mediation. A notable policy discussion emerged regarding the DR process itself, with Commissioner Chen suggesting that approving the original code-compliant project could disincentivize unnecessary DRs. Vote: The motion to not take DR and approve the project as modified passed 4-3, with Commissioners Chen, So, and Campbell voting against. Key Outcomes - Item 8 (PEG SUD): Commission voted 5-2 to recommend disapproval unless modified, sending the ordinance to the Board of Supervisors with a recommendation against the PEG SUD-specific affordability increases and the map amendments, but supporting the MOHCD implementation and cleanup amendments. - Item 9 (40 12th St): Approved unanimously (7-0) with conditions. - Item 10 (301 Mission St): Approved 6-1 with conditions. - Item 11 (3832 18th St): Informational presentation concluded. No vote. - Item 12 (3837 18th St): Discretionary Review not taken. Project approved as modified 4-3.

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on November 5, 2026. Chaired by Supervisor Steven Sherrill and joined by Vice Chair Jackie Fielder and Supervisor Alan Wong, the committee considered items on surveillance technology policies, retail self-checkout, campaign disclaimers, and multiple labor agreements. Public Comments & Testimony - A representative of the Ethics Commission spoke in support of Item 4 (Campaign Disclaimer Website), thanking the committee and the item's sponsor. - No other members of the public testified on the remaining agenda items. Discussion Items Item 1: Airport Surveillance Technology Policy (File 261035) Diana Bolloch, Guy Clark, and Adam Gubser from the San Francisco Airport presented an ordinance to amend the airport's surveillance technology policy to add authorized uses for Automated License Plate Readers (ALPRs) for a new parking access and revenue control system. The airport introduced amendments to clarify that data is only shared with law enforcement for active criminal investigations. Supervisor Fielder asked about personally identifiable information (PII) protections and the 18-month data retention period, which staff explained were based on city accounting requirements and role-based access controls. Item 2: Recreation and Park Surveillance Technology Policy (File 261036) Christine Nath, CIO of the Recreation and Park Department, presented an amendment authorizing vehicle-mounted ALPRs for parking enforcement in Golden Gate Park. The revenue is designated to fund accessible and affordable recreation programming. The policy mirrors SFMTA's data and ticket processing policies. Item 3: Restrictions on Self-Service Checkout (File 261103) The committee considered an ordinance sponsored by Board President Mandelman requiring minimum staffing levels and item limits for self-service checkout in drug and food retail establishments. The item was continued to the committee's November 19, 2026 meeting. Item 4: Campaign Disclaimer Website (File 260987) Grace Wong from President Mandelman's office presented an ordinance updating the campaign disclaimer website to a .gov domain, as required by state law by 2029. The Ethics Commission approved the ordinance 5-0 on September 11, 2026. Supervisor Wong asked about granting the Ethics Commission greater flexibility over disclaimer language, to which Michael Canning responded that the current language harmonizes well with state law. Items 5-12: Collective Bargaining Agreements and Compensation (Files 261136-261143) Artist Graham, Employee Relations Director, presented eight MOU extensions for unions representing auto mechanics, supervising probation officers, building inspectors, and other city employees, alongside the annual unrepresented employee compensation ordinance. The extensions provide a 12% total wage increase over four years (approximately 3% annually) and extend provisions through June 30, 2031, with no layoff provisions for permanent civil service employees through June 30, 2029. The unrepresented employee ordinance provides a 1% wage increase. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Airport ALPRs): Unanimously (3-0) approved amendments to the policy and forwarded the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors for the November 17, 2026 agenda. - Item 2 (Rec & Park ALPRs): Unanimously (3-0) forwarded the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report for the November 10, 2026 agenda. - Item 3 (Self-Checkout): Unanimously (3-0) continued to the November 19, 2026 committee meeting. - Item 4 (Disclaimer Website): Unanimously (3-0) forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Items 5-12 (Labor Agreements): Unanimously (3-0) forwarded the eight ordinances to the full Board of Supervisors as committee reports for the November 10, 2026 agenda.